Cardcaptor Sakura: Clear Card
| I personally love Card-hen a lot. The things is, that it does have the same charm and beautiful atmosphere like the Original first season. In my opinion, the second season is already too good already and I like it, that it's not too different or too similar. |
 I will not believe that everything is controlled by fate. ll X ll |
| I am not disapointed. But which is the point to show the same thing that we saw before? Sakura catched all cards, then she transformed them in Sakura cards. And now, again she is capturing the cards. I was hoping to a new story, not watching Sakura catching cards again. |
| I completely agree with all the points made, and I'd like to add the mystery is PAINFULLY obvious I haven't read the manga but I think it's obvious that Also not a fan of the new visuals, the original CCS looks great with the cel animation and is like the most comfortable thing ever but the digital animation doesn't do it for me. |
QueenNothingFeb 17, 2018 2:58 AM
| I mostly just want something to justify why it exists tbh, it's pretty much exactly the same as always but less interesting since the new "plot" is meh, the original was already fine as it was and there was no need for a sequel. |
 |
minimiau said: I am not disapointed. But which is the point to show the same thing that we saw before? Sakura catched all cards, then she transformed them in Sakura cards. And now, again she is capturing the cards. I was hoping to a new story, not watching Sakura catching cards again. Well the show is called Cardcaptors. So it would be odd if she wasn't at least doing that. As for me I'm fine with the show. It looks like, sounds good, and nothing makes me want to hate the show. When I watched Sailor Moon Crystal I hated it. CCS I just don't feel that way. The one thing I do miss is that Sakura seem's to be able to catch the cards much easier and none of them seem to have destroy vibe. Not to mention Sakura just get's close to the cards and catches it. She had to do more planing to even get the cards. I'll admit it's not a perfect show, but I still enjoy it. |
| Sakura has always been overrated here on MAL because most people gave it a high score because they remember they loved it as a kid. I rewatched the show last year because of this new season and I found myself laughing at many of the stories and character interactions: it is a solid 5/10 for me. Now due to this high as f- score people think they are supposed to treat this as a masterpiece. No. The characters are as simple as they can be, this was originally a kids' show: the show that appealed to us, KIDS of that time, a lot. This is most likely simply a nostalgia-bomb, it never was intended to be something very good storytelling or characterization-wise. |
 |
| You guys may not realized this but maybe you all just outgrown the show. So far from what I've seen is that the anime has stayed true to its format: a slice of life magical girl genre. Like its previous arcs, it introduced a new character via the transfer student e.g. Shaoran & Eriol, Sakura is still capturing cards per episode like she used to. The only thing some might consider disappointing is the Tomoyo x Sakura shippers, the anime is really pushing the Sakura x Shaoran home. The writers have so far avoided any yao and yuri undertones and also written off Rika who was having an implied relationship back then with an adult male teacher. |
Janethan23Feb 20, 2018 10:18 PM
| "Manga readers are annoying, all they do is complain or spoil the anime we discuss in an anime forum. They should really do their whining at manga forums. USERS ON MY IGNORED LIST: RayReynolds - SSL443 - Dr4kon - Nerdanimefan1992 - ToTheMountains - Fiveskies To add users to the Ignore list: (1) Go to Account settings (2) Click Forum tab and toggle down (3) Type or paste user name on entry box (4) Click Add and you're done. Problem solved, you'll never have to see someone trolling ever again because their post will be closed/collapsed. |
Autumne said: I have to say I'm in the same boat. I've been enjoying thinking a lot about how because of their unique experiences, these kids all act a LOT older than the 10 to 12 they'd be, but the show itself tends to be a bit dull. Additionally, I think the art/animation of the original show was a little more dynamic, whereas this animation feels a little bit more flat in its expressive quality. I do think the new cards are unique, though. I find the fact they're clear genuinely intriguing and I'd love to know who's behind the mask... ...I think what this show could really benefit from if it's gonna have this slower pace is a few more moments where the characters themselves are bothered by the mystery. Any scenes we get where the characters linger on the problems of their situation are very, very short. I really hope it picks up steam as it continues. I want to love this continuation, too. People were just expecting too much, S1 was 8 for me at the time, currently reading the manga for S1 and it is also an 8, same for Clear Hen. It is more of a nostalgia bomb than anything else and it suceeds at being very entertainable for the most part, aside