DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- William is a clever man. With that type of planning, it feels like he's playing chess by gathering all the pieces (people) he wants. It looks like this episode takes place on a liner with a new story arc. William himself managed to construct a drama scenario with a thrilling sensation. |
 |
| It's taking place on a boat this time, interesting, and the whole plan is pure genius, can't wait to see what will happen to Britts in the second part |
 |
| Chapter 5 of the manga: The "Noahtic" Act. 1 Another nobleman in the way of the Moriarty Family's ambition to revolt the status quo of nobles and commoners, and taking place in the Bible-named luxury liner of a chessboard, and all its people merely chess pieces in an intricate plan. LET THE CURTAIN ARISE! "Our goal isn't crime, crime is simply a means to an end." DAMN, to change the people's perspectives through death, this is such an interesting take on the psychological curve, even using criminals to do their dirty work without being accused of it. Parfait! And wait...did Sherlock appear THAT EARLY? Yes it is, the momentary bet of visual deciphering. Even though the whole thing was a staged event, it's just impressive that everything is kept under wraps as tightly as possible. A murder encountered...this sensation I cannot shake off...! Part 2 next week, and this series isn't letting up! |
KANLen09Nov 15, 2020 6:55 AM
 |
| WHOA! Another great episode! Team Moriarty is now executing their huge plan to change the world, pitting criminals against each other. Every part of the plan is well-executed. But, Sherlock Holmes is on board!!  |
| Ramsay Bolton would approve Enders. And my man Sherlock being slick af, as it should be. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
| That was Sherlock right? This show will get even better if he starts to make more appearances. |
 |
| Woah this time its a serial killer. We finally get to see Sherlock Holmes. |
| Sherlock is here and he already came face to face with Moriarty, that was amusing. Once again things went exactly as Moriarty planned and now he's at the crime scene. Now what will his next move be? Is he gonna get interupted by Sherlock? Really excited to see what will happen. |
 |
| Oh, boy, a bishounen Sherlock that likes to wow the ladies, no Watson in sight. Also, another soon-to-be-dead Warped Evil Guy. These stories are starting to get boring; I hope Sherlock at least makes Moriarity sweat a bit. |
| "Genki is Life, Genki is Love" |
| Sherlock can tell that someone is a mathematician because they stare at spiral staircases? Seems legit. I have a math degree too, and sure I like geometry sometimes, but come on. Enders is the most ridiculously evil noble yet. He is probably trying to set a new record. Also not the most subtle killer when he chooses to murder a person in his own cabin and makes very little effort to hide it. Much more entertaining than the last two episodes, for sure. |
| Great episode again. Enders comfortably strides his way to the top of the ignoble noble list. He's probably the worst among everyone we've seen till date. I like how they were slowly riling Ender up until he indulged in his "activities". They even made it so he killed a criminal. Interesting. We finally got to see Sherlock, he sure made an impression and I really do hope we see more of him. Very excited to finally have an "arc" of sorts instead of the episodic content from before. |
 |
| Moriarty>>>Eren Another 10/10 episode. We got to understand Moriarty’s plan to change the world thru staged crimes as well as an introduction to Sherlock. Can’t wait to see how he factors into the story over the second half. Enders caught red handed, literally, this’ll be fun |
 |
| Sherlock finally makes his appearance in the story. It would be interesting if he gets more involved in the future to try and counter Moriarty's ambitions, I think it would be nice to see Moriarty face challenges that would require him to alter his plans. |
| People on MAL refuse to actually enjoy watching anime. Your taste in anime isn't a personality trait. MAL is literally just anime Twitter as its own website lol. |
| Those first met between Sherlock and Moriarty just awesome. Even though, for the grand outline i am still confused as hell, how he could figure out his job pretty easily by my logic. But, hey, he was great at deducting something, so its not a big deal when knewing his intentions. Then, when Moriarty sent a counter statement to reply Sherlock's deduction, i knew the spark of rivality and competition already started from those coincidence meeting. Only if Sherlock had a supernatural premonition ability, he could easily dismantle Moriarty's grand scheme on these episode too, Lol. But, its looks like he might had a screen time to, at least, try to figuring out whats goin on happened on those ship. Well, only the next episode will tell the truth behind their action. Because so far, those Count, was ready to dance, over Moriarty's stage. Everyone might be looking at him, as the show at the first sequence. What a grand plan to destroyed the city from behind, via their own nobleman. Well, i simply like that! Okay, lets see how well Moriarty drama to confronted those awful human hunter that called himself a noble! |
