| I would flip. Because then it feels as if the show would suck more since you have no tits to pay attention to, you just realized how much the plot sucks ass. Take High School DxD for example, without the ecchi and fan service (no nipples as well) would it still be a good show to you because of the story? Bakemonogatari is another good example. Since it's so dialogue driven, would you be bored without seeing the work of art of their delicious bodies and become bored from all the talking no matter how smart and witty it is? ^ The are all optional questions. The real discussion/question is the title of this thread. |
 |
| I would still like DxD without Ecchi. For some shows, though, Ecchi is needed or it simply won't work. What if? It wouldn't matter much at all. Any show that relies on pure Ecchi isn't a good one. |
| Looking for a character or a certain Anime/Manga? Looking for recommendations? Rie Kugimiya Fanclub |
| In the case of HOTD it would only be about 8 episodes long, and a lot better |
| Alright Sushi, here is the thing. Some eroge type stories could really be just as good without the sex. F/SN is a perfect example. Sure, seeing Saber and Rin like that is kinda awesome but the h scenes are a bit pointless. On the other hand we have shows like To Love-Ru, which is a fluff comedy centered around awkward situations caused by nudity. So no, without tits, To Love-Ru would suck. Just go look at the first season. |
 |
Manglex said: Alright Sushi, here is the thing. Some eroge type stories could really be just as good without the sex. F/SN is a perfect example. Sure, seeing Saber and Rin like that is kinda awesome but the h scenes are a bit pointless. On the other hand we have shows like To Love-Ru, which is a fluff comedy centered around awkward situations caused by nudity. So no, without tits, To Love-Ru would suck. Just go look at the first season. Agreed, and also: Ecchi is made to have sexual-oriented Fanservice. It wouldn't make any sense to be called ecchi without those, which is all about. Another one could be Ben-To. Although the Fanservice was actually decent, the lack of it would still be compesated by the amounts of Fights and serious business. |
  |
012yArthur0 said: Manglex said: Alright Sushi, here is the thing. Some eroge type stories could really be just as good without the sex. F/SN is a perfect example. Sure, seeing Saber and Rin like that is kinda awesome but the h scenes are a bit pointless. On the other hand we have shows like To Love-Ru, which is a fluff comedy centered around awkward situations caused by nudity. So no, without tits, To Love-Ru would suck. Just go look at the first season. Agreed, and also: Ecchi is made to have sexual-oriented Fanservice. It wouldn't make any sense to be called ecchi without those, which is all about. Another one could be Ben-To. Although the Fanservice was actually decent, the lack of it would still be compesated by the amounts of Fights and serious business. Awww shit, I forgot that I dropped Ben-To a while ago. Don't know which episode I dropped it on though. Might watch it again. |
|
| Isn't ecchi the selling point of these shows? Taking away the ecchi from ecchi shows is like taking away romance from a romance anime. I think it simply won't work. |
 |
Mokkan said: Are you asking what if Ecchi anime had no ecchi? It wouldn't even be ecchi then. Is there no other explanation? Well people wouldn't understand what I mean by the thread yeah? When I ask a question about ecchi/borderline H anime, people will understand the sort of anime to discuss about (High School of The Dead, High School DxD, Love Hina.) |
|
| Ecchi anime are a big shit anyway. |
I luv u |
Jaguer91 said: Ecchi anime are a big shit anyway. Blasphemies. |
|
| It depends on how central the story is in the show. Some of them would stand pretty well on their own (Highschool of the Dead, Sekirei), whereas others would not. |
KruszerAug 18, 2013 6:03 PM
| "The name's Gambit. Remember it." -Gambit "X-Men '97"  |
| Then the said shows wouldn't be as popular. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| If Seikon no Qwaser had no fanservice, the episodes would have 2 minutes only. |
 |
| Your sig made me tilt my head. Does this answer your question? |
| Isn't this like asking "what if an action series had no violence"? It would most likely fail. Ecchi series usually depend on the fanservice. Now some anime may strive well without it. Take Highschool of the Dead for example. I've heard many people say that if it had less fanservice, among other things, it would've still been decent. Can't give any examples from my own experiences though. All the ecchi shows I've seen depended on the fanservice. (not counting normal anime with hints of ecchi-ness.) |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| It depends on the show, if it was a show like To Love-Ru Darkness, it would suck. If it was like Monogatari, it would still work just fine. As long as fanservice isn't the main purpose of the show. |
