DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
GenesisAria said: @Lanz Most of asian culture has had a not of western influx . . . though even eastern philosophy has been distorted over time. Asian culture is not and was not to celebrate consuming animals that killed fellow persons through the argument of effectiveness. Probably. At least it's not a western influence. |
Lanz said: Most of the natives of the americas would support that mentality, and they're of asian descent. Never waste what is killed. Eat the meat, make something of the skin & bones.GenesisAria said: Asian culture is not and was not to celebrate consuming animals that killed fellow persons through the argument of effectiveness. Probably.@Lanz Most of asian culture has had a not of western influx . . . though even eastern philosophy has been distorted over time. At least it's not a western influence. |
❀桜舞う空〜 Cute is Power. 🔗CosmoGenesis Project “Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.” “A truth seeker has no patience for BS.” I seek only to improve myself and others. |
GenesisAria said: Lanz said: Most of the natives of the americas would support that mentality, and they're of asian descent. Never waste what is killed. Eat the meat, make something of the skin & bones.Asian culture is not and was not to celebrate consuming animals that killed fellow persons through the argument of effectiveness. Probably. At least it's not a western influence. Yes, but it's strange to think of eating them as a way to channel the dead explorers' energy or something. Can't imagine native americans would think that neither. |
Lanz said: GenesisAria said: Most of the natives of the americas would support that mentality, and they're of asian descent. Never waste what is killed. Eat the meat, make something of the skin & bones. Yes, but it's strange to think of eating them as a way to channel the dead explorers' energy or something. Can't imagine native americans would think that neither. Not really, she was just talking about chi basically... Their life force was stolen by the bird, and she took it back, so it's like that person's life helped her, it's poetic in a way. You must be thinking about the person's literal body cells getting into the meat making it quasi-cannibalism or something... |
| ❀桜舞う空〜 Cute is Power. 🔗CosmoGenesis Project “Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.” “A truth seeker has no patience for BS.” I seek only to improve myself and others. |
GenesisAria said: Not really, she was just talking about chi basically... Their life force was stolen by the bird, and she took it back, so it's like that person's life helped her, it's poetic in a way. That's poetic in a way, yes. So long it's just life force and not human meat. Applied to animals alone feels better though. GenesisAria said: You must be thinking about the person's literal body cells getting into the meat making it quasi-cannibalism or something... That's how almost everyone understood that as, as semi-cannibalism. And the talk of Riko as "cannibalism is ok since the chi flows back that way" Which is odd to say, since chi or any kind of life force isn't directly bond to the meat, or isn't it? |
 Fixes to make the Profile more bearable after "the Modern★Profile★Update★★Rip★Profile★" |
Zeando said: GenesisAria said: Not really, she was just talking about chi basically... Their life force was stolen by the bird, and she took it back, so it's like that person's life helped her, it's poetic in a way. That's poetic in a way, yes. So long it's just life force and not human meat. Applied to animals alone feels better though. GenesisAria said: You must be thinking about the person's literal body cells getting into the meat making it quasi-cannibalism or something... That's how almost everyone understood that as, as semi-cannibalism. And the talk of Riko as "cannibalism is ok since the chi flows back that way" Which is odd to say, since chi or any kind of life force isn't directly bond to the meat, or isn't it? It's referring to the literal energy which comprises your body, the EM; cells and other such things are just constructs of that, which when consumed etc is manifested into other compounds and energies etc. You don't turn food into kinetic energy by magic. Granted that one didn't have much time to digest. They had a tonguey thing, so doesn't seem like they eat bites, but more like chisel away and suck. Again it's about spiritualistic optimism. You're gonna break real fast if you don't tell yourself things like that like a fool... Only a fool dwells on the thing and is unable to move on and seek merits. If it was modern humans going down there, they'd go insane real fast. I mean if you get real pedantic, the material always goes full circle through nature anyways... if you traced the material, you would find it coming back to human consumption eventually, so most of the taboos are only avoided in close proximity really. You're better off not having all these's arbitrary morals about it. Reminds me of Grisaia... |
