❌ Invalid Challenges

Offline

Jan 2017

2016

@Mnemosymnal @YayakoChii @SunflowerDaisho @sassss @isahbellah Your Challenges are all set now. Thanks for the corrections.

@Rno081 You August 2019 Challenge is all good. Did you want me to invalidate your Medium People Challenge? That way you can turn it in again whenever you finish it.

@YumeNoTsukii I'll go ahead and invalidate your Medium BINGO Challenge. No rush, you can resubmit it whenever you finish it again.

Sep 25, 2019 4:01 AM

#2204

Neo Angelique Abyss: Second Age

Offline

Jan 2017

2016

🚨PLEASE DO NOT DELETE YOUR TURN-IN POSTS!!🚨

greyjoie said:
Challenge: Character Tags Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: 10/22/18
End Date: 12/27/18
Post Link: here

Nana was started before the challenge.
The link for FLCL leads to a different anime.
❌INVALID

Amulet_Heart said:
Challenge: December 2018 Challenge
Start Date: December 1st
End Date: December 29nd
Post Link: here

User's list is private. Please make it public for challenge inspection.
❌INVALID

GNozaki said:
Challenge: Original Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: January 18, 2018
End Date: December 29, 2018
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1700442&show=0#msg53754685

The source for Aggressive Retsuko (ONA) is Other.
❌INVALID

Rno081 said:
Challenge: The Comedy Challenge.
Version: Medium
Start Date: Oct 21, 2017
End Date: Dec 28, 2018
Post Link: here.

Challenge: December 2018 Challenge.
Version: -
Start Date: Dec 1, 2018
End Date: Dec 29, 2018
Post Link: here.

Comedy Challenge MED - Kuroshitsuji II has characters with unnatural hair colors. (The triplets and Soma have purple hair, Grell has bright red hair)
Aggressive Retsuko: We Wish You a Metal Christmas had more than 3 characters listed.
The source for Astarotte no Omocha! EX is Manga. (Watch a game or unknown adaption comedy anime)
✅RESOLVED

December 2018 Challenge - Bakemono no Ko is not on your anime list. (Watch an anime with less than 31 episodes)
✅RESOLVED

SebastianOrf3 said:
Challenge: Fantasy Challenge
Version: Hard
Start Date: 27.04.2018
End Date: 25.12.2018
Link: Here

Challenge: The Ecchi Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Before Club
End Date: Before Club
Link: Here

Challenge: The Featured Article Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: 09.02.2018
End Date: 29.11.2018
Link: Here

Fantasy Challenge HARD - Zero kara Hajimeru Mahou no Sho has 4 genres listed. (Watch a TV-type that has only 3 or less genres listed)
✅RESOLVED

Ecchi Challenge EASY - Kuzu no Honkai is not tagged with Ecchi. (Watch an ecchi anime with a R+ rating)
✅RESOLVED

Featured Article Challenge EASY - Macross II: Lovers Again has less than 10 episodes.
Macross Plus has less than 10 episodes.
✅RESOLVED

FrostyFlame said:
Challenge: December 2018 Challenge
Version: N/A
Start Date: 25/12/2018
vEnd Date: 31/12/2018
Post Link: ~Link~

It doesn't seem like Kamichu! Specials has a Christmas episode. According to TV Tropes, the Christmas episode is in the main series so you could swap around the main series and the specials to fix this.
❌INVALID

TreasuredHopes said:
Challenge: School Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: May 19, 2017
End Date: January 02, 2019
Post Link: #14

Joshikousei: Girl's High was completed before the challenge.
❌INVALID

TheEdgelord said:
Challenge: The Drama Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: 16. 3. 2018
End Date: 2. 1. 2019
Post Link: HERE!

The link for Digimon Frontier: Ornismon Fukkatsu!! leads to a different anime.
Ginga Nagareboshi Gin is not ranked higher than 600. This requirement was recently reworded as "Watch an anime NOT ranked in the top 599."
✅RESOLVED

Jhiday said:
Challenge: Friday Collection
Start Date: 2018-10-11
End Date: 2019-01-01
Post Link: forum

Cuticle Tantei Inaba is used for both Friday and Unknown.
✅RESOLVED

AngelHana said:
Challenge: Romance Challenge
Version: Medium x1
Start Date: October 14th, 2017
End Date: December 31st, 2018
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1559055&show=200#post202

Itsuka Aeru Kimi ni is under 15 minutes total. (Watch an ONA)
✅RESOLVED

AobaSuzukaze said:
Challenge: Ecchi Challenge
Version: Hard
Start Date: 1-24-18
End Date: 1-3-19
Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1559904&show=179#msg53821822

It appears that you are upgrading from Easy to Hard, but the Easy challenge was never submitted. In the future, make sure to submit the challenge you are upgrading (Easy) then submit the upgraded challenge (Hard) using the correct form from the first page. I went ahead and inspected it as two challenges:

Ecchi Challenge EASY (previously watched) - Shuffle! Memories is a summary. (Watch a side story/spin-off)
✅RESOLVED

Ecchi Challenge HARD -
No Game No Life: Zero is not tagged with Ecchi. (Watch an anime with less than 5 episodes)
Grisaia no Kajitsu is not tagged with Ecchi. (Watch an ecchi anime adapted from a Visual Novel)
Masou Gakuen HxH Specials has more than 10k members.
✅RESOLVED (Note: Sin: Nanatsu no Taizai Zange-roku is 1.5 min per ep = 18 min total)

acestrawbs said:
Challenge: Mafia Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: BC
End Date: BC
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1743100&show=50#msg56552104

The following are not on any of the Mafia lists. They seem to be more themed around gangs and crime instead of the mafia:
Hakata Tonkotsu Ramens
K
Jormungand
❌INVALID

Memberdeactivate said:
Challenge: The Romance Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC
End Date: BC
Post link: Here

(Formerly Marmi)
Golden Time is not tagged with Shounen or Seinen.
❌INVALID

whibber said:
Challenge: Ecchi Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Before Club
End Date: Before Club
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1559904&show=250#msg56640245

Rosario to Vampire is used twice. (Watch an ecchi anime that aired between 2000 – 2010 & Watch an ecchi anime adapted from a Manga)
❌INVALID

AlexJ94 said:
Challenge: 2018 Anime Watching Challenge (Official)
Version: Hardcore
Start Date: 9 januari 2018
End Date: 24 december 2018
Post Link: (Sign up) https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1696289&show=1600#msg53650312
(turn in) https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1696289&show=1600#msg53650312

Challenge: January 2019 Challenge
Start Date: 3 jan
End Date: 4 jan
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1759369#msg56635939

2018 Anime Watching Challenge - The Official AWC Challenge is not handled by this club.

January 2019 Challenge - Sankarea OVA is not marked as completed on your anime list.
✅RESOLVED

CheeseKnife said:
Challenge: Fantasy Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Before Challenge Accepted
End Date: Before Challenge Accepted
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1567953&show=300#msg56644817

Shichisei no Subaru has more than 30k members.
Knight's & Magic has more than 80k members.
✅RESOLVED

YayakoChii said:
Challenge: Isekai Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC
End Date: 2018.12.03.
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1748492&show=0#post47

Challenge: Drama Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC
End Date: BC
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1713894&show=50#post70

Challenge: Fantasy Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: 2018.03.02.
End Date: 2018.12.31.
Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1567953&show=250#post251

Isekai Challenge EASY - Net-juu no Susume Special and Sword Art Online II: Sword Art Offline II are not tagged as Isekai. As far as I know, they aren't trapped in the game they are just playing it. (If you have another source, please provide it)
❌INVALID

Drama Challenge EASY - Love Stage!! is not tagged with Drama. (Watch a drama from J.C. Staff)
❌INVALID

Fantasy Challenge MED - Sword Art Online: Sword Art Offline - Extra Edition is under 15 minutes total and not tagged with Fantasy. (Watch a fantasy anime adapted from a Light Novel)
❌INVALID

greyjoie said:
Challenge: January 2019 Challenge
Version: n/a
Start Date: January 5, 2019
End Date: January 5, 2019
Post Link: here

Persona 5 the Animation TV Specials is not completed. (Watch any sequel/spin-off/OVA/special etc. related to anything you have watched before)
❌INVALID

YayakoChii said:
Challenge: Content Rating Challenge
Version:Easy
Start Date: 2018.03.01.
End Date: 2018.10.07.
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1630131&show=50#post86

Challenge: Original Challenge
Version:Medium
Start Date: 2018.03.07.
End Date: 2018.09.02.
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1700442&show=50#post69

Content Rating Challenge EASY - Gakuen Tokusou Hikaruon is rated R+ (Rated R)
❌INVALID

Original Challenge MED - The source for Aggressive Retsuko (ONA) is Other.
❌INVALID

TEMPEST_RIMURU said:
Challenge: The Original Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: May 03, 2018
End Date: Jan. 04, 2019
Post Link: Link!