 Hide and seek is the best offline games on this fatamorgana-called-world-thing. Please comment nicely. I am newbie here. I'm level  on mal-badges. View my badges  |
p0rkcandy said: The violin and chemical dependency pretty much confirmed that was Sherlock lol Yup. They made Sherlock a bit of ladies man though which is a bit of stretch, but I suppose they needed to add their own original ideas for the character somewhere. |
| "Perhaps there is a universal, absolute truth. Perhaps it justifies every question. But that's beyond the reach of these small hands." Mamoru Oshii There is a cult of ignorance (...) nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that “my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.” Isaac Asimov |
| Good episode, I like it, except if the smart man is Sherlock Holmes, then the mangaka blew the prestige of Sherlock. Sherlock wouldn't be afraid of Moriarty if he shows high intelligence, and Sherlock wouldn't SHOW OFF his skills to some women. I think it's like this because the mangaka likes Moriarty more than Sherlock, but he has to respect the character. |
| This show is quite enjoyable but I'd like if the bad guys were more than "comically evil". |
 |
| We finally get to see Sherlock in this episoide. Ender's is gonna get what's coming to him after Moriarty walked in on him. |
 |
| Definitely epic series, 10/10! :D |
TheDeedsOfMen said: You could definitely say the same thing to the BBC Sherlock, he would easily say I study in the bakery course with few clues, I would be astonished and surprised if he managed to do that.Sherlock can tell that someone is a mathematician because they stare at spiral staircases? Seems legit. I have a math degree too, and sure I like geometry sometimes, but come on. Enders is the most ridiculously evil noble yet. He is probably trying to set a new record. Also not the most subtle killer when he chooses to murder a person in his own cabin and makes very little effort to hide it. Much more entertaining than the last two episodes, for sure. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Farabeuf said: I am not exactly sure how you thought they made him into a ladies' man just because he were around some ladies who were impressed by his skills. I wouldn't say he is one, but I think he likes to impress? I don't know, but that type of Sherlock doesn't strike me as a ladies man.p0rkcandy said: The violin and chemical dependency pretty much confirmed that was Sherlock lol Yup. They made Sherlock a bit of ladies man though which is a bit of stretch, but I suppose they needed to add their own original ideas for the character somewhere. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Very interesting episode so far and it seems like it's split in multiple parts. This one definitely set the stage for what's coming up next, and I freakin' loved the way Sherlock and William had their first encounter. That was so funny. At this point I'm just waiting for the show to sell me the other characters as well, cuz so far it does a great job with everything else, especially setting the atmosphere and how much it makes it so that you too hate these noble bastards just as much as William's gang do. |
| I thought this was "The Hound of the Baskervilles" for a moment, and I was thinking that the characters weren't old enough to reach that arc yet. lol Sherlock showed up with his deductions!! I was so excited when I saw him. His deductions weren't as satisfying as they are in the books, but I still enjoyed seeing it. And, Moriarty also did his own deductions proving that he's Sherlock Holmes' equal. I wish they explained how he reached that conclusion. Sherlock Holmes isn't a grumpy or serious guy here. He's talking and laughing with people like he does in the books. Well, he was a bit too attractive. When I read the books, he feels like a thin old man. But, I don't think think his age has ever been mentioned in the story. (I might be wrong though.) I hope they do age a little by the time we reach the Reichenbach Waterfalls. |
| So the two geniuses met each other- finally! It appears that this anime (and I guess the manga it's derived from) will treat William Moriarty and Sherlock Holmes just like Arthur Conan Doyle (Sherlock Holme's writer) did : as virtually equivalent in observation and deduction skills, intelligence, knowledge and brilliance by and large; which is quite exciting! Professor Moriarty is Holmes' nemesis for a reason - though I guess in this particular story it will be the other way around; Holmes will serve as Moriarty's nemesis and basic obstacle to his plans. Since Moriarty already "solved" the murder I suppose the second part will be at least partly about Sherlock Holmes seeing through Moriarty's brilliant orchestration of that murder (though I doubt he will also be able to prove it). And so the conflict between the Moriarty gang and Holmes & Watson will at last begin! I loved that Moriarty "upgraded" his plans to a more nuanced and elaborate scheme; instead of having the "bad nobles" killed one by one (which could take forever) it is much more clever and effective to expose them for who they are to the public, starting with that psycho Count. Of course Holmes will see through that, either next week or eventually, so Moriarty should not have underestimated him. |
