Attack on Titan
| No. Third season is fairly boring with plot holes, and continuity errors. MHA has less errors but still fairly limp. So far, out of all the anime I’ve seen this season, Gegege takes the cake. Art, animation, story, plot, characters, actors, all pretty top notch. I’m not really a fan of episodic anime, I prefer continuing with arcs, but this is the only one with good stories, plot follows through even though it’s sometimes predictable. Nice normalized characters, no bipolar shit. Well, except for catchick, that tsundra. Art is retro but done well. |
 |
| I wasn’t too impressed by this arc in the manga but the anime version has been a lot more enjoyable. However it’s still isn’t anything too special. |
 |
Iaditya060 said: that's gonna beat my hero, steins gate0, jojo part 5? Also no spoilers You mentioned those like if it was some sign of quality or something lol. But yes. But all the CR awards will go to Banana fish, cuz its gay and thats more important. |
SwagernatorAug 17, 2018 7:33 AM
 |
| There's some really good stuff in both arcs, expecially the first one (mostly because it's a personnal favourite), but the second one is also great. There's definitely a moment that's going to break the fandom in two -it will most likely be the most controversial moment of the year (probably) (it had huge impact in the manga community, can't even imagine in the anime). Can it beat MHA? Probably. I read the manga and love the adaptation of All Might vs All for One. Definitely one of my favourite adapted arcs of all time (not that I've read a lot). On the contrary, not a big fan of the recap in the first episode, their poor adaptation of the training arc (was way to fast to enjoy basically anything) and they managed to make a good arc (licenses arc) in the manga a very boring one in the anime (plus, the filler are not helping anything). Steins;Gate Zero? Probably too. Even though it's a pretty good show, it feels like they are stretching the series and the animation quality is pretty weak (expecially this last episodes). Jojo's Part 5? Only watched until part 3 and it has been a pretty big disappointment. Dont't even know when I'll watch part 4 so can't comment. But this is all personal opinion. I prefer waiting for the end of the year and them really comment on them. |
| Stien;gate 0 is not that good. It is 7/10 anime for me Hero academia is becoming generic, and I'm not enjoying it as before. It still good but not so great. JoJo part 5 ?! Maybe. I'm big fan of jojo. However, I don't think it will beat attack on titan 3 SAO Alicization. I don't know anything about this arc. I like the previous SAO anime, but they are not same level as attack on titan. But I heard that Alicization will be best arc of SAO Banana Fish, which is currently airing is also so good. 2nd best anime in this season after AOT3 in my opinion. It could get better later. Username23489023 said: No. Third season is fairly boring with plot holes, and continuity errors. MHA has less errors but still fairly limp. So far, out of all the anime I’ve seen this season, Gegege takes the cake. Art, animation, story, plot, characters, actors, all pretty top notch. I’m not really a fan of episodic anime, I prefer continuing with arcs, but this is the only one with good stories, plot follows through even though it’s sometimes predictable. Nice normalized characters, no bipolar shit. Well, except for catchick, that tsundra. Art is retro but done well. Gegege no Kitarou you mean ?! LOL I hope you are joking. I dropped it after watching some episodes. It pure garbage, and so boring. I did not even bother to add it to my list. Not only episodic, but the plot and character are not so interesting. |
| Yeah. Attack on Talking will definitely be the best anime of the year. |
| Yes. I'm from the future and I saw that Attack on Titan season 3 will forever be hailed as the greatest anime of all time. |
 |
Mirai said: Yes. I'm from the future and I saw that Attack on Titan season 3 will forever be hailed as the greatest anime of all time. Name checks out, this is definitely legit. |
| as much as i love attack on titan i dont think so....where the eff are the titans ???? |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Honestly, I don't think it will beat my hero academia in terms of anime of the year, but this will always be my anime of the year 2018. |
| Nope,it wont beat bnha ss3 in both popularity and ranking |
