New
Feb 27, 2019 2:34 AM
#1
I don't dislike bunny girl but to be honest, I couldn't bring myself to love it as much as oregairu and hyouka. Maybe because of their really smart approach to the genre. People compare bunny girl to oregairu and monogatari while I felt bunny girl was more dramatic and lacked the brilliant dialogues of monogatari and unorthodox ideas of oregairu. I know it's all subjective so I just want to read other's opinion on this. Have a nice day :) |
[There was never a purpose or meaning to life] [No matter how you spin it.... I lose again] |
Feb 27, 2019 2:41 AM
#2
"Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). |
alshuFeb 27, 2019 2:46 AM
Feb 27, 2019 2:42 AM
#3
Oregairu is undoubtedly the most popular of all the three anime you mentioned. Then it's Hyouka and then Bunny Girl senpai. The thing is that Bunny girl senpai was too overhyped, but i can't know the reason of such thing since i dropped it after 2nd episode. Maybe because, in fact it's similar to Monogatari series and oregairu with a mix in between. Who knows, and who has let the dogs come out? |
ItsYaBoiSkanaFeb 27, 2019 2:48 AM
Feb 27, 2019 2:46 AM
#4
alshu said: Oh god, I thought seriously that I was the only one who thought so...And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. |
Feb 27, 2019 3:01 AM
#5
"Why isn't -insert favourite Anime- as popular and well rated like Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood" |
Feb 27, 2019 3:05 AM
#6
I'm sure Oregairu is the most popular among those three, Hyouka then Bunny Girl. With that 8.5x rating Bunny Girl will likely be a hit for a while and its hype not gonna die soon especially it's romance and drama, are one most of liked genre here, not to mention that Bunny Girl rather simpler among those three But those three not even similar except the main character and heroine |
ReeeiFeb 27, 2019 3:09 AM
Feb 27, 2019 3:27 AM
#7
First of all, it isn't. Oregairu is more popular and has a higher total viewer count. Hyouka even tops Oregairu (for some reason). Secondly Hyouka is just boring for the most part and doesn't really offer much aside from big chitanda eyes and lazy, pointless mysteries that don't go anywhere. Personally I don't see it coming even close to either of those shows in terms of the characters, the content, anything. Thirdly, I agree that Bunny Girl wasn't on the same level as Monogatari (or Oregairu) when it comes to the dialogues, but it was still entertaining enough. And lastly, personally I think it has a higher score than Oregairu for two reasons: a) Simply being more recent and not enough time having passed yet for people to watch it who weren't part of the initial hype. Almost all seasonals who get such high ratings don't stay that high forever. b) Because the romance is more central and explicit, and people like that. |
I probably regret this post by now. |
Feb 27, 2019 3:29 AM
#8
Someone kept telling me, "Bunny Girl Senpai is the best of the season, you have to watch it." I just watched last week, and I didn't get why it is so acclameid by the people. I mean... nothing original, right? there are a lot of anime like that. I think people prefer anime with cheap dialogue, then they can understand the story. |
"というわけで。待望の、体 操 服! でっあ~る。祭りであれば、余も着飾ってはいられぬと用意したが……うむ! 心身ともに軽くなったようだ。どうだ? 似合っているであろう、マスター?" - Random Quote From Internet by Saber Nero |
Feb 27, 2019 3:32 AM
#9
bunny girl is only popular for having the bunny girl on the poster, hyouka is 100 times better than bunny girl senpai |
Feb 27, 2019 4:19 AM
#10
So much hate for Hyouka here... Anyways, I slighty liked more Hyouka over Bunny Girl Senpai not only of Chitanda, but because of the absolute realism of the mysteries who many consider too basic, that itself is its greatest selling point for me. Bunny Girl Senpai is more dependant on methaphorical situations, but Rio Futaba and her constant quantic explanations were the best parts, should I mention that the romance is more advanced than many other romance animes? |
"What a Player, what a Champion here at Wimbledon, the first man to win 8 Championships." Andrew Castle on Roger Federer winning his 19th Grand Slam title. |
Feb 27, 2019 4:34 AM
#11
Feb 27, 2019 4:36 AM
#12
alshu said: those are some really shitty opinions bro"Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). |
Feb 27, 2019 4:38 AM
#13
