-MEHMET- said: Meusnier said: It will be interesting to see how the system deals with the Spring anime (SAO, Re:Zero, Fate Heaven's Fell, Kaguya - Yahari?), but even more with the Fall anime (SnK and Yakusoku no Neverland). I guess that if it survives having SnK (or another of these titles, but I think that Fate is the only other serious contender) getting into the top 5 anime, it will be safe to assume that it can deal with most attacks and score manipulations. Add Kimetsu no Yaiba Movie and 2nd Season (I'm sure ufotable will make a second season... I hope) too. First season's story was mediocre but KnY's story develops so well in the next arcs. Sure, but I was only mentioning 2020 anime (2nd season of KnY should be released rather next year, right?). But of course, you are right about the KnY movie. |
Might be a bit off-topic but was the english name below the japanese name added just now or was it added a while ago? |
| I'm so glad and thankful to the moderators for this, y'all deserve the world right now! Thank you as always, and keep up the fantastic work! Seeing Chihayafuru 3 being hit savagely and undeservedly like that was seriously disheartening and Ishozoku Reviewers surge right after adding salt to the wound, but I'm glad we're almost back to normal now. Nothing pleases me more than seeing Chihayafuru 3 with the deserved 8.67 score at the moment! Unsurprisingly, a lot of other changes too which I'm really glad to see. MAL is the most trust-able source of anime, manga and everything in between for me, so it's great to know that the scores aren't being tampered with by a third source anymore. Totally wasn't expecting this to be today, of all days. But thanks for making my day! Edit: Violet Evergarden Gaiden with the little rise is highly appreciable too! |
_MushiRock11_Feb 12, 2020 3:08 AM
#Anime4Life be my Life Motto! #PrayForKyoAni  |
| It's sad though that the actual score for Nogi Wakaba before the mass upvote for lesser known manga is 8.51. Now it is 8.24. I hope it get to the place it belong to. |
 Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
gamers12 said: If we notify accounts that are marked as illegitimate, then it becomes very easy for a malicious user to determine how to make the 1,000 accounts they create look like legitimate users. To have a stronger defence system, transparency has to be reduced.It feels as if it could become shadow banning. Are you making any notification to those users whose score doesn't count? I don't use bots, but I want to be safe and sure that I'm not shadow banned. I understand your effort but that could go to other extreme and final score will be solely made by MAL and user input would matter even less. gamers12 said: If we do that, a malicious user can make 10 accounts on a small member scored entry and tweak the account until their 10 accounts are added. All must be included everywhere but the score itself.Another suggestion to MAL. If they are not counting someones vote then they should be removed from user count on that vote. MagwitchOo said: Back-to-back announcements today :)Might be a bit off-topic but was the english name below the japanese name added just now or was it added a while ago? https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1824702 |
| Well, I'm happy to see that MAL was actually working on a fix. The frustration I felt when I couldn't report troll accounts and saw Joe 2's score (between others) being nuked in the process pissed me off so hard. RIP Pingu tho lol, we all knew it was being meme upvoted since it started, but I still think it's a really good short q_q |
 |
gamers12 said: They said they won't change the stats anymore so people don't understand how the formula works.I used two methods (basically both were the same). I'll try to describe. A | B | C | D Score | People voted | % | 10 | 58380 | 76,8% | 7,68 9 | 3141 | 4,1% | 0,37 8 | 3503 | 4,6% | 0,37 7 | 3095 | 4,1% | 0,29 6 | 1421 | 1,9% | 0,11 5 | 759 | 1,0% | 0,05 4 | 445 | 0,6% | 0,02 3 | 302 | 0,4% | 0,01 2 | 322 | 0,4% | 0,01 1 | 4615 | 6,1% | 0,06 sum of B =75983 Final scroe= 8,98 C=B/sum of B % D=C*B Final score = sum of D It's piss easy to understand though, so there's that. It obviously kills any scoring from 1 to 10, on accounts that aren't veterans (longer than X days) and/or don't have enough anime voted. Time gating might work if you're here just to frustrate your members. |
Play League of Legends here! Autocrat said: Hitler was good, objectively. |
| I think the top 50 most popular animes should also be looked into. SNK s1 and SAO s1 scores are reducing for the past few days. |
| SAO PROGRESSIVE ANIME HYPE |
