DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| This show had good family values like "pray the gay away" and "incest is a sin". It's great to see wholesome Christian entertainment these days. |
| Ok™ |
dotphil said: I really doubt Miyabi is actually his sister, it is still too early in the series to actually find out who it is. Yeah. There is no way they would drop the ball in episode 3 lol. |
| so 3 chicks were practically all over him this time. so uhm just take the reverse trap since there's no way that one is his sister I guess. plus she's hot, and amusing. oh and all 3 girls at some point break into his place. creepy. he has to refrain from banging them despite wanting to since one might be his sister. okay. again his father told him he had to get married, he should be thinking about it! It looks like whether sibling or not he has some past with Miyabi, and he probably pissed her off at the end. The other2 girls should get into it soon to I guess? They made brief appearances, but the sister cafe girl was absent. But uh yeah, no reason not get with the hot reverse trap. |
 |
Billzor said: I didn't really like this episode. Sure the fanservice and all was lovely, but the direction of the episode was just awful. I was actually convinced that everything that happened was just a dream sequence up until half the episode had passed. Then it dawned on me that everything had actually happened and there would be no waking up. Why would the crossdressing Ninja suddenly be all over him, why do Konoe and Miyabi know where he lives, why is the tsundere, shy and distant Miyabi suddenly über forceful and not having any problems getting naked infront of him, with another girl present? There was zero flow from the last episode into this one and everything that happened just felt so random and forced that I just can't do anything other than planting my face firmly on my desk. At the beginning I actually thought it was a dream, but then it just kept going, and I just kind of went with it. I mean, your right, it really had no flow, but it was enjoyable nonetheless. Also, that last scene broke my heart. I like Miyabi, and I want her to end up with him when this ends, so him rejecting her was hard to watch. |
I am a sucker for romance!!!! ] |
| I really thought it was Miyabi from the start but the fact that this is the only 3rd episode and the other girls barely had any screentime i'm not fully calling it just yet. |
 |
| Here's just my .02 Maybe it's just a simple misunderstanding, by all of us. The entire episode she was the "imoto" role. So, maybe she became sad when he said she was his sister because he misunderstood her intentions in being the "imoto" and real affections for him. Kind of like falling into the "friend" loop deal. "We're too good of friends to date." Lol, I dunno. Just trying to give a different take. |
    |
| Dammit! If the imouto called, he would have banged those girls for sure! Such misfortune...well, not really. If I was him I'd bang them for sure. "Bang now, think later" |
MagitoJul 21, 2012 6:21 AM
| The last part has saved this episode |
 |
| And the reverse-trap is the best girl yet again *sigh*. Those two girls sure are lewd, this episode reminded me of an ecchi-light KissxSis OVA. 4/5, had a few laughs. |
| Obviously it's not her, i thought it was miyabi but when he thought it was miyabi i knew i messed up. If he was going to ask a question it should have been did i used to know you or are you my sister so if she denies it he could say just kidding or some crap. i mean seriously, just because someone wants to marry you doesnt mean they are your sister |
 |
| The only reason im still watching is to find out who is damn sister is, im pretty disappointed with anime as a whole. |
 |
| As much as I like fan service (believe me, I do) this is getting terrible. |
| I see a few people doing picture comparison the two rooms, but dont they live in the dorms, last i checked dorm rooms all looked the same |
| "HARD AS A BOSS" is the best tagline for a product of all time. If that really existed it would be flying off shelves faster than you could say 'My sister can't possibly be this troll'. |
 |
| They have been laying the hints that Miyabi is his sister since episode 1. That doesn't mean that she is, just that they want us to believe she is. |
Now blogging at TheZenOf Mysterious Girlfriend X Anime Fan Club - It's about more than drool! Tari Tari Fan Club - Hyouka Fan Club - Chitanda Eru Fans Club~ |
Yumekichi11 said: .... I literally don't see how it is possible for you to write such long posts for every episode of every anime you watch. Like...I can't even. Yumekichi11 said: First proof as a guy's IMO that proves Shougo was a FAG. Any guy would have done them long ago with blood stained cloths and pregnancy.. That was vivid. And off base. Shougo did want to sleep with them. He just didn't want to screw his own sister. Yumekichi11 said: Billzor said: I though it would be due to them having their strings pulled. In other words someone told them on purpose. Someone is seriously sending girls towards Shougo. The mother? Why else would she be in the beginning for other than the obvious.why do Konoe and Miyabi know where he lives? What? That makes like no sense lol. Just because the mom appeared in the first episode doesn't mean she is pulling strings behind the scenes or something. It isn't that outrageous that they just found out where he lives. |
