The Current Events Board Will Be Closed on Friday JST

deg said:
its funny that some of the right wingers on this thread that are always posting fake news and disinformation are happy about this lol

Kayle_x_Morgana said:

hope you aren't talking about me. i have never ever once posted a fake news article.
at least i post articles about... my own country.

deg said:
its funny that some of the right wingers on this thread that are always posting fake news and disinformation are happy about this lol

RuneRem said:


Because this will stop yoyu leftists from propagandising on Mal like you do everywhere. Our original views were never right wing, but rather apolitical, and wanted people to leave their petty politics out of video games and anime.

So this is a loss for leftist political activists politicising everywhere.

RuneRem said:


Because this will stop yoyu leftists from propagandising on Mal like you do everywhere. Our original views were never right wing, but rather apolitical, and wanted people to leave their petty politics out of video games and anime.

So this is a loss for leftist political activists politicising everywhere.

deg said:


lol your beliefs is centered around white supremacy dont bother excusing yourself

RuneRem said:


Is that what my original views were centered around in 2017?

deg said:


youve made threads about national socialism and immigration is bad or invasion a lot remember

RuneRem said:


That was more generic Hearts of Iron 4 ww2 interest. Most of my threads were about feminism in games and anime.

deg said:


oh please any honest forum regular back then that are still active now knows your far right views overall so you saying you post more anti-feminism stuff does not help much

RuneRem said:


The anti-feminism perspective was incredibly common then, because of the constant feminist politicisation in tv, movies, video games, and it's potential entry into anime.

Ryuk9428 said:
I agree with @Milzol, we should just ban people who make dumb/false reports.

As for the OP. Honestly, the rules on both CE and CD are unrealistic. They get violated a lot or people skirt the rules because they are too strict. If people followed them to the letter there'd be no discussion here at all.

Internet forums cannot survive without arguing and a certain level of what is being called "toxic."

I get sick of people saying things like "this is an anime forum, not a X forum." The truth is that every hobby has overlapping interests. People are into this hobby for different reasons and I will admit, politics is a big reason why I got into and am still into anime. I find that anime fans have a unique set of social/ideological views and that's the biggest reason why I am here. I still watch anime plenty, but it gets to a point where there simply isn't much to discuss about the hobby itself and it becomes more interesting to talk about why we like or got involved in this hobby.

In my personal experience, true anime discussions happen much more naturally in real life then they do over the internet because in real life you are actually watching anime with people and can discuss it after each episode. In anime series discussion on the other hand, it is very difficult because often times the anime you watched is old and nobody is really talking about it anymore. Anime series discussion is only really good to on when the series in question is new or currently airing. Meanwhile, AD gets dragged down by repetitive topics that don't add much.

So to be frank, politics is the easiest way to build friendships with people on here. Being into anime is not enough because anime fans don't all think the same way. We're not into the same kind of anime and we're not watching for the same reasons. Knowing a person's political beliefs, however, gives you a much better clue to their personality. Its nice to know that liking anime is the default position here, I don't have to ask that question of somebody, but politics is how you actually get to know each person here imo.

Luna said:

The Spam board was created when the forum and the entire userbase were still very small, so it wasn't much of a problem in the beginning. But the userbase was growing and people kept spamming the board with rule violations (trolling, abuse, nsfm stuff etc). Even though it was a spam board, it couldn't go completely unmoderated, but moderating it became impossible. In 2010 the board was transformed into "Casual Chat" and in 2012 into "Forum Games". This was the only way to "close" the board because back then MAL was owned by a company that didn't care about the website, so getting a board name change was the most we could get back then.

deg said:
its funny that some of the right wingers on this thread that are always posting fake news and disinformation are happy about this lol

LordTuchanka said:

Well I feel bad (much more so to the old regulars who liked this place) and don't really want to make this place disappear. But yeah I find the comments here odd as well lmao. Though I think people just want to hold on to little pride that has been left.

mr_modest said:
This means better moderation for General anime discussion, YAY!!

RuneRem said:


Because this will stop you leftists from propagandising on Mal like you do everywhere. Our original views were never right wing, but rather apolitical, and wanted people to leave their petty politics out of video games and anime.

So this is a loss for leftist political activists politicising everywhere.

Auron_ said:
Sounds like the last nail in the coffin for MAL Forums' traffic. Good job. You guys must really like AniList to do them a favor like that I guess.

traed said:
Wow the mods are so bad they created new rules (most of which bad except the rule for CE on sources required) now entire boards are going to be deleted because of a small handful of users who will invade the rest of the site. This wont be the last board to go others will follow I gaurantee it. Mods being too spineless to ban a tiny number of dickwads just to pretend to be fair as if people promoting bigoted hatred have valid opinions to be respected. Wrong move. You will regret this as you see the results that will come from it. Why do MAL mods not understand simple forum concepts like containment boards and threads? I would have taken a role of a mod years ago if I didn't expect myself to not be alive long but what difference would it make if the rest of the staff doesn't care about my input I've given before? Even contradictions in the rules have never been fixed which made following rules in CE impossible. Iirc one rule said use a clear and unbiased title the other rule said use the title used in the article but these dont always align. I've already seen all the boards got shit up from the new rules added over the years and how it lead to a surge of thread of derailments and drop in thread quality and reply quality all over so I know what comes next. A bunch of the mods havent even been members for more than a year or two, a bunch if noobs that don't know what the site is like shouldn't be deciding these sort of things. This would be fine or even good if rules against controversy (thus restoring most of what is potentially interesting to discuss) was abolished but you're not even doing that. Might as well just get it over with and shut down all the forums because they have already been killed by overly strict rules anyway and that clearly is where we are headed because the downward spiral spearheaded by trash users and mods working together to destroy the community. Might as well shut down anime reviews as well that can get "problematic".


