Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (3) « 1 [2] 3 »
Jul 12, 2020 8:57 AM
Offline
Jul 2013
4
Samu-tan said:
QPR said:
The series started off an 8 but then slowly sank (pun intended) to a 4-5. The SJW shit was too much and so badly done.
Men=rapists
Japan=racist
gay politician kiss
multicultural people = good
quadriplegic = vital
making the disabled olympics

the first netflix anime I watched, it will be the last. I am sure Japan would be embarrassed at this abortion of a show. At least some of the deaths were funny and I am totally shocked they didn't shoehorn in some black characters. Maybe they were too afraid to animate them.


I have no clue how you even got to some of those conclusions, but lmfao if the stuff in this show gets you tilted, then crawl back under the rock of bigotry you came from


I know, right? That's his takeaway? What a snowflake
Jul 12, 2020 12:47 PM

Offline
Oct 2008
101
A decent conclusion, as good as you can really get with this time limitation and with the massive amount of plot points and characters they tried to hit on.

Overall the message of pushing forward despite your troubles seems, well, appropriate. It's a unique take at the least for me, often times disaster plots are doom and gloom and action, misery porn essentially and while some of the moments in this show get close to that it never dwells on it(for better of for worse, remember her dad and how quickly that was overlooked?).

That being said it's another one of Yuasa's mediocre works in comparison to Ping Pong. Which is to be expected if anyone know's his history. It really needed more focus, better pacing most importantly and more time focused on these characters to make their sacrifices mean more to us. It takes a tremendous suspension of disbelief to follow along with this story and not roll your eyes out of your skull(360 gramps no scope, famous youtuber and famous scientist survive and tag along, finding eachother in the middle of the ocean, everyone coming across working boats, one even military). The amount of plot conveniences within these 10 episodes is incredible. The show requires quite a lot out of it's viewers to get to what's good and to ignore the flaws and that's a huge problem for this show for a lot of people.

I'd love to see what non anime fans thought of this, if Yuasa's minimal and wonky animation style ruined it or not basically. Because while in Ping Pong it adds to the aesthetic it doesn't do that so much here. I'd say beyond Kite's balloon scene and maybe Ayuma's final crying scene that wonky, exposed roughness rarely adds to anything going on and often times it probably leaves viewers wondering if they're watching an unfinished product.

Final thoughts, I didn't feel much but I was entertained for the most part and at times it made me think a little about how I interpret tragedy. I did have to get over quite a few stupid plot decisions and really just accept this rapid pacing though. Making an anime this janky and at comparable length to a movie which would have much higher production values seems counterintuitive. But overall I enjoyed it, the characters were generally likable, the thematic elements were a pleasant and uplifting change, some of the character moments we do get are satisfying and it finishes pretty damn strong all things considered. It's not as good as I hoped but it's not much worse either.

7/10 for me.

Jul 12, 2020 3:12 PM
Offline
Nov 2018
395
i wasn't sure how the ending was gonna be with ayumu and go surviving, but it worked for me. this definitely was supposed to make me feel all warm and inspired going into the tokyo 2020 olympics, but the overall message about moving forward even after losing all my family and friends still works with the world trying to get through COVID-19.

if only ayumu's family went east instead of west, they would have possibly been fine based on that map, but nope, had to lose everybody and suffer a big fat L. i did like how my expectations were subverted at times, especially where they went with the cult stuff ep 5-6. overall, i was very entertained by the show.
Jul 12, 2020 3:49 PM

Offline
Sep 2009
2821
I finished the whole series straight in one night. I just can't believe I didn't cry. But there lots of tearjerking moments. *^* I'm just disappointed I didn't cry like some of the you did. Probably because of sleepiness? I already expected that both of their parents are gonna die but I didn't want it to happen. I'm also sad that Haruo died :'( And KITE -- He's one of my favorite character in the series. He's the MVP in this anime after the father died. (Only for me)
Jul 12, 2020 10:51 PM

Offline
Sep 2014
90
I found the show to be a mixed bag. There's good stuff happening throughout, but the story felt rushed at points, the tone can be really weird at times, the animation shifts in the later half and felt distracting, and there's a number of things with the story that bugged me. Generally the survival story stuff was what I was wanting, so when we would veer away from that or kinda dumb story stuff happened (Finding an amphibious APC on the ocean, the secret cave base, the whole Kite ending) and I almost stopped at a few times around the half way point when they reached the commune place and everything afterwards.