zBluee said: Someone kept telling me, "Bunny Girl Senpai is the best of the season, you have to watch it." I just watched last week, and I didn't get why it is so acclameid by the people. I mean... nothing original, right? there are a lot of anime like that. I think people prefer anime with cheap dialogue, then they can understand the story. are there really? There's exactly one show I can think of that has a comparable structure and emphasis and that is Monogatari (and that chinese Monogatari clone probably), and Bunny Girl manages to still be distinct enough from that by focusing much more on the main relationship so it didn't bother me that much. I've seen 5k anime and Bunny Girl seemed pretty unique overall so what do you know that I don't? Or is it that because I've seen so much, having only 1 or 2 similar shows still counts as pretty unique for me? But let's set the originality debate aside. I was getting into it expecting it to be generic and not to my liking but ended up pleasantly surprised by how effective it was and how likable the characters and romance were. It wasn't as good at the arc-based mysteries and sharp dialogues as Monogatari and didn't pull off the cynicism as well as Oregairu, and you can certainly compare certain elements of it to other shows, but as a whole it felt like a fairly unique mix of things and most importantly it was executed very well, which is always more important than how unique the concept is. Getting hung up on the originiality of an anime that just perfectly executes stuff that is generally enjoyed by a lot of people, is really missing the point of their appeal. People know what they like and they like seeing those things done really well. That's almost always gonna be more appealing to a larger amount of people than trying to do something completely new. Virtual-san is doing something new this season, something unique that no show has done before, and it still isn't doing well. That's because execution matters over originality. |
I probably regret this post by now. |
Feb 27, 2019 4:39 AM
#14
I haven t watch Bunny senpai. But Oreigaru way above Hyouka by 10 times. Better plot, better main characters and consistent characters. Hachiman and Yukino>>>>>>>>>Oreki and Chitanda. |
Feb 27, 2019 4:41 AM
#15
Kuraya said: alshu said: those are some really shitty opinions bro"Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). My counter point is that I am not an elitist thus my taste and opinions are shit by default. Thanks for stating the obvious...Captain? |
Feb 27, 2019 4:42 AM
#16
I don't really know if my opinion would add up to this but I think this : Oregairu>Hyouka>Bunny Girl Senpai. Although, I like all of them but I just prefer Oregairu and Hyouka than Bunny Girl. To think about it it just comes to a personal preference but most shows from very recent years have high ratings in MAL so the date of release might show bias on putting the rating of the show. Also, who really cares about a mean score from this site, people disagree on a lot of ratings anyways. Other sites have different ratings so this is just statistics of people who rate on a certain site. |
Once we realize it, everything will fall into place Our hearts calling to the future with all their might We'll move forward, holding each other's shaking hands |
Feb 27, 2019 4:43 AM
#17
Bunny girls was overhyped, the anime is not very good, i would say the cause of that its the 3 eps(and the rest its not very good)- they rush things. Hyouka and oregairu are obvious better than bunny girl. On Oregairu the biggest problem, for me, its the 2 season. In relation to hyouka(my favourite anime with gurren lagann too) i would say the bigeest problem(wich its not necessarily a problem for me) its the slow pace. |
Tiago_KTFeb 27, 2019 4:49 AM
Feb 27, 2019 4:49 AM
#18
alshu said: no, they're not.... I'm not elitist eitherKuraya said: alshu said: "Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). My counter point is that I am not an elitist thus my taste and opinions are shit by default. Thanks for stating the obvious...Captain? |
Feb 27, 2019 4:51 AM
#19
Kuraya said: alshu said: no, they're not.... I'm not elitist eitherKuraya said: alshu said: those are some really shitty opinions bro"Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). My counter point is that I am not an elitist thus my taste and opinions are shit by default. Thanks for stating the obvious...Captain? 'your opinions are shit because they're not the same as mine' 'I'm not an elitist' pick one |
I probably regret this post by now. |
Feb 27, 2019 4:52 AM
#20
Kuraya said: alshu said: no, they're not.... I'm not elitist eitherKuraya said: alshu said: those are some really shitty opinions bro"Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). My counter point is that I am not an elitist thus my taste and opinions are shit by default. Thanks for stating the obvious...Captain? So your opinion how shitty are my shitty opinions is by default shitty too. |
