Haibane Renmei

Similar premise, very different execution.. Haibane takes away the comedy, action and some cuteness factor in order to bring more deepness to the premise setting, but both anime can leave you wondering the same questions about life purpose, and death. 

Similar in both is by accepting yourself(regret) or atone your sin of your past before death you will be free from that world. Born to other world where they had to do work and live on with other people a.k.a citizen of that world. 

In both, people are born into another world after they die because of regrets from their life before and stuck there until they can get rid of their regrets and become at peace with themselves. 

Angel Beats! and Haibane Renmei have similar concepts, as both are centered around characters who are in a purgatory-like setting. While Angel Beats! has more comedy and action, Haibane Renmei takes a much more serious tone, and also likes to leave things up to the viewer to interpret. Liking one of these shows does not necessarily mean you will like the other, but it is worth trying.  

Imagine having found yourself, to an unknown world, as if a lucid daydream not to be awakened. The rejection and self-denial is nigh, as the individuals, Yuzuru and Rekka, slowly identify with their pasts and gradually accept the truth, within the labyrinth of both worlds, the "afterworld", and the real world. Haibane Renmei, an astute yet nostalgic series that carries an abstract, yet distinct air of suspense to it; Angel Beats, a fulfilling adventure in an alternative (afterlife) world to slowly depreciate and disintegrate as reality steps in. Both attempt to carry a complete and touching plot, with a natural flow in Haibane Renmei; while Angel Beats takes upon an aggressive, and relentless spirit towards the truth. read more 

Both stories take place in an after life of some sort and has simmilar themes. Haibane Renmei is more serious then Angel Beats, though. 

Both anime explore the concept of "Afterlife", and features the characters being trapped in another world due to their regrets from their past lives. Both characters are required to find peace within themselves to be finally set free. Haibane Renmei is much more serious and complex, while Angel Beats! is a lot more comedic and action-packed.  

Similarities: + Different interpretations of the afterlife for a group of people who appear to be adolescents despite not being human + The wall in Haibane Renmei is similar to how the world just ends outside of the high school in Angel Beats! Differences: - Angel Beats has action and much more vivid animation (granted it is 8 years younger) than Haibane Renmei which has a much calmer yet eerie atmosphere throughout the show 

Haibane Renmei has been renowned as "Angel Beats for Hipsters" due to having more philosophical approach, classic western settings, symbolism, and less comedy/action/moe. Both are stories about little children that have to accept their conditions and moving on from their past life sins/regrets in afterlife settiings. 

Watch Haibane Renmei A F T E R Angel Beats. You'll see a TRUE sad anime, and not a random tear-jerker. 

both focus on a heaven themed story and a ya cast and the journeys they go on along the way. 

Although Angel Beats! and Haibane Renmei each possess a different atmosphere and overall feel, they both share a similar setting and the theme of people moving on to the next life. Both shows start off with the main character (Otonashi in Angel Beats! and Rakka in Haibane Remnei) awaking unsure of their past and where they are. Throughout the series, the protagonists learn about the true nature of the worlds they inhabit and that they have moved on to a new life. Also, both of these anime end on a sad note, but Haibane Renmei's ending is more welcome and hopeful than Angel Beats!'s ending. However, Angel Beats! and Haibane Renmei are not entirely similar when it comes to the moods they set. Haibane Renmei appears much more calm and realistic while Angel Beats! can feel intense and fast paced. These different moods can be easily seen in the comedic portions of each anime. The comedy in Haibane Renmei feels more down to earth or relatable, but the comedy in Angel Beats! is often extreme. This is not necessiarily a bad thing (the humor is actually quite funny), but it can and does feel out of place at some momements, especially during serious scenes. read more 

The characters live in some sort of afterlife, and we get to know each of them individually as they grow and, with the help of the main character, learn to acknowledge their regrets and move on. 

"Haibane Renmei" is the art-house original, "Angel Beats!" is the action remake. Same premise, similar message, very different genre and art specific execution. Both tell he story of an afterlife world where souls with an unfortunate death try to find answers to fundamental questions, and only get vague answers. Pacing is reversed. Haibane has a slower start (5-6 eps) and ends in a banger (for arthouse standards). AB! literally starts in a firefight and ends on a low key. 

Similar premise of purgatory, but explores the human nature and 'moving on' in a more mature fashion. 

Similiar themes, setting, and character progression. This one being artsier, slow-paced, and pragmatic than Angel Beats. Is still highly emotional and has a beautiful soundtrack, so I highly recommend it  

Very similar premise. While it is clear in Angel Beats that it is about a sort of "after life", in Haibane Renmei it is not said exactly but it is very obvious. These shows are similar in concept but different in execution. Angel Beats focuses more on action and comedy while Haibane Renmei is more deep. 

Similar setting and angelic theme, similar atmosphere and quest to understand a supernatural world around the characters. 