It's certainly not bad, it's very watchable, this isn't something awful like 7 Seeds, but I felt that it could've been better. I'd put it at like a 3/5.
KamikazeKeegJul 12, 2020 11:42 PM
Jul 12, 2020 11:27 PM

Offline
Apr 2013
1174
What a great show. I'm glad I picked this up! Of course it's not perfect and the animation is kinda wack sometimes but I thought it did well in the emotional side of things and the journey as a whole was quite nice to see. Interesting finale!
Jul 13, 2020 5:41 AM

Offline
May 2018
25
Lol. I happened to watch Hello World movie and Japan Sinks yesterday and I still can't believe that a piece of trash like Hello World got 7.76 and Japan Sinks is hated by nearly everyone here. Must be some rare case of collective blindness.
Not gonna say anything about the animation, I never cared about it, but this is my second Yuasa's work (after Eizouken ni Te wo Dasu na) and I really liked the style. This roughness and imperfection are what makes it good.

Pros:
- A lot of people are writing about unrealistic characters and their reactions. I can't agree with that at all. It's really common to be seemingly in high spirits after a death of a person close to you, to joke and smile a lot etc., especially when you're in such a stressful situation. It's just a protective mechanism, you know, so you don't lose your mind with grief immediately. Scenes like the one where mom was cutting Ayumu's hair show that in such situations people deal with grief later.
- The same can be said about characters. Yeah, people IRL are often annoying, cheesy, cringey, they make stupid jokes all the time, insult each other, being insufferable weaboos like Go, get into unnecessary arguments with their parents or children, show their worst side when faced with extreme situations and so on. But they also help each other, genuinely love each other, overcome the difficulties and grow. I think the show mostly managed to portray both of these sides well.
- I'm pretty empathetic and can sympathize with characters even in really generic shows, but the impact is not the same every time. Some deaths in this anime were a bit forced or didn't happen at the right moment to have the necessary impact, some made me really sad, and Mari's death actually made me cry a lot. I don't cry at every even remotely sad scene in every anime I watch, but I can't just shrug off children trying to save their mother with all their strength, and I don't give a shit about the fact that it's generic, has been done a thousand times everywhere, cheesy, badly animated etc.

Cons:
- A lot of plot conveniences, not going to argue about this one. But as long as I still cared about the characters, it's fine. I guess I could describe the characters as mostly realistic and the plot as mostly unrealistic (excluding sudden stupid deaths, that's not really unrealistic, you could expect that in every disaster).
- Yeah, it's really predictable most of the time, like the moment Ayumu's leg was infected you could guess that she would have it amputated and then perform at the Olympics with a prosthetic in the last episode. Or you could easily predict how Haruo will die. It's not necessarily a bad thing. A good show doesn't have to be completely unpredictable, it could be just good old predictable things that are done right and still have impact.
- Some things felt like they were really just there for shock value, like the scene where seagulls are eating the fisherman's body was good and emotional enough, but the shark after that was really unnecessary. It broke the mood sometimes, but as I said most of the deaths ranged from okay to really strong and emotional to me.

Overall: solid 8/10 for me. It's fairly predictable show about simple people and simple things. Yeah, Japanese culture like any other culture deserves to be protected and remembered. Yeah, people often have conflicting beliefs and world views but they can achieve great things if they overcome it. Yeah, we go through a lot of sadness and pain in our lives, but if we live through it all, it will probably help us grow. So what is so bad about the anime that tells about these things in kinda generic but emotional and impactful way? Ah, yeah, "ugly animation", lol.