| LOGH is back at the top 10. Finally. |
TheFirmSword said: Such a pity I can guarantee you this still doesn't change anything. MAL ratings are still irrelevant. And the change in the top and some other few anime doesn't matter and no one cares. People with legit accounts still will continue to influence the score. So instead of recounting those stupid scores please improve on basis of how a anime should be scored. I wonder how this post isn't repeated more. The ratings haven't mattered in the long time I have (not) used MAL. gamers12 said: -MEHMET- said: Stats aren't changed mate, the only change happened on the weighted scores. You can't calculate the scores by using stats anymore. Then they should remove that Stats page all together if stats doesn't reflect score any more. It becomes confusing. When I made same calculation earlier my score was almost the same as in MAL calculation. Users won't be able to trust any score anymore. Usually for me any anime over 7 turned out to be good to watch. Some times I liked anime with score 6. Now it will become similar to "Rotten tomatoes" site, where for bad shows "critics" put high scores. It is easy to go towards downward spiral. Do you (edit:or think general people) really use Rotten tomatoes to gauge if you will watch something? Perhaps if you use some automation and go through a rankings list and then sorting is done, but with the volume of media (all types) coming out, the ratings absolutely do not matter except for being just part of data. (e.g. Machine Learning Recommendations) Plus, the prizes that carry fame and fortune are NOT tied to MAL rankings explicitly. (i.e. Bluray sales, Seiyuu Awards, etc.) EDIT: I noticed you say that you generally enjoy Anime rated 7 and above - it only means that your taste is highly similar to a very 'generic' person on MAL. Also, it's not only 'critics' that rate what they believe to be underrated highly - many people go against the grain and are not 'critics.' |
ZmffkskemFeb 12, 2020 3:42 AM
 「みんながいるからだ。」 － 棗鈴 |
| @Zmffkskem Actually, if there's a dissonance in critic reviews and user reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, you can gauge if you should watch it or not. E.g. higher critic score than user score? Clearly not to be watched unless you're part of the current Hollywood politics. Opposite? Then it's more of a classic film that people enjoy, but the critics need to put down for money and politics. Equal? Harder to gauge, most likely OK though. It would be nice to have that on MAL. It'll be very easy to gauge if "Reviewers" are taking into consideration what genres they're reviewing and aren't the usual "it's ecchi, it's trash" types. I mean, I sometimes look at reviews to see something like "This comedy that was meant only to be about gags is trash because it's lacking character development and a story.". Like, what are you on about? You need to assume the purpose of what you watch before you try to claim a "certain quality". |
Play League of Legends here! Autocrat said: Hitler was good, objectively. |
Immahnoob said: @Zmffkskem Actually, if there's a dissonance in critic reviews and user reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, you can gauge if you should watch it or not. E.g. higher critic score than user score? Clearly not to be watched unless you're part of the current Hollywood politics. Opposite? Then it's more of a classic film that people enjoy, but the critics need to put down for money and politics. Equal? Harder to gauge, most likely OK though. It would be nice to have that on MAL. It'll be very easy to gauge if "Reviewers" are taking into consideration what genres they're reviewing and aren't the usual "it's ecchi, it's trash" types. I mean, I sometimes look at reviews to see something like "This comedy that was meant only to be about gags is trash because it's lacking character development and a story.". Like, what the fuck? A two-label (or 4?) classification algorithm (i.e. did 'critics' like it? did 'general public' like it?) is fairly terrible in deciding what to watch given that there are so many nuances to media. From what you write about reviews, it's clear you and that specific reviewer don't have quite the same priorities. I certainly don't care about 'character development' as commonly written in reviews, and honestly any one attesting to 'character development' means little to my own enjoyment. This is just one of many examples of how not to look for relevant data in terms of finding the next show to watch. A much better approach is to use a Netflix-style/Amazon-shopping recommendation mechanism. I'm not sure if all the other sites that measure user similarity have been disallowed/banned, but if they aren't then any user is more likely to get good recommendations by checking similar users than reading reviews. |
