| I think your rating system sucks almost all my anime are below 5/10. Thats like saying there's no need to differentiate horse shit from cow shit. |
 |
| Mal's default 1-10 point scale is too much of a headache for me so I decided to use 0-1 scale. If I like anime I rate it 1 and if I don't like anime I don't rate it at all. Sounds like a flawless rating system to me. |
 |
| 1- darling in the franxx 10- ginga eiyuu densetsu |
 |
| You could at least use 10, 8, 6, 4 and 2 instead. I use the MAL rating system from 1-10. 1 are the worst anime ever, 5 is average and 10 is masterpiece. |
| For me 3/10 means I still enjoyed some parts of the show, like art or music or some particular moment, when it comes to this I just count good points and decide between 2, 3, and 4. 1 means it was irredeemably terrible. 5 is a breaking point, truly average, when I don't even feel much about the show. 6 is ok, maybe even good but just not my cup of tea. 7 is good, but nothing too special. 8 is what I personally like but have some issues nevertheless. 9 is what I loved a lot with just 1 or 2 points that keep it from being perfect. 10 is either perfect or when can overlook any flaws just for emotional value alone. |
TenAug 27, 2018 1:48 AM
| 1-5 = unwatchable. (Exists but I barely use it because I'm good at selecting stuff that might be at least watchable for me.) 6-10 is explained in my profile. I try to be rare with 10 now. Even 9 doesn't get used that often. 9 is almost perfect all of the time. 6 is barely watchable. Very boring and I probably had higher hopes at the beginning. At epi 1-3 I need to hope for 7 (better 8) at least or I'd drop it. 6 or lower are those where I thought "it might get better" ... for the hole anime until the last episode ... to notice it did not get better. :D 7-8 are normal. 8 is just good. Not great. But entertaining most of the time. 7 is entertaining ... but also with a lot boring episodes in between wich are not that bad. But "okay" to have such episodes mixed in to wait for the better ones. |
| As long as you follow your own system consistently and there's logic to it, then it's fine. Unless it's done inconsistently, falsely or illogically, then there shouldn't be criticism for scoring systems; to each their own. 1-5 is for anime I thought was truly bad or I truly disliked, but that rarely happens so most of my scoring is above that line, where it becomes more about how much I enjoyed it rather than whether I did or not. I do consider objective values when rating anime, but I mostly stick to how much I enjoyed it/what I thought of it. I boil it down to the image below in all simplicity. I ask myself "did I like it? did I really like it?" etc. and I think about "did I like/dislike this more than this anime at this score?"  |
| 10/10 = Good anime. 5/10 = bad anime. |
| I usually rate shows between 3-9. If i rate something less than 3 then that is because i hated every single minute of it. On the other hand shows rated 10 aren't necessarily flawless but they are the best in the genre that i have seen. For example i haven't seen that many Romance/ School shows. "Re-life" is the best one of that genre i have seen by a long shot so i gave it a 10. If i later find a better romance show i'll give that a 10 instead and Relife would be a 9. |
| I use the 1-10 rating system that MAL has. |
 |
| 10 Love it 9 l 8 l 7 l 6 l 5 l 4 l 3 l 2 l 1 Hate it |
 |
| anyone who still has my ecchi rating system please bring it out anyway 10 - personal preference 9 - unique and captivating 8 - captivating + personal preference 7 - captivating 6 - unique but fails to deliver 5 - entertaining but has nothing to really offer or intrigue me; a show by the book 4 - has unique elements but fails at presenting it properly; there is potential for a good show 3 - entertaining but has few redeeming elements 2 - not even entertaining 1 - i was bored as heck |
| 10- Best thing of it's genre I've seen, I pretty much loved all aspects and every second of the experience was bliss. The series have also to leave a big impact on me. 9- One of the greatest series ever and basically as enjoyable and impactful as my 10's. It's just that they were qualitywise not on pair with them, examples are Golden Time, Plastic Memories or The Ping Pong Club. 8- Awesome watch in almost every aspect, the very few flaws or things I personally disliked they might have had were easily overshadowed by their merits. Consider series with this rating also as part of my favs. 7 Enjoyable watch with little to complain, usually solid in everything it tried to achieve. Some of my 7's might have had a bigger issue which was outbalanced by something else, tho. Overall very satisfying, but not quite as impactful as 8 and above. 