P. S. People who are now posting things like "good job for ruining Yuasa's name" in the director's profile, are the cancer of anime community, I'm not exaggerating even a little bit. People who are upset with Olympics for the disabled (it literally exists in the real world, wtf) or the fact that different cultures can coexist, IDK, probably go back to your cave.
(edited, forgot to add the score lol)
Jul 13, 2020 8:44 AM
Offline
Dec 2019
4
I think I missed something, why Ayumu didn't asked for help with the injury on her leg when she was at the weed farm? I'm sure they would have the resources to stop the infection
ZeytobaJul 13, 2020 8:52 AM
Jul 13, 2020 8:59 AM
Offline
Aug 2018
10
Because they needed to cut off her leg for the olympic ending, which seems to be one of the important messages of the show.
Just another painfully obvious case of bad writing : /
Unfortunatelly, virtue signaling took precedence over delivering a good and beliveable story.
This show feels like a bunch of moral/ethical/political statements with some random plot and characters slapped on it. Waaaaay too hamfisted to be impactful or enjoyable.
Jul 13, 2020 9:45 AM

Offline
May 2015
5927
The pure stupidity of characters of this show is way beyond me. That girls leg could be treated like in 1st episode, when her father had first aid kid (or some sort of) or even at this weird cult place. Not to mention some weird ass siutation like taking a freaking photos, Granda-rambo, random Rap battle etc.

I just wanted some Tokyo Magnitude vibe. What I get was this abomination.

Giving it 4 is mercy.
"The future is always blank. Only your willpower can leave footsteps there."

"Ruling over death means ruling over life. Death is the climax of life. To have the best death, you must honor life."
Jul 13, 2020 6:20 PM
News Team
YEEHAW

Offline
Nov 2014
9534
I mean, the finale was nice I guess but... I didn't care much because most of the anime until now was pretty shit and poorly executed.

Hurts to do that to my boi Yuasa but it's gonna be a 3/10.

Just go watch Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 instead, it's waaaaaaaaaaaay better than this garbage.
STOP SLEEPING ON ODD TAXI

Jul 14, 2020 2:32 AM

Offline
Jan 2019
598
Wow that kinda sucked balls
Jul 14, 2020 4:55 AM
Offline
Dec 2018
1
Netflix still strong with their propaganda.
Jul 14, 2020 6:45 AM
Offline
Apr 2019
84
Tried to be 10.5 the anime; failed miserably
Jul 14, 2020 9:02 AM

Offline
Jun 2016
1896
seriously at some scene that animation looks so ugly !!!
Jul 14, 2020 1:11 PM

Offline
Dec 2015
3194
I stay with 7/10. Episodes 1+2 were nice. (Though the weird scenes and random English already started there.)

Later it got worse. The cult and Daniel ... were totally random. After that it got a bit better gain. Though it feels a bit pointless in the end. Still ... the last episode was nice.

I would have preferred some actual and more realistic survival though. With different kinds of chars working together (different skills) to survive.

Was just some kind of adventure anime with a weird attempt trying to mix comedy and serious stuff. More serious and I could have enjoyed this a bit more. (Still not great then unless it would have been a real survival anime.)
Jul 14, 2020 1:48 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
2052
yo how the fuck did kite survive? man has at least 9 lives.

PANDEMlC said:
I'd love to see what non anime fans thought of this, if Yuasa's minimal and wonky animation style ruined it or not basically.

i watched a couple episodes with a non-anime-watching pal, and they told me they really liked the art style: apparently because it wasn’t jarring on the eyes.
AnimeFreak-San said:
is this a male gender issure...human issue...mental illness perhaps?
Jul 14, 2020 2:00 PM
Offline
Jun 2020
15
I don't remember when's the last time I cried like shit. The characters were incredible. The way everyone sacrificed themselves,i couldn't cry less.
I'm SO MUCH happy that kite was alive. I cried like shit when he sacrificed himself, although for a moment i believed he ditched them. But gosh i literally screamed my heart when i saw him with his cap casually smiling. My heart
Jul 14, 2020 7:14 PM

Offline
Feb 2019
97
Idk even know what to say omo
I only liked Kite because of his voice/seiyuu

He looks okay on the first episodes that he appeared and btw he's dead right?
Since it was the scientist/dr operating the YT channel or something?

Edit: NVM he's alive, oh great :0

saeran_choiiiiJul 14, 2020 7:19 PM
owkey
Jul 14, 2020 9:11 PM

Offline
Dec 2018
124
did they just reveal Kite as trans at the end, or...?
Jul 14, 2020 10:40 PM

Offline
May 2018
70
fuwahfuwaaaaaah said:
So Kaito is alive, right?