It looks like Garo: Vanishing Line Recap was deleted from MAL.
✅RESOLVED

greyjoie said:
Challenge: Scavenger Hunt #2
Version: n/a
Start Date: 9/9/18
End Date: 1/5/19
Post Link: here

Persona 5 the Animation was started before the challenge. (Find and watch a series with more than 10,000 drops)
❌INVALID

Schlopsi said:
Challenge: School
Version: Easy
Start Date: July 01, 2017 (+ prior titles)
End Date: Feb 02, 2018
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1616522&show=50#msg51345009

Challenge: Romance
Version: Easy
Start Date: March 31, 2017 (+ prior finished titles)
End Date: Feb 01, 2018
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1559055&show=150#msg50167814

School Challenge EASY - Boku no Hero Academia the Movie 1: Futari no Hero is not tagged with School. (Watch a 2nd movie)
Prison School: Mad Wax (Prison School OVA) is used twice. (Watch an anime where all of the main characters are male & Watch an anime that first started airing the same month you joined MAL)
✅RESOLVED

Romance Challenge EASY - Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun: Tonari no Gokudou-kun is labeled Alternative Setting. (Watch a Side Story/Spin-off/Other)
✅RESOLVED

TundraIB said:
Challenge: Ecchi Challenge
Version: Easy Difficulty
Start Date: Before Club
End Date: 1/6/2019
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1559904&show=250#msg56659933

Maken-Ki! Two Aired in the Winter (Jan, Feb, Mar), MAL was joined in the Fall (Oct, Nov, Dec). (Watch an ecchi anime that aired the same season you joined MAL)
❌INVALID

TreasuredHopes said:
Challenge: OVA-per-day Challenge
Version: Conquered x2
Start Date: November 27, 2018
End Date: January 04, 2019
Post Link: #118

Challenge is OK - Please update your challenge to show that you missed Dec 2 and made it up on Dec 3.

Mari004 said:
Challenge: Historical
Version: Easy
Start Date: 3/26/18
End Date: 1/6/19
Post Link: Here

For the future, please put all challenges completed within 24 hours into one post.
Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun: Tonari no Gokudou-kun is an Alternative Setting. (Watch a Spin off or Side Story)
❌INVALID

TheEdgelord said:
Challenge: The 52 Weeks Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: 15. 10. 2018
End Date: 10. 1. 2019
Post Link: HERE!

Challenge: The JST Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: 21. 4. 2018
End Date: 10. 1. 2019
Post Link: HERE!

52 Weeks Challenge EASY - Challenge is OK - The link for Ping Pong the Animation leads to a different anime.

JST Challenge EASY - Jinzou Ningen Kikaider The Animation aired at 23:25 (23:30-23:59)
✅RESOLVED

Zenit said:
Challenge: The Original Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: 18 January, 2018
End Date: 10 January, 2019
Post Link: Here

The source for Aggressive Retsuko: We Wish You a Metal Christmas is Other.
✅RESOLVED on Jun 3, 2020

Memberdeactivate said:
Challenge: Drama
Version: Easy
Start Date: B.C.
End Date: B.C.
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1713894&show=150#msg56684561

(Formerly Marmi)
Interstella5555: The 5tory of The 5ecret 5tar 5ystem is a Music type. (Watch a second Movie)
❌INVALID

Kuollut98 said:
Challenge: January 2019 Challenge
Version:
Start Date: 1.1.2019
End Date: 11.1.2019
Post Link: here

Taishou Mebiusline: Chicchai-san - You and I is under 15 minutes total. (Watch any sequel/spin-off/OVA/special etc. related to anything you have watched before)
✅RESOLVED

Jhiday said:
Challenge: January 2019 Challenge
Start Date: 2019-01-01
End Date: 2019-01-14
Post Link: forum

Persona 5 the Animation TV Specials has 2 episodes. (Watch an anime that has only 1 episode)
✅RESOLVED

greyjoie said:
Challenge: User Ratings Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: May 9, 2018
End Date: January 15, 2019
Post Link: here

Wotaku ni Koi wa Muzukashii was started before the challenge. (Rated 10)
Shokugeki no Souma: San no Sara - Tootsuki Ressha-hen was started before the challenge. (Rated 7)
Tokyo Ghoul:re was started before the challenge. (Rated 6)
Samurai Champloo was started before the challenge. (Rated 4)
The link for FLCL leads to a different anime.
❌INVALID

AngelShiva said:
Challenge: Toriko Collection
Start Date: 2018-09-03
End Date: 2019-01-14
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/blog.php?eid=796441

Toriko Movie: Bishokushin no Special Menu is not on your anime list.
✅RESOLVED

Amulet_Heart said:
Challenge: January 2019 Challenge
Start Date: 2019-01-02
End Date: 2019-01-15
Post Link: Link

Anime list is private, please make it public for challenge inspection.
❌INVALID

Yterbium said:
Challenge: Game Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC
End Date: BC
Post Link: Link

The following do not have the Game genre or a Game source:

Higurashi no Naku Koro ni (Watch a TV Series)
Steins;Gate: Oukoubakko no Poriomania (Watch a Special/OVA)
Corpse Party: Tortured Souls - Bougyakusareta Tamashii no Jukyou (Watch a 3rd Special/OVA)
Steins;Gate Movie: Fuka Ryouiki no Déjà vu (Watch a Movie)
Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Rei (Watch an anime with 5 or less episodes)
Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai (Watch an Anime with between 20 and 30 episodes)
Clannad (Watch a Comedy anime)

Sword Art Online Alternative: Gun Gale Online is not labeled a Spinoff or Side-Story to another anime.
❌INVALID

Ace_Angel said:
Challenge: Horror Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC (Post Date: Jan 14, 2019)
End Date: BC (Turn in Date: Jan 19,2019)
Post Link: Challenge Post

Shinsekai yori aired in the Fall (Oct, Nov, Dec). MAL was joined in the Summer season (Jul, Aug, Sep). (Watch a Series that aired the same season you joined MAL)
❌INVALID

breathesunshine said:
Challenge: The Aired 2017 Challenge
Version:
Start Date: 11-08-18
End Date: 01-18-19
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1582386&show=350#msg56184870

Challenge: The 52 Weeks Challenge
Version: Conquered
Start Date: 01-22-18
End Date: 01-20-2019
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1544268&show=50#msg53804354

Aired 2017 Challenge - Omiai Aite wa Oshiego, Tsuyoki na, Mondaiji. is not on your anime list. (Fall 2017)
✅RESOLVED

52 Weeks Challenge CONQ - The requirement "Watch a series with a main character voiced by Nakamura Yuuichi" is used twice. (Week 30 and Week 39)
Ao no Exorcist: Kyoto Fujouou-hen OVA, Another: The Other - Inga, and Boku no Hero Academia: Training of the Dead are all OVA's (Watch at least 3 ONAs/Specials that are each 15+ minutes long) (Week 24)
Sugita Tomokazu's character in Ansatsu Kyoushitsu is not a main character. (Week 15)
If you don't have replacements for these mistakes, let me know and we can come up with a solution.
❌INVALID

AngelShiva said:
Challenge: The Monday Collection
Start Date: Oct 12, 2018
End Date: 2018/12/16
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/blog.php?eid=820015

Challenge: The Friday Collection
Start Date: Oct 12, 2018
End Date: 2018/12/16
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/blog.php?eid=820015

Challenge: The Aired January Challenge
Start Date: BC
End Date: 2018/12/19
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/blog.php?eid=809040

Monday Collection - The following are used for both Monday and Unknown:

Kanamemo

Gunslinger Girl: Il Teatrino (also used for Tues?)