Feb 27, 2019 4:56 AM
#21
Simple. Cuz they're not as good as Mai Bunny Girl Senpai |
Feb 27, 2019 4:57 AM
#22
Why ponder over such a trivial question. All three are pretty much the same crap. |
Feb 27, 2019 5:01 AM
#23
DaddyClapCheeks said: Why ponder over such a trivial question. All three are pretty much the same crap. Not really. From the bunch I like Hyouka way more then the other two, so maybe they are crap but different crap. |
Feb 27, 2019 5:01 AM
#24
Feb 27, 2019 5:07 AM
#25
alshu said: no... Who said opinions that aren't those of an elitist are shitty ?Kuraya said: alshu said: Kuraya said: alshu said: those are some really shitty opinions bro"Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). My counter point is that I am not an elitist thus my taste and opinions are shit by default. Thanks for stating the obvious...Captain? So your opinion how shitty are my shitty opinions is by default shitty too. |
Feb 27, 2019 5:09 AM
#26
Pullman said: it seems natural to me to say that an opinion is pretty shitty if it says things like "oregairu S2 is bad" Kuraya said: alshu said: Kuraya said: alshu said: those are some really shitty opinions bro"Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). My counter point is that I am not an elitist thus my taste and opinions are shit by default. Thanks for stating the obvious...Captain? 'your opinions are shit because they're not the same as mine' 'I'm not an elitist' pick one Am I not allowed to have opinions on someone's opinions ? Elitists have more characteristics than just saying people's opinions are shit |
Feb 27, 2019 5:19 AM
#27
Kuraya said: alshu said: no... Who said opinions that aren't those of an elitist are shitty ?Kuraya said: alshu said: no, they're not.... I'm not elitist eitherKuraya said: alshu said: those are some really shitty opinions bro"Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). My counter point is that I am not an elitist thus my taste and opinions are shit by default. Thanks for stating the obvious...Captain? So your opinion how shitty are my shitty opinions is by default shitty too. The elitists. Without them we couldn't tell which crap is the shittiest. Kuraya said: "oregairu S2 is bad" Maybe I said it in a positive way? Like "This sudden change when the MC become a whining random dude after being such a based badass is definitely a great twist...if you hate your audience." Kuraya said: Am I not allowed to have opinions on someone's opinions ? You are allowed but it is still a shitty opinion. (Well both of them.) |
alshuFeb 27, 2019 5:31 AM
Feb 27, 2019 5:30 AM
#28
alshu said: this is giving me headaches, lets just say everything is shittyKuraya said: alshu said: Kuraya said: alshu said: no, they're not.... I'm not elitist eitherKuraya said: alshu said: those are some really shitty opinions bro"Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). My counter point is that I am not an elitist thus my taste and opinions are shit by default. Thanks for stating the obvious...Captain? So your opinion how shitty are my shitty opinions is by default shitty too. The elitists. Without them we couldn't tell which crap is the shittiest. Kuraya said: "oregairu S2 is bad" Maybe I meant it in a positive way? Like "This sudden change when the MC become a whining random dude after being such a based badass is deffinetly a great twist...if you hate your audience." Kuraya said: Am I not allowed to have opinions on someone's opinions ? You are allowed but it is still a shitty opinion. (Well both of them.) |
Feb 27, 2019 5:32 AM
#29
I absolutely loved Bunny Girl Senpai mostly because of the romance in the first three episodes For me it felt real and didn’t seem like it was scripted not to mention Sakuta was an MC that isn’t really prevalent in romance anime’s and it gave me a Spice and Wolf kind of vibe which is one of my favorites. I dropped Hyouka after episode 3 because honestly I though Chitanda was boring and really didn’t care enough about her backstory I thought it was boring however I can understand why the simplistic aspect of things would entice others not to mention I did like the MC but I wish it had been a different setting Lastly Oregairu is another anime I loved and 8man is just absolutely well written The only thing that it lacked it comparison to Bunny Girl Senpai was the romance which at times felt cringe and unnatural however I will admit that some scenes were cringe in Bunny Girl as well Other than that I guess the ending left me a bit bitter but I won’t go into depth for spoiler reasons |