A lot of problems are easy to solve. Thread titles could be automatically generated by linked sources and linked sources could be cross checked with media bias fact check if it's a known bad source when certain words are present in the opening post.

Users should have a black list that allows them to automatically hide certain topics or posts that contain whatever words they choose. This would mean more sensitive users can just stay out of controversial topics entirely instead of complaining they exist and can avoid topics that upset them too much. Plus blocking a user should hide their threads not just their posts in threads which also would help reduce conflict needing to be moderated.

Auron_ said:
Sounds like the last nail in the coffin for MAL Forums' traffic. Good job. You guys must really like AniList to do them a favor like that I guess.

Mienus said:


Yeah, people are just going to be running to anilist after this with its non-existent current events board. Hell, the OP even says that CE is only an extremely small portion of the forum's overall activity.

traed said:
Wow the mods are so bad they created new rules (most of which bad except the rule for CE on sources required) now entire boards are going to be deleted because of a small handful of users who will invade the rest of the site. This wont be the last board to go others will follow I gaurantee it. Mods being too spineless to ban a tiny number of dickwads just to pretend to be fair as if people promoting bigoted hatred have valid opinions to be respected. Wrong move. You will regret this as you see the results that will come from it. Why do MAL mods not understand simple forum concepts like containment boards and threads? I would have taken a role of a mod years ago if I didn't expect myself to not be alive long but what difference would it make if the rest of the staff doesn't care about my input I've given before? Even contradictions in the rules have never been fixed which made following rules in CE impossible. Iirc one rule said use a clear and unbiased title the other rule said use the title used in the article but these dont always align. I've already seen all the boards got shit up from the new rules added over the years and how it lead to a surge of thread of derailments and drop in thread quality and reply quality all over so I know what comes next. A bunch of the mods havent even been members for more than a year or two, a bunch if noobs that don't know what the site is like shouldn't be deciding these sort of things. This would be fine or even good if rules against controversy (thus restoring most of what is potentially interesting to discuss) was abolished but you're not even doing that. Might as well just get it over with and shut down all the forums because they have already been killed by overly strict rules anyway and that clearly is where we are headed because the downward spiral spearheaded by trash users and mods working together to destroy the community. Might as well shut down anime reviews as well that can get "problematic".


A lot of problems are easy to solve. Thread titles could be automatically generated by linked sources and linked sources could be cross checked with media bias fact check if it's a known bad source when certain words are present in the opening post.

Users should have a black list that allows them to automatically hide certain topics or posts that contain whatever words they choose. This would mean more sensitive users can just stay out of controversial topics entirely instead of complaining they exist and can avoid topics that upset them too much. Plus blocking a user should hide their threads not just their posts in threads which also would help reduce conflict needing to be moderated.

Deathko said:

This is hilarious from the local basement-dwelling neo-nazi who can't post without spouting 19th century racial theories and bringing up the mondial jewspiracy, and NEVER discusses anything in any other subsection than CE.

I guess when you're wearing a tinfoil hat you suspect everybody of doing the same.

deg said:
>And ultimately, MyAnimeList is an anime website; it is not a political or news forum.

reminds me of the talking point of Ardanaz too lol and he recently became a mod again, my conspiracy theory mind is triggering

but anyway its their site so its their rule

Ardanaz said:

I swear I have nothing to do with this one lmao

traed said:
Wow the mods are so bad they created new rules (most of which bad except the rule for CE on sources required) now entire boards are going to be deleted because of a small handful of users who will invade the rest of the site. This wont be the last board to go others will follow I gaurantee it. Mods being too spineless to ban a tiny number of dickwads just to pretend to be fair as if people promoting bigoted hatred have valid opinions to be respected. Wrong move. You will regret this as you see the results that will come from it. Why do MAL mods not understand simple forum concepts like containment boards and threads? I would have taken a role of a mod years ago if I didn't expect myself to not be alive long but what difference would it make if the rest of the staff doesn't care about my input I've given before? Even contradictions in the rules have never been fixed which made following rules in CE impossible. Iirc one rule said use a clear and unbiased title the other rule said use the title used in the article but these dont always align. I've already seen all the boards got shit up from the new rules added over the years and how it lead to a surge of thread of derailments and drop in thread quality and reply quality all over so I know what comes next. A bunch of the mods havent even been members for more than a year or two, a bunch if noobs that don't know what the site is like shouldn't be deciding these sort of things. This would be fine or even good if rules against controversy (thus restoring most of what is potentially interesting to discuss) was abolished but you're not even doing that. Might as well just get it over with and shut down all the forums because they have already been killed by overly strict rules anyway and that clearly is where we are headed because the downward spiral spearheaded by trash users and mods working together to destroy the community. Might as well shut down anime reviews as well that can get "problematic".


A lot of problems are easy to solve. Thread titles could be automatically generated by linked sources and linked sources could be cross checked with media bias fact check if it's a known bad source when certain words are present in the opening post.

Users should have a black list that allows them to automatically hide certain topics or posts that contain whatever words they choose. This would mean more sensitive users can just stay out of controversial topics entirely instead of complaining they exist and can avoid topics that upset them too much. Plus blocking a user should hide their threads not just their posts in threads which also would help reduce conflict needing to be moderated.