DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
tysonultima said: Well for you Miyabi fans i have good news and bad news about the light novel. source: Volume 8 of the light novel translated thanks to a nice anonymous user. Well that sucks that bitch with the glasses who did the dna test screwed with us again. |
 |
| Didn't expect Miyabi to be honest but I'm so glad it was. She's my least liked character so that frees up Shougo to pick Konoe instead. I still think Mr. X is the best choice out of them all though. Too bad she's off limits. I applaud this show for making my mind run wild at guessing who the imouto could be. I think this show was at it's peak before the introduction of Yuzurina and it was systematically leading us through all of Shougo's potential options. It was very suspenseful and lots of fun to watch. The latter portion wavered when it tried to bring everything together I think. Of all the girls, I never really understood the purpose of Mana for Shougo. I didn't think they had spent any meaningful time together and she was only interested in filling her hearty appetite. I question why she might have been a mate for him. I hope there is potential for a second season since they left the ending open. 7/10. |
| lol then i'm not the only Mr. X fan XD 7/10 |
 |
| too bad i guess he doesn't really choose anyone to marry.. |
AP24 said: The scene where Miyabi tells Shougo that she's his little sister, is it in the light novel (vol.4) as well? The light novel is still ongoing so I thought the ending is an anime original ending when the little sister is revealed. Based on previous posts, yes... But on volume 8(?), there's another revelation and it seems like Miyabi is just his cousin. |
| Hmm I always had this feeling that Ikusu would be his sister. A little plot twist you know xD and I like her. I want to see more Ikusu. From the five girls of potential girlfriend/sister for Shougo, Miyabi is my favorite, but it is obvious that Shougo likes Konoe. All in all this anime gets 6 /10 from me. Typical harem comedy which get a little weird at the end. Cream puffs are serious 0.0?! I kinda hoped that the detective part finding is sister would be interesting, but in the end that was rather plain and not exciting at all. |
 |
| In the end Miyabi was his sister after all. She was my number one suspect after we found out Yuzurina was actually lying. "Let's be closer siblings than any lovers could be"? Incest route it is. Overall a very generic harem, but it had it's funny moments. 6/10 |
 |
| eat my cream puffs was the funniest part of this episode :D lol |
LunaOct 2, 2012 11:25 PM
   |
| Fitting end with Shougo the faggot running away from girls, second season is possible. Dont really want one though. 6/10 |
| Konoe's Cream puffs...om nom |
  |
| I don't know who's trolling who anymore. Shougo should Marry X, he'll need a bodyguard anyway. The show was decent for a harem/ecchi but it had too many ups and downs. |
| Lol, and I was hoping for incest |
 |
| I knew not to expect much when I started watching this, but I didn't think it would be this horribly crappy. The plot was at least trying to be interesting and at times I did try to put the pieces together, but all that trolling, all the horrible, horrible characterization made a mess out of it, that not even Ikusu could save. A very generous 4/10 for this show. And a 1/5 for the episode itself. I just want to vent the anger that the worst possible girl had a quasi-victory. Also, what's with worst girls kissing the MC this (past) season? It's getting out of hand. I'm too used to seeing best girls winning, sigh. |
Mogami-kunOct 6, 2012 1:37 PM
| Ah, should've known he wasn't going to pick anyone at the end. Oh well, it was a nice sibling reunion. I hope when he comes to power in the family company, he'll treat his sister well. Too bad Mr. X didn't get to reveal her gender to the girls. Now that would've been another shock. That's why he should've picked Konoe in the first place! (rant from a Konoe supporter) Why do I get the feeling this story is still incomplete? (don't answer this question) |
| I guess the ending was right. It would have been funnier if the guy told the other girls he was a she... |
| huh? |
| I was liking the show, but got boring. Wasn't a surprise to me about Miyabi be his sister. I was thinking about it since her appearance. 6/10 Expected more >: |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
alkyl said: I cannot express my displeasure at the fact that Ikusu didn't reveal her true gender at the end. Would have made for a great shocker ending leading to a new candidate for the harem rivalry. Also, the lack of actions taken by the "enemy" sorta turns this anime into a merry go round of harem action with no real plot progression. lol this isn't even the whole of its story :D |
| This series really gets me depressed about why the Japanese keep doing this shit. I will admit that I like ecchi, I will admit that I'm OK with harems.... BUT WHY would you take an interesting plot such as the one presented in this anime and combine it with all this unnecessary shit? This anime had a lot of potential (Fuck, I feel I say that line far too often) but in the end, it's always the same bullshit. If these guys seriously put an effort in presenting a well written out story with depth and an actual storyline without all the generic shit, this could have been a great anime. There were so many elements that are completely unnecessary, and in the end this anime seemed exactly like an eroge rather than an actual story. *Sigh*.....6/10, it could have been so much more. |
| 7/10 if there would be a girl he dated at the end maybe 8 or 9 |
| Hahaha! Dude, what? That finisher was nice enough but this series got quite weird. Still, Miyabi for the win. There hasn't been a cuter imouto since Kobato from Haganai! Well, all's well that ends well. I hope the BD bonus OVA is just puire fan-service treacle of loveliness. |
 |
| a harem ending as predicted.. who cares, a 10/10 just for konoe being in the anime and her creampuffs |
MoeXtremeNov 6, 2012 2:27 PM
 |
| An open end..................I wanted her to end up with Konoe:(.anyways atleast we found out that Miyabi really is his sister.9/10!I really enjoyed it. |