Feb 27, 2019 5:33 AM
#30
Kuraya said: lets just say everything is shitty Ha! Funny thing, everybody repeats that after arguing with me. |
Feb 27, 2019 5:44 AM
#31
They don't need to, ratings means nothing on this site. Oregairu is fine as it is and Hyouka is not that good. The only reason BGS is popular, is because the MC is an asshole and likes to tease girls that somehow ends up falling for him, which is a wet dream for the majority of its audience. |
"We could make the world better, but it's easier to just shut our eyes." ~Blackwall |
Feb 27, 2019 5:46 AM
#32
Kuraya said: Pullman said: it seems natural to me to say that an opinion is pretty shitty if it says things like "oregairu S2 is bad" Kuraya said: alshu said: no, they're not.... I'm not elitist eitherKuraya said: alshu said: those are some really shitty opinions bro"Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). My counter point is that I am not an elitist thus my taste and opinions are shit by default. Thanks for stating the obvious...Captain? 'your opinions are shit because they're not the same as mine' 'I'm not an elitist' pick one Am I not allowed to have opinions on someone's opinions ? Elitists have more characteristics than just saying people's opinions are shit Like what? If you think your opinion is inherently better than other opinions without even attempting to bring in arguments or anything to back it up you're basically implying that you and your opinions are better than others by default, which is pretty 'elitist' if you ask me. But whatever, keep on being condescending towards disagreeing opinions while not even providing arguments and feel like you're the good guy in the process. Hypocrisy is rampant in this fandom already, one more of you won't make a difference. |
AlcoholicideFeb 27, 2019 5:53 AM
I probably regret this post by now. |
Feb 27, 2019 5:48 AM
#33
alshu said: OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. I did not know people disliked 2nd season that much :0 |
"We could make the world better, but it's easier to just shut our eyes." ~Blackwall |
Feb 27, 2019 5:57 AM
#34
Bunny Girl Senpai is currently more popular and talked about than those shows simply because it's new. 80% of online discussion will be always about seasonals, not because they are better, not because there's any unwritten rule about this. It's a mixture of force of habit and the fact that is certain you're watching it all at the same time. An example of this latter aspect: if you complete a show from the 90s you might be able to find someone who has watched it, but maybe they did 3-4 years ago and it's not fresh in their memory, hence discussing specific things is harder. Also Hyouka's reference to They Were Eleven in ep 12 makes it the best of the three by far, if that's the current debate. :X |
Feb 27, 2019 6:04 AM
#35
HereticHunter said: alshu said: OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. I did not know people disliked 2nd season that much :0 This is my op... OK but from my perspective when OreGairu was airing every 5-th post on any topic was "But 8man would do this better!"...nobody argued, 8man was a legendary meme. This stopped after season 2. |
alshuFeb 27, 2019 6:16 AM
Feb 27, 2019 6:09 AM
#36
As others have said Oregairu and Hyouka are still more popular, give it some time and BGS hype will die down probably. I haven't seen Oregairu but Hyouka is far better then BGS. Even if you hate Hyouka's story at least they do interesting things visually, BGS is boring af visually. There is very little animation and the art design is ugly. Most of the shots are them just walking down the street throwing teenager level banter at each other. It's garbage. |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Feb 27, 2019 6:10 AM
#37
Yah. But i think theme is also popular as bunny girls. My friend who don't really like anine that much. But he already watch and love oregairu. |
still having great time with my stuff |
Feb 27, 2019 6:15 AM
#38