Neo Angelique Abyss

UG☆Ultimate Girls

Chou Henshin Cosprayers is also used for Unknownx2
Kita e.: Diamond Dust Drops is also used for Tues and Unknownx2
✅RESOLVED

Friday Collection - The following are used for both Friday and Unknown:

GA: Geijutsuka Art Design Class Aired on Tuesday and is also used for Unknown.
Futsuu no Joshikousei ga [Locodol] Yattemita. was started before the challenge.
Gakuen Heaven: Hamu Hamu Heaven is under 15 minutes total.
✅RESOLVED

Full Year JAN - Afro Samurai aired on May 3. (Jan 4)
Ranma ½ Super did not initially air on Jan 19.
Ima, Soko ni Iru Boku did not initially air on Jan 20.
Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kira did not initially air on Jan 25.
Sugar*Soldier is under 10 minutes total.
Tabi Machi Late Show did not initially air on Jan 29.
Mobile Suit Gundam ZZ did not initially air on Jan 31.
✅RESOLVED

Jhiday said:
Challenge: Saturday Collection
Start Date: 2018-10-15
End Date: 2019-01-20
Post Link: here

Seiken no Blacksmith is used for both Saturday and Unknown.
Zettai Bouei Leviathan is used for both Saturday and Unknown.
✅RESOLVED

dianali said:
Challenge: January 2019 Challenge
Start Date: 14.01.2019
End Date: 20.01.2019
Post Link: Link

Boku no Hero Academia: Training of the Dead is a sequel/spin-off/OVA/special etc. to a show you have not seen. (Boku no Hero Academia S2)
❌INVALID

Odd Entries Completed
#8251 – #8499
SKIPPED #8253, #8405 @TreasuredHopes

Unresolved Posts have been Invalidated

ImyreldJun 3, 2020 8:23 AM

Sep 25, 2019 5:03 AM

#2205

TEMPEST_RIMURU

Offline

May 2015

1796

Imyreld said:

TEMPEST_RIMURU said:
Challenge: The Original Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: May 03, 2018
End Date: Jan. 04, 2019
Post Link: Link!

It looks like Garo: Vanishing Line Recap was deleted from MAL.

Replaced Garo: Vanishing Line Recap to Akanesasu Shoujo

Sep 25, 2019 5:27 AM

#2206

Rno081

Offline

Aug 2010

497

Imyreld said:

🚨PLEASE DO NOT DELETE YOUR TURN-IN POSTS!!🚨

Rno081 said:
Challenge: The Comedy Challenge.
Version: Medium
Start Date: Oct 21, 2017
End Date: Dec 28, 2018
Post Link: here.

Challenge: December 2018 Challenge.
Version: -
Start Date: Dec 1, 2018
End Date: Dec 29, 2018
Post Link: here.

Comedy Challenge MED - Kuroshitsuji II has characters with unnatural hair colors. (The triplets and Soma have purple hair, Grell has bright red hair)
Aggressive Retsuko: We Wish You a Metal Christmas had more than 3 characters listed.
The source for Astarotte no Omocha! EX is Manga. (Watch a game or unknown adaption comedy anime)

December 2018 Challenge - Bakemono no Ko is not on your anime list. (Watch an anime with less than 31 episodes)

All Entries Completed
#8251 – #8499 ODD
SKIPPED #8253, #8405 @TreasuredHopes

As for the Comdey Challenge MED:
* Changed the criteria for Kuroshitsuji II to (Watch a comedy anime with an all male main cast)
* Changed the criteria for Astarotte no Omocha! EX to (Watch a manga adaption comedy anime)
* Moved Ookami Shoujo to Kuro Ouji OVA to (Watch a comedy anime where all characters have natural color hair), and changed the criteria for Aggressive Retsuko: We Wish You a Metal Christmas to (Watch a comedy with only 1 episode)

As for the December 2018: Added the anime to my anime list.

Imyreld said:

@Rno081 You August 2019 Challenge is all good. Did you want me to invalidate your Medium People Challenge? That way you can turn it in again whenever you finish it.

Yes, please invalidate it.

Sep 25, 2019 5:50 AM

#2207

Jhiday

Offline

Apr 2010

2612

Imyreld said:

Jhiday said:
Challenge: Friday Collection
Start Date: 2018-10-11
End Date: 2019-01-01
Post Link: forum

Cuticle Tantei Inaba is used for both Friday and Unknown.

I replaced it (for Friday) with Saiki Kusuo no Ψ-nan: Kanketsu-hen, pushing the end date to 2019-01-13.

Jhiday said:
Challenge: January 2019 Challenge
Start Date: 2019-01-01
End Date: 2019-01-14
Post Link: forum

Persona 5 the Animation TV Specials has 2 episodes. (Watch an anime that has only 1 episode)

This entry used to track only one episode, until it got merged with a second special a few months later.
Anyway, I've swapped it with Lord El-Melloi II Sei no Jikenbo: Rail Zeppelin Grace Note - Hakamori to Neko to Majutsushi, also watched on 2019-01-01 (so no dates needed changing).

Jhiday said:
Challenge: Saturday Collection
Start Date: 2018-10-15
End Date: 2019-01-20
Post Link: here

Seiken no Blacksmith is used for both Saturday and Unknown.
Zettai Bouei Leviathan is used for both Saturday and Unknown.

I replaced them (for Saturday) with Weiß Survive R & Gintama Movie 1: Shinyaku Benizakura-hen, pushing the end date to 2019-01-24.

[AWC '16] - [AWC '17] - [AWC '18] - [AWC '19] - [AWC '20] - [AWC '21]

Sep 25, 2019 6:51 AM

#2208

Jhiday

Offline

Apr 2010

2612

isahbellah said:
Challenge: Demographics
Version: Hard
Start Date: 10/02/2019
End Date: 24/09/2019
Post Link:
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1525688&show=200#msg56916066

Please edit your post so that the link to your challenge is on the same line as "Post Link:" ; otherwise, the Hall of Fame can't recognize your turn-in as valid.

[AWC '16] - [AWC '17] - [AWC '18] - [AWC '19] - [AWC '20] - [AWC '21]

Sep 25, 2019 7:43 AM

#2209

Schlopsi

Offline

Mar 2016

1067

Imyreld said:

Schlopsi said:
Challenge: School
Version: Easy
Start Date: July 01, 2017 (+ prior titles)
End Date: Sep 25, 2019
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1616522&show=50#msg51345009

School Challenge EASY - Boku no Hero Academia the Movie 1: Futari no Hero is not tagged with School. (Watch a 2nd movie)
Prison School: Mad Wax (Prison School OVA) is used twice. (Watch an anime where all of the main characters are male & Watch an anime that first started airing the same month you joined MAL)

Replaced Boku no Hero the Movie 1: Futari no Hero with Little Witch Academia.
Replaced Prison School: Mad Wax with Aki no Kanade for Watch an anime that first started airing the same month you joined MAL.
Also fixed the name from Prison School OVA to Prison School: Mad Wax.
Edited the challenge ending date to today.

Challenge: Romance
Version: Easy
Start Date: March 31, 2017 (+ prior finished titles)
End Date: Sep 25, 2019
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1559055&show=150#msg50167814

Romance Challenge EASY - Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun: Tonari no Gokudou-kun is labeled Alternative Setting. (Watch a Side Story/Spin-off/Other)

Switched items to Watch an anime adapted from manga: Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun: Tonari no Gokudou-kun
Edited the challenge ending date to today.