「みんながいるからだ。」 － 棗鈴 |
| Well tbh this was pretty fun mess to watch and see how cancerous some people can be. |
 |
| lol great work MAL finally some development going on again |
| Great work, I appreciate it. I didn't expect Symphogear XV to be also affected, but at least the score didn't change much. |
| You're a louse, Roger Smith. - R. Dorothy Wayneright This is my fight! No Senpai, this is our fight! - Kojou Akatsuki & Yukina Himeragi  |
gamers12 said: [...] So what if I'm 'generic'? I enjoy many anime. So will you say that your taste is so sophisticated that only your opinion should matter? Why I made comparison with "Rotten tomatoes"? Usually I wasn't wrong with MAL scores. By score itself I already knew what to expect. I wasn't disappointed. I haven't used "Rotten tomatoes" but I have seen how scores are manipulated there. At the end tastes - score - are different for everyone. One likes something other don't. Like I haven't watched Yaoi, Yuri. I don't like those types of anime (stories). I'm not going out of my way to down vote that, just because I don't like them. If you enjoy many anime, then why should you care about the ratings themselves? Does an anime being in 200 or 2000 slot really change the enjoyment of the anime to you? You are still free to watch from large portions of seasonal anime, much of which also don't have fixed ranks anyway. If you are searching amongst older titles, does it really matter to you what anime you watch if you enjoy them? If you will watch most of them, does the order matter to you? If somehow any of the questions you answer 'yes,' then somehow the ratings on MAL matter to you. But they are all 'no' to me, especially when I can more finely look out for what to watch when the ratings become secondary rather than being the primary reason to watch things. |
「みんながいるからだ。」 － 棗鈴 |
| There's not really that much change actually Still think shows like Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu should be higher though, same for some Gintama Some other animes like Mo Dao Zu Shi or Aria (which had a lot of 1s) didn't have any change in their score (but they're not in the top 50 so I guess they haven't been updated yet) |
| Thanks for ur work on this. And sorry for contributing to the 50+ pages thread xd I was hoping for bit more change in top 50, would been fun. But I don't think the top 50 were inaccurate representation of what people rate high so I wasn't expected much change. Glad that Chihayahafuru 3 finally has justice. I don't have to feel bad anymore for rating it 7 and kinda dragging it down too. Hopefully this system is able to battle vote manipulation for a while at least. Couldn't have been easy to implement. |
| Thank you for this! I didnt even watch chihayafuru yet but seeing it going back to true score made my day. :) |
| Thank you for all the hard work! Kineta you really managed to do it! I'm so happy for you and for this community in general. Hopefully the YouTubers that started it are going to drop their "act of good will" now and not escalate it again. |
Fortune favours the bold!  |
Mattinator95 said: The formula will work for everything. Will all anime / manga etc get a score adjustment in the next 7 days or is it just for the top 50 |
Play League of Legends here! Autocrat said: Hitler was good, objectively. |
gamers12 said: Like with Ishuzoku Reviewers I calculated score and it should be 8,98 but it is 7.56 now. It clearly shows artificial manipulation. That is even worse than it was before. You need to read the opening post by the mod again. This is addressed. Mattinator95 said: Will all anime / manga etc get a score adjustment in the next 7 days or is it just for the top 50 This is addressed in the opening post. |
| https://myanimelist.net/profile/SirZechs77 Another illegitimate/duplicate account. |
 |
It's hillarious how the very first replies to this topic are from MAL staff congratulating MAL staff for their work |
 |
| Thank you moderators. Honestly, the whole thing was kinda funny, but that fun quickly turned into a toxic mess. |
Seitaro11 said: It's hillarious how the very first replies to this topic are from MAL staff congratulating MAL staff for their work [img]https://i.imgur.com/gadws25.jpg[ /img] those staff aren't in charge of this stuff so it's not that surprising lol |
Still it's weird. Just like when Sony awarded tLoU as game of the decade, even though Sony was the one who published it. Of course people that chose this game aren't the same that worked on this game, but it's still pretty huge boasting, just like in here |