The world-building is similar, both explores the concept of afterlife, where it's much more subtle in Haibane Renmei. Both show emphasizes on salvation and has many thought-provoking themes. 

These anime share the same weird atmophere. The stories are mostly slow and in the end, you will probably still have lots of questions. The story lines aren't always similliar, but they are both about a girl who doesn't understand the world.  

Both series feature character designs by Yoshitoshi Abe and they are both very atmospheric. 

both very psycological with a great atmosphere of comfusion both drawned by yoshotoshi ABe 

weirdness, art of life, drawing 

Both series were created by Yoshitoshi ABe, as as such they both share similar art and even atmosphere. However, Haibane Renmei is less dark and has a much simpler plot that doesn't rely on interpretation from the audience. If you liked most of the aspects from SEL, but aren't looking for as much of a mindfuck or experimental anime, this is the series to watch next.  

I consider these two anime to be counterparts in a way - if Lain is Hardboiled Wonderland, then Haibane Renmei is The End of the World. The two shows are extremely different in feel, story, and themes, and honestly I don't really think many people who liked one of the shows would like the other. But I would still urge you to watch the other to get the "full experience". 

Both have a similar idea of life and similar story telling including mixing the drama the art aspects very similar to each other. The plots are still different and at this point if you are watching one of these you probably be fine to branch off to the other.  

both have ABe participation in the creation, the way the story is constructed is very similar to a bit of slowness to focus on mysteries, ranma and Lain are really very similar and charismatic, in short, the 2 animes are very close 

The atmosphere of two shows are pretty much similar. Both shows focus on the main character's psychology regarding their respective circumstances. Both are also symbolic. 

From the original character designer for Lain, Abe Yoshitoshi, Haibane Renmai features many similarities, including: Excellent and thoughtful writing, nuanced characters with their own psychology, and solid worldbuilding. The story is paced slower than the average anime but concludes in such a way as to be a satisfying conclusion that still leaves room to theorize. I would highly recommend to anyone who appreciates the writing style seen in Lain.  

both shows heavily involve the same artist, yoshitoshi abe, and have a similar overall feeling. while haibane renmei starts off with a lighter tone, it still has a similar quietness that lain has. it’s also philosophical like lain, and has some very interesting world building. i can’t really say what’s best about this show without spoiling it, though. if you watch it, you’ll see what i mean. 

Same artstyle, similar staff and crew, also deals with exisential themes. 

Both are weird and made by the same director If you like weird shows watch haibane renmei 

You could consider Haibane Renmei and Serial Experiments Lain as sister anime, due to both being about existentialism, the protagonists are very similar in appearance and personality, there's a heavy psychological element and both also deal with sensitive topics like death or suicide. They're done by the same author as well. Both anime have opposite characteristics as well: Serial Experiments Lain feels like the darker sister, taking place in a dystopian cybernetic world where everything is connected, while Haibane Renmei is the lighter sister which takes place in a peaceful village, isolated from the rest of the world. Serial Experiments Lain is a very complex anime, while Haibane Renmei is simple and straightforward. One rarely sees two anime complement and relate so well to each other actually. read more 

Similar visual aesthetic, created by the lead character designer on Lain. Covers many of the same themes of mental health, alienation, and suicide. 

Las 2 hablan sobre el existencialismo, los diseños de sus personajes son muy parecidos ( son del mismo autor ), el misterio de ambos están muy bien llevadas acabo. Ambos son animes excelente y ambos son unos imposibles de perder.  

two psychological gems with Yoshitoshi ABe's alluring character designs, both holding a special place in my heart. going through their existentialist journey haibane renmei offers a bit of a calm and warmer tone along its wholesome experience, a different pace compared to lain. i wholeheartedly recommend it to anyone calling themselves lover of the unusual <3 

Both are slow-paced, slice-of-life quiet shows with a lot of character development. Kino's Journey is more episodic, while Haibane Renmei has an over-arching plot. 

Slow-paced story about life in a world different than ours. Both anime have the same light atmosphere. 

Both are lyrical, soft, eccentric collections of stories about various philosophical observations. Kino is far more preachy and direct with its observations, but is ultimately no less beautiful. 

Both Animes start quite slow, and carry on calm and relaxing, but have got a very deep meaning about them. As well, both have got a theme you could call "talk about philosophical life and meanings". A bit exaggerated, but they still definitely have got a special meaning. The Ending is quite open too, nothing really ever happens particular, but still both have got that little, special sparkle, that's rare to find in an anime. 

same beautiful and philosophical plot 

they have a very similar atmosphere and are both philosofical and reflexive 

Both have a calm and slightly ominous atmosphere, make good use of muted colour palettes, and are chock full of metaphor. Kino no Tabi is episodic and more focused on giving a different message or making a different point each episode while Haibane Renmei is built around character interaction and drama. 