I like to believe that he was watching Ayumu at the end
Jul 15, 2020 5:38 AM

Offline
Sep 2019
193
The ending had a similar tone to girls last tour's ending but wasn't as emotive, which is weird because I engaged with those characters unlike the archive of humanity in girl's last tour that we know nothing about the world they are in, when they show that montage in this show i just dont feel it man, I think it has something to do with the writing going downhill in the second half, all the stupid coincidences and the mf tank was enough, i can't get over the ridiculous stupid coincidences, they left a bad taste and don't let me enjoy the ending memories montage because without those the ending can't happen, the show in the state it is doesn't deserve that ending even if its one that should fit in.
Carpal_Tunnel69Jul 15, 2020 5:41 AM
Jul 15, 2020 7:32 AM

Offline
Jun 2015
3463
A valiant effort from the last 3 episodes to give some emotional depth to the deaths and further expose whatever topics the anime is meant to be cemented on.

Except I can't buy it one bit considering the nature of the events throughout the series and how it failed miserably in making me invested (or remotely interested) in these characters. Which ultimately leaves me with a painfully long epilogue, without any of its benefits.

A (very rare) 1/10 in my book.
Jul 15, 2020 8:06 AM

Offline
Oct 2019
502
I mean it pretty much felt like the average disaster movie just with some awkward animation style and without Dwayne Johnson.

5/10 for me...
Jul 15, 2020 12:15 PM
Offline
Jan 2017
2
Am I the only one wondering what the hell happened to the other country mentioned after like everything? Lol
Jul 15, 2020 12:19 PM
Offline
May 2020
63
RafaelDeJongh said:
THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE.
----------------------------------------
Really enjoyed this anime, reminded me a lot of Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 but had a lot more aspects and different focus points.

Loved the ending a lot as well, really a very enjoyable episode and ending if you ask me, and certainly felt quite sad yet really loved how the whole story turned out!


Agreed! I thought the show show was overall enjoyable. I would rewatch it at some point I think. First episode especially was really interesting.
Jul 16, 2020 12:37 AM

Offline
Mar 2019
421
So this is one of the lowest rated anime I've watched in a while. They killed off most of my favorite characters, but I'll still rate the show highly. My reaction to character death isn't always the same. Maybe Kite is a bifauxnen who doesn't mind being called 'he.' LoL. (Watched it before checking MAL and lol not gonna say anything besides did they expect waifus doing cute things or something.)

Ayumu didn't have much time to spend on her PTSD and neither did the series. So there's less of a psychology tone here or the controversial 'you said they should get over it and they did.' I thought it was a good anime. And btw I thought the Japan pure people's boat demise was deserved. It's an anime, it doesn't have to solve anything. Also there are reasons for Japanese people to not totally approve their country.

Animation budget was gone in the last few episodes or something it seemed.

Interesting apocalypse genre work. I don't mind some characters survived ending because true enough, there are survivors. It's not Evangelion which has different plot points anyway.
Eris-w-Jul 16, 2020 5:25 PM
Jul 16, 2020 7:53 AM
Offline
Jan 2017
2
Am I the only one wondering what the hell happened to the other country mentioned after like everything? Lol
Jul 16, 2020 11:24 AM
Offline
May 2020
1
horrible show, why can't Go just speak Japanese. Also that annoying English dude who ruined the sad climax by saying "Asta la vista baby!" This show was poorly executed with trashy animation and voice acting
Jul 16, 2020 1:47 PM

Offline
Jul 2010
181
QPR said:
The series started off an 8 but then slowly sank (pun intended) to a 4-5. The SJW shit was too much and so badly done.
Men=rapists
Japan=racist
gay politician kiss
multicultural people = good
quadriplegic = vital
making the disabled olympics

the first netflix anime I watched, it will be the last. I am sure Japan would be embarrassed at this abortion of a show. At least some of the deaths were funny and I am totally shocked they didn't shoehorn in some black characters. Maybe they were too afraid to animate them.


you are right. I am really bored of netflix forcing peoples eyes about their values. I dont care someone gay or aseksuel or racist. But they should make it good story telling. İnstead of doing something good they just mix everything and they hope it will be good. This is not curry
Jul 16, 2020 3:24 PM