GenesisAriaAug 9, 2017 11:43 PM
| ❀桜舞う空〜 Cute is Power. 🔗CosmoGenesis Project “Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.” “A truth seeker has no patience for BS.” I seek only to improve myself and others. |
GenesisAria said: Lanz said: Yes, but it's strange to think of eating them as a way to channel the dead explorers' energy or something. Can't imagine native americans would think that neither. Not really, she was just talking about chi basically... Their life force was stolen by the bird, and she took it back, so it's like that person's life helped her, it's poetic in a way. You must be thinking about the person's literal body cells getting into the meat making it quasi-cannibalism or something... I personally don't have gripes with them eating the human-eating animals- it's natural for irl humans to do that in some way or another, but the creepy thing was that from my view Riko herself was viewing the consumption in a 'quasi-cannibalistic' way. Maybe it was poetic but I felt she was using realistic language Not that that's a huge problem |
| They need to pick up the pace just a little more, wasting time on weird lolicon shit isn't ideal. |
haydnwright said: They need to pick up the pace just a little more, wasting time on weird lolicon shit isn't ideal. Just tell me how much time did it waste. About 15 seconds? |
GenesisAria said: For some reason i knew that the "tasukete" was a mimic. I'm so good at being aware and intuitive and thinking on my feet with stuff like that, contrary to the mundane world we all live in... What am i even doing on earth? Why am i here when literally all my skillsets are suitable for somewhere else. At the very least, when society collapses, i won't be one of the ones that fall with it. Lanz said: It's not creepy at all. The cycle of energy and material comes back around. It's better to make light of and appreciate nature's way. Better to eat it than to let it rot. If anything, the societal norms we have in the west that are contrary, is what's disturbing.Riko's speech on the meat was v creepy, that world is quite so too Aidoru-Ojisan said: I still love this series to bits! Yet I'm worried by the scenes where Riko is half-naked is going to make some newcomers to the series be a little wary of that, [...] if this keeps them away from it I dunno man, it's gonna suck badly fishpun said: and you'd be right. i decided to drop it this week. my friend dropped it last week, and at that point i was like "eeeeh it doesn't happen often enough that i can't ignore it". then this week happened. it's just not appropriate. and i disagree with it 'not being sexualized', because we all know who this shit panders to. what's the purpose of having naked children? you don't need it for "realism", so there's only 1 other explanation for it. it's a shame too because the premise of this series is really cool. but whatever, this season is full of cool shows so i won't miss it too terribly Kittens-kun said: Ya, frankly, seeing the nudity as an issue actually exacerbates the issue... instead of just letting naked people be naked people, it's "OMG IT'S SO IMMORAL!" Who fucking cares? Nobody should.Really? Dropping it because of THAT? Ok, she was nude. Ok, she's a little girl. But, 1. She's not a real human being and 2. There's literally nothing there. She's as washboard as washboard gets. I don't see the issue here. Benmashi said: It's a punishment not much different than the strap (i'd say it's less bad). Sure it's deranged, but we were also there not very long ago, and it's even still considered normal by some. If you think it's the nudity that's messed up then you're priorities are way backwards.And for the hanging up naked, just shows how f*cked up their world is. I surely could have done without that scene tbh. Doesn't ruin the narrative though. At the end of the day this is a fantasy world and it should be appreciated as such. Whether it's great characters or not, whether it's moral or not... There's plenty of anime with great characters and shit plot, plenty with shit characters and great plot... There's plenty of gore-fest anime, and nobody whines about that... Just arbitrarily picking and choosing what to whine about with no logical consistency... damn the western world is retarded. As i made clear, the nudity isn't an issue for me. In the show even with the "strung up naked" tossed in, it never strays to the macabre. But still, getting punished with ruler was a thing in our world, hanging up a kid and whipping is something else. Also Nat's story of the kids in his hometown before he went to the orphanage, is more disturbing. And people can get very fickly, that's always been the case. Just look at Sia's videos Chandelier and Elastic heart. How many people on the internet looked to deep into that and were blind for the artistic side of it. Complainers gonna complain i suppose. |