| DxD will still be great without that. And a good example is R+V when it discarded fanservice in II it become more awesome. |
 Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
| I'd prefer that, but I do enjoy Free!'s man-service....so maybe not. DxD would be more plot driven without all of the ecchi so maybe it'd be better? |
  |
| I hate ecchi, and I liked Highschool DxD, BUT if it didn't have ecchi, I wouldn't have liked it. |
 |
OriginANIME said: I hate ecchi, and I liked Highschool DxD, BUT if it didn't have ecchi, I wouldn't have liked it. Wait what? You hate ecchi, but you liked High School DxD, but if it didn't have ecchi, you wouldn't have liked it? |
NotSushiAug 18, 2013 9:21 PM
|
LegendsOfSushi said: OriginANIME said: I hate ecchi, and I liked Highschool DxD, BUT if it didn't have ecchi, I wouldn't have liked it. Wait what? You hate ecchi, but you liked High School DxD, but if it didn't have ecchi, you wouldn't have liked it? I think what he is trying to say is that he normally wouldn't be drawn to something just because its ecchi, but high school dxd was interesting enough to allow him to watch it in spite of it. However, if it didn't have the comic relief/lewdness, the show wouldn't have been quite as fun to watch. |
umbralogix said: LegendsOfSushi said: OriginANIME said: I hate ecchi, and I liked Highschool DxD, BUT if it didn't have ecchi, I wouldn't have liked it. Wait what? You hate ecchi, but you liked High School DxD, but if it didn't have ecchi, you wouldn't have liked it? I think what he is trying to say is that he normally wouldn't be drawn to something just because its ecchi, but high school dxd was interesting enough to allow him to watch it in spite of it. However, if it didn't have the comic relief/lewdness, the show wouldn't have been quite as fun to watch. Fair enough. |
|
| they won't be ecchi anymore :/ |
 |
| They wouldn't sell especially series like Ro-Kyu-Bu, the main appeal of the series are the 10 very sexy loli basketball players. |
 |
umbralogix said: LegendsOfSushi said: OriginANIME said: I hate ecchi, and I liked Highschool DxD, BUT if it didn't have ecchi, I wouldn't have liked it. Wait what? You hate ecchi, but you liked High School DxD, but if it didn't have ecchi, you wouldn't have liked it? I think what he is trying to say is that he normally wouldn't be drawn to something just because its ecchi, but high school dxd was interesting enough to allow him to watch it in spite of it. However, if it didn't have the comic relief/lewdness, the show wouldn't have been quite as fun to watch. That's exactly what I meant. Thanks~ But now that I re-read what I typed, man, that is some mind fking shit right there. LOL |
|
JD2411 said: In the case of HOTD it would only be about 8 episodes long, and a lot better Wrong. It would be just another zombie survival thing with no end in sight. That's what it is right now, but thankfully we do have the ecchi to stir things up....not to mention one of the greatest characters ever created....Saeko. |
| To Love Ru Darkness without it's borderline Hentai storylines would be absolutely terrible. High School DXD without it's tits would be just another shitty, annoying ass shounen. So there you go... |
JustALEX said: To Love Ru Darkness without it's borderline Hentai storylines would be absolutely terrible. High School DXD without it's tits would be just another shitty, annoying ass shounen. So there you go... I salute you. |
|
| An Ecchi without fanservice would be like Tomb Raider without Lara Croft, a.k.a. it would suck. RockerXD said: If it was like Monogatari, it would still work just fine. As long as fanservice isn't the main purpose of the show. I'm willing to bet that if Monogatari didn't have it's trademark art, then it would be considered pretty low-tier. |
 |
LegendsOfSushi said: Bakemonogatari is another good example. Since it's so dialogue driven, would you be bored without seeing the work of art of their delicious bodies and become bored from all the talking no matter how smart and witty it is? I actually don't like the fan-service in the Monogatari series that much, hence why I gave Nise a 7. It annoys me to no end when someone implies that people watch Bake for the fan-service. |
 |
tsudman said: LegendsOfSushi said: Bakemonogatari is another good example. Since it's so dialogue driven, would you be bored without seeing the work of art of their delicious bodies and become bored from all the talking no matter how smart and witty it is? I actually don't like the fan-service in the Monogatari series that much, hence why I gave Nise a 7. It annoys me to no end when someone implies that people watch Bake for the fan-service. The art can be considered fanservice. Fanservice doesn't only relate to ecchi and let's be honest, it's art is one it's biggest, if not it's biggest, asset. |