Aoun29 said: Boobsftw said: Nope,it wont beat bnha ss3 in both popularity and ranking Fanboy my hero has the worst anime art ever Even the training is not good In dbs dbz and naruto the training was intense and hard and they still lost sometimes Haha all might took a 100 punches vs nomo in season 1 and only one punch to defeat all for one in s3 But 2nd season of my hero was great Wtf man??That's a fact that BNHA ss3's ranking and popularity are higher than SNK ss3.What a fucking SNK "fanboy" |
| All comes down for me with the adaptation of Jojo Part 5, where I've instilled the power to be compelled as I've trust in David Production to deliver the manga the way it is, if not more as seen from the quality first episode that I've involuntarily watched as the force of temptation has never been stalwartly strong. |
 πππ«π«π π±π¬π²π π₯ πΆπ¬π², πππ«π±π¦π«' πΆπ¬π² π΄π¦π±π₯ ππ©π© πͺπΆ πͺπ¦π€π₯π± ______________________ |
| Are you blind?! can't you see the scores?! 4 anime just right now have higher score so no and never will be |
mhkr said: Are you blind?! can't you see the scores?! 4 anime just right now have higher score so no and never will be Well this isn't the most well loved arc in the series, you know with there being no titans and all, I actually thought the 3rd season would rank much lower while this arc is airing, like 8.40s, but it seems anime only are enjoying it a bit more than the manga readers. I expect the 2nd arc to spike the score up, not sure how high it will get by time this season ends, but we will see, but as I said far too early to make a prediction yet. Boobsftw said: Nope,it wont beat bnha ss3 in both popularity and ranking Of course ny hero acadamia season 3 has more members than snk season 3, my hero s3 has been airing since April, it means it has more time to gain more members, while snk literally started 5 weeks ago. Check my hero s2 and snk s2 member count in comparison, both aired in April last year, snk s2 has 40k more members than my hero s2, even though my hero s2 had 25 episodes which means it was airing for 6 month compare to snk that was airing for only 3 month, and still couldn't gather more members than snk season 2. You are right on the score though, my hero has better rating than snk overall, but this season of snk hasn't even gone to gear 2 yet, the best parts are yet to come, so it is already impressive for me that its already rated 8.62, when it has not touch on the good stuff yet, which is promising especially since this season is 24 episode. |
keragammingAug 19, 2018 9:43 AM
Boobsftw said: Nope,it wont beat bnha ss3 in both popularity and ranking And yaoi doujinshis. Noting can beat MHA in that, not even SNK. |
|
| It will be interesting to see if any opinion change for the good or the bad once December 31/Janauary 1 2019 arrives when the season ends. |
Iaditya060 said: It was the best anime of 2013 and 2017, so I don't see why it can't be again. Specially with MHA having a boring arc right now (even though the All for One arc was the best of the series), Steins;Gate not being as good as the original, and Jojo probably won't even be consider one of the bets of the yearI have heard that there is gonna be crazy stuff happening in the next arc. They say its gonna be the best arc adapted of all time. Is it gonna be the best arc that's gonna beat my hero, steins gate0, jojo part 5? Also no spoilers mhkr said: SNK is known for having some haters because of the popularity,and because it choose to focus more on story and action instead of character fanservice (because aparently character fanservice is what everyone care right now). Meanwhile BNHA is having it's weakesrt arc right now, that most of people are claiming it's getting extremely boring, but the score almost hasn't dropped, so it's clear the most of people are being fanboy towards the show. Steins;Gate 0 is having a high score thanks to the original anime only. All I'm saying is trusting the MAL site to claim something is better is really ridiculous.Are you blind?! can't you see the scores?! 4 anime just right now have higher score so no and never will be |
 |
| Gurl pls we all know that Iya na Kao sare nagara Opantsu Misete Moraitai is anime of the year. |
"What has two arms, two legs, and is alive? Not your favorite character lol! xD" |
Aoun29 said: Boobsftw said: Wtf man??That's a fact that BNHA ss3's ranking and popularity are higher than SNK ss3.What a fucking SNK "fanboy" I never talked about ranking idiot You are poor in understanding english I am just explaining that its not a masterpiece and season 3 was dull as compared to previous seasons of mha or bnha were very good I'm just mad because you called me 'fanboy' and i felt insulted hearing that word |
