| Madhouse made Overlord. Nuff said. |
 |
| Their adaptation of Chaos;Head is generally panned and regarded as a poor treatment of the visual novel. |
 |
| I didn't think you were serious but you actually did it, haha |
| Overlord Opm Mahouka Highschool of the Dead Btooom! Hellsing Ultimate you want more? |
 |
| Of course, some stuff here and there back then even in their good old days and most of the stuff they've made recently (specially if they don't plan to make Chihayafuru's season 3 a reality) , from the horrific Chaos;head to the insulting NGNL. |
 |
| Every studio has their bad anime. Madhouse had Mahou Sensou and Mahouka just one season apart in 2014, for instance. While Mahouka's quality is polarizing, I think most will agree that Mahou Sensou is just... well, a terrible anime, and that was by Madhouse. I'm sure there are a lot more, but I've not seen seen them personally. A studio with so many titles is bound to have its black sheep(s). |
| Lots of "good anime" from madhouse have their quality coming from the source material rather than from the anime itself. As an anime studio they aren't that great ImO. Lots of blunders, and the like. Look at what happens when the source isn't good : you get the disaster that is Mahou sensou. A source that was already doubtful to be good rushed so much that it became a ridiculously incomprehensible train-wreck. Ironically Madhouse fanboys will always dismiss cases such as mahou sensou saying it's the fault of the source material and only of the source material, but will still praise Madhouse as being responsible when they adapt good source material. Suddenly when the anime is good, the source material isn't responsible for it being good. it's only when it's bad. That's so cute. Don't get me wrong , they REALLY did very good stuff tho. But they did a shit tons of anime, so that's to be expected, in a way. Madhouse's anime currently airing (Alderamin) has ALL of its strength coming from the original material. ALL of it. And all of what peoples complain about comes from the anime. |
ZefyrisAug 27, 2016 5:01 AM
 |
| No Game No Life and Overlord. ................... |
 |
| Madhouse's adadaptation of Mahouka is pretty terrible. Pretty much one of the most boring anime I ever watched. |
| Just like every other studio in existence, yes, they also have bad anime. Examples: Mahou Sensou, Chaos;Head and Prince of Stride: Alternative. |
| Every anime they ever made!! (except NGNL) |
 |
| ngnl chaos;head overlord too many to mention, I heard they do suck at imagination, they just make a carbon copy out of their adaptations. |
| Yes Madhouse is not the all powerful Overlord that people think it is. Don't me get wrong they've produced a lot of good stuff, but with the departure of a lot of their key staff over the years they kinda hit a bump. |
 |
| Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei, most boring anime from madhouse seriously, fell asleep multiple times trying to watch this and i'm not even joking. |
 |
| Mahouka, obviously. It's not even a contest, Mahouka wins by default. The original ending they gave to Claymore was also horrible. |
 |
| Cardcaptor Sakura, Claymore, Mahou Sensou, Perfect Blue and many others. |
  |
| I don't know, maybe just... every one of their light novel adaptations? Yeah. |
| Yup , theres No game no life . #30char |
| Chaos;Head was a very weak adaptation of the visual novel. It had all the makings of a terrible anime including but not limited to rushed ending, poor development, leaving out explanations etc. |
 |
Idiots_on_MAL said: Madhouse made Overlord. Nuff said. TheKillerAngel said: Their adaptation of Chaos;Head is generally panned and regarded as a poor treatment of the visual novel. I fully approve of these comments. Zefyris said: Lots of "good anime" from madhouse have their quality coming from the source material rather than from the anime itself. As an anime studio they aren't that great ImO. Lots of blunders, and the like. Look at what happens when the source isn't good : you get the disaster that is Mahou sensou. A source that was already doubtful to be good rushed so much that it became a ridiculously incomprehensible train-wreck. Ironically Madhouse fanboys will always dismiss cases such as mahou sensou saying it's the fault of the source material and only of the source material, but will still praise Madhouse as being responsible when they adapt good source material. Suddenly when the