I liked both but prefer Bunny girl by a good margin. For a few reasons. For Oregairu, Hachiman was the only character I found interesting. While I wouldn't say I hated any of the characters, I found it hard to care about any of them either. The pacing also felt slow in a couple of places. Hachiman's cynicism, while refreshing for a character, felt overplayed a few times. I also remember the ending not being great. Here's hoping we get a final season. For Hyouka the biggest problem is the logic is all over the place sometimes and other times it feels contrived, simply for the sake of trying to make the protagonist look like a genius. Towards the end of the series the pacing also seemed to weirdly slow down. The ending was mediocre. Never really got a satisfying conclusion to the girl/protag's relationship, or that one chick who manipulated the protagonist. That's all I can remember from the two. It's been a while since I've seen them. But yeah, I liked both anyway. The only fault I had with Bunny Girl was some of the supernatural explanations being a bunch of hokey-pokey. And personally, I strongly dislike the monogatari series. The dialogue feels all over the place with random conversation topics, and the mishmashed art makes it even more of a mess. Certainly a unique style, though. |
BStrifeSword114Feb 27, 2019 6:20 AM
Feb 27, 2019 6:18 AM
#39
Unowen said: Bunny Girl Senpai is currently more popular and talked about than those shows simply because it's new. 80% of online discussion will be always about seasonals, not because they are better, not because there's any unwritten rule about this. It's a mixture of force of habit and the fact that is certain you're watching it all at the same time. An example of this latter aspect: if you complete a show from the 90s you might be able to find someone who has watched it, but maybe they did 3-4 years ago and it's not fresh in their memory, hence discussing specific things is harder. Also Hyouka's reference to They Were Eleven in ep 12 makes it the best of the three by far, if that's the current debate. :X That was literally the only memorable scene from Hyouka for me :>. Not enough to beat the others who actually have interesting chars and actual stuff happening, but still. I was pleased to see that ^^. |
I probably regret this post by now. |
Feb 27, 2019 6:46 AM
#40
Both are way more popular than Bunny Girl (just compare the numbers of people who've rated it). Bunny Girl is just being more talked about nowadays since it came out just last season, and was overrated as fuck. As for the rating...well, lately lot of mediocre seasonals are being overrated so I'm not surprised. Also, I'd say Bunny Girl is an easier anime than Hyouka (haven't watched Oregairu), since it's just a harem full of trope characters and a self-insert protagonist, coped with a bunch of mildly funny banter that for the most part only match Monogatari at its worst, so it's an understandable rating. So yeah, it manages to nicely deceive you that it's doing something great. It did for me until that banter developed to the MC kicking someone's butt. Also, the most frequent criticism I've seen towards Hyouka is that nothing happens, so...yikes. |
Feb 27, 2019 7:07 AM
#41
I liked Bunny girl because of the main cast. Sakuta and Mai imo blow the water out of Araragi/Hitagi/Shinobi, Hachiman/Yukino/Yui and Houtarou/Chitanda. Sakuta and Mai interactions really sold the show for me. They remind me of Holo and Lawrence in Spice and Wolf one of my favorite. Hyouka was particularly a snorefest never really enjoyed it. Monogatri and Oregairu are decent shows and I liked them but they both come up short. |
Feb 27, 2019 7:11 AM
#42
You missed the waifu material in Hyouka - Fuyumi aka The Empress. She is the Irene Adler of the show. |
Feb 27, 2019 7:20 AM
#43
alshu said: You missed the waifu material in Hyouka - Fuyumi aka The Empress. She is the Irene Adler of the show. Yeah she was the favorite in the show |
Feb 27, 2019 7:21 AM
#44
YouAreGoingToSay said: I don't dislike bunny girl but to be honest, I couldn't bring myself to love it as much as oregairu and hyouka. Maybe because of their really smart approach to the genre. People compare bunny girl to oregairu and monogatari while I felt bunny girl was more dramatic and lacked the brilliant dialogues of monogatari and unorthodox ideas of oregairu. I know it's all subjective so I just want to read other's opinion on this. Have a nice day :) First have a nice day 2 :) Well for me I think it's because time flied and also number of episodes might be an important factor here. At this point we only have one season of Bunny Girl Senpai now, and there might be situation than if/when second one premieres and it be "weak" then it can "downgrade" even first seasons ratings. Also it's obvious that new currently airing series will have more hyped and will be more popular online. Look how many people now are talking about Mob Psycho 100 II or Rising Shield Hero. It's always like that. Look now no one is talking anymore about Violet Evergarden, yeah people will recomm it to some newbies on MAL forum but time flies and hype is... gone. |
The Young Noble of the Field is currently watching - Diamond no Ace: Act II Misugi-kun is also reading - Kanojo, Okarishimasu |