mhkr said: Are you blind?! can't you see the scores?! 4 anime just right now have higher score so no and never will be MAL scores don't mean shit |
Eight-Man said: SNK has been shit since the 2nd half of the first season. The third season is a large improvement over the borefest that was season 2, but I wouldn't even consider it good, with the only exception being the op which is great. BNHA is leagues above it. Its only leagues above it if you prefer a childish & predictable Shounen over a compelling story with a more mature tone |
I know... why many guys quoting my post?! I just want to say SnK fandom can't beat MHA, Jojo, Gintama and Steins;Gate fandom And yeah I also think this season of Attack on Titan is better than at least My Hero Academia S3 and Steins;Gate 0 |
Daniel_Naumov said: Now that's a stretch I know I would not be willing to make if I were to retain my sense of what is true. mhkr said: I know... why many guys quoting my post?! I just want to say SnK fandom can't beat MHA, Jojo, Gintama and Steins;Gate fandom And yeah I also think this season of Attack on Titan is better than at least My Hero Academia S3 and Steins;Gate 0 Steins Gate does not even get to compare! It is a (pseudo)scientific drama stretched almost to the point of not resembling reality. Almost. The rest is action packed... something. Anyone comparing them to S:G and trying to determine which is better should drink some brain vitamins or something. Its not a stretch at all. I'm not saying AoT doesn't have its "juvenile" aspects but it clearly deals with more mature subjects and the writing improves a lot (S3 currently shows that). BNHA is an enjoyable but overall very childish & cliche Shounen, it just avoids the worst aspects of other popular Shounen and somehow people think its a masterpiece |
Aardwolf94 said: Eight-Man said: SNK has been shit since the 2nd half of the first season. The third season is a large improvement over the borefest that was season 2, but I wouldn't even consider it good, with the only exception being the op which is great. BNHA is leagues above it. Its only leagues above it if you prefer a childish & predictable Shounen over a compelling story with a more mature tone And sicne when is SnK "compelling story with a more mature tone" ? |
|
Swagernator said: Aardwolf94 said: Its only leagues above it if you prefer a childish & predictable Shounen over a compelling story with a more mature tone And sicne when is SnK "compelling story with a more mature tone" ? At least since S2, if not already the second arc of the first season and the story has only gotten more interesting since then. It still has its juvenile aspects like 99% of anime but I don't think its a reach to say its more mature and compelling (in terms of plot) than BnhA which is as childish and cliche as Shounen get (freaking Naruto explored more interesting stuff, especially early on) |
keragamming said: Boobsftw said: Nope,it wont beat bnha ss3 in both popularity and ranking Of course ny hero acadamia season 3 has more members than snk season 3, my hero s3 has been airing since April, it means it has more time to gain more members, while snk literally started 5 weeks ago. Check my hero s2 and snk s2 member count in comparison, both aired in April last year, snk s2 has 40k more members than my hero s2, even though my hero s2 had 25 episodes which means it was airing for 6 month compare to snk that was airing for only 3 month, and still couldn't gather more members than snk season 2. what about ss1?Aot ss1 has more like 500k members than bnha,then Aot ss2 has ONLY more about 40k members than bnha ss2 so my prediction is that bnha ss3 is gonna beat Aot ss3 this time. |
keragamming said: It will be interesting to see if any opinion change for the good or the bad once December 31/Janauary 1 2019 arrives when the season ends. I think it will be good but BnHA will sadly still be higher ranked and maybe even more popular. AoT has had the "its overrated" circlejerk since S1 and BnHA seems to have avoided it somehow. Also they took too long for S2 and the hype has died down compared to BnHA |