those overused jokes with the kid fooling Sakura and Li around. Nostalgik said: Sakura has always been overrated here on MAL because most people gave it a high score because they remember they loved it as a kid. I rewatched the show last year because of this new season and I found myself laughing at many of the stories and character interactions: it is a solid 5/10 for me. Now due to this high as f- score people think they are supposed to treat this as a masterpiece. No. The characters are as simple as they can be, this was originally a kids' show: the show that appealed to us, KIDS of that time, a lot. This is most likely simply a nostalgia-bomb, it never was intended to be something very good storytelling or characterization-wise. I agree with 90% of what you said, aside the rating, it is okay not to give this anime 9 and 10's, I fully admit it I would have had a much harder time getting into this series IF I have never had some context with it in the past, and that is alright for me, it is fine. |
 |
Bluekirby2 said: I completely agree with all the points made, and I'd like to add the mystery is PAINFULLY obvious I haven't read the manga but I think it's obvious that Also not a fan of the new visuals, the original CCS looks great with the cel animation and is like the most comfortable thing ever but the digital animation doesn't do it for me. On the visuals I agree, they are cute but I favor more the originals, besides almost everyone looks way younger now, and that is just weird, older design were better. |
|
Janethan23 said: I didn't outgrow the show, I didn't watch it until last yearYou guys may not realized this but maybe you all just outgrown the show. So far from what I've seen is that the anime has stayed true to its format: a slice of life magical girl genre. Like its previous arcs, it introduced a new character via the transfer student e.g. Shaoran & Eriol, Sakura is still capturing cards per episode like she used to. The only thing some might consider disappointing is the Tomoyo x Sakura shippers, the anime is really pushing the Sakura x Shaoran home. The writers have so far avoided any yao and yuri undertones and also written off Rika who was having an implied relationship back then with an adult male teacher. |
| I'm seeing such a ridiculous reaction towards this anime and also towards the original as well. What were your expectations from an anime aimed at little girls? It's "slice of life" which explains the show pacing and over indulgence of fluffs. The "magical girl" aspect of this anime are mostly secondary and happens at the better half of the season. If you're hoping for anything tragic or psychological like: Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru and Puella Magi Madoka Magica then this anime isn't for you. |
| "Manga readers are annoying, all they do is complain or spoil the anime we discuss in an anime forum. They should really do their whining at manga forums. USERS ON MY IGNORED LIST: RayReynolds - SSL443 - Dr4kon - Nerdanimefan1992 - ToTheMountains - Fiveskies To add users to the Ignore list: (1) Go to Account settings (2) Click Forum tab and toggle down (3) Type or paste user name on entry box (4) Click Add and you're done. Problem solved, you'll never have to see someone trolling ever again because their post will be closed/collapsed. |
| Alright, imma try to put this idea to rest that people don't like the new show because "We've simply outgrown it", because that simply isn't true. I have a friend whose a HUGE fan of this show but she hadn't seen it until a few years back, and I saw it last year and got a good amount of enjoyment out of it. Hell, I'm 19 and I love Shugo Chara to death despite having not read it until December of last year and liking things such as Evangelion, Berserk, Kaiji, and the works. There is an audience for magical girl anime outside of just kids, look at the following the Precure series has gotten outside of its target audience, there's a good amount of otaku into that show. Janethan23 said: Nobody is going into this is expecting a dark tragic anime, thats really silly to assumeIf you're hoping for anything tragic or psychological like: Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru and Puella Magi Madoka Magica then this anime isn't for you. Nostalgik said: I'm pretty sure the people who are fans of CCS are aware of the fact that the characters aren't "deep", but for fans of the show that isn't what CCS is about. I don't know why the fuck people fucking EVERYWHERE talking about anime judge anime based on shit like "character and story", if thats all that matters to you in anime find a different medium. Now due to this high as f- score people think they are supposed to treat this as a masterpiece. No. The characters are as simple as they can be, this was originally a kids' show: the show that appealed to us, KIDS of that time, a lot. This is most likely simply a nostalgia-bomb, it never was intended to be something very good storytelling or characterization-wise. What I'm saying is I don't enjoy the new show not because "Oh it has a bad story and bad characters", that would be retarded, I dislike the new show because its very derivative of the original series which REALLY doesn't need a sequel and lacks the charm the original had with its cell animation, and thats just a level of comfort for me you just can't match with digital animation (Or at least you can and the new CCS just does it poorly). I'm probably wasting my time typing this since I expect everyone to miss the point of this but hopefully I can shoot the ridiculous idea of "Oh you've just outgrown the original!" |