|
| I want to see what are the worst shows after this mostly than the good ones. Lol But good job on the staff of this site. |
Seitaro11 said: Still it's weird. Just like when Sony awarded tLoU as game of the decade, even though Sony was the one who published it. Of course people that chose this game aren't the same that worked on this game, but it's still pretty huge boasting, just like in here Well, I wouldn't say boasting, but more like celebrating. Whenever I finish a big project at work, I compliment my peers and celebrate with them. Don't see anything wrong with that. |
 |
Seitaro11 said: It's hillarious how the very first replies to this topic are from MAL staff congratulating MAL staff for their work It's hilarious how most ones who are complaining either have a low post count, joined recently, have no avatar or a combination of those. |
Skittles said: It's great and all, but the fact that there's not one staffer that isn't against this change is rather telling. Seitaro11 said: Still it's weird. Just like when Sony awarded tLoU as game of the decade, even though Sony was the one who published it. Of course people that chose this game aren't the same that worked on this game, but it's still pretty huge boasting, just like in here Well, I wouldn't say boasting, but more like celebrating. Whenever I finish a big project at work, I compliment my peers and celebrate with them. Don't see anything wrong with that. Gator said: Elitism, huh? See, I'm older than you here, you should be really careful.Seitaro11 said: It's hillarious how the very first replies to this topic are from MAL staff congratulating MAL staff for their work It's hilarious how most ones who are complaining either have a low post count, joined recently, have no avatar or a combination of those. |
Play League of Legends here! Autocrat said: Hitler was good, objectively. |
Connortit said: Meusnier said: is the fate movie going to be that good im not trying to say its bad i just havent kept up with it since seeing the 2nd movieIt will be interesting to see how the system deals with the Spring anime (SAO, Re:Zero, Fate Heaven's Fell, Kaguya - Yahari?), but even more with the Fall anime (SnK and Yakusoku no Neverland). I guess that if it survives having SnK (or another of these titles, but I think that Fate is the only other serious contender) getting into the top 5 anime, it will be safe to assume that it can deal with most attacks and score manipulations. Its considered to be the best Fate route by many and it will have even more flashy action scenes than the previous two movies (which were also high quality). I'm sure it will get a high rating. |
Gator said: Seitaro11 said: It's hillarious how the very first replies to this topic are from MAL staff congratulating MAL staff for their work It's hilarious how most ones who are complaining either have a low post count, joined recently, have no avatar or a combination of those. I have an avatar on MAL, just it doesn't display on the forum for some reason. And it never troubled me enough to look and fix it Edit: Also I don't see how not having an avatar correlates with being "complaining type" Edit2: I don't see where exactly I'm complaining. I said that it's hillarious. "It made me laugh, so I decided to complain about it. HOW dare they make me laugh!?" |
Seitaro11Feb 12, 2020 5:41 AM
|
| I don't post on forums that much but I want to say, you guys are doing god's work! This is amazing news |
| Good job and thanks for your work :) |
  I will show no mercy for you You had no mercy for me The only thing that I ask Love me mercilessly |
| No more ranting about troll down votes by alts. Sweet.~☆♡ |
 サディスティックな考え "JUST KILL ME." サディスティックマインド |
LogicalPoint said: Care to mention why you threatened Chibi, Nux, LP, RGE, Animoe, and SDE? Care to back up that claim with any instance of that being done? |
More topics from this board
» MAL Yearbook 2024: Brainstorming Sessiontingy - Dec 23 |
12 |
by LittleStar
»»
7 hours ago |
|
» New Page! Manga Adapted to Anime ( 1 2 )Kineta - Dec 9 |
55 |
by cpebora
»»
Today, 2:15 AM |
|
» MAL Game "Fantasy Anime League" Opens for Fall 2024 ( 1 2 3 4 )Kineta - Sep 12 |
157 |
by tokomata
»»
Today, 1:40 AM |
|
» MAL Secret Santa 2024 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kineta - Nov 17 |
258 |
by DeadlyRaven
»»
Yesterday, 10:23 AM |
|
» [Update May 24] Interest Stacks: New feature for custom theme lists and challenges ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Kineta - Apr 6, 2022 |
209 |
by okwhynot
»»
Dec 22, 6:36 AM |