Benmashi said: These were way too abstract my god.And people can get very fickly, that's always been the case. Just look at Sia's videos Chandelier and Elastic heart. How many people on the internet looked to deep into that and were blind for the artistic side of it. Complainers gonna complain i suppose. People have been punished by much more than a mere ruler, but anyways. When did anyone say anything about whipping when tied up naked? |
| ❀桜舞う空〜 Cute is Power. 🔗CosmoGenesis Project “Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.” “A truth seeker has no patience for BS.” I seek only to improve myself and others. |
GenesisAria said: Benmashi said: These were way too abstract my god.And people can get very fickly, that's always been the case. Just look at Sia's videos Chandelier and Elastic heart. How many people on the internet looked to deep into that and were blind for the artistic side of it. Complainers gonna complain i suppose. People have been punished by much more than a mere ruler, but anyways. When did anyone say anything about whipping when tied up naked? My mistake. I thought the director did that in episode 2. She just holds a stick in the strung up scene. Either way, it's that scene i was referring to. As for the clips of Sia. Some people complained using Maddie (the dancer) in the clips the way she was portraye GenesisAria said: Benmashi said: These were way too abstract my god.And people can get very fickly, that's always been the case. Just look at Sia's videos Chandelier and Elastic heart. How many people on the internet looked to deep into that and were blind for the artistic side of it. Complainers gonna complain i suppose. People have been punished by much more than a mere ruler, but anyways. When did anyone say anything about whipping when tied up naked? My mistake. I thought the director did that in episode 2. She just holds a stick in the strung up scene. Either way, it's that scene i was referring to. As for the clips of Sia. Some people complained using Maddie (the dancer) in the clips the way she was portrayed. While it had a much deeper meaning than what those people thought of it. This is in response to the people criticising the pandering this show does, looking for things that aren't there.d. While it had a much deeper meaning than what those people thought of it. This is in response to the people criticising the show for using fanservice, while it isn't meant in such a way. |
| Ima firin mah lazer! Creepy birds though. "Help me." |
  |
| The first half of the episode, full of action, was incredible when this mosnter simulated do a help call to catch her "food"!!!!! kekekeke |
| The corpse weeper is kind of freaky, it mimics the sounds of help of its victims. Poor cave dweller. Still, it's scary thinking you'd hear someone crying for help and then you encounter that thing waiting to eat you. Finally, Regu uses his cannon beam again. So awesome, wished he used it more or show us other tricks he has up his sleeve. Why is Regu blushing with a shirtless Riko? She looks just like another boy without her shirt. lol Riko is savage, after seeing that corpse weeper eat a human, she grilled the motherfucker and turned it into wagyu steak. Ozen doesn't seem to like Riko or either of them. |
| 臭い- |
| This is probably the most interesting setting I've seen in anime since Shinsekai Yori. |
 |
| To be an object created by man, Reg is far too human, the mystery over him gets stuck, wow! There is nothing to complain about in this episode, even this time the soundtrack succeeds in giving more emphasis to moments of anxiety and releasing even more vivid feelings of dramatic and melancholy during the narrated events. Really raw and without spinning of certain scenes. Fabulous the scene of the "Incinerator", reminds me so much of Genos's character, Reg has not even his brother? XD |
 |
| Reg is definitely the best possible partner Riko could have for the Abyss. He channeled some kind of amazing inner strength/memory from his past and his arm became a goddamn incinerator. That whole scene was pretty cool. Anyone who is describing non-descript nudity that was well explained/required in the story (Riko's clothes were covered in vomit, was Reg really supposed to leave them on her?) as "fanservice" or "lolicon shit" needs to grow up. The camera didn't pander on her body at all, seemingly avoiding any long shots that could be misinterpreted as fanservice. I hope this White Whistle chick won't give them a hard time. |
| "No, son, you may not have your body pillow at the dinner table!" |
| The white whistle actually looks so cool |
 |
| those corpse weepers were great reminded me of scp 939 |
 |
| I'm certain Regu is a cyborg since there's no reason for a Robot to have emotions or genitalia. Guessing he might've been a Diver that was severely wounded and had some of his body replaced with artificial parts. Would be cool if that explains the voice he heard in his head. |
 |
| This show just keeps getting better and better! I hope Reg learns/remembers how to control his fire shot! |
| “I love heroes, but I don't want to be one. Do you even know what a hero is!? For example, you have some meat. Pirates will feast on the meat, but the hero will distribute it among the people! I want to eat the meat!” - Monkey D. Luffy |