I found these two series quite alike with their philosophical themes with an emotional story and an insightful main female protagonist. Although slow paced, both of their stories are intriguing and unique that explores subjects that can be emotional for viewers. Both series also made me think about life and death occasionally that also deals with themes like redemption and forgiveness. Both series takes an approach in a dream like environment with an insightful depth exploring questions that we often so much around the world. I also found two female protagonist in both series quite similar in several aspects especially in their independence and personalities. Both series are quite beautiful as well that takes journey of its own. read more 

Both anime have a very similar feel in terms of storytelling and both contain many philosophical and thoughtful undertones, like Kino's Journey Haibane Renmei is very unique and intelligent, and will make you think deeply after every episode. While the plot may be different at the core you will find many similarities, it is safe to say that if you enjoyed Kino's Journey you will definitely enjoy Haibane Renmei. 

Kino's Journey feels very similar in tone to Haibane Renmei. They both share a sort of thoughtful, dreamlike melancholy, though Kino's Journey has a little bit more action. They're both slow-paced, mature shows that pose philosophical questions and make you want to think. Kino's Journey is one of the few shows that really captures the same sort of feeling as Haibane Renmei.  

These are two quiet, philosophical Slice-of-life anime, which mainly center around humanity and our lifes. They have the same kind of atmossphere and tone and are both open-ended, even when the story is over, with a message that slowly unfolds to the viewer. 

The art style is the main reason. It has this old storybook kind of feel that is very relaxing to see. The stories in both are very similar. While Kino may be more episodic, both cover complicated issues like suicide, death, forgiveness, and despair in simplistic ways. The writing itself is very similar. The diction of the characters is surprisingly similar. I don't want to give away anymore, lest I spoil some plot, but both a great! 

The art, the tone, the worldbuilding, the way the plot makes you think. If you've ever felt like they just don't make shows like Kino no Tabi anymore, Haibane Renmei is exactly what you're missing. 

A similar main lead exploring a very well realized world, with detailed cities and societies, always with a contemplative and philosophical tone. Same early 2000's aesthetic, with beautiful background and OST, creating a tranquil atmosphere that often contrasts with some darker moments. 

Both show us the best and worst of people, mantain a very similar eerie aesthetic, and show how our protagonists are looking for all means to belong to somewhere. 

both focus on the youngest/ newest person of a special type of people (winged people or gems) developing their identify in a world different from our own. both develop abilities throughout the show from understanding the world around them 

Both have a similar calm air to them, as well as moving through the plot in a mellow way, and leave the viewer at a point where the end goal of the series is not predictable or clearly present.  

Very similar in premise and progression. Both are supernatural slice-of-life series that focus heavily on character and world-building. Both feature a cast of characters who cannot fully explain their origin or purpose, who are subject to a mysterious and occasionally suspicious power structure. I reckon Haibane Renmei does it better - it's very nearly a masterpiece, even if it starts slow. 

If nothing else, these two shows are conceptually similar with a strong story focus. BTW: The english dub of Haibane Renmei is great if you care 

A crucial part of Houseki no Kuni core identity could be summarised as a a buddhist parallel to Haibane Renmei. 

Both focus on the least experienced member of a certain society and there's a lot of abstract concepts thrown around and feature a very unique world to learn about. 

Both emotional introspective anime. 

Both have: - community of a different kind of humans, mostly girlish alike. - the community is located in a mysterious isolated place. - The show is sorta about the slice of life of the girls in this special world, their friendship, dramas, discoveries, tragedies etc. - So much instigating. 

Both are about the MC exploring and trying to understand their world. Both series feature a more gruesome twist. Drama, mystery. 

Both focus on the newest member of the group and how they adapt to their new life, Haibane Renmei is more wholesome, melancholic and slow-paced, closer to Iyashikei; while Houseki no Kuni is more action-based and overall harsher on character development. The world-building and soundtracks are spectacular on both too. 

In both we follow the newest member of a colorful cast of characters who cannot fully explain their origin or purpose. We follow this MC as they try to find their place in their world, battling themselves with their low self esteem. Both focus heavily on character and world-building; though I will mention Haibane Renmei does so a bit more slowly and gently, while Houseki no Kuni is more harsh. Both are a visual masterpiece in their own right, with great soundtracks to match. 

Seemingly unassuming slice of life shows which eventually take a more dramatic, sinister twist. The settings in these shows are fascinating and mysterious, and play a huge role in the story, as much as the main characters themselves. 

Similar setting: an isolated, ancient outpost near a small medieval town with odd traditions. Similar style: cheerful slice-of-lifeish with periodic depressing points. Similar focus: characters and their pasts. Similar Characters: A friendly, yet initally immaturely self-centered protagonist: check A highly respected, yet sometimes moody leader who takes the protgonist under her wing: check A motherly and sedate character: check A mechanically-inclined character: check Sora no Woto is just Haibane Renmai with a K-ONesque art style  

If K-on similar in music motives and character design, than Haibane Renmei is similar in atmosphere. We have small closed society inside the city. Platoon 1121 is honorable part of towns life, but they aren't part of town itself. Same as Graywings honored within the city, they are outcasts in peaceful world. The beginning of Kanata's and Rio's relationships resembles Reki's and Raka's. And of course we have this quiet sensation of something hidden, but it is not dangerous, but simply unknown.  