Manga Reading Challenges Club

Sep 25, 2019 8:36 AM

#2210

acestrawbs

Offline

Jan 2015

906

@Imyreld
I just looked for best mafia anime and found this https://www.ranker.com/list/best-mafia-anime/reference

Sep 25, 2019 8:56 AM

#2211

isahbellah

Offline

Jul 2013

379

Jhiday said:

isahbellah said:
Challenge: Demographics
Version: Hard
Start Date: 10/02/2019
End Date: 24/09/2019
Post Link:
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1525688&show=200#msg56916066

Please edit your post so that the link to your challenge is on the same line as "Post Link:" ; otherwise, the Hall of Fame can't recognize your turn-in as valid.

Fixed it!! :)

Sep 25, 2019 9:21 AM

#2212

Kuollut98

Offline

Feb 2017

2373

Imyreld said:

Kuollut98 said:
Challenge: January 2019 Challenge
Version:
Start Date: 1.1.2019
End Date: 11.1.2019
Post Link: here

Taishou Mebiusline: Chicchai-san - You and I is under 15 minutes total. (Watch any sequel/spin-off/OVA/special etc. related to anything you have watched before)

Replaced wit wotakoi OVA

FS made by KonoDioDa <3

Sep 25, 2019 11:51 AM

#2213

SebastianOrf3

Offline

Oct 2012

249

Imyreld said:

SebastianOrf3 said:
Challenge: Fantasy Challenge
Version: Hard
Start Date: 27.04.2018
End Date: 25.12.2018
Link: Here

Challenge: The Ecchi Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Before Club
End Date: Before Club
Link: Here

Challenge: The Featured Article Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: 09.02.2018
End Date: 29.11.2018
Link: Here

Fantasy Challenge HARD - Zero kara Hajimeru Mahou no Sho has 4 genres listed. (Watch a TV-type that has only 3 or less genres listed)

Ecchi Challenge EASY - Kuzu no Honkai is not tagged with Ecchi. (Watch an ecchi anime with a R+ rating)

Featured Article Challenge EASY - Macross II: Lovers Again has less than 10 episodes.
Macross Plus has less than 10 episodes.

Fantasy Challenge HARD - Deleted this anime. Added for this requirement Divine Gate. Changed completed date to 29.04.2019

Ecchi Challenge EASY - Deleted this anime. Added for requirement Watch an OVA Sankarea OVA.

Featured Article Challenge EASY - Deleted this anime. Moved from not complete another level - Ichigo Mashimaro and Yojouhan Shinwa Taikei. Changed completed date to 27.12.2018.

P.A.Works isn't an anime studio. P.A.Works is the meaning of life

Sep 26, 2019 7:04 PM

#2214

KitsunehimeMilhi

Offline

Jul 2016

810

@Imyreld

That's why I guess I'll need to screenshot from now on. I know those entries were tagged ecchi when I used them. Sorry for using the form wrong. I was following the format one of my friends on here used when they did challenges here, and he didn't seem to get complaints, so it seemed fine.

I probably have enough for medium then. Would it possible to just change my challenge to that difficulty after making corrections?

Sep 27, 2019 5:57 AM

#2215

AngelHana

Offline

Jul 2009

4679

@Imyreld

replaced it with Tong Ling Fei. (Took it from my Romance hard challenge.

signature set credited to Bunnyama

「No human has ever been whole. 」

Oct 1, 2019 1:46 PM

#2216

Offline

Jul 2016

12951

PLEASE DO NOT DELETE YOUR TURN-IN POST(S)! THANK YOU.

NickWilks said:
Challenge: December 2018
Version: N/A
Start Date: 06 December 2018
End Date: 31/December 2018
Post Link: Link

*Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 is not tagged with horror.
*Overlord III is in your Watching list.
❌INVALID

jho0on_ said:
Challenge: Ecchi
Version: Easy
Start Date: Before Club
End Date: Before Club
Post Link: Link

*Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai Next is not tagged with Ecchi.
Resolved

Niveen_Sleem said:

EDITED

October 2018
*Yami Shibai does not have a score below 6 or above 8.
Resolved

October 2017
*Please state which main character has orange hair. Both Erina Nakiri and Takumi Aldini have blonde hair.
Resolved

May 2017
*Da Yu Hai Tang (Movie) is not tagged with Super Power nor does it have a Superhero theme.
Resolved

March 2017
*Madlax does not have only female main characters (Carrossea Doon is also a main character).
Resolved

greyjoie said:
Challenge: Time Travel Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: 9/19/18
End Date: 12/29/18
Post Link: here

*CLAMP in Wonderland and CLAMP in Wonderland 2 are in your PTW list.
❌INVALID

Yterbium said:

Challenge: The Sports Challenge #2
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC
End Date: 1-4-2018
Post Link: Here

Challenge: The Romance Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC
End Date: 1-4-2018
Post Link: Here

Challenge: The Drama Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC
End Date: 1-4-2018
Post Link: Here

Sports
*Kuroko no Basket NG-shuuis a special.
*Haikyuu!!: Lev Genzan! is an OVA.
❌INVALID

Romance
*Elfen Lied cannot have anime-related entries for this requirement.
*Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei does not end with the same last letter as your username (Yterbium).
*Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu (2009) is not tagged with Supernatural or Drama.
❌INVALID

Drama
*Angel Beats!: Another Epilogue is less than 15 minutes.
❌INVALID

Charlotte1412 said:
Challenge: Content Rating TV Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: 30/9/17
End Date: 4/1/19
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1522281&show=100#msg52501973

*According to your anime list, Tonari no Seki-kun was previously completed.
Resolved

mansprout said:
Challenge: comedy challenge
Version: easy
Start Date: 05.01.2019
End Date: 05.01.2019
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1560539&show=350#msg56645802

*Keijo!!!!!!!! is not tagged with Comedy.
Resolved

ExperienceLD said:
Challenge: Scavenger Hunt #11
Version:
Start Date: Oct 30, 2018
End Date: Jan 04, 2018
Post Link: Link

*According to your anime list, Pokemon Movie 05: Mizu no Miyako no Mamorigami Latias to Latios was previously completed.
Resolved

Wyvern22 said:
Challenge: - The Multi. Genre Challenge x2 -
Version: Medium
Start Date: 08.10.2018
End Date: 05.01.2019
Post Link: Link

*You have used Action six times.
Resolved

vvicked said:
Challenge: The Fantasy Challenge
Version: Med
Start Date: May 8, 2018
End Date: Jan 3, 2019
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1567953&show=250#msg55197116

*Yakusoku no Nanaya Matsuri is not tagged with fantasy.
❌INVALID

AnshiAneko said:
Challenge: Reviewed Challenge x2
Version: Easy
Start Date: 16 Nov 2018
End Date: 7 Jan 2019
Post Link: link

*Reviews must be written after your challenge start date. As for your entries, Yagate Kimi ni Naru would qualify for the challenge, the rest were written before your challenge.
Invalid

Titadou said:
Challenge: The Romance Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: December 13, 2017
End Date: January 5, 2019
Post Link: here

*Asobi ni Iku yo! has not been scored by 80k+ members (around 65k, the number right under the score).
Resolved

All Entries Completed
#8301 – #8400

Unresolved Posts have been Invalidated

NaineLIEzJan 13, 2020 2:17 PM

"Happy Unbirthday."

set by ani ♥

Oct 1, 2019 1:46 PM

#2217

Offline

Jul 2016

12951

PLEASE DO NOT DELETE YOUR TURN-IN POST(S)! THANK YOU.