Offline
Jun 2017
311
This was the only good episode out of the series. I'm glad Kite was alive in the end. I'm not sure what to rate this, this episode alone could be a 7 or 8 but looking back throughout the series the other episodes would score low.
The way the characters acted sometimes, the pictures, the rap battle, etc. are what put me off from this. I feel like if it was more serious and more "realistic" (Not saying that some parts weren't.) it would be better. But I'll admit it was really entertaining to watch.
It was okay and entertaining but I wouldn't give it a 5 so, 4/10.
yura_marinetteJul 16, 2020 3:38 PM
Jul 16, 2020 5:51 PM

Offline
Apr 2017
208
So Kite is a man the whole series last minutes in Episode 10 they changed his gender to get woke progressive points not to mention the out of nowhere Gay politicians.
Jul 18, 2020 1:26 AM

Offline
Oct 2012
15
kinasato said:
Because they needed to cut off her leg for the olympic ending, which seems to be one of the important messages of the show.
Just another painfully obvious case of bad writing : /
Unfortunatelly, virtue signaling took precedence over delivering a good and beliveable story.
This show feels like a bunch of moral/ethical/political statements with some random plot and characters slapped on it. Waaaaay too hamfisted to be impactful or enjoyable.

Exactly. This show has it all, race diversity, a trans character, a disabled character, rape attempts, nationalist bigots... everything except decent writing.
Feels like it was made to appeal liberals.
Jul 18, 2020 4:26 PM

Offline
Jun 2010
145
Just is episode felt like someone was using a cat as a condom just to shag some burnt crippled hobo booty in a dumpsterfire.
Jul 19, 2020 2:08 AM
Offline
May 2019
38
Xenocrisi said:
I believe I cried for 10 minutes straight. What a wilde ride holy fuck lmao so many things happened.

As a whole, this anime went downhill in quality as soon as Kite was introduced

So many plot holes and stuff happened just because it was convenient, also the development was way too unrealistic. I have to give credit to the incredible relationships that were built and all the characters were likeable. This anime excelled at conveying feeling, so although I have a lot of negative things to say about it, it still is a 8/10 because managed to make me cry more than once throughout the series
What are u talking about, KITE was the best character, he was the most intresting and smart,the only one that actually thinks in this anime, yeah i agree that a lot of staff were to unrealistic and convenient for the plot, like wtf my man got a tank, but for me, KITE saved the series
Jul 19, 2020 6:34 AM

Offline
Jun 2013
3514
I hope Kaito/Kite is still alive. He was the only younger character who was interesting and useful, aside from Haruo who died after saving that hard drive.

All my favorite characters died: mom, dad, gramps and even Haruo, who I began to like when he started to talk more.

The ending was confusing and unsatisfying.

6/10 for me. I was so looking forward to this. However, I got pissed off many times while watching it. Some parts were enjoyable. The deaths were pretty funny but mom's death hit me the hardest. Lots of plot holes, lots of things didn't make sense.

I had a feeling Ayumu vegan yam girl was going to join the paralympics after they mentioned they had to amputate her leg.

I'm guessing she and her brother lived in Russia or Estonia for a few years. Whee did they get their money?? Who supported them? Did Onedera adopt them? So many unanswered questions. They kept saying Mari, best mom, was from the Philippines but they didn't say a single Tagalog or Visayan word or introduce anything from her culture.
臭い-
Jul 20, 2020 11:53 AM

Offline
Oct 2013
7811
I was shocked to see KITE turning into an asshole, but I was wrong - he performed something heroic. I'm glad Kaito survived everything and that Ayumu and Go were able to find happiness in the new reality.

This anime had many flaws, but it was a good one. I really enjoyed watching it.
Jul 21, 2020 7:30 AM

Offline
Apr 2019
84
QPR said:
Rickydory123 said:
Is Kite really alive? It looked like someone else was operating his YouTube channel

Yes, he was clearly shown at the end with a kite cap at the stadium.


Where? I don't see him anywhere in the end except for when Onadera is controlling the virtual kite.
Jul 21, 2020 4:53 PM
Offline
Jun 2020
1
The anime had a solid start but felt that it kinda derailed as things went on, the plot was average, the emotion impact this anime has is quite effective at reaching its viewers I’d give this a solid 7/10
Jul 21, 2020 7:17 PM
Offline
Jun 2015
80
This show is difficult for me to judge tbh. Parts of it left me speechless and other parts were just odd. I’m a sucker for survival shows and just watched TM 8.0 a few months ago. Seeing the TV-MA rating, I assumed this might be a more mature, graphic version take on the genre. I thought the soundtrack was great and some of the moments were shocking, like the bodies in the trees at the end of episode 1. But others meant to be shocking were more comical than anything like the boy being killed by the falling debris.