anime is good, the source material isn't responsible for it being good. it's only when it's bad. That's so cute. Don't get me wrong , they REALLY did very good stuff tho. But they did a shit tons of anime, so that's to be expected, in a way. Madhouse's anime currently airing (Alderamin) has ALL of its strength coming from the original material. ALL of it. And all of what peoples complain about comes from the anime. I don't think Mahou Sensou is that much of a 'bad production' as much as it is a bad adaptation. I think they knew there wasn't much value in the work so when adapting it they just made it a rushed commercial and ended it there. I haven't watched Alderamin yet, but doesn't that still mean they managed to translate it over to the anime medium without taking away anything from the source? Or do you mean that the only good things about it are what was retained from the source? Plenty of studios take away good things from the source, so keeping the good parts from being lost when moving into a different medium and thus (usually) making those strong parts work in this new medium is enough for me to call a studio good. I agree with you that you should never generalize or avoid acknowledging failures the way some people do though, don't get me wrong. How've you been btw? |
Rinth said: Every opinion is not equal. Some opinions are simply made out of shit. nasuverse > your favorite anime |
tragedydesu said: Overlord Opm Mahouka Highschool of the Dead Btooom! Hellsing Ultimate you want more? Nahh dude, u just have shit taste :s As for the thread itself, just call every Madhouse adaption shit and off you go :) |
| I think OVERLORD is the worst anime that MAD HOUSE, it have very weak and generic story. But Mad house is my favorite production house,I always anticipating an masterpiece form Mad house ,most of my favorite anime like death note,hunter x hunter,Parasyte,monster,wolf children,no game no life,....are from Mad house. |
| Madhouse hate in this thread is kinda weak....losers |
 |
tragedydesu said: Overlord Opm Mahouka Highschool of the Dead Btooom! Hellsing Ultimate you want more? Why do so many people hate on Btooom!...? I'm up for hearing your opinion on it :P |
  WORK IN PROGRESS ~The frog leapt forth to my lilypad memory.~ I was indoctrinated by an inamorata rabbit, Adenomata affronted. It was the verecund, dismissed creatures That I jubilated in most. This rabbit I would nurture, At the aiguille of esse, The anneal of noblesse. ❤️ Birdie ❤️ |
| Fuck Madhouse, they're overrated as shit, all of the shit I've seen from them has just been "animated manga" or "light novels but with arm movement instead of monolouging" or fucking whatever. Tatami Galaxy is the only thing I've seen from them that didn't do that, cause not only does Tatami have a bunch of awesome shit about it, I heard that it's actually different from the novel(correct me if I'm wrong.) I'm hoping that the Satoshi Kon stuff is going to be as good as Wolf Children was, so they would atleast make good movies. Anyways, Madhouse is overr8, praise Gainax. |
| every single one of my forum posts is dumb and invalid except for 1, I don't claim them it was a different person it was all fake |
Senpaoi said: I don't think he even cares too much about his own thread, ever since he didn't post again and didn't specify much, besides mentioning that other one that back again, wasn't asking for popularity as only you interpret. Lordwen said: Of course, some stuff here and there back then even in their good old days and most of the stuff they've made recently (specially if they don't plan to make Chihayafuru's season 3 a reality) , from the horrific Chaos;head to the insulting NGNL. I don't think the OP was asking for opinion, nobody cares about it... NGNL was extremely successful. Their success rate is something like 25% though. Can't say that's good. As far as opinion goes, sometimes is less depressing than facts! There's way too many people aroused by little girls and stories trying to run away from reality instead of getting a grasp of it - even if from an innovative angle. |
|
| I don't think it is that bad overall, I still was able to like it, but particularly the animation in Magical Nyan Nyan Taruto is often poor. MAL lists it as : Madhouse + TNK |
| *darn, using my right hand is off-limits for a while. Typing with my left hand only is ... eww.* |