Tubbyman said:
Challenge: Scavenger Hunt #25
Version: Butterfly
Start Date: 4-10-18
End Date: 5-30-18
Post Link: Here

*You already have turned in your SH#25 in a previous post and it already got validated.
❌INVALID

TreasuredHopes said:
Challenge: Content Rating Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: June 27, 2017
End Date: January 10, 2019
Post Link: #23

*Hanasaku Kizuna no Romantan doesn't have a rating.
❌INVALID

JGChaves said:
Challenge: Comedy Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: 07/22/17
End Date: 01/11/19
Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1560539&show=150#msg51625139

*Net-juu no Susume Special is adapted from a web manga and cannot be used for your chosen requirement.
*Kobayashi-san Chi no Maid Dragon: Valentine, Soshite Onsen! - Amari Kitai Shinaide Kudasai is a special.
Resolved

Punkero said:
Challenge: Saturday Collection
Start Date: 13/10/2018
End Date: 12/01/2019
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1745311#msg55948279

*According to your anime list, you have completed Bleach Movie 1: Memories of Nobody before your start date.
Resolved

MissCactus said:
Challenge: Isekai Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Before Club
End Date: Before Club
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1748492&show=50#msg56712675

Challenge: User Ratings Challenge
Version: Hard
Start Date: October 7, 2017
End Date: January 14, 2019
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1509858&show=50#msg51310263

Challenge: Reviewed Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: May 17, 2018
End Date: September 25, 2018
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1565485&show=50#msg54340444

Isekai
*Zero no Tsukaima: Princesses no Rondo is in your on-hold list.
Resolved

User Rating
*Fairy Tail: User must have completed the series.
*AvatarTrix is not a club member.
*GrapefruitNeko doesn't exist/cannot be found.
❌INVALID

Review
The following reviews have been deleted:
*Mushishi Zoku Shou
*3-gatsu no Lion
❌INVALID

The following reviews were written before your start date:
*Mangirl!
*Suisei no Gargantia
*BanG Dream!
Resolved

Wyvern22 said:
Challenge: - The Character Tags Challenge -
Version: Medium
Start Date: 05.11.2018
End Date: 07.01.2019
Post Link: Link

Challenge: - The Character Tags Challenge -
Version: Easy
Start Date: 07.12.2018
End Date: 14.01.2019
Post Link: Link

You have used the following characters twice (characters can only be used once throughout all difficulties):
*Joe Gibson (Easy and Medium)
*Hugo (Easy and Medium)
*Satou (Conquered and Medium)
*Charles de Guise (Hard and Easy)
Resolved

greyjoie said:
Challenge: User Ratings Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: May 9, 2018
End Date: January 15, 2019
Post Link: here

- (Adding onto previous post) -
The following series don't have 10+ episodes and need to be replaced since they're not 15+ min or longer per episode:
*Hetalia World Series Specials
*Hetalia: The World Twinkle Specials
*Kamisama Hajimemashita OVA
❌INVALID

blaziken25 said:
Challenge: January 2019 Challenge
Version:
Start Date: 6 January
End Date: 10 January
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1759369&show=150#msg56653644

*Samurai Noodles: The Originator is less than 15 minutes.
❌INVALID

Punkero said:
Challenge: Comedy Challenge X2
Version: Hard
Start Date: 30/01/2018
End Date: 15/01/2019
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1560539&show=250#msg53894093

*There is no series listed for the requirement Watch a comedy series with only a Japanese title.
*Kiitarou Shounen no Youkai Enikki is rated PG-13.
*According to your anime list, you have completed Slam Dunk: Zenkoku Seiha Da! - Sakuragi Hanamichi before your challenge start date (Last Updated shows as 01-27-18).
*Cardcaptor Sakura: Clear Card-hen also has been used for your Medium x2 difficulty.
Invalid

greyjoie said:
Challenge: Featured Article Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: September 25, 2018
End Date: January 9, 2019
Post Link: here

*Panzer Dragoon does not have 10+ episodes.
❌INVALID

Jhiday said:
Challenge: Steampunk Challenge
Start Date: Before Club
End Date: 2019-01-17
Post Link: Link

The following series do not have a Steampunk tag or were removed from the club:

Resolved

breathesunshine said:
Challenge: The 52 Weeks Challenge
Version: Conquered
Start Date: 01-22-18
End Date: 01-20-2019
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1544268&show=50#msg53804354

- (Adding onto previous post) -
*Week 49 should've run from Dec 24th to Dec 30th (Week Start/End: MON-SUN). For this, you have started Kamisama Hajimemashita◎ one day earlier (Dec 23rd).
❌INVALID

All Entries Completed
#8401 – #8500

Unresolved Posts have been Invalidated

ImyreldJan 16, 2020 12:04 AM

"Happy Unbirthday."

set by ani ♥

Oct 1, 2019 1:47 PM

#2218

Offline

Jul 2016

12951

PLEASE DO NOT DELETE YOUR TURN-IN POST(S)! THANK YOU.

AngelShiva said:
Challenge: The Tuesday Collection
Start Date: Oct 12, 2018
End Date: 2018/12/28
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/blog.php?eid=820015

(Partially overlapping with this invalidation):
*Gunslinger Girl: Il Teatrino initially aired on Monday (start date). You have listed this series in your Monday, Tuesday and Unknown collection. It can only count to the Monday or Unknown challenge.
*Yuugo: Koushounin has been used twice.
*GA: Geijutsuka Art Design Class has been used in your Friday and Unknown Collection.
*Hanoka was also used for your Unknown Collection.
Resolved

Klllady said:
Challenge: The Romance Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC
End Date: 11/15/2018
Post Link: Here

- (Adding onto previous post) -
*Toradora! has anime related series.
❌INVALID

YayakoChii said:
Challenge: The Character Tags Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: 2018.10.27.
End Date: 2018.12.07.
Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1747235&show=0#post47

*Otoya Ittoki does not have the Singers tag.
Resolved

daedaccount2028 said:
Challenge: The Action Challenge
Version: Easy x1
Start Date: BC
End Date: BC
Post Link: Here

*Access to your anime list has been restricted.
❌INVALID

ownitlikeaboss said:
Challenge: CGI Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Before Club
End Date: 12/29/18
Post Link: Here

*Ao Oni The Animation is not tagged with CGI.
Resolved

Imyreld said:
Challenge: CGI Challenge
Version: Hard
Start Date: BC
End Date: Jan 28, 2019
Post Link: Link

*Kuroshitsuji Movie: Book of the Atlantic is not tagged with CGI.
Resolved

lifeiscrazy said:
Challenge: Mascot Challenge
Version: Conquered
Start Date: Before Club [if it's counted from the first series, from the original Easy part, if it's only from the new entries starting from number 11, it's 06/10/2017]
End Date: 07/03/2019
Post Link: xxx

Upgrading From: Easy
Upgrading To: Conquered

(Please note that this challenge has been crossed out in the HoF and you might need to resubmit)
Please explain in which way the following characters can be seen as mascots:
*Shouko "Spooky Boogie" Sugawara - As mascots are non-humans, Shouko Sugawara is a human and is "just" using her avatar and cannot transform or the likes, so I wouldn't see her as a mascot. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
*Ebon Candle
*Strawberry Heart - It seems like a guitar that can talk (?).
Returned-in
❌INVALID

Sethlans said:
Challenge: Post-Apocalyptic Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: BC
End Date: BC
Post Link: Here

*Your challenge is valid as you have enough entries listed, but please make the following changes:
*Cowboy Bebop: Tengoku no Tobira is not tagged as post-apocalyptic.

All Entries Completed
#8501 – #8600

Unresolved Posts have been Invalidated

NaineLIEzJan 13, 2020 2:17 PM

"Happy Unbirthday."

set by ani ♥

Oct 1, 2019 1:57 PM

#2219

YayakoChii

Offline

Mar 2016

2044

NaineLIEz said:

YayakoChii said:
Challenge: The Character Tags Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: 2018.10.27.
End Date: 2018.12.07.
Post Link:https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1747235&show=0#post47

*Otoya Ittoki does not have the Singers tag.

Thats interesting, if he didnt have I wouldnt use it so maybe they changed it. I changed Singers tag to Idols tag.