Very similar art style and characters, has the same atmosphere of a peaceful, secluded town in a very unknown world. The only key difference is that Sora no Woto tends to open it's world a bit more, while the Haibane world is only limited to both people and locales inside the wall. In fact, I was quite surprised that the two series weren't made by the same person. 0_o 

Sora no woto is setting is a post-war era where the previous humanity was nearly wiped out. Very little culture and knowledge seems to have survived. Throughout the series you just try to piece together what's the world is like from the main cast daily interactions. Similar to Haibane Renmei, it is some what of a mystery as to what the world around them is like. A female main character joins an existing group of characters to learn their way of life. Each episode is structured like a slice of life genre, and also the entire cast is female. You can expect character development to unfold slowly with each episode. You have a bunch of cute/moe moments but the over arcing story is rather tense. Sora no Woto does have some sad moments, but I wouldn't call it a tear jerker like how Haibane Renmei built up to. But overall I think you would see similarities you might enjoy in Sora no Woto. read more 

While both are essentially atmospheric slice of life series with a focus on world-building, there are some key differences. The contrast between the serious and the lighthearted is more dramatic in So Ra No Wo To while Haibane Renmei's tends to be subtler in all aspects. Furthermore, the post-apocalyptic setting of So Ra No Wo To is beautifully tangible and chillingly possible with the story taking place in a colorful town littered with cultural relics from our own world while Haibane Renmei's magical realist universe is more allegorical in nature with fantastical elements alongside the mundane. Ultimately both series are wonderfully paced atmospheric pieces that forgo plot in favor of letting the characters explore and guide the viewers through meticulously crafted environments. read more 

Both series have a similar atmosphere of slice of life with character drama. Haibane Renmei has more thorough theme exploration whereas So Ra No Wo To has more varied character interactions. Both series start off quite slow but have fantastic endings. 

-both have rather similar atmospheres -both have rather similar characters -both similar lengths -both start out more slice of life esc and have darker undertones 

Haibane Renmei and So Ra No Wo To both feature a similar atmosphere, but, most importantly, they both feature some similar characters and character relationships. For example, Rakka from Haibane Renmei and Kanata from So Ra No Wo To are both young, female protagonists. They are both befriended by an older girl with a mysterious and unkown past, Reki in Haibane Renmei and Rio in So Ra No Wo To. Futhermore, each series showcase a motherly character that knows more about our older girl with a mysterious and unkown past than she first lets on. In Haibane Renmei, Nemu fits this discription and Filicia from So Ra No Wo To also fits this discription. read more 

These series have similar atmosphere of mysterious world surrounding main characters. They both have relaxing soundtrack and beautiful art style. I recommend you to watch them after hard day ;) 

Slow paced, mystical, unique, extremely tasteful and artistic. Very high quality show. Certainly not for every anime watcher out there but if you like one you'll almost definitely like the other. 

These two anime series have a few things in common. They both share a light-fantasy setting and they are both very calming to watch. 

Both are very soul cleansing shows, very therapeutic.  

Tranquility, gentleness, melancholy, and philosophy carry these two anime that have a firm understanding of how an anime can wield atmosphere to its advantage. Both are pensive, slow, and beautiful, and they share a similar art direction. 

A rather mellow and relaxing atmosphere is present in both of them, only ocasionally broken. They more or less focus on getting the viewer to reflect upon oneself, without coming off as pretentious or intrusive. While Mushishi is definitely not to be marathoned, one can do so with Haibane, as matters presented in the latter usually require a little more thought than the former. 

Mushishi and Haibane renmei give the viewer a deep sense of being trapped psychologically in anime philosophies, and a deep sense of reflection about their universe. 

Low-key fantasy anime that rely on atmosphere for immersion, both employ modest storytelling methods along with a reliance on grey morality to get their messages across. Both push Zen-Buddhist concepts and beliefs; universal compassion as well as the equilibrium of the human psyche for Haibane Renmei, the relationship between man and nature for Mushishi, coexistence and karma for both. 

Like "Mushishi," this anime has a serene and dreamlike atmosphere that invites reflection and introspection. It follows the story of a group of angel-like beings called Haibane, who live in a walled town and must come to terms with their existence and purpose. 

Although the topics aren't the same, they have an extremely similar emotion to them. If you liked Haibane Renmei, you'll surely enjoy Gunslinger Girl. 

As another user said, there is a certain emotion one feels for the girls. As you watch you feel sorry for them yet enjoy that they can still manage to find happiness from day to day. 