SharpedonNov 15, 2020 4:06 PM
 |
FuMomo-kun said: I thought this was "The Hound of the Baskervilles" for a moment, and I was thinking that the characters weren't old enough to reach that arc yet. lol Sherlock showed up with his deductions!! I was so excited when I saw him. His deductions weren't as satisfying as they are in the books, but I still enjoyed seeing it. And, Moriarty also did his own deductions proving that he's Sherlock Holmes' equal. I wish they explained how he reached that conclusion. Sherlock Holmes isn't a grumpy or serious guy here. He's talking and laughing with people like he does in the books. Well, he was a bit too attractive. When I read the books, he feels like a thin old man. But, I don't think think his age has ever been mentioned in the story. (I might be wrong though.) I hope they do age a little by the time we reach the Reichenbach Waterfalls. The violin bit was from Sherlock's fingers (the hands and fingers of violinists have very subtle "tells"); the fighting skills bit was from Sherlock's build and probably from his body language (probably a guestimate). We all know about the "chemicals" bit (Moriarty must have smelled them) but I have no idea how he got that "scientific instruments" part; did he also smell them too? I don't know, did Victoria era scientific instruments emit smells? What Moriarty didn't get is the same that Holmes didn't get : their respective private criminal (consultant) / detective jobs. Why? Because there was no way to tell just from observing and examining each other. They are both observation prodigies but cannot read minds. I was also impressed that this Sherlock is much more social - or at least must less anti-social - and extroverted than most other Sherlock portrayals. |
|
Sharpedon said: FuMomo-kun said: I thought this was "The Hound of the Baskervilles" for a moment, and I was thinking that the characters weren't old enough to reach that arc yet. lol Sherlock showed up with his deductions!! I was so excited when I saw him. His deductions weren't as satisfying as they are in the books, but I still enjoyed seeing it. And, Moriarty also did his own deductions proving that he's Sherlock Holmes' equal. I wish they explained how he reached that conclusion. Sherlock Holmes isn't a grumpy or serious guy here. He's talking and laughing with people like he does in the books. Well, he was a bit too attractive. When I read the books, he feels like a thin old man. But, I don't think think his age has ever been mentioned in the story. (I might be wrong though.) I hope they do age a little by the time we reach the Reichenbach Waterfalls. The violin bit was from Sherlock's fingers (the hands and fingers of violinists have very subtle "tells"); the fighting skills bit was from Sherlock's build and probably from his body language (probably a guestimate). We all know about the "chemicals" bit (Moriarty must have smelled them) but I have no idea how he got that "scientific instruments" part; did he also smell them too? I don't know, did Victoria era scientific instruments emit smells? What Moriarty didn't get is the same that Holmes didn't get : their respective private criminal (consultant) / detective jobs. Why? Because there was no way to tell just from observing and examining each other. They are both observation prodigies but cannot read minds. I was also impressed that this Sherlock is much more social - or at least must less anti-social - and extroverted than most other Sherlock portrayals. You have interesting observation skills. Also, I didn't know you could recognise violin players with their hands. I never thought of Sherlock being an extrovert. He always felt like a social introvert to me. You know, like the kind of person who can talk to people without any problems, but wouldn't talk to people if he doesn't have to. |
damn Sherlock Holmes and fuck I'm starting to like him |