Oct 1, 2019 2:03 PM

#2220

Offline

Jul 2016

12951

@YayakoChii thanks for fixing, your challenge looks good now.

"Happy Unbirthday."

set by ani ♥

Oct 1, 2019 2:09 PM

#2221

Keiken

Fantasy lover

Offline

Aug 2017

1280

NaineLIEz said:

ExperienceLD said:
Challenge: Scavenger Hunt #11
Version:
Start Date: Oct 30, 2018
End Date: Jan 04, 2018
Post Link: Link

*According to your anime list, Pokemon Movie 05: Mizu no Miyako no Mamorigami Latias to Latios was previously completed.

I watched some of the movies as a child and I started adding the start/end dates for all my series a month ago. I probably thought that I watched that one as a child. Here is a screenshot of my list.

Oct 1, 2019 2:13 PM

#2222

lifeiscrazy

꧁ marr

Offline

Sep 2014

1345

NaineLIEz said:

lifeiscrazy said:
Challenge: Mascot Challenge
Version: Conquered
Start Date: Before Club [if it's counted from the first series, from the original Easy part, if it's only from the new entries starting from number 11, it's 06/10/2017]
End Date: 07/03/2019
Post Link: xxx

Upgrading From: Easy
Upgrading To: Conquered

(Please note that this challenge has been crossed out in the HoF and you might need to resubmit)
Please explain in which way the following characters can be seen as mascots:
*Shouko "Spooky Boogie" Sugawara - As mascots are non-humans, Shouko Sugawara is a human and is "just" using her avatar and cannot transform or the likes, so I wouldn't see her as a mascot. Please correct me if I'm wrong. -- yeah it it is. Is Dominator a mascot? Then I'll switch it for that. Honestly those mascots are confusing, isn't there like a master list/tag on anime-planet for it maybe?
*Ebon Candle -https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WorldEnd#Characters its way too long ago that i remember much about it, it's some sort of deity/beast/monster?!
*Strawberry Heart - It seems like a guitar that can talk (?). - it is, can mascots not be things/sentient objects?

if they're not ok i'll add those from medium to it and be done with it :P
✔ #01 Tokyo Marble Chocolate [Miniroba ~ mini donkey]
✔ #04 Sidonia no Kishi: Daikyuu Wakusei Seneki [Tsumugi Shiraui ~ alien sorta something]
✔ #06 One Punch Man [Armored Gorilla ~ monster gorilla]

lifeiscrazyOct 1, 2019 2:21 PM

LIFE IS CRAZY AND SO ARE YOU
♫♫♫

Oct 1, 2019 2:49 PM

#2223

Wyvern22

Offline

Jan 2013

1818

NaineLIEz said:

Wyvern22 said:
Challenge: - The Multi. Genre Challenge x2 -
Version: Medium
Start Date: 08.10.2018
End Date: 05.01.2019
Post Link: Link

*You have used Action six times.

Sorry about that. For 「 Hokuto no Ken: Yuria-den 」 changed Action for Adventure.

NaineLIEz said:

Wyvern22 said:
Challenge: - The Character Tags Challenge -
Version: Medium
Start Date: 05.11.2018
End Date: 07.01.2019
Post Link: Link

Challenge: - The Character Tags Challenge -
Version: Easy
Start Date: 07.12.2018
End Date: 14.01.2019
Post Link: Link

You have used the following characters twice (characters can only be used once throughout all difficulties):
*Joe Gibson (Easy and Medium)
*Hugo (Easy and Medium)
*Satou (Conquered and Medium)
*Charles de Guise (Hard and Easy)

I was pretty sure that rule wasn't there before. Since my second try was invalidated i'm using what i did there.

The Character Tags Challenge (Medium)
Replaced Satou with 「 Kouichirou Tamaki "Rinko's Father" 」
Ending date updated.

The Character Tags Challenge (Easy)
Replaced Joe Gibson with 「 Hyou 」
Replaced Hugo with 「 Meroko Yui 」
Replaced Charles de Guise with 「 Hamel 」
Ending date updated.

Wyvern22Oct 3, 2019 3:13 AM

Oct 1, 2019 2:52 PM

#2224

JGChaves

Offline

Nov 2013

1842

NaineLIEz said:

PLEASE DO NOT DELETE YOUR TURN-IN POST(S)! THANK YOU.

JGChaves said:
Challenge: Comedy Challenge
Version: Medium
Start Date: 07/22/17
End Date: 01/11/19
Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1560539&show=150#msg51625139

*Net-juu no Susume Special is adapted from a web manga and cannot be used for your chosen requirement.
*Kobayashi-san Chi no Maid Dragon: Valentine, Soshite Onsen! - Amari Kitai Shinaide Kudasai is a special.

Fixed that. Removed Net-juu no Susume special and moved Kobayashi-san Special to Watch a manga adaption comedy anime. Then I added Top wo Nerae! Gunbuster under Watch a comedy AND drama anime.

Oct 1, 2019 3:17 PM

#2225

Offline

Jun 2015

2500

Niveen_Sleem said:

EDITED

October 2018
*Yami Shibai does not have a score below 6 or above 8.

October 2017
*Please state which main character has orange hair. Both Erina Nakiri and Takumi Aldini have blonde hair.

May 2017
*Da Yu Hai Tang (Movie) is not tagged with Super Power nor does it have a Superhero theme.

March 2017
*Madlax does not have only female main characters (Carrossea Doon is also a main character).

These are old challenges. At the time they met the criteria. The database changes every now and then as you know. I designated Erina as my character of choice. I removed Madlax and put El Cazador de la Bruja instead (this was started and finished in March). About Da Yu Hai Tang, it did have a super power tag at the time I watched it and the same goes for Yami Shibai. It was below 6 at the time I watched it. The score has increased.

Niveen_SleemOct 1, 2019 3:31 PM

If you are going to disagree with me, don't bother talking to me. I will seriously hurt you!

Oct 1, 2019 3:27 PM

#2226

ownitlikeaboss

Offline

Sep 2014

4340

NaineLIEz said:

PLEASE DO NOT DELETE YOUR TURN-IN POST(S)! THANK YOU.

ownitlikeaboss said:
Challenge: CGI Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: Before Club
End Date: 12/29/18
Post Link: Here

*Ao Oni The Animation is not tagged with CGI.

Replaced with Zhen Hun Jie

ルルリラ
♡♡

Oct 1, 2019 4:19 PM

#2227

Punkero

Offline

Feb 2014

7796

@NaineLIEz is ok if I replace that entry with one seasonal I finished recently?, I don't really to touch the start and end date of the later turn-ins of the Saturday Collection

If so, it will be DanMachi season 2 https://myanimelist.net/anime/37347/Dungeon_ni_Deai_wo_Motomeru_no_wa_Machigatteiru_Darou_ka_II

As for the Comedy Challenge, I will let it be invalidated and continue working and it and turn in again at a later date.

Oct 1, 2019 7:19 PM

#2228

Charlotte1412

Offline

Apr 2016

8351

NaineLIEz said:

Charlotte1412 said:
Challenge: Content Rating TV Challenge
Version: Easy
Start Date: 30/9/17
End Date: 4/1/19
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1522281&show=100#msg52501973

*According to your anime list, Tonari no Seki-kun was previously completed.

Edited my post!