Gar_LoganJul 22, 2012 1:39 AM
| I nominate Mr. X as the sister. (S)he appears out of nowhere, and thus far we only have his/her story to indicate that (s)he is in fact an employee of Shougo's company. If Mr. X really wanted to be helpful (S)he would figure out a way to get a swab from each of the girls for DNA testing using the unlimited resources of the zaibatsu that Shougo will be taking over. The whole thing is pretty fishy if you ask me... Oops, sorry. For a moment I got confused between real life and harem comedy. I'll try not to let it happen again... |
Please don't feed the trolls! In my next life I want to collide at the corner with the cute transfer student carrying a piece of toast in her mouth...rodac |
| "Get married, procreate, cure your homosexuality!" Birth rates in Japan surely will raise with this show... pfffthahaha yeah right. |
| The ecchi for the first half of the episode is just wrong.. How can they get so attached to him to the point of getting naked and sleep with him.. I was surprised they revealed his sister so soon.. I wonder if everything is solved.. It's pretty dumb to ask "Who do you want to marry" since it doesn't prove anything.. Though Miyabi kept quiet when he talked about sibling stuff.. (x.x ) |
| Oh god the "tap that" haters are back :D Seriously? hating on someone that doesnt want to do something he might regret? He has my respect for being able to hold it in like a real man and not go crazy like a pervert, especially in that horny position. |
Awesome Sig by Lailide |
elior1 said: KaitoDash said: I find it hard to believe that this is from LN. I mean, LN plot usually has some certain sense in it. If you know what I mean. BTW, did he jump the gun? They can't possibly conclude the main mystery here, can they? actully this episode cover chapter 4 from the manga I actually read that chapter before watching this and still wasn't fully convinced. Maybe there are something more to it? |
 |
| Okay I'm thinking of starting this series soon but before that I have a question. In the first episode I noticed the cursed black void of censorship wherever a girls skirt was. So by episode 3 has the censorship gotten really ubnoxious or in the way? I don't mind some censorship but sometimes they take it so far they make it hard to see anything at all. So how is this one looking so far? |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Dropped this show about 7.5 minutes into episode 3 (I try to watch the first three episodes of something nowadays before forming a full opinion). Okay, um, no. This show trying to use the idea of homosexual conversion therapy as comedy offends me. Saying that being a siscon is better than being gay is insulting. Fuck this tripe. |
GarLogan78 said: Sure he wanted to do the whole thing. Like you mention it was the whole sister thing. It was more of a moral thing cause genetically he would have to money to make any kind of birth problem fixed in terms of that. The group he owns has millions in domestic product sales. So did the stocks indicate.Yumekichi11 said: First proof as a guy's IMO that proves Shougo was a FAG. Any guy would have done them long ago with blood stained cloths and pregnancy.. That was vivid. And off base. Shougo did want to sleep with them. He just didn't want to screw his own sister. GarLogan78 said: Sure it does, how else would they find out without going through shit piles of troubles? Sure money can be a factor to find him out but I am not sure those 2 girls would do that. Stalking at worst could be another explanation. Still pans out as a big risk taking. MC must totally stupid for not noticing people following him considering his position in society.Yumekichi11 said: Billzor said: I though it would be due to them having their strings pulled. In other words someone told them on purpose. Someone is seriously sending girls towards Shougo. The mother? Why else would she be in the beginning for other than the obvious.why do Konoe and Miyabi know where he lives? What? That makes like no sense lol. Just because the mom appeared in the first episode doesn't mean she is pulling strings behind the scenes or something. It isn't that outrageous that they just found out where he lives. |