QueenNothingFeb 26, 2018 1:54 AM
Bluekirby2 said: I don't have that close-minded mentality at all. All I know is that I watched the show and even for an innocent mahou shoujo school anime it doesn't use its fun ideas to their full potential (like the cards themselves, the way some affect Sakura's staff, the matches and situations the cards appear in, etc.), meaning to me it has the fun ideas in but it doesn't use the possibilities the plot provides from the beginning at their best. So all in all, I get what fans of the show mean when they state their reasons for not only liking it, but LOVING it, but I simply see the show has much more room to grow.Alright, imma try to put this idea to rest that people don't like the new show because "We've simply outgrown it", because that simply isn't true. I have a friend whose a HUGE fan of this show but she hadn't seen it until a few years back, and I saw it last year and got a good amount of enjoyment out of it. Hell, I'm 19 and I love Shugo Chara to death despite having not read it until December of last year and liking things such as Evangelion, Berserk, Kaiji, and the works. There is an audience for magical girl anime outside of just kids, look at the following the Precure series has gotten outside of its target audience, there's a good amount of otaku into that show. Janethan23 said: Nobody is going into this is expecting a dark tragic anime, thats really silly to assumeIf you're hoping for anything tragic or psychological like: Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru and Puella Magi Madoka Magica then this anime isn't for you. Nostalgik said: I'm pretty sure the people who are fans of CCS are aware of the fact that the characters aren't "deep", but for fans of the show that isn't what CCS is about. I don't know why the fuck people fucking EVERYWHERE talking about anime judge anime based on shit like "character and story", if thats all that matters to you in anime find a different medium. Now due to this high as f- score people think they are supposed to treat this as a masterpiece. No. The characters are as simple as they can be, this was originally a kids' show: the show that appealed to us, KIDS of that time, a lot. This is most likely simply a nostalgia-bomb, it never was intended to be something very good storytelling or characterization-wise. What I'm saying is I don't enjoy the new show not because "Oh it has a bad story and bad characters", that would be retarded, I dislike the new show because its very derivative of the original series which REALLY doesn't a sequel and lacks the charm the original had with its cell animation, and thats just a level of comfort for me you just can't match with digital animation (Or at least you can and the new CCS just does it poorly). I'm probably wasting my time typing this since I expect everyone to miss the point of this but hopefully I can shoot the ridiculous idea of "Oh you've just outgrown the original!" I can't opinate on the new series because all I've seen is the new OVA (which, for the record, I disliked) and the first episode of Clear Card (which was ok). I am highly looking forward to see that beautiful outfit from the opening. If in the show it shines as much as that one then I think they are doing a great job in terms of utilizing modern visuals to still sell the appeal of Sakura. |
|
| It basically feel like a watered down, more safe version of the original. As for "you have outgrown it" yeah, not really, I read CCS manga like a couple of years ago and it was a pretty good experience. The characters in particular really stuck with me, while I can't say the same thing about this sequel. |
 |
| I'm also having a hard time enjoying this Arc. I don't think we haven't outgrown the show because I can go back watching to the original Cardcaptor Sakura and still say I thoroughly enjoy it. I am sure many of us fall in the same boat. I like the character development and the story in the previous installment (plus their movies). Perhaps because it felt fresh at the time I watched it as a kid and nostalgia plays a role, but I think it is more. The Clear Card-hen is visually clean and music is nice; although, I'm not liking the new cards design for some odd reason (not the clear part just the design in general). For me, the problem is the story feels rehash of the Sakura Arc (evening have some card using the same ability) and character feels flat. They could have explored more (ie. Sakura and Syaoran`s relationship) in Clear Card-hen. The creators are playing a bit too safe. Despite this, I`m going to stick with the show cause I like Cardcaptor and essence is still there. I hope it improves later on. Otherwise, the only way to enjoy it is to not think too much and just watch it as is. BTW, I am glad you made this discussion. I thought it was only me who feels this way. |