Typically I try not to let a less than perfect looking show bother me. Aku no Hana was a near masterpiece despite its odd character design and wacky rotoscoping. But the characters in this were too inconsistent. They looked different in nearly every scene and the animation was choppy, missing frames in between.

One thing that irked me was how little the characters seemed affected by the deaths of their family and friends at times, though this was later amended when Mom finally allowed herself to mourn the dad. The cult part was as others have said, unnecessary padding and just felt so out of context to the story. It was as if the creators had this cool idea for this cult city and shoehorned it into the narrative despite it not really fitting in. I could make a list of all the issues i had but it would take too long.

On the flip side, I liked the ending and I liked the bond the characters made, strangers working together to overcome the odds. It had the found family vibe. While some pieces of the show seemed disjointed, there was something about it that had me dying for more after each episode. Japan Sinks May not be the next masterpiece disaster anime, but if you’re a fan of the genre, I’d recommend giving it a watch as it’s only 10 episodes. 6/10 for me.
Jul 21, 2020 11:29 PM
Offline
Feb 2020
273
Honestly just didn’t vibe right with this one. Started off really strong, got slower, then just fell to a stand still in this ones opinion. 4/10..
Jul 21, 2020 11:43 PM

Offline
Mar 2009
8123
The most unbelievable thing about this series is how the world just let the Japanese people suffer. Really, other countries didn't rush to help Japan?

Honestly speaking, this ending had some genuine emotional moments. Unfortunately, it certainly wasn't deserving of such an ending thanks to everything that came before. Despite the overwhelming negativity on the internet(comments, reviews, etc), I went into this show with an open mind. Expected a disaster-type anime with Yuasa's general directorial flair. Instead, I certainly got a disaster, and people were mostly right about it. Should've just played it as a straight disaster-type anime, but it was some of the most over-the-top, unbelievable, silly, and random shit with a strong side of tragedy porn. I checked out during the random cult part. I still can't believe it lasted 3 entire episodes. 10 episodes and you spend 3 of them on some stupid cult. The series should've been longer. Maybe that would've fixed some things. I don't know. Also, the budget absolutely tanked halfway through the anime. Netflix, what happened to your money?

I have no idea what happened with this anime, but this was a miss for Science SARU. I hope their next work will be better.
Jul 22, 2020 10:11 AM

Offline
Feb 2019
780
7/10.

Made me cry more than once, but too many issues and deaths.

Grandpa's death and the ending were the most emotional parts.
I am not a weeb, I simply enjoy 2D girls
Jul 22, 2020 1:25 PM
Offline
Mar 2016
207

I agree with you for the most part, although I would say the quality drops continuously throughout the show apart from key scenes.

I would also argue that this show addresses the folly of nationalism and pride pretty well, by ham-fisting in the concept of a culture being divorced from it's geography. I would take it one step further and divorce it from it's people too, but it really circles back around on that one.

As for the choice and sacrifice metaphors, the series proves that both are often meaningless, and success/survival often comes down to luck.



This is true, but the entire emotional character of this show is shoehorned. None of it feels organic or natural. Realistically, they had many points of relative safety before they found the compound. It would have been more realistic to see characters engage in bad coping techniques more often, exhibit pained and conflicted expressions, cry in their sleep. Honestly the watershed moments have no real buildup to them. The conversations and inner monologues you'd expect haven't occured, yet their conclusions are still interjected into the story. "You blame me for Dad's death," and, "You only care about your new boyfriend," are both reasonable in this scenario, but they are presented as coming out of nowhere and so lack any depth or weight.

This is another case of a writing team relying on people who've shared a similar experience inserting their own experience in order to make the characters and plot work. You really don't need much at all to convey an emotion or feeling in visual media. Often just sitting in a scene will work, hence why slower episodes and movie scenes tend to be the most poignant. You don't need to regurgitate the feeling down the viewer's throat-- a subtle remark, specific body language, a restrained expression all work wonders in that department.

This writing is super lazy. Why are the later deaths more impactful because the characters react to them for more than a few seconds a single time. Are you less secure stranded on a boat or island? Do you have less time than when you're roaming the countryside during the apocalypse?