| HotD - One of the most wretched anime I have ever seen. Vizioz said: Perfect Blue Leave now...leave and never come back. RainyRai said: I'm hoping that the Satoshi Kon stuff is going to be as good as Wolf Children was, so they would atleast make good movies. I don't think any of Satoshi Kon's movies are as good as Wolf Children but they are still excellent. RainyRai said: Anyways, Madhouse is overr8, praise Gainax. Agreed, all must bow down before the clearly superior nonsense of Gainax. |
Bobby2HandsAug 27, 2016 6:50 AM
 |
YaoiMaster said: tragedydesu said: Overlord Opm Mahouka Highschool of the Dead Btooom! Hellsing Ultimate you want more? Why do so many people hate on Btooom!...? I'm up for hearing your opinion on it :P Creepy rapists multiple times per episode, characters that make zero sense, shitty distasteful fanservice during the rape scenes, and a non-ending to top it all off. |
|
tragedydesu said: Creepy rapists multiple times per episode, characters that make zero sense, shitty distasteful fanservice during the rape scenes, and a non-ending to top it all off. Good point XD. I hated the ending. //30 characters// |
WORK IN PROGRESS ~The frog leapt forth to my lilypad memory.~ I was indoctrinated by an inamorata rabbit, Adenomata affronted. It was the verecund, dismissed creatures That I jubilated in most. This rabbit I would nurture, At the aiguille of esse, The anneal of noblesse. ❤️ Birdie ❤️ |
| They're animes are not bad but their typical 12 ep animes are what gives them the bad image, thats why people when seeing a new madhouse anime dont expect it to have a good long story. |
 |
| Guess people have never tried that Maplestory anime or the marvel anime by them. Mahou Sensou is a pretty popular pick for being their worst though. |
Paul said: Guess people have never tried that Maplestory anime or the marvel anime by them. Mahou Sensou is a pretty popular pick for being their worst though. I saw the Iron Man anime (oh hey I even forgot to add it to my list, gonna do that now) and Black Widow vs Punisher. Yeah they weren't very good (particularly Iron Man) oh yeah, and there's also Devil May Cry, that sucked too. |
|
| mahouka I assure you watch this and it will answer your question |
RainyRai said: Out of the two Satoshi Kon movies I've watched, one of them (Perfect Blue) beats all of Hosada's work combinedFuck Madhouse, they're overrated as shit, all of the shit I've seen from them has just been "animated manga" or "light novels but with arm movement instead of monolouging" or fucking whatever. Tatami Galaxy is the only thing I've seen from them that didn't do that, cause not only does Tatami have a bunch of awesome shit about it, I heard that it's actually different from the novel(correct me if I'm wrong.) I'm hoping that the Satoshi Kon stuff is going to be as good as Wolf Children was, so they would atleast make good movies. Anyways, Madhouse is overr8, praise Gainax. |
|
amk_2397 said: RainyRai said: Out of the two Satoshi Kon movies I've watched, one of them (Perfect Blue) beats all of Hosada's work combinedFuck Madhouse, they're overrated as shit, all of the shit I've seen from them has just been "animated manga" or "light novels but with arm movement instead of monolouging" or fucking whatever. Tatami Galaxy is the only thing I've seen from them that didn't do that, cause not only does Tatami have a bunch of awesome shit about it, I heard that it's actually different from the novel(correct me if I'm wrong.) I'm hoping that the Satoshi Kon stuff is going to be as good as Wolf Children was, so they would atleast make good movies. Anyways, Madhouse is overr8, praise Gainax. I love both Kon and Hosoda, but In my opinion Wolf Children is better than any Kon movie. |
|
Prathmesh31 said: I think OVERLORD is the worst anime that MAD HOUSE, it have very weak and generic story. Overlord's story is too slow, but it is by no means generic. Don't throw around words whose meaning you don't know. I see your "Mahou Sensou", and raise "Abenobashi Mahou☆Shoutengai", meaningless and merciless. And not funny enough to work. I could not endure Di Gi Charat long enough to comment about it much, but it was notably bad. Overlord: Ple Ple Pleiades series of specials is probably the worst. Way worse than specials to Chuu2Koi in the other thread. |
| Mahou Sensou ................................................................................................... |
 |