CorbitFeb 25, 2018 5:16 PM
Level:  on MAL-Badges |
| Well, I'm not going to say I told you so, but... I told you so! (^.^') Feel free to read any of my rant posts in any of the other threads where I identify all the problems that I had with this show. But in summary, here's what I said after Episode 3: While it might have been obvious to most, it just occurred to me that this is pretty much a reboot in disguise. Other than new merchandise, they needed to take away her old cards in order to start her from zero again so that she could start collecting cards from scratch again. Not to mention, the cards are pretty much the exact same in terms of abilities save for the designs. Gale = Windy, Aqua = Watery, Reflect = Mirror, Siege = Shadow, etc... At the moment, there is literally nothing new. That was one of my issues about this series. Why do we have to retread the same formula again? Yes, she is indeed Cardcaptor Sakura, but I stand by my initial opinion of wanting to have seen Sakura develop her existing powers more. Think of the opening scene of the second movie. More of that, where she has already mastered her powers. The original show spent so much time building it up and throwing all of that away is just heartbreaking. The best outcome I see for this series is for her to lose all these new cards and reclaim her old ones in a triumphant return. Jeez... It's the Metroid problem. What reason do we give players for taking away all of her upgrades from the previous games to necessitate yet another treasure hunt? That became painfully clear with the heavy rain thing. I found it weird when Sakura never mentioned something like this happening before. But I guess that would have drawn far more attention to that reused plot point than necessary. Canon issues aside, one of my biggest pet peeves is how Sakura didn't seem to care about the Sakura Cards. However, I have to admit that at least they acknowledged it in the previous episode with Sakura saying "Nothing I can do... So, why worry?" Fair enough. Li doing nothing is also a tad frustrating. Why is he not in his battle attire coming to Sakura's aid? He still can use elemental magic. Last but not least, like all other nostalgia-bait properties, is there anything to like about it once the nostalgia has been taken away? That's the issue I have with sequels to old properties that aren't adaptations of existing unadapted material like Full Metal Panic IV (eg. Digimon Tri., Yu-Gi-Oh! Dark Side of Dimensions, etc...). When the original series aired, it didn't rely on nostalgia. It had to prove itself and stand on its own merits. And we loved it. Now, all these years later, the only thing that anyone talks about is the nostalgia factor. Okay... but nostalgia aside, what does the show have to offer? That's why I'm curious to see how it will fare after the initial squeals of nostalgia have died down. The reason I'm cynical is because everything feels so contrived. One of the main reasons companies do sequels is to capitalize on people's nostalgia. It's an easy way out without putting in any thought or effort into them. Seeing everyone squeal over the nostalgia and not talk about anything else is somewhat disheartening as it kinda validates my cynicism. Yup. I called this falling out once the nostalgia goggles fell off long, long ago. But to add on to that, with the original season, we actually had tangible goals, be it for Sakura to capture all the Clow Cards or to turn all of them into Sakura Cards. Not only did we have the rivalry with Li at the beginning to make things competitive and exciting, Eriol played the villain role in the second arc that tied everything together. Here, we don't know how many of these new cards there are. We don't know what collecting them will achieve (we don't even know if it will restore the Sakura Cards) and there really isn't any compelling reason for us to be invested in the collection of the cards (which are again repeats of the original). I'm really hoping this is all building up to something because the mystery is the only thing that's driving the story. I'd argue that while Madhouse did indeed recapture the feel of the original (save for all those shojo flowers and comedic cut-aways), they have yet to recapture the magic. Like, where's Sakura's triumphant theme? Also, I don't remember the jokes being this repetitive. It's like each episode has a checklist that they need to fill. Touya joke - check. Yamazaki joke - check. Tomoyo joke - check. I do remember them being far more subtle and with far more variation. I guess you can say that the series is far too... formulaic? It's like they went back and tried to reverse engineer the original series but only managed it half-way. |
ActarMar 1, 2018 11:20 PM
| I think it's just perfect. Nostalgia was very strong for that one and I'm glad to see the spirit of the show didn't change, it's very recognizable with even more colors. I love it they way it is, it's different from most animes we have these days, a breath of fresh air :) |