 |
| Out of all the girls, Miyabi is definitely my favorite. She isn't as annoying and overly attached to Shougo like the other girls. Shougo and Miyabi really go together if they weren't related. From the looks of it, I think it'll get a second season to it, he still has to choose one of the girls to be his wife. I was hoping that Ikusu will finally reveal [his] true identity in front of everyone, but that didn't happen. Hoping for a second season! |
"Do you want to accelerate to the next level, young man?" - Kuroyukihime |
| This is actually quite a good episode.. Though it should have a better conclusive ending about Yuzurina.. Overall the show is quite unique with the combination of mystery and ecchi.. Though I can't stand the ecchi part.. Lol.. |
| 6/10 I'll try to remind my self from now on to stay away from these kind of shows. |
 |
| i gave 8/10 for the story . I want him to end up with Konoe too :( . Konoe is just too cute for me hahah. Also wished before that ikusu was attached to shougo :))))) |
| After watching this series, I have something to say. It has been on my mind since even before half of the series, before episode 6. I have to say this... KNEW IT.. ^^ |
| uhh... |
| Possibly the greatest finale to the world's best imoto anime! Just kidding! This is possibly one of the worst anime I've seen, including harems. Let's see all we've accomplished throughout this anime. Fan service. Imoto fetishes established Fan service Bs'd storyline. Annoyance towards all the female characters. Passionate targeting at the hatred for actual mysteries The plot was an excuse to draw in stupid otakus who finally can argue that their favorite ecchi anime had a -plot- twist. Right, go to hell please. This anime embodies the worst script and the biggest excuses for plot devices. Yet, people still will rate it 10/10 or 9/10. And this is why I'm losing hope for humanity. Apparently writing a negative review for this anime means you deserve crap from the otaku viewers? I never understood how the top review for this anime which has no more than an intelligence of a 6 year old and a basically 1 sentence summary got 50 helpful's and is one of the top reviews. It's not even an assumption anymore, but a fact that the people who watch this anime are just here for ecchi. And the majority of them don't know what proper reviewing or writing is. Nonetheless comprehending the complexity within multitudes of sarcastic sadist terms I only sublimely for tricked into existence into genuinely conferring syntax. 2deep4u? To that I just have to say one thing. Would you really believe a real imuoto would want your dick? If you like this incest stuff then there's honestly something wrong with you. And the girls that are depicted in this anime. Worst girls I've seen. Even in anime. If you're going for an ecchi/incest anime at least go for quality ones like kissxsis. This has the most irksome dialogue throughout. Worst Crap Ever. 1/10. Would fight the producer of the anime and kick him in ballz. Who Is Imouto? Imouto Is Da Hood |
| The story is better than average. One thing i love about this anime is the personalities of MC. He's not like most harem MC which are usually stupid, wimp and crybaby. Overall 7/10. P.S - I hope he choose Ikusu at the end of the anime. She is the hottest girl in the anime and funnier compare to others. |
| Typical harem ending, but still pretty good in my book. I really enjoyed it! :D Man, Miyabi was the sister? I consider this a loss. |
 |
AP24 said: Thanks :) Read the spoiler since getting a 2nd season is unlikely~ |
| so after 12 episodes he still hasn't made a decision to who he will marry. doesn't look like there will be a 2nd season either |
 |
FifthAveSenseiJan 22, 2015 11:38 PM
| Too Much ANIME......Not enough LIFETIME!!!!!! |
| that was good anime doesn't deserve the very low score it has but whatever not gonna watch the ova because i hate ova in genral.. 7/10 |
 |
AP24 said: That's because the anime stopped at vol 4's story. It doesn't look like there will be another season so you'll have to read the novels to know what happens next. And what happens next? For me most of the cast except Ikusu can just go eat ... ehm. Spoiler it for me, if you can sey with which heroine he ends up. Or it's nice boat ending? |
| HANDS DOWN, the most disappointing anime I've ever seen was Kono Naka ni Hitori, Imouto ga Iru! It was a giant piece of horse crap. A waste of time and money. Seriously, what in the hell?! It was like watching a crappy ass episode of House, without the medical diagnoses. I enjoyed House. I hated Kono Naka ni Hitori, Imouto ga Iru with a passion you could only dream of. I hoped that stupid little turd Shougo would grow some mother fricking balls and date someone instead of obsessing over the SISTER thing but nope! The entire anime was shit. Those foggy-eyed characters were annoying too, excluding Miyabi. First he thinks he found his sister then he realizes the girl he though was his sister actually wasn't. This happened practically EVERY EPISODE! It was annoying. VERY annoying. Please don't waste your time on this anime. Trust me, please don't do it. I'd rather be a Russian racehorse at the Kentucky Derby with a busted leg and a glue truck on my tail than re-watch this anime or even consider watching a new season, in the event the creators are dumb enough to make one. |
 |
| garbage /10 except for Ikusu... wood berry her so hard that whoever can pull me out would be crowned king arthur. |
 |
More topics from this board
» Season 2Ahmeteemin - Aug 16, 2021 |
6 |
by Kaneki456
»»
Jul 11, 2024 7:17 AM |
|
Poll: » Kono Naka ni Hitori, Imouto ga Iru! Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Uiriamu_Busujima - Jun 28, 2012 |
155 |
by Netbug
»»
Dec 10, 2023 9:10 AM |
|
» small questionfricksalot - May 31, 2021 |
13 |
by Rnonsenseguy
»»
Aug 10, 2022 6:43 AM |
|
» What if it turns out they were all his sister!Guts-Valley - Jul 5, 2022 |
8 |
by tmsy
»»
Jul 6, 2022 6:55 PM |
|
Poll: » Kono Naka ni Hitori, Imouto ga Iru! Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jul 19, 2012 |
127 |
by Summer111a
»»
Aug 10, 2021 9:45 PM |