6- More positive aspects than negative ones and even if I'm not 100% buying the series I can still appreciate it for it's quality. Vice versa the same, enjoyment overshadows the rather poorly written story or characters. So my 6's are basically reserved for series where I'm either convinced by it's quality or it's entertaiment value. 5- Pros and cons are balancing each other out, yet I tend to think of my 5's as a positive experience while watching, they're easily forgotten after finishing them most of the time, tho. 4- Cons are starting to ruin the watching experience, these shows might have some good aspects, but they are rarely enjoyable thanks to the rest being mediocre at best. 3- Now it's getting into the territory where the watching experience equals suffering. The very few things I liked aren't worth it all, clear failure. 2- Among the worst und unpleasant experiences I've had. Aside from the premise they didn't have anything going for them. Horrible TV series and bad OVA's are to find here. 1- Absolute trash. There's literally nothing, aside from laughing about how miserably they failed, that you can gain from watching the entries I've rated with this score. TV series I've rated with this score are series I love to hate. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
| 10 - masterpiece 9 - great 8 - very good 7 - good 6 - fine 5 - average 4 - bad 3 - very bad 2 - horrible 1 - appalling I think it's good enough. |
 |
| you can choose upper 5 (6,7,8,9,10) why did you choose the others? |
 |
| I have a rubic that varies in Story, Characters, Animation/Art, Choreography (If Im watching a Tokusatsu) and music. Then I add them and average them up by percentage. 100- S Class 99-95- Almost Perfect 95-90- Awesome 89-80- Nice 79-70- Above Average 69-65- Average 64-50- Below Average 49-40- Poor 39-30- Bad 29-20- Horrible 19-1- Garbage 0- Just Fuck this show (Only 2 shows managed to enter this level) |
| 10 - Masterpiece 9 - Great 8 - Very Good 7 - Good 6 - Fair/Decent 5 - Mediocre 4 - Bad 3 - Very Bad 2 - Horrendous 1 - Worst |
| I use MAL's default rating system as it was intented to be used. Going out of my way to create a new one is just too much of a headache for me. |
| The beauty of humans is that they say one thing then do another, but at the same time that can also be their ugliest side. |
| 10 - absolutely master piece probally would watch it again 9 - awesome 8 - really really good 7 - averagely good 6 - has some good points but is overall mediocre/has some bad points as well 5 - absolutely mediocre 4 - Bad 3 - has good points but overall still really bad 2 - not as bad as 1 but still really really bad 1 - I'll rage about it and tell my friends how bad it is and how much I hate it I wish it could have a " I freaking hate this anime " tier because it is way bellow 1 to me in most occasions. |
| 1-4 = varying degress of bad 5-6 = average, fine, but could be better 7-10 = varying degrees of good |
| - Any entry with less than 20 minutes total running time; not counting credits, still frames or black screens, do not get rated. - Anime dropped within the first 3 episodes do not get listed or rated, unless I have a grudge with it, or I watched it while it was airing. - Art style, art quality and animation can not affect a score negatively except for in the most dire examples. It can however affect scores positively if it is above & beyond what good anime typically do. The exception to this being anime rated 9 - art/ animation can not improve a 9 to a 10. Scores 10: Flawless/ masterpiece 9: Only has extremely minor imperfections 8: Very good+, deserving of classic status 7: Very Good-, great in terms of entertainment but lacks X-factor or depth 6: Above average (enjoyable for a majority of the time) 5: Completely average to slightly below average (enjoyable less than half of the time) 4: Bad/ A let-down (mostly not enjoyable) 3: Annoyingly bad 2: Offensively bad 1: Filth |
 |
| I use a rating system based on my own enjoyment and its recommendability. So far I haven't found or watched anything deserving a score of below 4 or above 9. 9 - Either touched me on a personal level or so good I would recommend it to anybody regardless of preference 8 - Had a good time with it, would recommend to friends and to whoever may enjoy it 7 - Mostly enjoyable with a few lows here and there, I would maybe recommend to those who enjoy the genre or similar kinds of shows 6 - It's watchable with a few entertaining moments here and there 5 - It's not particularly entertaining but not entirely unwatchable 4 - Either so bad I dropped it, or so unsatisfying it belongs in the same category There's some I really enjoy but cannot recommend to everybody. Hence a partially recommendation based rating system. It's not perfect, that I have to admit. But it's a tad more fair system than exclusively judging based on my own preferences. |
 |
| A rating system that does not exist. |