Syaoran--Li said: I think it's just perfect. Nostalgia was very strong for that one and I'm glad to see the spirit of the show didn't change, it's very recognizable with even more colors. I love it they way it is, it's different from most animes we have these days, a breath of fresh air :) Breath of fresh air? C'mon, you may like the anime as it is and see not problem with it. It's totally fine, but there is no reason to be delusional. The anime doesn't bring a single thing new from anything we have nowadays. |
I despise woke people. |
| It would be surprising for a sequel to come out after decades and *not* fail to please a lot of fans, no matter how good it was. Katt_Cleo said: Nothing freaking goes wrong, they are like robots(....) Mmmm, that may be the main reason why I like it more than the old show. Which ties in with this: Kaetokiha said: Syaoran--Li said: I think it's just perfect. Nostalgia was very strong for that one and I'm glad to see the spirit of the show didn't change, it's very recognizable with even more colors. I love it they way it is, it's different from most animes we have these days, a breath of fresh air :) Breath of fresh air? C'mon, you may like the anime as it is and see not problem with it. It's totally fine, but there is no reason to be delusional. The anime doesn't bring a single thing new from anything we have nowadays. Most of the time I feel like I'm watching a modern relaxing iyashikei slice of life moe girls doing cute things fluff show. The old show was cute, but it didn't feel like that at all. |
Katt_Cleo said: Quite honestly there's a perfectly good reason (or list of reasons) why the new season is, well.. boring a f. And I don't think it has anything to do with people growing up and just not feeling it anymore. Sure, it looks like it has the same format,but that's just on the surface. In reality, this season in my honest opinion lacks a soul. It's basically a very bare plot that makes up for that by getting thrown into a pool of nostalgia. In the first and second season episodes explored things ranging from Sakura's family relations (her longing from not getting to know her mother, wanting to look dependable to her father, bantering all the time and yet forming a relationship of trust with her brother), the different types of love explored by characters throughout the show (of course Tomoko's unconditional love for Sakura, Yue's love for Clow and Touya and Yukito's relationship, Touya's relationship with Sayuri, that one friend that Sakura had that was in love with their elementary school teacher, Sakura's and Syaoran's crush on Yukito and them getting to move on from it), I mean, the list goes on and on! All of her friends and all characters have their own moments and provide fodder to the story And now, what do we get? Without any of the aforementioned stuff, we just get replayed gags of Yamazaki, Sakura doing cheerleading, Tomoyo fangirling over Sakura in costumes, it's like the show just keeps on shouting to your face "SEE? SEE? REMEMBER THAT??" And yet apart from that there's no story. It's like instead of listening to a full song we get a broken record going on repeat. Nothing freaking goes wrong, they are like robots, I was so done when the "mysterious transfer student girl" who's totally unrelated to the antagonist (-___-) was reading in class and then all the girls came up to her afterwards to praise her for it! WTF? Who does that?? That basically summarises the problem! Everyone is just doing things they are good at and then they praise each other over it and then a monst- sorry, a card appears and Sakura easily catches it and THE END. Quite honestly I'm finishing it because fuck it but it's quite disappointing. If all I wanted was reminisce cute moments then I'd watch the old show. What you're saying is true. The first anime had a lot of funny moments involving Sakura as she was more childish and more prone to throw a tantrum or make weird faces when things were happening to her. I laughed a lot when watching CCS. Here are some pics i took from just the episode 5 of the CCS.     Sakura now just tries to act mature which makes her a very boring character. Before i thought she had a personality of a little girl, but now she acts too perfect all the time which makes her seem unreal. The new anime comedic stuff is basically just some stuff Kero does and Sakura overreacting to Tomoyo wanting to film her (none of them are funny). The scenes where she captures the new cards are also much inferior to the CCS. Before Sakura would have quite a struggle against some cards (like the card Fire) and the cards were way more interesting too (like the card Mirror who could talk and wanted hurt to Toya, but then she regretted it and let herself be captured) and the scenes were overall much much longer (some times half of the episode). Now the card capturing scenes are very fast, going from 30 seconds to usually 3 mins. The biggest one i think was Siege and even so it was nothing special, she just popped it like a balloon and used her staff. It doesn't seem like Clamp is thinking too much about the new cards, the cards seem to be there just to fulfill the "monster of the week" stuff instead of being something interesting and entertaining. The SoL stuff is as generic as it could be. I like SoL animes too, but Sakura and her friends just praising each other all the time with nothing else happening (aside from a card appearing at the end) is just boring and uninteresting. I skipped most of the episode 9 dialogues cause i found Sakura and Syoran relationship extremely dull. So yeah i do think this anime is riding solely on Nostalgia feels instead of quality content. It's NOWHERE NEAR as good as the original CCS and this has nothing to do with people growing up like some people here are saying. |