I've never experienced a natural disaster like this, but I am a workaholic with a lot of damage. I've watched people stifle their feelings and seen them break. I know what it means to doggedly force yourself and others forward until you just can't anymore. The problem with a lot of "happy" people secretly being miserable is that if you pay attention to them and really talk to them, you know full well that they are not happy. Most people choose to ignore or avoid that to make themselves feel better. That's what this show does. It makes the audience a child, taking in everything its parents do at face value, but without taking acknowledging the subtle incongruencies such innocence would be unable to compute. It MISSES the mark completely and wants you to presently or retroactively fill in all the gaps for them.

It's perfectly fine for people to do that, but it doesn't mean that the writing isn't lazy. These are the most unfortunate shortcuts writers/directors take, and I find it very depressing when they take them. Especially when it's so easily fixed. Even if the rest of the show remains a tonal mess. I hate that so many people defend this practice. I would rather people sacrifice every other element.

But yeah, I enjoyed this show. 4/10 for me. I laughed so hard throughout most of this but still managed to tear up at the epilogue. The characters were pretty annoying. I grew to like Kite and Koga more towards the end. My favorite character was definitely the grandpa. The mom was the worst out of the bunch, even though her death was somewhat redeeming.
Jul 27, 2020 11:39 AM
The Shrike

Offline
Nov 2009
11380
Far from Yuasa's best work, but not really as bad as some people are painting it to be. I think they tried to do too much and make too many points instead of focusing on the characters a bit more. They only really started doing that towards the end.

I would have also skipped the cult arc completely. Didn't really fit with the theme of the series. Maybe it makes more sense in the source material.
"Perhaps there is a universal, absolute truth. Perhaps it justifies every question. But that's beyond the reach of these small hands." Mamoru Oshii

There is a cult of ignorance (...) nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that “my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.” Isaac Asimov

Jul 29, 2020 6:56 AM
Offline
Jan 2017
703
the f*ck i did watching man...
the entire anime make me sick..
Dead and dead and dead..
.
.
and tge final i see the old man was kissing each other.. wtf
Jul 29, 2020 12:14 PM

Offline
Jan 2008
134
gift62 said:
Does anyone know the ending song that played in this episode?

The song is called "景色" (keshiki). It is sung by Kaf (花譜) and written by Kanzaki Iori (カンザキイオリ).

You can find it on the YouTube channel of Kaf : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=46HgoDkRCns.
Jul 31, 2020 8:09 PM
Offline
May 2020
2
can someone explain why she didn’t treat her leg all the time? maybe then it wouldn’t have been amputated
Aug 2, 2020 4:25 AM
Offline
Oct 2018
2
Denzitsu said:
can someone explain why she didn’t treat her leg all the time? maybe then it wouldn’t have been amputated


Ayamu doesn't want to treat her wound that she got while escaping from her school, without trying to help any of her teammates, because she has a guilty conscience over it.
Aug 2, 2020 7:11 PM
Offline
May 2015
4
Papy-1412 said:
Damn, that was one kind of a journey...

Let's be honest, this show has a lot of issues. But I definitely disagree with those saying "this isn't worth your time". Because it is. It definitely is. Even with those issues, I think Japan Sinks deserves a watch.

The first one, that most people are talking about, is the animation/art. And yeah, the first episodes are very, very ugly, and more than that, they ruin some scenes that are supposed to be emotional. The scene about the senpai and the playing of his disk didn't make me feel anything, even though it should've, and it's because the art was just so... bad.
However, a show should never be judged only on it's direction, I mean it baffles me that people could come to watch a Yuasa and complain about animation not being super fluid/super pretty. And while Japan Sinks is certainly the "ugliest" (like, in an unwanted way, cos you know, Ping Pong) Yuasa work, I find it unfair to just talk about the failings when there's also tons and tons of amazing scenes and a wonderful direction overall. Episode 1 is, like, impeccable, and some scenes further on, the rap scene in particular, are brilliant. I'd say ep 2 to 5 are really hard to watch, and after that it's overall very good, art-wise.