 |
| You really can' process or conceive of more than 5 different ways of feeling about an anime? I'm honestly envious. My brain would end up differentiating not on 10, not on 100 but on 1000s of levels if you give it an adequate rating scale. It's never enough, the options of differentiating that these rating systems offer. Some shows always end up at the same score where I think 'No, I don't feel the same way about these two shows'. Differentiating between things is what prevents life from becoming one uniform blob of sameness, of feeling the same about everything so it's just something I naturally start doing all the time, it's not something I can really turn off. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| 10 - Re-watch value 9 - It's lovely 8 - Very entertaining 7 - It's good 6 and below - MAL scores |
| 1 to 10 like MAL suggests. For more details look into my profile if you want. |
| I'll just plug a part of my profile description here: "How I rate shows: 10 = A Must Watch (Self Explanatory) 9 = Personal Favorite (^) 8 = Great (Strongly Recommend) 7 = Good (Can Recommend) 6 = Above Average (Enjoyed but can't Recommend) 5 = Average (Bland but not Offensive) 4 = Below Average (Avoid) 3 = Bad (RUN) 2 = Terrible (I SAID FUCKING RUN) 1 = WHAT THE FUCK!?!?!? (YOU SHOULD HAVE LISTENED)" |
| Here is my rating system: Enjoy yourself. |
 "Blood and rain mixed with broken dreams flow together along the curb, But even in the darkest corners of misery the roses bloom at sunset" |
| 7-10 good 5-6 meh 2-4 what was this anime again? 1 good nothing= too lazy to think of rating Took years to perfect the system, but I think I got it down. |
| 10- God tier (Had to have significantly moved me) 9- Great (If a show has many enjoyable aspects and hooks me in for the long haul) 8- Good (What most shows I watch fall into usually I enjoy these shows but they're not particularly amazing) 7- Solid (Usually an ok show that has a decent amount of strong redeeming qualities about it) 6- Meh (These shows usually fail to impress me but often have some kind of pull to keep me watching) 5- Average (Nothing really special but nothing extremely bad) 4- Bad (These shows usually fall short in every sense of the word) 3- Horrible (These shows usually have a very weak story and very few redeeming qualities) 2- Garbage (These shows were probably more painful than enjoyable for me) 1- An Utter piece of shit (These shows are so bad that they personally offended me.) |
| I use the highly complicated and technical rating system of: - Watch what seems to interest me - Mark it off as watched - Move on to the next show that interests me |
 You're never too old to watch anime. If I ever stop watching anime, check my pulse I'm likely dead. I wake up with coffee & anime, I go to sleep with coffee & anime. Sorry if my sarcasm is bad, it's not my first language. |
| mine is simple 1-7 = different variety of shit anime 8 and 9 = average anime 10= ok anime |
| N.etorare T.echnical R.esearcher |
I use this system and it's nothing wrong with it... |
Some that could be the reasons 1. Too many options that it's confusing 2. Too many bad options that're unneeded to include 3. The chosen words are vague and confusing 4. Hard to decide, especially for the middle values (due to the reason 1 and/or 3) 5. So some people want easier way to rate I guess no matter what rating system people have, as long as they use a full 1-10 rating scale then it doesn't matter. When people use different ones in regard of the interval scores (1-5 or 6-10 for example), does it matter. It makes the rating less representative because people don't watch the same anime. Edited for bad grammars and chosen words. |
_Mataga_Aug 27, 2018 3:38 PM
|
| here it is, copy pasted from my profile: my clusterfuck of a rating system :
5: meh 4:meh, but worse |-"_7_"-|: cool cool 1: HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA(in a negative way) <(~\'9'/~)>: *orgasm* [-|6|-]: ok 2: trashy trash (°\-8-/°): Dank as FUCK |
| Whichever one the website I'm on uses. In this case it's MAL's. |
| "The name's Gambit. Remember it." -Gambit "X-Men '97"  |
| i use mal's rating system. if its good 7, if its average 5. etc |
 |
More topics from this board
» The "Backstory" Problemsimonitro - 7 hours ago |
23 |
by DigiCat
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» do you guys get mad when others talk bad about your favorite anime?Ymir_The_Viking - Yesterday |
39 |
by Stanis150
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Has BL animanga been getting better?Auron - 2 hours ago |
5 |
by Cmonth
»»
22 minutes ago |
|
» What's the name for this concept?thewiru - 5 hours ago |
13 |
by JaniSIr
»»
25 minutes ago |
|
» Characters you want to become your siblingsm_alhafidz - 9 hours ago |
9 |
by WaterMage
»»
33 minutes ago |