KaeUBWMar 13, 2018 1:53 PM
| I despise woke people. |
| I am enjoying the show, but I agree with several of the previous posters. There is barely any focus on the actual card capturing. Sakura just gets close to the cards and uses her staff and it's done. Very little strategy or wondering about the card. Large parts of the episode are just "slice of life" without anything actually happening. Only a lot of "you are so good at cooking!" and "you are so good at singing" and "let's all be friends!". |
| Actually, the past two episodes seem to be improving IMO. At least now the cards don't just let themselves to be captured. |
| "The world appears wonderful in the eyes of wonderful people." (Alicia Florence, ARIA) |
| Well i might be a little biased, since original CCS is one of my favorite anime of all time, but personally, i dont have ssues with it, characters act mostly same, but, they also matured, grew up with its audience, while still having that charm and innocence :) Plus, comparing it to such crap as first two seasons of Sailor Moon Crystal or most parts of Dragon Ball Super, CCS Clear Card shines even more :) |
| The only thing I'm disappointed with is Sakura's lack of TWIN TAILS. DX She looks cuter with them; don't give me this "it's to make her look more mature" shit; you know how many characters 16+ wear twin tails!? |
  |
| I just find the tech update weird- because it becomes obvious how much time has passed between this and the original series, almost feels like a parallel unniverse |
| I was starting to think I was the only one with the same issue. I'm trying to keep watching it just to see where the story is going, but overall I feel like most people here commenting their issues with this series. Let's see where this goes, I still have hopes it will improve |
 |
| Mahou Shoujo Ore aired yesterday is 10x more fun to watch than this Just saying |
| I feel the same. rather than try to be a new, revitalized sequel, with a fresh new take on the classic you know and love, Clear Card is too busy living in the shadow of the original series. its going more for the "remember this?" approach then actually creating a new interesting story. the original Cardcaptor Sakura was great because it felt fresh and brought new concepts to the rapidly growing stale magical girl genre. but that anime is now around 18 years old, and doing the same thing isn't fresh anymore. I still think there's more room to grow if they branch out the plot a bit, but as of now I feel like I'm gonna have to chalk this anime up to yet another unnecessary reboot of a classic anime. |
| Not, you’re not. Not only I’m disappointed with it (12 episodes in), but I have come to question why was this even green-lighted in the first place. Nostalgia is the only thing that comes to mind. Cardcaptor Sakura was an OK TV mahou shoujo’s series from the late nineties-early 2000s. It is one of those old series that didn’t need to be “revived”, especially with a sequel as lackluster as this one. Honestly, producers should just stop reviving old series that have already finished with unnecessary sequels. Code Geass seems to be another victim of this ridiculous “trend”. |
 We ultimately fear what spawns from within us ~Shinsekai yori Music is freedom. ~Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso |
| not a fan either. the new characters and the cards aren't interesting and imo the fights used to be more entertaining at least. i facepalmed when they had the throwback episode at the same location sakura caught The Watery. ...at least we getting new outfits |
 |
Kaetokiha said: Syaoran--Li said: I think it's just perfect. Nostalgia was very strong for that one and I'm glad to see the spirit of the show didn't change, it's very recognizable with even more colors. I love it they way it is, it's different from most animes we have these days, a breath of fresh air :) Breath of fresh air? C'mon, you may like the anime as it is and see not problem with it. It's totally fine, but there is no reason to be delusional. The anime doesn't bring a single thing new from anything we have nowadays. Well, at least there is no oversexualization/pandering. It's quite good to see this given that seems to be increasingly rare not to use these things to appeal to some people. It's pretty innocent and I like this. |
| Im satisfied with the season. |