Yumekichi11 said: GarLogan78 said: Yumekichi11 said: First proof as a guy's IMO that proves Shougo was a FAG. Any guy would have done them long ago with blood stained cloths and pregnancy.. That was vivid. And off base. Shougo did want to sleep with them. He just didn't want to screw his own sister. Sure he wanted to do the whole thing. Like you mention it was the whole sister thing. It was more of a moral thing cause genetically he would have to money to make any kind of birth problem fixed in terms of that. The group he owns has millions in domestic product sales. So did the stocks indicate. Yeah...that isn't a response to what I said at all. I said that calling him a fag was off base because he did want to sleep with the girls. I wasn't questioning the ethics or the consequences with the company. GarLogan78 said: Sure it does, how else would they find out without going through shit piles of troubles? Sure money can be a factor to find him out but I am not sure those 2 girls would do that. Stalking at worst could be another explanation. Still pans out as a big risk taking. MC must totally stupid for not noticing people following him considering his position in society.Yumekichi11 said: Billzor said: I though it would be due to them having their strings pulled. In other words someone told them on purpose. Someone is seriously sending girls towards Shougo. The mother? Why else would she be in the beginning for other than the obvious.why do Konoe and Miyabi know where he lives? What? That makes like no sense lol. Just because the mom appeared in the first episode doesn't mean she is pulling strings behind the scenes or something. It isn't that outrageous that they just found out where he lives. I agree that people would want to get close to him because his position. I just don't think his own mother is pulling the strings. Mr. X said she didn't want to know anything about the illegitimate child. Also, the company's profits would affect her too...considering she is living off of her husband's fortune and/or the company profits. I just don't see how the mother is the first suspect to the girls finding Shougo's apartment. It doesn't seem that hard to do. (School directory? Asking a teacher?) People drop off homework assignments and such in anime all the time. Also, this anime isn't the most realistic in the first place so I wouldn't jump straight to mother conspiracy. |
GarLogan78 said: Most outlook on males if you don't screw with a girl is bad. In Japan bullying can result in you being chicken to show out your feelings for girls and such problems may surface. Ultimately to justify myself of calling him a FAG is that he showed no determinations of males. In fact he showed what a caveman would not even do. Hence all of this behaviour is really coined as "FAG" in other words incapable to show male viewers a good response. Of course it's all a matter of an IMO being mines.Yumekichi11 said: GarLogan78 said: Yumekichi11 said: First proof as a guy's IMO that proves Shougo was a FAG. Any guy would have done them long ago with blood stained cloths and pregnancy.. That was vivid. And off base. Shougo did want to sleep with them. He just didn't want to screw his own sister. Sure he wanted to do the whole thing. Like you mention it was the whole sister thing. It was more of a moral thing cause genetically he would have to money to make any kind of birth problem fixed in terms of that. The group he owns has millions in domestic product sales. So did the stocks indicate. Yeah...that isn't a response to what I said at all. I said that calling him a fag was off base because he did want to sleep with the girls. I wasn't questioning the ethics or the consequences with the company. GarLogan78 said: GarLogan78 said: Sure it does, how else would they find out without going through shit piles of troubles? Sure money can be a factor to find him out but I am not sure those 2 girls would do that. Stalking at worst could be another explanation. Still pans out as a big risk taking. MC must totally stupid for not noticing people following him considering his position in society.Yumekichi11 said: Billzor said: I though it would be due to them having their strings pulled. In other words someone told them on purpose. Someone is seriously sending girls towards Shougo. The mother? Why else would she be in the beginning for other than the obvious.why do Konoe and Miyabi know where he lives? What? That makes like no sense lol. Just because the mom appeared in the first episode doesn't mean she is pulling strings behind the scenes or something. It isn't that outrageous that they just found out where he lives. GarLogan78 said: Yes but Mr.X has other circumstances that would not make all go smoothly for one she already is in a field where to be found as a female is deadly.I agree that people would want to get close to him because his position. I just don't think his own mother is pulling the strings. Mr. X said she didn't want to know anything about the illegitimate child. Also, the company's profits would affect her too...considering she is living off of her husband's fortune and/or the company profits. GarLogan78 said: Well to put it simple the way she behaved and the way she went about his own place. As in she knows it will be for the sex and mistake of making a kid. She like gave off the feeling of wanting him to do all that. I just don't see how the mother is the first suspect to the girls finding Shougo's apartment. It doesn't seem that hard to do. (School directory? Asking a teacher?) People drop off homework assignments and such in anime all the time. Also, this anime isn't the most realistic in the first place so I wouldn't jump straight to mother conspiracy. Just a notice of behaviour and I happen to have education see that. Psychological behaviour to be exact applied non seriously considering this is entertainment. That being said the mother I think knows more than she lets out TBH. The fact she is not around the series but might pop by later sends out anticipation TBH. |