Vizioz said: Cardcaptor Sakura, Claymore, Mahou Sensou, Perfect Blue and many others.  OT: I used to think Madhouse was an all-powerful studio who did no wrong, but they have actually been growing worse lately. A better studio for this topic could be Ufotable or Ghibli. |
 |
| Is this even a question? They have so many bad anime. Madhouse is quite possibly the worst animation studio of all time. They have so many garbage series under their profile it's astounding. Photo Kano, mahou sensou, mahouka, marvel anime, hotd, chaos;head & the list goes on & on. Not to mention how grossly overrated hxh2011 is as an adaptation, when hxh99 does everything so much better. Why even such an obviously bad studio has so much popularity & acclaim behind it is beyond me. |
| Imagine a berserk anime by Yoshiaki kawajiri at Madhouse. Now take a look at Berserk (2016). YOU HAVE MY PERMISSION TO CRY. |
| other than a bunch of those mentioned, i didn't like Kami sama ga inai nichiyoubi.. guess it falls under the light novel category ?_? |
 |
JetNoir said: Is this even a question? They have so many bad anime. Madhouse is quite possibly the worst animation studio of all time. They have so many garbage series under their profile it's astounding. Photo Kano, mahou sensou, mahouka, marvel anime, hotd, chaos;head & the list goes on & on. Not to mention how grossly overrated hxh2011 is as an adaptation, when hxh99 does everything so much better. Why even such an obviously bad studio has so much popularity & acclaim behind it is beyond me. Madhouse studio is a very prolific studio and in many ways are like prolific voice actors. When you have so many anime/VO roles there will always be garbage in your resume (everyone needs to make a living and sometimes you can't push the boat out and take chances) But still the overall bulk of Madhouse's work leans more towards quality than crap. |
|
JetNoir said: they have so many great series under their profile it's astoundingIs this even a question? They have so many bad anime. Madhouse is quite possibly the worst animation studio of all time. They have so many garbage series under their profile it's astounding. Photo Kano, mahou sensou, mahouka, marvel anime, hotd, chaos;head & the list goes on & on. Not to mention how grossly overrated hxh2011 is as an adaptation, when hxh99 does everything so much better. Why even such an obviously bad studio has so much popularity & acclaim behind it is beyond me. monster, death note, hajime no ippo, all the satoshi kon stuff, nana, trigun, death parade, black lagoon, and so on they made so many good stuff, from all sorts of genres, both in percentage and absolute numbers, that you'd have to try hard to not like at least one of their shows but given it's the studio with the highest weighted score by far on your malgraph i cant help but think i have been baited, in which case 8/8 gr8 sir |
|
Bobby2Hands said: Ohhhh them's fighting words buddy amk_2397 said: Out of the two Satoshi Kon movies I've watched, one of them (Perfect Blue) beats all of Hosada's work combined I love both Kon and Hosoda, but In my opinion Wolf Children is better than any Kon movie.  Jokes. Like no disrespect to Wolf Children but for me Perfect Blue does many things right that I see in high regard. One of those being having both really good horror AND a really good story/characters. Plus I'm a sucker for media that analyses pop culture. CheekyKunt said: Meh with ufotable they don't really have many known works outside of The Garden of Sinners and the Fate series aside from God Eater and Tales of Zesteria. Maybe like Kyoto Ani, Bones or J.C. Staff.Vizioz said: Cardcaptor Sakura, Claymore, Mahou Sensou, Perfect Blue and many others. OT: I used to think Madhouse was an all-powerful studio who did no wrong, but they have actually been growing worse lately. A better studio for this topic could be Ufotable or Ghibli. |
|
More topics from this board
» Has using MAL made you enjoy anime less?Dragevard - 1 hour ago |
1 |
by AllAlone8
»»
15 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Retro (1970-2000) vs Modern (2001+)HusbandosVabbingSips - 15 minutes ago |
0 |
by VabbingSips
»»
15 minutes ago |
|
» About Horror Anime...KMIR - 3 hours ago |
8 |
by MadanielFL
»»
21 minutes ago |
|
» Riddle me this: If anime really is mainstream... ( 1 2 )thewiru - Oct 6 |
51 |
by chronofantasy
»»
1 hour ago |
|
» How to make your social-media algorithms send you posts about the seasonal anime you're watching?thewiru - Yesterday |
26 |
by JaniSIr
»»
1 hour ago |