Syaoran--Li said: Kaetokiha said: Breath of fresh air? C'mon, you may like the anime as it is and see not problem with it. It's totally fine, but there is no reason to be delusional. The anime doesn't bring a single thing new from anything we have nowadays. Well, at least there is no oversexualization/pandering. It's quite good to see this given that seems to be increasingly rare not to use these things to appeal to some people. It's pretty innocent and I like this. It seems like you're saying "it could be worse, therefore it's good". I'm not trying to make you dislike the anime as i'm already tired of people trying this kind of thing here on MAL. If you like it then it's ll good and you can enjoy it to the fullest, but the anime is not bringing anything new to the genre or even the series. There is no breath of fresh air here. Everything so far has been basically a re-do from the first series, but with less charisma, less comedy, worse SoL and much duller action sequences. The anime is completely relying on nostalgia, which is sad. I think Clamp could have done a much better job if they tried something new, but they didn't want to risk anything and went with the safest route possible. |
| I despise woke people. |
Kaetokiha said: Syaoran--Li said: Well, at least there is no oversexualization/pandering. It's quite good to see this given that seems to be increasingly rare not to use these things to appeal to some people. It's pretty innocent and I like this. It seems like you're saying "it could be worse, therefore it's good". I'm not trying to make you dislike the anime as i'm already tired of people trying this kind of thing here on MAL. If you like it then it's ll good and you can enjoy it to the fullest, but the anime is not bringing anything new to the genre or even the series. There is no breath of fresh air here. Everything so far has been basically a re-do from the first series, but with less charisma, less comedy, worse SoL and much duller action sequences. The anime is completely relying on nostalgia, which is sad. I think Clamp could have done a much better job if they tried something new, but they didn't want to risk anything and went with the safest route possible. Fair enough, that's a criticism that I can understand, there's certainly some truth to it. Nostalgia is so strong that I don't mind but it can be different for other people. |
| CCS is in my top favorite anime and top 3 favorite manga. When the Clear Card manga came out, I wasn't excited. There is NO reason for there to be more CardCaptor. The story was wrapped up perfectly and I'm not one to get high off nostalgia. Anyway, I read it to some point and there was nothing exciting about it but at least the art was good. Now watching the anime, I'm just here trying to give it a chance, trying to find a sliver of goodness about this series and it's a struggle. Animation is flat, characters are souless copies of their former selves, episodes are a step-by-step rehash of the previous series, it lacks charm overall. It's nothing but one of the many, lame-ass magical girl for children anime that come out in hordes every year. Yes it's a children show, but there was a certain level of complexity before between these characters and their feelings and relationships which is non-existent here. Just like what happened to Sailor Moon Crystal, the characters are here to be 'pretty'. What happened to Sakura's and Syaoran's crazy faces, strong personalities, funny moments? Nowhere to be seen here, because these are plastic dolls that are just supposed to look cute. I'll try to watch this through to the end, but the main problem is the lack of charm and inspiration in this work. CLAMP must really be thinking about all the money they'll make from nostalgia-stans. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I discovered CCS through magazine articles then found a chance to get the story through the TV dulled down french version and finally read the whole manga series (I liked the manga, even the anime despite its excedingly long duration). But... sea-lemon said: When the Clear Card manga came out, I wasn't excited. There is NO reason for there to be more CardCaptor. The story was wrapped up perfectly and I'm not one to get high off nostalgia. Anyway, I read it to some point and there was nothing exciting about it but at least the art was good. Episodes are a step-by-step rehash of the previous series, it lacks charm overall. The main problem is the lack of inspiration in this work. CLAMP must really be thinking about all the money they'll make. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Cardcaptor Sakura: Clear Card-hen Episode 14 DiscussionStark700 - Apr 14, 2018 |
38 |
by Serhiyko
»»
Apr 10, 1:31 PM |
|
Poll: » Cardcaptor Sakura: Clear Card-hen Episode 22 DiscussionFayrin - Aug 9, 2018 |
36 |
by glowings
»»
Jan 3, 4:20 PM |
|
» How much of the manga does this adapt?GrayZStars - Nov 12, 2023 |
2 |
by GrayZStars
»»
Nov 12, 2023 8:16 PM |
|
Poll: » With who will Daidouji Tomoyo and Li Mei Ling end up or will they end up single ?KingSunWukong - Nov 11, 2023 |
7 |
by KingSunWukong
»»
Nov 12, 2023 10:08 AM |
|
Poll: » Cardcaptor Sakura: Clear Card-hen Episode 8 DiscussionStark700 - Feb 24, 2018 |
43 |
by KhoaVN
»»
Jul 6, 2023 3:09 AM |