|
yhunata said: tsudman said: LegendsOfSushi said: Bakemonogatari is another good example. Since it's so dialogue driven, would you be bored without seeing the work of art of their delicious bodies and become bored from all the talking no matter how smart and witty it is? I actually don't like the fan-service in the Monogatari series that much, hence why I gave Nise a 7. It annoys me to no end when someone implies that people watch Bake for the fan-service. The art can be considered fanservice. Fanservice doesn't only relate to ecchi and let's be honest, it's art is one it's biggest, if not it's biggest, asset. I think the art is what draws people to watch it, but the dialogues, the characters and the interactions between them is what makes it worthwhile... |
| 5 main aspects I base my ratings on: 1. Did DramaEnthusiast make a thread about it? 2. Is it better than Breaking Bad? 3. Did MellowJello recommend the shit out of it? 4. Has it caused a (very entertaining) shitstorm on MAL? 5. Is it actually good? Scratch the fifth point, it's not very relevant... |
yhunata said: tsudman said: LegendsOfSushi said: Bakemonogatari is another good example. Since it's so dialogue driven, would you be bored without seeing the work of art of their delicious bodies and become bored from all the talking no matter how smart and witty it is? I actually don't like the fan-service in the Monogatari series that much, hence why I gave Nise a 7. It annoys me to no end when someone implies that people watch Bake for the fan-service. The art can be considered fanservice. Fanservice doesn't only relate to ecchi and let's be honest, it's art is one it's biggest, if not it's biggest, asset. The art is not considered fan-service, don't twist the definition. Fan-service include longer fight scenes, extra gore and violence, panty shots, any lewdness or nudity unless it's relevant to the plot. The fans that I know that rated high or have it on their favorite like it for it's dialogue, witty humor, plot, characters and their interesting interactions, the atmosphere, etc. Fan-service and is just a bonus when it comes to the Monogatari series, some people might not think so but hey, to each their own. And the art belongs to the directing of Shinbou Akiyuki and his team, it's not a trademark of Monogatari, it's a trademark of SHAFT. The Monogatari series have a very solid fan-base in Japan, if people only liked the Monogatari series for it's art or fan-service, the novels wouldn't have been so successful. |
|
tsudman said: yhunata said: tsudman said: LegendsOfSushi said: Bakemonogatari is another good example. Since it's so dialogue driven, would you be bored without seeing the work of art of their delicious bodies and become bored from all the talking no matter how smart and witty it is? I actually don't like the fan-service in the Monogatari series that much, hence why I gave Nise a 7. It annoys me to no end when someone implies that people watch Bake for the fan-service. The art can be considered fanservice. Fanservice doesn't only relate to ecchi and let's be honest, it's art is one it's biggest, if not it's biggest, asset. The art is not considered fan-service, don't twist the definition. Fan-service include longer fight scenes, extra gore and violence, panty shots, any lewdness or nudity unless it's relevant to the plot. The fans that I know that rated high or have it on their favorite like it for it's dialogue, witty humor, plot, characters and their interesting interactions, the atmosphere, etc. Fan-service and is just a bonus when it comes to the Monogatari series, some people might not think so but hey, to each their own. And the art belongs to the directing of Shinbou Akiyuki and his team, it's not a trademark of Monogatari, it's a trademark of SHAFT. The Monogatari series have a very solid fan-base in Japan, if people only liked the Monogatari series for it's art or fan-service, the novels wouldn't have been so successful. Fanservice is anything that is designed to pull fans into the show and/or keep them happy. Therefore, the unusual artstyle of the Monogatari series counts. |
|
| w/e |
|
| What if ultraviolent anime had no violence? What if mature/intellectual anime had no rambling philosophical elements? What if battle shounen had no fighting or character who wants to get stronger? What if a baseball anime had no baseball? Pointless counterfactual question. yhunata said: I know I can't get enough of those trademark SHAFT slideshow elements, like walls of text, "incomplete animation" messages, recycled cityscape shots, and character stills.The art [in ~monogatari] can be considered fanservice. Fanservice doesn't only relate to ecchi and let's be honest, its art is one its biggest, if not its biggest, asset. |