~~}~MY PROFILE

♥ Delivery Blog ♥

~~~~~MY CLUB

Oct 1, 2019 10:43 PM

#2229

Offline

Jan 2017

2016

NaineLIEz said:

Imyreld said:
Challenge: CGI Challenge
Version: Hard
Start Date: BC
End Date: Jan 28, 2019
Post Link: Link

*Kuroshitsuji Movie: Book of the Atlantic is not tagged with CGI.

Replaced with Mo Dao Zu Shi and updated the end date.

Oct 2, 2019 1:32 AM

#2230

Jhiday

Offline

Apr 2010

2612

NaineLIEz said:

Jhiday said:
Challenge: Steampunk Challenge
Start Date: Before Club
End Date: 2019-01-17
Post Link: Link

The following series do not have a Steampunk tag or were removed from the club:

Uh, that must have happened after I turned in (and the first inspection).
Anyway, I replaced them with the following :
Mahou Shoujo-tai Arusu
Mahou Shoujo-tai Arusu the Adventure
Megalo Box
Sirius
Tegamibachi
Fullmetal Alchemist
Fullmetal Alchemist: Premium Collection
Fullmetal Alchemist: Reflections
Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2
... which pushes the completion date all the way down to 2019-06-30.

[AWC '16] - [AWC '17] - [AWC '18] - [AWC '19] - [AWC '20] - [AWC '21]

Oct 2, 2019 3:53 AM

#2231

AlexJ94

Offline

Sep 2013

116

Imyreld said:

AlexJ94 said:
Challenge: 2018 Anime Watching Challenge (Official)
Version: Hardcore
Start Date: 9 januari 2018
End Date: 24 december 2018
Post Link: (Sign up) https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1696289&show=1600#msg53650312
(turn in) https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1696289&show=1600#msg53650312

Challenge: January 2019 Challenge
Start Date: 3 jan
End Date: 4 jan
Post Link: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1759369#msg56635939

2018 Anime Watching Challenge - The Official AWC Challenge is not handled by this club.

January 2019 Challenge - Sankarea OVA is not marked as completed on your anime list.

fixed sankarea

ImyreldOct 8, 2019 9:05 PM

Oct 2, 2019 11:04 AM

#2232

Offline

Jul 2016

12951

@ExperienceLD @Wyvern22 @ownitlikeaboss @Charlotte1412 @Imyreld @Jhiday Your challenges are valid now, thanks for fixing.

@JGChaves Your challenge is also valid, but please remember to change your end date in the Challenge Turn-in thread.

@Punkero I'll go ahead and invalidate your Comedy Challenge. Your Saturday collection looks good now.

lifeiscrazy said:

NaineLIEz said:
(Please note that this challenge has been crossed out in the HoF and you might need to resubmit)
Please explain in which way the following characters can be seen as mascots:
*Shouko "Spooky Boogie" Sugawara - As mascots are non-humans, Shouko Sugawara is a human and is "just" using her avatar and cannot transform or the likes, so I wouldn't see her as a mascot. Please correct me if I'm wrong. -- yeah it it is. Is Dominator a mascot? Then I'll switch it for that. Honestly those mascots are confusing, isn't there like a master list/tag on anime-planet for it maybe?
*Ebon Candle -https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WorldEnd#Characters its way too long ago that i remember much about it, it's some sort of deity/beast/monster?!
*Strawberry Heart - It seems like a guitar that can talk (?). - it is, can mascots not be things/sentient objects?

if they're not ok i'll add those from medium to it and be done with it :P
✔ #01 Tokyo Marble Chocolate [Miniroba ~ mini donkey]
✔ #04 Sidonia no Kishi: Daikyuu Wakusei Seneki [Tsumugi Shiraui ~ alien sorta something]
✔ #06 One Punch Man [Armored Gorilla ~ monster gorilla]

From what I've read on wiki, Ebon Candle can be accepted as a mascot. As for Dominator, it's unfortunately also a no. (I'll shamelessly copy & paste my answer when somebody asked me about the challenge):
'Inanimate objects with voices don't count as mascots automatically. They must be either alive, or at least they aren't primarily meant to be a weapon and such. So a magical wand or a speaking motorcycle like Hermes from Kino no Tabi wouldn't be considered as one.' The Dominator and Strawberry Heart wouldn't also count. 'A mascot is a (non-human) character that most likely serves as a symbolization of an anime. They must possess a level of intelligence and the ability to act and move on its own will.'
I hope that helped you a bit and didn't confuse you even more. We're aware that this challenge is a bit confusing, that's why we barely invalidate this challenge directly and ask for an explanation to why you've chosen these characters as mascots before we decide.
tl;dr Ebon Candle has been accepted as a mascot. I'll have to ask you to change Shouko Sugawara/Dominator and Strawberry Heart though. Thank you for your patience.

Niveen_Sleem said:
These are old challenges. At the time they met the criteria. The database changes every now and then as you know. I designated Erina as my character of choice. I removed Madlax and put El Cazador de la Bruja instead (this was started and finished in March). About Da Yu Hai Tang, it did have a super power tag at the time I watched it and the same goes for Yami Shibai. It was below 6 at the time I watched it. The score has increased.

As anisearch states that Erina's hair color is orange, your October 2017 challenge is valid. Your March 2017 challenge also looks good now.
As for Da Yu Hai Tang, I've used http://web.archive.org/ to check the genres. Here is a screenshot from May 9, 2017. I couldn't find the Super Power tag in the snapshots before and after the challenge month either.
My hands are also for Yami Shibai S6. Unfortunately, the score isn't close enough to a score of 5.99 to let it pass. Maybe you have watched anything to be able to replace the series? Or a screenshot. As scores always change, it is not bad to make screenshots, just in case.

NaineLIEzOct 2, 2019 11:09 AM

"Happy Unbirthday."

set by ani ♥

Oct 2, 2019 11:32 AM

#2233

lifeiscrazy

꧁ marr

Offline

Sep 2014

1345

NaineLIEz said:

lifeiscrazy said:

if they're not ok i'll add those from medium to it and be done with it :P
✔ #01 Tokyo Marble Chocolate [Miniroba ~ mini donkey]
✔ #04 Sidonia no Kishi: Daikyuu Wakusei Seneki [Tsumugi Shiraui ~ alien sorta something]
✔ #06 One Punch Man [Armored Gorilla ~ monster gorilla]

From what I've read on wiki, Ebon Candle can be accepted as a mascot. As for Dominator, it's unfortunately also a no. (I'll shamelessly copy & paste my answer when somebody asked me about the challenge):
'Inanimate objects with voices don't count as mascots automatically. They must be either alive, or at least they aren't primarily meant to be a weapon and such. So a magical wand or a speaking motorcycle like Hermes from Kino no Tabi wouldn't be considered as one.' The Dominator and Strawberry Heart wouldn't also count. 'A mascot is a (non-human) character that most likely serves as a symbolization of an anime. They must possess a level of intelligence and the ability to act and move on its own will.'
I hope that helped you a bit and didn't confuse you even more. We're aware that this challenge is a bit confusing, that's why we barely invalidate this challenge directly and ask for an explanation to why you've chosen these characters as mascots before we decide.
tl;dr Ebon Candle has been accepted as a mascot. I'll have to ask you to change Shouko Sugawara/Dominator and Strawberry Heart though. Thank you for your patience.

It'll always be my least fav challenge hahahah :P

I changed the Conquered + original Easy one (because spooky was from the original easy I upgraded).

I'll resubmitted it, does that mean it's all the way at the back again?
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1797918&show=400#msg58454977

LIFE IS CRAZY AND SO ARE YOU
♫♫♫

Oct 2, 2019 12:21 PM

#2234

Offline

Jul 2016

12951

@lifeiscrazy Thanks for the changes. I'm not sure why exactly this has been crossed out in the HoF, but it's high likely that you won't be called out for this challenge again (at least for this difficulty) since it has been inspected twice now. And you've also linked to the Invalidation post, so there shouldn't be any problems anymore (:

"Happy Unbirthday."

set by ani ♥

Oct 2, 2019 12:25 PM

#2235

lifeiscrazy

꧁ marr

Offline

Sep 2014

1345

NaineLIEz said:
@lifeiscrazy Thanks for the changes. I'm not sure why exactly this has been crossed out in the HoF, but it's high likely that you won't be called out for this challenge again (at least for this difficulty) since it has been inspected twice now. And you've also linked to the Invalidation post, so there shouldn't be any problems anymore (:

I'll link to this post just in case too~. Merci beaucoup and have a good evening (or day!)

LIFE IS CRAZY AND SO ARE YOU
♫♫♫

Oct 2, 2019 12:25 PM

#2236

Offline

Jun 2015

2500

NaineLIEz said:
@ExperienceLD @Wyvern22 @ownitlikeaboss @Charlotte1412 @Imyreld @Jhiday Your challenges are valid now, thanks for fixing.

@JGChaves Your challenge is also valid, but please remember to change your end date in the Challenge Turn-in thread.

@Punkero I'll go ahead and invalidate your Comedy Challenge. Your Saturday collection looks good now.
unfortunately I don't have any replacements for the other two

lifeiscrazy said:

if they're not ok i'll add those from medium to it and be done with it :P
✔ #01 Tokyo Marble Chocolate [Miniroba ~ mini donkey]
✔ #04 Sidonia no Kishi: Daikyuu Wakusei Seneki [Tsumugi Shiraui ~ alien sorta something]
✔ #06 One Punch Man [Armored Gorilla ~ monster gorilla]

From what I've read on wiki, Ebon Candle can be accepted as a mascot. As for Dominator, it's unfortunately also a no. (I'll shamelessly copy & paste my answer when somebody asked me about the challenge):
'Inanimate objects with voices don't count as mascots automatically. They must be either alive, or at least they aren't primarily meant to be a weapon and such. So a magical wand or a speaking motorcycle like Hermes from Kino no Tabi wouldn't be considered as one.' The Dominator and Strawberry Heart wouldn't also count. 'A mascot is a (non-human) character that most likely serves as a symbolization of an anime. They must possess a level of intelligence and the ability to act and move on its own will.'
I hope that helped you a bit and didn't confuse you even more. We're aware that this challenge is a bit confusing, that's why we barely invalidate this challenge directly and ask for an explanation to why you've chosen these characters as mascots before we decide.
tl;dr Ebon Candle has been accepted as a mascot. I'll have to ask you to change Shouko Sugawara/Dominator and Strawberry Heart though. Thank you for your patience.

Niveen_Sleem said:
These are old challenges. At the time they met the criteria. The database changes every now and then as you know. I designated Erina as my character of choice. I removed Madlax and put El Cazador de la Bruja instead (this was started and finished in March). About Da Yu Hai Tang, it did have a super power tag at the time I watched it and the same goes for Yami Shibai. It was below 6 at the time I watched it. The score has increased.

As anisearch states that Erina's hair color is orange, your October 2017 challenge is valid. Your March 2017 challenge also looks good now.
As for Da Yu Hai Tang, I've used http://web.archive.org/ to check the genres. Here is a screenshot from May 9, 2017. I couldn't find the Super Power tag in the snapshots before and after the challenge month either.
My hands are also for Yami Shibai S6. Unfortunately, the score isn't close enough to a score of 5.99 to let it pass. Maybe you have watched anything to be able to replace the series? Or a screenshot. As scores always change, it is not bad to make screenshots, just in case.

If you are going to disagree with me, don't bother talking to me. I will seriously hurt you!

Oct 3, 2019 2:28 AM

#2237

Offline

Jul 2016

12951

Niveen_Sleem said:
unfortunately I don't have any replacements for the other two

I've asked and searched for a bit, and there have been cases where it was allowed to fix the monthlies within a short time period. So I can give you one week starting today to replace the two series, of course only if you want. If you do, just add a little note in your challenge posts that you've got the permission from an inspector and please notify me when you have watched the replacements.

"Happy Unbirthday."

set by ani ♥

Oct 3, 2019 4:24 AM

#2238

AnshiAneko

Offline

May 2017

642

NaineLIEz said:

AnshiAneko said:
Challenge: Reviewed Challenge x2
Version: Easy
Start Date: 16 Nov 2018
End Date: 7 Jan 2019
Post Link: link

*Reviews must be written after your challenge start date. As for your entries, Yagate Kimi ni Naru would qualify for the challenge, the rest were written before your challenge.

When I did this challenge (this also applies for the x1) I misunderstood the rules and so every one of my Reviewed challenges is filled out incorrectly. I would like to withdraw from the Reviewed challenge because I don't really have the energy to do it all again from the beginning.

Oct 3, 2019 6:13 AM

#2239

jho0on_

Offline

Oct 2014

323

@NaineLIEz

Entry changed from Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai Next to Sora no Otoshimono.

Oct 3, 2019 6:50 AM

#2240

Offline

Jul 2016

12951

@jho0on_ Your challenge is valid now, thanks for fixing.

AnshiAneko said:
When I did this challenge (this also applies for the x1) I misunderstood the rules and so every one of my Reviewed challenges is filled out incorrectly. I would like to withdraw from the Reviewed challenge because I don't really have the energy to do it all again from the beginning.

Alright, I'll go ahead and invalidate it. Some of your previous turn-ins of this challenge (in the HoF) haven't been crossed out yet, would you also like to have them invalidated so you won't have to be called out anymore?

"Happy Unbirthday."

set by ani ♥

Oct 3, 2019 7:09 AM

#2241

AnshiAneko

Offline

May 2017

642

NaineLIEz said:
Alright, I'll go ahead and invalidate it. Some of your previous turn-ins of this challenge (in the HoF) haven't been crossed out yet, would you also like to have them invalidated so you won't have to be called out anymore?

Yes please.

Oct 3, 2019 10:47 AM

#2242

Offline

Jun 2015

2500

NaineLIEz said:

Niveen_Sleem said:
unfortunately I don't have any replacements for the other two

I've asked and searched for a bit, and there have been cases where it was allowed to fix the monthlies within a short time period. So I can give you one week starting today to replace the two series, of course only if you want. If you do, just add a little note in your challenge posts that you've got the permission from an inspector and please notify me when you have watched the replacements.

I checked my history and I don't have anything matching the criteria watched within the challenges time period. If you mean I can watch and replace the shows now, I can do it.

If you are going to disagree with me, don't bother talking to me. I will seriously hurt you!

Oct 3, 2019 11:01 AM

#2243

Offline

Jul 2016

12951

Niveen_Sleem said:
I checked my history and I don't have anything matching the criteria watched within the challenges time period. If you mean I can watch and replace the shows now, I can do it.

Yes, I meant you can watch 2 series (matching the criterias of course) now within a week. Sorry if my wording was confusing.

"Happy Unbirthday."

set by ani ♥

Oct 3, 2019 11:04 AM

#2244

Offline

Jun 2015

2500

NaineLIEz said:

Niveen_Sleem said:
I checked my history and I don't have anything matching the criteria watched within the challenges time period. If you mean I can watch and replace the shows now, I can do it.

Yes, I meant you can watch 2 series (matching the criterias of course) now within a week. Sorry if my wording was confusing.

OK I'll start working on it right away. Should I inform you when I finish?

If you are going to disagree with me, don't bother talking to me. I will seriously hurt you!

Oct 3, 2019 11:06 AM

#2245

Offline

Jul 2016

12951

Niveen_Sleem said:
OK I'll start working on it right away. Should I inform you when I finish?

Please do that, thank you in advance.

"Happy Unbirthday."

set by ani ♥

Oct 7, 2019 1:38 PM

#2246

Offline

Jun 2015

2500

NaineLIEz said:

Niveen_Sleem said:
OK I'll start working on it right away. Should I inform you when I finish?

Please do that, thank you in advance.

I finished watching the replacements and fixed the forum posts.

If you are going to disagree with me, don't bother talking to me. I will seriously hurt you!

Oct 7, 2019 2:34 PM

#2247

Offline

Jul 2016

12951

Niveen_Sleem said:

NaineLIEz said:

Please do that, thank you in advance.

I finished watching the replacements and fixed the forum posts.

Alright, looks good now. Please remember to change your end dates in the Challenge Turn-in thread, then you're all set.

"Happy Unbirthday."

set by ani ♥

Oct 8, 2019 9:38 PM

#2248