The premises of both series are, at their most basic level, very similar, if not identical – a cast of predominantly female characters are essentially “reborn” into a new way of life, with no recollection of who they were previously. The girls in both series experience similar emotional and existential dilemmas. In general, these are series in which drama and atmosphere take precedence over action. 

These two shows deal with similar themes, including mortality and the loss of memory. The girls in both have a gentle innocence about them, though Gunslinger Girl's are marred by their purpose as tools. Excellent series to compare and contrast because of this. 

Minus the occasional action in Gunslinger Girl, these series have a very similar tone and cast of characters. Gunslinger Girl and Haibane Renmei are more soft and subdued series, where the quiet moments are often the most powerful.  

You can compare anime by mood or by plot. If you go by mood, Haibane Renmei and Gunslinger Girl are very similar. Both have the slow-moving, heavy-thinking setup that makes you ponder moral questions. The plot, however, could not be more different. 

Tone, mood, pacing and art style are almost identical, even when the plot is superficially very different. The underlying situation is similar, though. Girls are "reborn" while losing all memories of a previous life and find themselves in a world with strict rules and uncertain future. Both anime focus on the psychology of the girls and the questions they ask themselves. Both have no "real" plot but are rather a philosophical slice of life in a very strange world, which requires suspension of disbelief to enjoy. 

Both are kinda eery and have a dramatic plot with cute girls to add 

Mainly, the atmosphere of both 'Haibane Renmei' and the 'Aria' series is extremely similar for their overwhelming calmness. Also, the plot of both are somewhat similar in that both characters are in a certain type of organization and are striving to become a 'useful' member of that organization. If you liked Haibane Renmei, then there is a 90% chance that you'll love the Aria series (In my case, it was so ^_^)  

These two slice of life animes are similar in the calm atmosphere both have The characters kindness and in some way the peaceful worlds are also something alike While Haibane is more melancholic, Aria is more effusive. However, in both series you get a warm feeling in every episode 

Its a very soft anime. It's about enjoying life, I think. I also recommend the manga. 

Haibane Renmei and Aria are both rather slow-paced "iyashikei" (healing) slice-of-life shows with a hint of melancholy that concentrate more on relaxing the viewer instead of trying to make them laugh.  

Similarities: + Calm slice of life anime about a group of six girls working, living together, and helping people + The main character is the newest to join the group Differences: - Haibane Renmei has much more drama and much eerier atmosphere - Aria is about gondoliers and Haibane Renmei are about people who are similar to angels  

While Haibane Renmei is notably more reflective, melancholic and cohesive than Aria, they still share so many characteristics that I'm actually surprised they are not on the top in their respective lists of recommendations. Both are set in an isolated alternate world which is introduced trough multiple episodes, all of their prominent characters are female, main characters can be described as curious, complying and kind, both are mentored by a more experienced and respected woman which they adore. Episodic storytelling is also a shared trait between the two series, as is the slow pacing and delusive absence of coherent progression. The most apparent similarity is the constant alteration between various relaxing and mysterious settings. The overall impression differs, however. In Aria, relaxation and cheerfulness is emphasized, while the atmosphere of eeriness and mystery is more prevalent in Haibane Renmei. Even with that being said, it's remarkable how similar these independent series are conceptually, as we are talking about very unconventional concepts to begin with. read more 

Both shows have characters going about relatively peaceful lives. No action, no violence. Haibane Renmai does have darker moments. 

Both series focus heavily on trying to understand an initially mysterious and confusing world. The characters understand that something is wrong with their setting, but aren't sure what it is at the start. Both series slowly build towards understanding how their societies function. Shinsekai Yori focuses a lot more on society at large, whereas Haibane Renmei focuses more on individual character struggles. Both are fantastic at conveying a sense of both confusion and anticipation. They are also both excellent at conveying the internal struggles that come with grief, responsibility, and doubt. 

Both shows are based around a group of characters that are living in a seemingly utopia, which have rules that should not be questioned. One common rule is that their stay is limited within some kind of a barrier/wall. They are shown to have some privilege compared to other groups in both series. As they enjoy their utopia they both have an atmosphere of a mystery and that something is missing. The main characters of both shows show less fear to find out what is actually going on, and try to unfold the mystery. If you liked one show, it is very likely that you will like the other.  read more 

Both shows are characterized by their inexplicable mystique, philosophical nature and simple but masterful style of art. As each show progresses, the plot thickens and more questions need answering - the difference between the two? Shinsekai Yori answers said questions in full, while Haibane Renmei leaves everything to the viewer's interpretation. Both are modern masterpieces, and require a certain type of viewer to fully appreciate them. Not recommended for those who dislike slow starts. 

Evoking awe, wonder, and suspense, Haibane and Shinsekai share similar atmosphere: mysterious, beautiful, often tranquil (especially in Haibane) but vaguely ominous. Neither has a setting too willing to reveal its secrets. Both are set in a society of "anachronistic" technology, arcane rules, and enigmatic authority. And both carry a sense of foreboding fueled by the sudden disappearances of characters. While both carry philosophical underpinnings, Haibane tends to focus more on a personal level in contrast to Shinsekai's social commentary. Shinsekai also tends to be more action-driven and a bit darker in tone. 