Feb 27, 2019 7:44 AM
#45
more weeb culture = win more waifus + 'supernatural nonsense shit' = win hyouka is 'novel' (non weeb / non light novel), first realse at 2001, a light toned mystery story with school setting with almost no weeb culture whatsoever |
MAL score and most user-based rating system are all joke, Imagine trusting plebs and hivemind. Find users who have good sense and rating and use them as a reference. Check my guide to rate Your taste is trash. Cope, seethe, mald |
Feb 27, 2019 8:20 AM
#46
Pullman said: Secondly Hyouka is just boring for the most part and doesn't really offer much aside from big chitanda eyes and lazy, pointless mysteries that don't go anywhere. Personally I don't see it coming even close to either of those shows in terms of the characters, the content, anything. invalid reason, why '3-gatsu' have a lot of fans despite the whole story and premise is so simple and boring ? the reason is weeb community doesnt like a slice of life / normal story. just look at 'Shirobako', only few people watch it because weebs just not interested because no waifu, no bewbs, no weeb culture on the paper. compared to this: https://myanimelist.net/anime/34497/Death_March_kara_Hajimaru_Isekai_Kyousoukyoku (2018) more people completed this shit compared to shirobako (2014) (top 100 anime by nhk poll) (https://myanimelist.net/news/50582644) an ordinary isekai shit, but people watch it despite it is a clusterfuck white weeb mostly only watch weeb culture weird stuff |
MAL score and most user-based rating system are all joke, Imagine trusting plebs and hivemind. Find users who have good sense and rating and use them as a reference. Check my guide to rate Your taste is trash. Cope, seethe, mald |
Feb 27, 2019 8:29 AM
#47
alshu said: "Why isn't OreGairu and Hyouka as popular and well rated like Bunny Girl Senpai?" OreGairu was way more popular than Bunny Girl Senpai but the horrible second season ruined its creds. Hyouka is a slow detective show about school mysteries like "Who locked the door?", "Who have stolen those useless random objects?" and "What Hyouka even means?" - very few people like those also didn't have a conclusion. PS And yeah Chitanda is really annoying. If it will be some sort of comfort to you I value OreGairu and Hyouka way above Bunny Girl Senpai (which I dropped after a half of episode). bahahahahahaha i lost it at your description of Hyouka even though i haven't seen it, thats hilarious |
Feb 27, 2019 8:42 AM
#48
Not from where I am standing. If you mean the scores - second season is scored by less users. (Probably the ones that gave lower score to the first have dropped the second without scoring it.) ASaid99 said: Also most people love Chitanda. But even more people hate her...including fans. |
alshuFeb 27, 2019 8:48 AM
Feb 27, 2019 8:45 AM
#49
Daphi said: bahahahahahaha i lost it at your description of Hyouka even though i haven't seen it, thats hilarious Take note that I am a big fan of the show...just trying to explain why probably it hasn't such mass appeal as the others. |
Feb 27, 2019 8:52 AM
#50
evoniee said: Pullman said: Secondly Hyouka is just boring for the most part and doesn't really offer much aside from big chitanda eyes and lazy, pointless mysteries that don't go anywhere. Personally I don't see it coming even close to either of those shows in terms of the characters, the content, anything. invalid reason, why '3-gatsu' have a lot of fans despite the whole story and premise is so simple and boring ? the reason is weeb community doesnt like a slice of life / normal story. just look at 'Shirobako', only few people watch it because weebs just not interested because no waifu, no bewbs, no weeb culture on the paper. compared to this: https://myanimelist.net/anime/34497/Death_March_kara_Hajimaru_Isekai_Kyousoukyoku (2018) more people completed this shit compared to shirobako (2014) (top 100 anime by nhk poll) (https://myanimelist.net/news/50582644) an ordinary isekai shit, but people watch it despite it is a clusterfuck white weeb mostly only watch weeb culture weird stuff Okay, that just sounds like incoherent ramblings so I'll try to make sense of it. 1. 