| The pacing of this episode was amazing! Really wonder what's up next! |
 |
| I love how bizzare the beasts look here. The fact that they're drawn differently comparing to the other elements of the show just makes them all the more eerie. Although the show reminds me of a Ghibli film at first, the dark tonal shift and unsettling atmosphere of the world are gradually giving me Shinsekai Yori vibes. Wouldn't be surprised if the story becomes extremely disturbing later. |
 |
| Wew, that sure got dark and Reg's Incinerator was frigging beast! Ozen looks like she's seen some shit damn, her assistant's pretty cute tho! |
 |
| After watching Hunter X Hunter, one can already tell that was a trap creature with the "calling for help" shit lolol. I'm so glad Riko warned Reg, even though she ended up getting caught anyways >< |
| Oh wow those creatures are scary for sure! Glad to see them past the worst of it - for this level! Looking forward to learning about Ozen, she seems intriguing |
| I'm Bruneian and I like anime. And Manchester United. And fat cats. |
| I'm loving the series so far. It feels like im having an adventure with them. |
 |
| Hmmmm that Ozen character seems evil :O . That corspe weeper has neat that was a close call. |
| [url=http://myanimelist.net/animelist/QcK_Dagger_HeaT&sclick=1][IMG] |
| This anime is really cute and is full of bright colors and adventurous spirit, but it's also really, REALLY morbid and frightening when it wants to be. Seeing Riko's outlook on survival while eating that creature's meat really spoke volumes on life in and around the Abyss. In a way, it makes the farewells in the third and fourth episodes even more impactful, as everyone knew that they might not ever see each other again. As such, Riko and Reg can't be picky about their means of survival. So far, I'm really liking Made in Abyss. There's this great feeling of mystery surrounding the series, and it's really great in building atmosphere with its good amount of silent moments, letting viewers observe the environments and characters' actions. Though, as of thus far, there's only been the rustic fantasy city and forests to show off. While the scenery is really beautiful, it's also not really varied. Though, criticizing the show for not showing off more might be a good thing, as it means there's a lot of potential for imaginative places and creatures as the main characters dive deeper into the Abyss. It's like watching a playthrough of a dungeon crawling RPG, but one with a greater emphasis on both wonder and danger. |
| Cool iron man-like laser in action again! They're sure are lucky, Reg would've vaporized Riko completely like the nightmare he had. Some darks scenes like the corpse feeding monster and Riko's death (nightmare) Interesting... |
  |
| Nice episode, the atmosphere is scary, though. The pacing a bit slow, but that's ok. |
| Seeing Reg's laser kamehameha made me realize something. If these raiders risk their lives to go down the abyss to gather relics that is in demand world wide, wouldn't it make sense to develop some kind of weapon to help them agaisnt these beasts? All they're carrying are mining instruments and others but no weapon whatsoever. That's why they die. Also I like Riko's little speech about eating meat. |
 |
| It's definitely getting darker here. Corpse Weepers in the 2nd layer only means that there will be even worse creatures down there. Good thing Reg's Incinerator was there to save them both again. And by eating meat, the circle of life continues~ They managed to get to the end of the 2nd layer too. |
 |
| Booooo. Nothing scary here. I wonder why they have given this a high rating. Whatever Riko told this episode about is just Archaeology 101. No dark stuff at all. F**k this series. So we met the crying reapers and the 2 of them got through with it because of some shitty plot armor that Reg develops to save Riko. The entire episode is just one big pile of jokes and stuff. We see more of loli body of Riko and lame jokes about journal and stuff. Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull was better than this. 1000x better.  One more episode,then I will drop this. Such a over hyped series, yet ZER0 development in the status quo for 6 episodes. If this is the case, I might as well rate it a 6/10 for not living up to the expectations. I bet the next episode will be focusing on how humans can be monsters sometimes and stuff like that. And there will be a plot twist showing how cruel the world really is. Otherwise, this is just the worst. |
 Without change,we end up becoming the very person we hate. I was dead until the moment I met you. I was a powerless corpse pretending to be alive. Living without power, without the ability to change my course, was bound to lead me to a slow death. |
| That corpse-weeper creature must be one of the most disturbing creatures I've ever seen. I hope we won't see any more of those in action... |
"At some point, I stopped hoping." |