In both series the main protagonists are born with "special abilities" or a different appereance without knowing why they are so different from the others. The female MC's of these series shows their struggling with their life, which they didn't choose.  

Both are unsettling and explore world markedly different from our own. Although significant plot elements differ, the tone of the two stories is fairly similar.  

Where Madoka features Magical Girls, Haibane Renmei feature the Haibane or Charcoal Feathers. These two series explore some of the more intricate parts of human nature through a fantasy setting, and the general development of their plots are very similar. Worlds that at first seem to be utopic suggest more melancholic truths, while cute and likable characters deal with heavy existential questions and are forced to make difficult choices.  

Similarities: + A group of girls who are put into a rough situation where they must work together + They look similar to normal humans, but are no longer human + Plenty of drama Differences: - Haibane Renmei is calmer with more of eerie mood throughout whereas Madoka Magica has more obvious dark aspects - Madoka Magica is a magical girl show while Haibane Renmei is an "afterlife" one 

At first, both series start with a slow pace but then they both start to get darker and deeper. however, madoka magica takes the turn faster.... both series also have similar atmosphere... you should watch this anime if you haven't, it's awesome. :)  

Both of these series are dramas with supernatural elements that have an emphasis on the relationships between compelling female characters. They both start out innocently enough and both have unexpected dark twists. Haibane Renmei is more peaceful and episodic, whereas Madoka Magica is much darker and more suspenseful. Each anime has its own strengths and weaknesses. Madoka has a stronger cast of characters, better writing, and is much more addicting. However, Haibane doesn't really need to have an epic plot that will constantly keep you on the edge of your seat to stand on its own. Haibane's atmosphere, symbolism and character interactions are nothing short of magical. I like to call Haibane "the subtler Madoka" because I found a lot of similarities in the relationship dynamic between the two most important characters in each series. Either way, both of these series are nearly equally matched terms of how they will move you emotionally. If you're looking for something more dark and tragic, try Madoka. In the mood for something more uplifting? Try Haibane. Absolute must watches, the both of them! read more 

Despite being completely different at first sight, both shows share similar characters' traits and concept. Both, Puella Magi and Haibane, have similar protagonists, anti-hero and "antagonists" (will not say anything further regarding the last one to not spoil anyone). In both series the characters must fight against inner struggles to find their own identity, in other words, the constant fight of girl vs self that is present in both ultimateley leads them to reach their own salvation. 

Both are supernatural themed stories with an all female ya cast and their relationships together as well as them getting caught up in a bunch of strange shit happening around them as well too. 

Both series are atmospheric in nature, relying on tasteful grande soundtracks. Both series express a lot with choice colour palets, both have a mystique about them. Haibane Renmei features a community of characters but it's focused on self reliance and the isolation that in the end comes with constant inner struggle and vacant threats in the surrounding world. Both series deals with death and religion/spirituality in some way, in both knowledge is acquired through books. Both series build sympathetic characters with individual goals and aspirations despite limits put on their existence. 

Both series potentially deal with the afterlife. Both series have a laid-back but melancholy feel to them and a slow, slice-of-life pacing. Both series are about calm, peaceful human interaction in an otherwise unsettling and ambiguous world.  

These two shows rich in melancholy, yet an immense comfortability is to be found. Getting along with despair and accepting life in the enigmatic worlds the characters inhabit. The pair are slice of life "CGDST" (of course that stands for "cute girls doing sad things"). 

Both have a bit of a somber mysterious setting where the background is not totally explained. The characters explore the world and must make their own conclusions about purpose and existence 

Both do not basically explain anything in the world and are much more in the daily life of the characters and their relationships and every once in a while there is something more reflective like Haibane ep 5 and Shoujo Shuumatsu ep 9. I think Shoujo Shuuumatsu is better than Haibane. 

same feeling, melancholic - mystery. hope in a hopeless world  

Haibane Renmei and Denno Coil may seem very different at first glance, HR taking place in an environment deprived of modern technology while DC focuses on the borders between reality and the internet but the spirit of both shows is remarkably similar. Both deal with young female leads who must learn how to adjust to unusual circumstances surrounded by mystery in a world where things are not as they at first may seem. The original take on this theme is enhaced by thoughtful moments and a subdued but very lush artwork. What truly seals the deal in establishing a kinship between the two titles is the relationship between two young girls: a certain emotional healing takes place in HR and DC, providing excellent character development through and through.  read more 

In both these series, the ultimate conflict involves an emotionally damaged girl having to come to terms with her past trauma through the help and friendship of another girl. The latter parts of both series have a similar mood. 

They are both about young people coming to trust others and move on from the past. Endearing, believable cast of characters combined with a surreal setting that both warms and chills the viewer, makes these two more similar at heart than any other series that are recommended. 