3-gatsu isn't boring, there is a lot going on, many intense and captivating scenes, many emotions. A lot of it feels significant and relevant too. In Hyouka they just spent most time on trivial mysteries, none of the characters were particularly compelling, I don't remember any emotional impact from that show. It wasn't bad, it just kinda was. Idk why you thought of comparing it to a show like 3-gatsu that has a lot of shit going on and made me be on the edge of my seat for a lot of episodes. They don't even have a lot in common conceptually, there is no romance, almost no school setting, a much larger and older support cast. You can compare Hyouka to other school slice-of-life shows or to shows who have a similar laid back and kinda cynical MC, which is why I understand the comparisons to Oregairu and Bunny Girl even when I think both of these shows are just so much more interesting and eventful than Hyouka, but comparing it to 3-gatsu just seems to come out of nowhere, they have very little in common. Also how in the holy fuck did you come to the conclusion that 3-gatsu appeals to waifu weebs? You say the anime community doesn't like 'normal' slice of life stories and then proceed to list a very beloved and well-received 'normal' slice of life story in 3-gatsu. You're basically undermining your whole argument by doing that. What was the point? 2. Shirobako is still pretty popular with around 100k viewers and being in the top 500 most popular anime easily. You can always compare stuff to even more popular titles, but that's not gonna give an accurate representation of how popular something is in the grand scheme of things. Not to mention how much better received Shirobaki was than Death March if you look at the score, reviews or just general interest in it. It might have less completions, but more people actually have it on their list, being interested in it. That's also part of popularity. I'm not gonna deny that anything fantasy and action based is on average more popular than a realistic slice of life show, but why does that even matter? They each have their own fanbases. And we're not talking about people who don't even watch something, we're talking about people who have seen the titles we're talking about, hence already having some interest in them. I actually like slice of life and mystery and cynical MCs and even with all that going for it I still ended up finding Hyouka terribly mediocre and mostly boring. That's not just me disliking that type of show, it's just me finding Hyouka to be a pretty unimpressive one. Nothing interesting and very little entertaining things happen in that show, and I would not say the same thing about most slow slice of life shows. 3. What's up with the excessive use of the word weeb? If you mean 'anime fans' then just say so, weeb means something different and in general what do you get of using derogatory terms to refer to your fellow anime fans? I could say the same about you, there's nothing to like about Kyoukai no Kanata, it's just another generic weeb waifu show with 'supernatural nonsense'. And honestly, that's not even far from my opinion on it, I'm not just saying it because it's hilariously accurate and you used that same phrase to shit on the rest of the community, thinking your taste is so much better. Were the other KyoAni titles too slice of lifey and realistic for you? Because they're mostly better than Kyoukai no Kanata, except the latter has some action and more waifu tropes, but I guess you don't like normal, realistic slice of life stories and always need some random megane waifu, pointless action and random supernatural nonsense to enjoy an anime, hence Kyoukai no Kanata is your KyoAni show of choice. And I could also just assume that you dropped Megalo Box because it didn't have enough cute girls and weeb culture for you. Do you enjoy it when people start making random assumptions about you, your taste and why you like what you like? Yeah, neither does anyone else. So please stop. You're not that special and your taste isn't the end of it all. You don't have any right to call my reason for disliking something 'invalid' just because you seem to be butthurt in some vague way about the community in general not valuing a certain genre as high as you do. |
AlcoholicideFeb 27, 2019 8:56 AM
I probably regret this post by now. |
More topics from this board
» Things you've learned about Japan from anime.TheBlockernator - Yesterday |
35 |
by LifelineByNature
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» About Horror Anime...KMIR - 1 hour ago |
3 |
by Zarutaku
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Which anime do you rewatch all the time?Rally- - Oct 3 |
41 |
by Cmonth
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Waifu War V5 (Anniversary-Edition!) (Round 1) ( 1 2 3 4 5 )TheMinkalex - Sep 28 |
219 |
by Yamada_Jakkun
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» Riddle me this: If anime really is mainstream... ( 1 2 )thewiru - Oct 6 |
51 |
by LifelineByNature
»»
15 minutes ago |