Another problem I had with the show was the pacing/writing. Really, I honestly enjoyed the Sect arc (thanks to ep 6) but it didn't really go anywhere, and it left too much unexplained. And also I really can't understand the most stupid decision I've seen of the show aka all of them jumping on that little boat, when there's just been an earthquake. ...like, no, no, even to further the plot, you just can't, cmon.

But there's times when I kinda get it? Because, in my opinion, this anime is not about earthquakes/surviving etc. I really think this is what people who disliked the show missed. A lot about the show is metaphorical, it's shown very clearly in the second episode, with those two roads to follow. Who goes west, who goes east; who chooses to trust media and who chooses to distrust it. It's not even subtle. That's why I accepted a lot of the show's weird writing. Even if it comes from nowhere, if you look at it like a tale and not like a survival story, a lot of the weird deus ex machinas just make sense. This is not about realism, this is about putting characters in situations. And sometimes, it's not well done, that I completely agree. But still. I get it, somehow.

So yeah, I don't think you should watch Japan Sinks and just take everything it says for face value. And now I'm breaching what I wanted to talk about : I really don't understand how people could think the ending was some Japanese propaganda. Like... really, did we watch the same show? You know, the one where Japanese Nationalists, proudly wearing the hinomaru, manage to explode their own ship (once again, the metaphor is clear lol)? Or the show which ends with two hafus as Japan symbols? Really, you think this is propaganda?

Well I certainly don't see it that way. Because I think that what the show tries to convey is this message "Cherish your memories while you can". Taking pictures comes again and again in the show, it's not for nothing. The voice-over lines are all part of the memories of those that survived Japan sinking, in the end. All the pictures of "what Japan is", those are precious and beloved elements to the Japanese public (and not in a nationalist way). Those are not just cliches, those are things that deserve to be protected, and beloved while we can. Really, I remember when living in Kyoto, I asked a colleague what her favorite place in Kyoto was, and she answered Fushimi Inari & the Sagano train, both of which are in the epilogue.

And this is not even like this show shows Japan as a perfect place, like, come on. During ten episodes, peoples are fighting, stealing, some guys are trying to rape girls, and they're clearly shown as Japanese. The rap scene is about this exact thing, it's literally about confronting visions of Japan (and it's interesting because I've seen this exact debate while living in Japan, I met a Japanese guy who adores Japan, and one who hates it and dreams of living in Germany).

So yeah, I think Japan Sinks 2020 is mostly about the importance of cherishing the instant, what you have now, and that Japanese culture as a whole is something that deserves protection, like any other cultures. This makes terrible sense, not only with the current world situation (who even knows if humanity will survive past 2030 at this point...), but also, come on, history guys. You can't see this epilogue and think this is some propaganda, not if you've ever been to Hiroshima once in your life to visit the Peace Museum.

Because this is what Peace Museum in Hiroshima is. It shows how life was before the bombings. Then it shows in gruesome details everything that happened, during, after, long after, with a lot of pictures and explanations and words from witnesses. And then the museum ends exactly like the show did. What was before, all the memories of the beautiful times and now vanished buildings and dead people. But also a wide window to see the city, to see today's Hiroshima, which is a wonderful, green city, full of life, still standing.

This is what the epilogue of Japan Sinks is, for me, it's a call to protect what the world has to offer, but also the beautiful things humanity has managed to create. It's what it's gonna mean for a lot of Japanese watchers too, I think. And I guess that's what matters the most.
Thank you for writing this. I just wanted to say that.
Pages (3) « 1 [2] 3 »

More topics from this board

Poll: » Nihon Chinbotsu 2020 Episode 8 Discussion

Xenocrisi - Jul 9, 2020

32 by Baskarite »»
Jun 8, 10:47 PM

Poll: » Nihon Chinbotsu 2020 Episode 7 Discussion

Sigmar-Unberogen - Jul 9, 2020

25 by Baskarite »»
Jun 8, 10:07 PM

Poll: » Nihon Chinbotsu 2020 Episode 6 Discussion

FMmatron - Jul 9, 2020

47 by Baskarite »»
Jun 6, 9:22 PM

Poll: » Nihon Chinbotsu 2020 Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Gadottinho - Jul 9, 2020

54 by Baskarite »»
Jun 6, 8:42 PM

Poll: » Nihon Chinbotsu 2020 Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Gadottinho - Jul 9, 2020

59 by Baskarite »»
Jun 5, 8:04 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login