Yumekichi11 said: ..... You are right. All males want to sleep with their sisters. If they don't they are fags. ~ I don't know what you are trying to say in the other two points...(is English your first language?) |
| I like how one person is trying to use 'fag' in a serious context. gg, MAL. |
| Really? She's his little sister revealed in the 3rd ep? I'm relieved that it wasn't Konoe but I'm still doubtful about Miyabi. She didn't deny it either so... Ikusu at the beginning was great, so direct in her approach! I'm liking her more and more. |
^ me Shougo you scumbag, why do you keep all the cute imoutos with you? Dear god, since when is fucking your little sister better than being gay? Seriously, Japan? And that 'hard as a boss' stuff... Whut. So, is the mystery of the year, 'who's the imouto?' solved? I think it's still too early... This episode annoyed me for some reason... |
| Too early, tl;dr for your spoilers & predictions guys XD anyway, probably a fake :) Also, this anime is too fast paced or lacks a bit of side story. I feel like I missed an episode or two lol |
"Your taste is shit cause you like what I hate. Believe me I have 1000 cartoons that I rated with less than 5."  |
| I WANT INCEST ENDING! |
| Honobono Log - best slice of life short -------------------------------------------- most kawaii loli overlord ---------------------------- Donquixote Doflamingo AMV - Control |
| With only a few hours before the new episode. The preview pics are out. Here is my impression of them. About the preview, looks like the loli teacher has some fun imagination in the spoiler I am curious as to why Konoe’s reaction in the spoiler Mana with the VP will be interesting to see in the spoiler More of Mei is good in the spoiler Konoe’s crying in the spoiler  Shows she knew the MC when she was young. Could she be the sister now? She sure bumps into someone in the spoiler About the fan service, multi points in the list
Still can’t wait to see the MC/Konoe surprise facials in the spoiler  She looks so MOE! Can’t wait to get to that part! Along with that fight in the spoiler What do expect? |
| This episode was great and it was awesome seeing Shougo get tempted by those two like that. I have absolutely no idea how the hell he was able to resist the temptation to do something when there are two topless beauties snuggling next to you. That takes some strong ass will. That ending was definitely a misunderstanding, there's no way they would reveal who the sister is this early on. And aww Miyabi crying like that was hard to watch. That scene when those two girls got thrown out was soooo adorable and so is that toy machine mid point break. |
 |
| Nice episode, I didn't expect this to be animated since there hasn't been any serious echii-shots before. I'm looking forward to more, but I should really watch some other stuff first. |
I almost never read discussions after I made my post, if you want to reply PM me or post on my profile page. |
| LOL@ His face after saying "She didnt' call last night". Priceless. |
  |
| /late. First two minutes... pure gold. |
| Uh, wow! What the holy fuck is with this show??!! Did not expect at all. |
| DAMMIT SHOUGO! Instead of ask her if she's your imouto, you just assume that she is, and tell her that you both can't be married? What's wrong with you? :( Urgh, so no more Tsun-Miyabi? |
 Toshino Kyoko!!! |
| The whole "turning Shougo straight" part was maybe fun for a minute, then it got old. Like really fast. The two girls obsession was mostly annoying. Pretty sure Miyabi isn't his sister. 3/5 Sent with Mal Updater |
| I lol'd at the early morning scene with "Mr. X". Ikusu is clearly taking the matter of marriage too lightly. I can't believe he fell for his little sister's trick, though. The crazy part with Konoe and Miyabi in his room was better explained in the anime than in the manga adaptation, I'll give it that - though it was no less ridiculous and incredible. That lucky bastard, any man would have loved to have his problems that night. So, the mystery identity of his little sister was resolved quite early. Which means that it shouldn't be the primary problem of the story. But it does open the way for supporters of the other girls... personally Konoe gets my support. |
| Actually I disliked this episode and almost dropped the anime, I hate homophobia D: But Miyabi is soo cute that I'll still give this show a chance... Though this doen't look like anything that's meant to be taken seriously, but it might not be a bad thing. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Kono Naka ni Hitori, Imouto ga Iru! Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Uiriamu_Busujima - Jun 28, 2012 |
155 |
by Netbug
»»
Dec 10, 2023 9:10 AM |
|
Poll: » Kono Naka ni Hitori, Imouto ga Iru! Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Sep 27, 2012 |
188 |
by rsc-pl
»»
Jan 6, 2023 9:49 AM |
|
» Season 2Ahmeteemin - Aug 16, 2021 |
5 |
by yveltalkyogre
»»
Dec 30, 2022 7:40 AM |
|
» small questionfricksalot - May 31, 2021 |
13 |
by Rnonsenseguy
»»
Aug 10, 2022 6:43 AM |
|
» What if it turns out they were all his sister!Guts-Valley - Jul 5, 2022 |
8 |
by tmsy
»»
Jul 6, 2022 6:55 PM |