joe_g7 said: That corpse-weeper creature must be one of the most disturbing creatures I've ever seen. I hope we won't see any more of those in action... Just want to know whether you'll get scared of playing 7 days to die where the zombie horde cry at night seeking for you. the forest too if you're a gamer (: |
hazecloud said: Nahh man, it's not the same. This thing can call "help" to draw it's victims in. And it's not even human. It's creepy af.joe_g7 said: That corpse-weeper creature must be one of the most disturbing creatures I've ever seen. I hope we won't see any more of those in action... Just want to know whether you'll get scared of playing 7 days to die where the zombie horde cry at night seeking for you. the forest too if you're a gamer (: |
"At some point, I stopped hoping." |
| The design of the creatures is weirdly creepy, they look like bloodlusted pokemons, ugh. Ozen reminds me so much of Ougi from Monogatari series, they look like twins! |
  |
| Still hasn't got any less boring. Sheesh. |
 |
Scalpelexis said: JCvetich said: This episode was okay. The creatures were cool, and the fight with the corpse-weepers was pretty awesome. Reg's use of his "incinerator" was neat. The past few episodes have just been missing something.... and I can't really put my finger on it. I went from feeling like this show was awesome, to feeling like it was just alright. I think part of it is the knowledge that there's only 13 episodes, so I feel like each episode has to be extremely important. That said, I guess I just haven't felt like enough important things have happened in the past few episodes. For instance, this episode really didn't reveal anything new. Reg used his "incinerator", but we didn't get any explanation of how or why he has it, why he can only use it occasionally, why it affected him the way it did, etc. I also feel like this show spends a lot of time on really random, seemingly trivial things. We got an extended scene about food, and a talk about the semi-cannibalistic rituals of the cave raiders. While somewhat interesting, I didn't feel it was really needed. In the same way, the time Riko spent lamenting the loss of her journal also felt wasted. I understand that, in the grand scheme of things, these scenes aren't that long... but it brings me back to the number of episodes and feeling like every moment needs to be important. Perhaps it will be moot and there will be more than one season. I guess we'll see. I absolutely agree and understand you. Until now it's been pretty much "child's play". But I assure you from now on we are getting much more serious. Whew that's good to hear, I thought I just wasn't getting it or something. I mean the show is good, but I guess coming into it knowing how well critically received it is made me think I was missing something. |
| ~ The world is not beautiful, therefore it is. |
| cor blimey, these 30 minute episodes breeze by. The way those birds consuming the explorers to then be consumed by the duo was framed as some sort of pseudo-cannibalism was, I dunno, strange. "LEND ME YOUR NUTRIENTS!" |
 ☩ Discord: the.path.to.pathos ☩ RateYourMusic ☩ last.fm |
| Those birds were super creepy, I was sure that was a trap. |
 |
| The corpse-weeper was pretty cool and we got to see Reg's blaster arm in action again. Maybe it's just the visual presentation but this time the Incinerator looks even more powerful than the last one. Reg is really a handy partner. They've descended that far already by taking shortcuts. This episode also expanded more on the cave raiders' culture with all the meat talks which was very interesting. |
 |
| "The resilience of those who live here was built up for the sake of life in the Abyss." The part about eating the beasts who feed on cave raiders and the cyclical nature of their deaths seems like an addition to one of this show's overall themes. I get the feeling that diving into the abyss and sacrificing one's self is controlled either by the orphanage head or some other part of their society as a "necessary sacrifice for the greater good." |
 |
| Ozen looks so cool :D She should be the one to give them the cruel reality of their journey. It's so annoying to see despite Riko's stubborness from the beginning, she has not been punished or learned anything. |
tuanguyenOct 31, 2019 3:43 AM
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Made in Abyss Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Sep 29, 2017 |
786 |
by Pixelbuddha
»»
4 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Made in Abyss Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Sep 1, 2017 |
198 |
by SlightWeeb
»»
Dec 3, 5:11 AM |
|
» Question about Riko's birthplace.TonyStank235 - Jan 6, 2023 |
7 |
by The_critical_Fan
»»
Dec 2, 7:55 AM |
|
Poll: » Made in Abyss Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Jul 21, 2017 |
202 |
by Merra_
»»
Nov 29, 5:06 AM |
|
Poll: » Made in Abyss Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )EasyGo-er - Sep 8, 2017 |
613 |
by Megakarim
»»
Nov 28, 4:24 AM |