FuMomo-kun said: Sharpedon said: The violin bit was from Sherlock's fingers (the hands and fingers of violinists have very subtle "tells"); the fighting skills bit was from Sherlock's build and probably from his body language (probably a guestimate). We all know about the "chemicals" bit (Moriarty must have smelled them) but I have no idea how he got that "scientific instruments" part; did he also smell them too? I don't know, did Victoria era scientific instruments emit smells? What Moriarty didn't get is the same that Holmes didn't get : their respective private criminal (consultant) / detective jobs. Why? Because there was no way to tell just from observing and examining each other. They are both observation prodigies but cannot read minds. I was also impressed that this Sherlock is much more social - or at least must less anti-social - and extroverted than most other Sherlock portrayals. You have interesting observation skills. Also, I didn't know you could recognise violin players with their hands. I never thought of Sherlock being an extrovert. He always felt like a social introvert to me. You know, like the kind of person who can talk to people without any problems, but wouldn't talk to people if he doesn't have to. Thanks, but I am much less observant than I wish I was (for instance, since I occasionally write, it would help me to write better stories). Mere mortals cannot recognize violinists from their hands or fingers (I certainly couldn't) but people like top violin pros could probably do it. However I doubt anyone could distinguish an occasional violin player like Sherlock from a professional violin player (like Moriarty did) or a violin player from a viola player just from examining their hands. You are right, I believe that's how Arthur Conan Doyle wrote Sherlock, as largely an introvert and rather anti-social. So this manga/anime is quite a departure from the source material, at least in that regard. |
|
| We finally get to see Sherlock and it looks like he will be done well. This arc has started off pretty well. I’m looking forward to how it continues. |
| Ahh I love this show. That other guy was def sherlock. What a great encounter. I hope to get some sort of Light vs L kinda shenanigans in the future. |
| bruh that sherlock v moriarty scenario was pretty dope lol. I just hope their rivalry is more of a Light v L type rather than a more one sided one (which it doesn't seem like it will be the case) |
 'On-Hold' is another way for a completionist to say 'Dropped' |
| Sherlock was the only redeemable points in this episodes. Otherwise it's still the usual story of eradicating one-dimensional evil nobleman. It's getting boring if they don't tweaks or vary this repetitive nature of the storytelling. |
| I'm too weird to live but much too rare to die. |
| Damn, the moment Enders mouth opened I already want that bitch to die. Hitting 2 birds with one stone, at least that rapists despicable life will be put into good use for the betterment of society. Moriarty's interaction with Sherlock (assuming his Sherlock but, I am sure he is) was interesting as fuck. I don't understand how Sherlock and Moriarty were able to deduce those things about each other but, intelligent people are built differently lmao. Cool, this is our first multiple parts story. I appreciate that there is more build up to the crime for this story. Now how will they end Enders. |
 |
| This plan is just so good. They used the commoner(who is already a criminal) as a sacrifice to catch the Count. 2 birds 1 stone. I thought that was Luis and not William due to his hairstyle. |
| --AbiSa-- |
| Dio Brando looking ass lmao... I wish Koyasu would have voiced him. And Sherlock, finally! |
 |
z00nex said: That was Sherlock right? This show will get even better if he starts to make more appearances. I did not like Sherlock very much... Seems too crude. |
| can't wait for more sherlock already. i can't deny that i'm enjoying this anime more than i should because of the bishies, everyone looks so good. enders voiced by suzuki tatsuhisa. what a nutcase of a character lol i wonder what's the grand plan they are up to, can't wait for the next episode! |
 ꕤ but i’ll probably remember over and over again you were there and everyone else was there — the day we all searched for just one thing ꕤ |
| love William and this anime. They perfectly set that up. Enders caught red handed, kore wa... taihen desu... Hopefully good old sherlock there doesn't create many problems for Moriarty, though it would be interesting to see them battle each other death note style. |
 |
| I love this show so much~~ Bishounen everywhere! *-* I definitely want more Sherlock! Also, let's appreciate the way how Albert looks at his uke Will! |
 |
| This whole plan is so clever I love it. Actually I'm starting to think this is the best anime of the season. Also new guy is quite interesting, I have a suspicion who he is and I really hope I'm right. Btw Albert will defo propose to William when they leave this ship lmao |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Yuukoku no Moriarty Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Nov 8, 2020 |
96 |
by 3miL
»»
Nov 20, 4:05 AM |
|
» Which of the original Holmes stories did this show adapt?Curlybrace101 - Sep 24 |
2 |
by TheSoundOfQin
»»
Sep 25, 9:07 AM |
|
Poll: » Yuukoku no Moriarty Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Oct 25, 2020 |
120 |
by RaizelSandress
»»
Sep 17, 10:42 AM |
|
Poll: » Yuukoku no Moriarty Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Oct 18, 2020 |
105 |
by RaizelSandress
»»
Sep 17, 2:57 AM |
|
Poll: » Yuukoku no Moriarty Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Wolfie8338 - Oct 3, 2020 |
157 |
by vinnywizanime
»»
Jul 28, 11:57 AM |