There are strange parallels in characters. And o much kindness in both titles! 

Small, personal stories of drama and exploration set in a fascinating, "big" setting. Both are likely to leave you wanting to find out far more about the world they take place in than is revealed while following the footsteps of only a few people in it and their limited viewpoint. Dennou Coil is soft sci-fi; Haibane Renmei is spiritual fantasy. 

While in many ways opposite in terms of execution, the similarities in symbolism, introspection, character exposition, and a feel for mystery in world development give these two comparable goals and create a sense of familiarity between one another. 

While both shows have very different literal plots, some of the main themes behind them are the same: - The exploration of mental illness, particularly depression, without directly naming it. In NGE this is explored through the majority of the characters and in Haibane Renmei it is explored through Rakka and Reki. (Though it can be argued that other characters are implied to be involved in this theme.) - Giving hope for people in such situations. Both shows do not shy away from the seriousness of mental illness, but utilize the acknowledgement of such struggles to provide the message that despite all this, you can save yourself. - The exploration of every-day morality. Unlike other shows which tend to only explore morality in the context of life and death scenarios, NGE and Haibane Renmei are also concerned with moral problems anyone can identify with, such as the conflict between selfishness and selflessness and the ambiguous relationship between sin and forgiveness. - The exploration of existential philosophy. - An emphasis on character development, the 'internal' being more important to the story than the 'external'. - Both the shows use Christian imagery and symbolism, though do not necessarily argue Christian ideology.  read more 

Both are somber and downbeat series with a focus around angels with their interactions with the human race and lots of poigant and facinating psychological elements in it as well too and a focus around some very touchy themes as well too during the story.  

For me, Eva and Haibane are the best psychological anime out there. Both deal with similar themes like loss, guilt and self-acceptance. Both series also share kinda similar characters. The main difference is that, while Eva is a mecha anime (And thus, is more action focused), Haibane is for all intents and purposes a slice of life anime. 

They both use deep symbolism, like religious themes, beliefs and dogma. They are ambiguous and can varying interpretations.  

Both anime have heavy doses of symbolism, religious imagery and a unique, dream-like atmosphere. The setting in both anime appear to be based off of an old European city, and the location is largely abandoned in both (moreso in Angel's Egg than in Haibane Renmei). 

Both have really nice to look at art and animation still holding up pretty well and some how religious particularly angelic concepts are tied to the story. 

Both of these anime deal with self discovery. But while Haibane Renmei is about learning who you are to move on and liberate yourself, Colorful (Movie) is about learning who you are to reorient yourself in life. They're each other's antithesis on the same subject. 

Both shows deal with souls set apart from the usual system of reincarnation and given a time-limited chance to correct the errors of their former lives. 

These are two stories about characters dealing with their own existence. I won't go into the story spoilers as to why, but they find themselves in unfamiliar places and have to come to terms with themselves. The art in both is great, and they both feel like they could have come from the same era, despite Haibane coming out nearly 10 years prior. They both left me feeling similar things, though Haibane took me on more of an emotional roller-coaster toward the end. 

both r by the same creator....and the art,character design and atmosphere is pretty much the same... 

same art style and same atmosphere. both are a little mysterious because Haibane Renmei deals with angels while Niea Under 7 deals with aliens. Both also deal with human behavior and such. Niea Under 7 is like the comedy and less serious version of Haibane Renmei in my opinion.  

Both are slice-of-life anime that have their lighthearted moments, but also feature some darker more cerebral, and introspective moments. Both feature characters were designed and created by Yoshitoshi ABe, who also did the artwork for Lain and Texhnolyze as well. Both are more mellow, chill shows with worlds that have creative lore behind them. Both feature similar story and character beats but do them differently enough to differentiate themselves from each other. Both also feature heavy acoustic and softer soundtracks to accommodate their vibes. Both shows are also just wonderful in my eyes too, so yeah. 

both are deep anime about life-afterlife 

If you like a story showing the afterlife, haibane renmei is for you.  

both focused on a super natural themed story with heaven and hell concepts in it. 

Zettai Shounen has a slow, melancholy pace, unexplained or slowly explained phenomenon, and mystery with some connection to an unclear past. I'm not crazy about the character art but gets the job done but the background art combined with minimal dialogue and a natural sound track that includes bird songs and insect noises works very well. The summer arc conveys the slow, heavy, hot, sun bleached, dusty feel of August and the winter arc the quiet chill of winter as the story oozes forward. Not for every one but worth a look if you enjoy the mystic.  