| I would have still watched Queen's blade with out all the ecchi or fan service. It actually had a good plot once you got past the boobes and not quite lesbian sex scenes. Then again, that was all that Rebellion was. So. Also I have a feeling that Eiko would not be a series. I haven't even watched it and I can say that for sure. |
| "Canaan. You're a victim whose past was taken away by war. And she's a defeated person who lost her past in a power struggle. Soldiers who are born within destruction take hatred as their weapon. Even though you and her became soldiers for the same reason, you both live differently. Listen Canaan, you cannot counter hatred with hatred... ever." -Siam, Canaan |
JustALEX said: Took the words right out of my mouth. What happens when you take <x> elements out of a show made expressly for <x> fans? (x = action, romantic, dramatic, comedic, ecchi, etc.) Garbage.To Love Ru Darkness without it's borderline Hentai storylines would be absolutely terrible. High School DXD without it's tits would be just another shitty, annoying ass shounen. So there you go... Though I can kind of see this question having meaning when it's applied to shows that shoehorn their ecchi scenes. It's hard to take a show seriously when you see a panty shot every five seconds, assuming the show wants you to take it seriously. Although, if you're looking for the opposite (i.e. removal of ecchi = good, regardless of whether or not the show was serious), see Rosario + Vampire (the manga). |
gamer2710Aug 19, 2013 11:41 AM
This topic has not been locked and is still available for discussion. |
| The title sounds exactly like "What if water isnt wet anymore?" , does it makes sense? Nope , not to me . I'm a bit of a stupid one so please enlight me how can an "Ecchi" anime can be called "Ecchi" if there is no "Ecchi" in it? Besides the point , the anime itself is a fanservice...... No fanservice=no anime. |
| "Love is a drug to our brain , it stops the thinking function and when you realize it wether you acomplish it or not you'll enter in one of the 3 withdrawal states : happy , sad or anger. Once this drug gets hold of you you'd better be prepaired beforehand." - Me |
| Well seikon no qwaser would still be bad ass if they didn't shove boobs and panty shots in my face every second. Not that I mind however. |
| *Cringey anime weeb stuff* |
| Monogatari d be better without ecchi, almost dropped Nise cause of that stuff |
 |
| Then they wouldn't be borderline H/ecchi anime. In fact, they wouldn't exist. Some anime solely rely on the ecchi to draw viewers in, and if that's gone, then so is the anime. Although I think High School DxD would be alright. |
| Eminem meets Clannad Just when you thought Clannad's OST was as sad as it could get ;_; If you seen School Days, rewatch the ending while listening to A Little of Piece of Heaven by A7X. I guarantee laughs. |
CallMePriest said: Then they wouldn't be borderline H/ecchi anime. In fact, they wouldn't exist. Some anime solely rely on the ecchi to draw viewers in, and if that's gone, then so is the anime. Although I think High School DxD would be alright. HSDXD popularity is because of ecchi , the plot is the most generic one I've ever seen and the ecchiness hides that , take that out and you'll get a SnO without Sakurai's funny moments . |
| "Love is a drug to our brain , it stops the thinking function and when you realize it wether you acomplish it or not you'll enter in one of the 3 withdrawal states : happy , sad or anger. Once this drug gets hold of you you'd better be prepaired beforehand." - Me |
| Then we'd probably go crazy on Free instead. |
| "The more inexperienced you are, the more you want to show off." - Oreki, Hyouka |
| In most cases, I would lose it. I don't like harem/ecchi much anyway, getting rid of the fanservice would make it more unbearable to watch. I think Yosuga no Sora would be better without the sex scenes, though. |
 |
Diran-kun said: I would still like DxD without Ecchi. Really? |
 |
~What If Ecchi/Borderline H Anime Has No Fan Service Or Ecchi? Then it wouldn't be considered Ecchi/borderline you retard. |
كنت تهدر وقتك عن طريق ترجمة هذه. mattbenz99 said: Christians and Satanists are technically the same thing |
More topics from this board
» At what age you should stop watching anime?swirlydragon - Yesterday |
36 |
by Nemo_Niemand
»»
8 seconds ago |
|
» On the subject of anime and assthewiru - Yesterday |
42 |
by Merve2Love
»»
12 minutes ago |
|
» 🖊️ Hall of Sensei: Who Teaches Best! ( 1 2 3 4 5 )nirererin - Sep 23 |
228 |
by 5hadow17
»»
12 minutes ago |
|
» Anime you randomly came across and it turned out to be a great watchMs_Muffin - Yesterday |
33 |
by rbp_pbr2
»»
35 minutes ago |
|
» College Life animeNilyaaa - Sep 25 |
20 |
by Zalis
»»
41 minutes ago |