The genres of these two shows are slice of life with a few supernatural/fantasy quirks added. A plot later does reveal itself. The two start off with a very similar atmosphere of a sleepy peaceful town and a newcomer to that place. If you can stand slow pacing, these two are great. Along with a similar atmosphere, the music is also very similar. I can't stress this enough. I had to actually check if they had the same composer but they are different. Both soundtracks are very great. Also, if you were alright with either one of the two shows endings which left a few unanswered questions, you'll be alright with the other as well. They have satisfying endings. read more 

Haibane Renmei and Zettai Shounen are slice-of-life stories that chronicle the main characters' progressive movements throughout each episode. They have similar pacing with a natural feeling of serenity. There are phases of supernatural involved as both series have a lighthearted tone. Throughout both series, issues are explored and mysteries are unraveled. The soundtracks for both series are also smooth with a calm background. 

There isn't exactly an abundance of subtle animes. Most of them are very loud and with little to no subtext. Characters, I've noticed, are prone to holding speeches about absolutely everything they think and feel. Spice and Wolf is the only other series I've seen apart from this where I felt that everything wasn't spelled out for you, and so, while they aren't very much alike story-wise, they are similarily quiet but effectful. 

Light-hearted, slow-paced, incredibly respectful of their audience's intelligence. If you liked Spice and Wolf, you'll probably like Haibane Renmei. 

Two melancholic anime, with a mostly calm setting but with psychological/supernatural aspects, a mystery that surrounds the town the people live at, mysterious dreams, crows, and people wishing to fly either metaphorically or literally. Both also present the topics of loss. The biggest difference is that AIR has some Harem/Romance elements and Haibane Renmei is mostly a Slice of Life. 

Their stories - whilst mostly different - parallel each other through their focus on people with wings. They also explore existentialist concepts and can get quite emotional at times. 

These series both left me speechless. Not in a cliche, "beautiful wonderful" way, but just in the sense that I really didn't know what to think. It's an ambiguous melancholy that walks directly between intolerable and enjoyable, so I assume that one who enjoyed the unique atmosphere crafted by Haibane Renmei would certainly enjoy the universe presented in Simoun. 

Both detail a fairly large cast (of largely girls), with significant religious imagery and touching coming-of-age stories and rounded out conclusions that leave the right questions in your head afterwards. 

The setting and pacing is similar to Haibane Renmei. Though in all honesty, Made in Abyss is like the perfect mix between The Promised Neverland and Haibane Renmei, two shows which I've enjoyed a lot. Haibane is admittedly, less gritty and raunchy, though it still has that fantastical setting and intriguing world building.  

It has a similar feel to it. In both we have a group of people gathered in some unfamiliar place, which seems a bit off for them, with no recollections of the past. In both at one point or another their pasts start catching up to them. And in both the characters must get to work as soon as they get there in order to survive. Also both have this warm, yet melancholic and for some reason uneasy feeling about them.  

OK, here me out here, Of course these two anime are completely different in terms of plots, for me these two anime will present you with a range of different emotions and within the end will leave you with a very happy feeling which you get from only good anime, they both tell tales of the start of something awesome to the end of something with both having a very melancholy feel at times. 

The settings are drastically different, but they share some crucial aspects: Main cast is about two girls, one that is naive and tries to find her place in the world and other that is more serious, introvert and with tons of hidden pain, the relationship between Reki and Rakka seems pretty similar to the relationship between Anthy and Utena, although the later is closer to a romantic one. Secondly, both series are psychological, heavy on symbolism, are character driven, involves dialogue and open many questions that aren't explicitly answered in any of the series. 

Slow paced...stuck in a strange new world...calming...and there is fantasy. 

In both anime there is a female protagonist, both anime shows the protagonist's quotidian, and also during the anime the protagonist tries to solve the problems of others and also her own problems. 

Both shows have similar character archetypes and interactions. One won't find many similarities in terms of plot or setting. But the way that the characters are portrayed ultimately gives one similar emotions that can best be described as "a warm fuzzy feeling." 

Both are slice-of-life series, with something fictional and fantastical (magic in Someday's Dreamers, and the Haibane in Haibane Renmei) existing in a mostly "regular" world. Both series have a relaxing, calm atmosphere, and the female protagonists of both have fairly similar personalities and demeanour. They also have a vaguely similar art style. 

no, you dont want to watch these shows. bcuz if you do, you will never stop asking yourself the most important questions! like is pizza a pie??! who the hell knows??!!1 trust me, if ya love ur deep THINKing stuff youll love this. hope ya have 𝓕𝓤𝓝 anyways! 

Both Gile and Neo-Venezia are cities where people share generousity and politeness, where animals have symbolic meaning and working is pure happiness.Sheer utopia  

Slow and contemplative shows, with beautifully drawn backgrounds, and main leads that take a back seat to just observing the world and atmosphere. 

Both Aria the Origination and Haibane Renmei are slice of life, with themes of growing up and a strong melancholy undertone. Both also have beautiful art and settings inspired by Europe, though Aria's is Italian and Haibane Renmei's is Central European. Haibane Renmei is not as sweet and happy as Aria, and it uses fantasy elements where Aria uses sci-fi elements, but both shows are beautiful, moving, and combine slice of life stories with great art and likable characters.