Boobsftw said: keragamming said: Of course ny hero acadamia season 3 has more members than snk season 3, my hero s3 has been airing since April, it means it has more time to gain more members, while snk literally started 5 weeks ago. Check my hero s2 and snk s2 member count in comparison, both aired in April last year, snk s2 has 40k more members than my hero s2, even though my hero s2 had 25 episodes which means it was airing for 6 month compare to snk that was airing for only 3 month, and still couldn't gather more members than snk season 2. what about ss1?Aot ss1 has more like 500k members than bnha,then Aot ss2 has ONLY more about 40k members than bnha ss2 so my prediction is that bnha ss3 is gonna beat Aot ss3 this time. It is already beating snk season 3, the question is if with time snk s3 will surpass bnh s3 member count, maybe by next year it will pass it, maybe not. It's not really something I'm really interested in, just was pointing out something. Aardwolf94 said: keragamming said: It will be interesting to see if any opinion change for the good or the bad once December 31/Janauary 1 2019 arrives when the season ends. I think it will be good but BnHA will sadly still be higher ranked and maybe even more popular. AoT has had the "its overrated" circlejerk since S1 and BnHA seems to have avoided it somehow. Also they took too long for S2 and the hype has died down compared to BnHA We will see, we have not even gotten to the good stuff yet of this season 8.62 rating currently, and as you said the hype is not that big, which may also be a blessing in disguise, because less hype, means less haters as well. This season will be answering the most questions and it will have some of the best fights in anime this year, I'm pretty sure Levi battle in episode 2 is already a top 10 contender, and the ending will overall be good, if its ending were I think it is, this season offer character development and strong story story progression compare to the last two season. And I have notice bnh s3 score has been dropping, not sure why I'm not up to date with the anime, but it may have a good ending and spike back its score up. A lot of persons that don't like the series are not even watching snk anymore, especially since it is not as hype again, so there is no reason to hop on the hate train, so if this season can do a good job to please the fans or the persons that find the series decent at best, which it has done so far, I think this season 3 will have a really high score. |
| Nah, SNK needs to beat this score https://myanimelist.net/anime/35180/3-gatsu_no_Lion_2nd_Season and https://myanimelist.net/anime/30484/Steins_Gate_0?q=stein%20gate |
| All weebs creatures of the galaxy, hear this message. Those of you who listen will not be struck by western animation. You will no longer know hunger, nor pain. Your Anime have come to lead you now. Our strength shall serve as a luminous sun toward which all intelligence may blossom. And the impervious shelter beneath which you will prosper. However, for those who refuse our offer and cling to their western animation ways… For you, there will be great wrath. |
| Hopefully it beats Steins Gate Zero |
Boobsftw said: keragamming said: Of course ny hero acadamia season 3 has more members than snk season 3, my hero s3 has been airing since April, it means it has more time to gain more members, while snk literally started 5 weeks ago. Check my hero s2 and snk s2 member count in comparison, both aired in April last year, snk s2 has 40k more members than my hero s2, even though my hero s2 had 25 episodes which means it was airing for 6 month compare to snk that was airing for only 3 month, and still couldn't gather more members than snk season 2. what about ss1?Aot ss1 has more like 500k members than bnha,then Aot ss2 has ONLY more about 40k members than bnha ss2 so my prediction is that bnha ss3 is gonna beat Aot ss3 this time. One thing people are forgetting is that a lot of people stopped using MAL after the site take a long time to be back. But BNH S3 launched before all this happend, so it's only natural SNK S3 have less members right now |
|
| since the year already started/continued with a better one, no. Also Jojo and maybe Index? lets see I definitely like the season so far though |
| "This emotion is mine alone. It is for Madoka alone." - Homura or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica. |
| sadly hero garbage is overhyped and overrated, so maybe not in terms of popularity, but it is definitely on an other level than any anime this year/decade. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Aug 26, 2018 |
227 |
by GengarGrinn
»»
Apr 25, 7:14 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Sapewloth - Aug 8, 2018 |
117 |
by Adrian610
»»
Apr 8, 1:02 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 14, 2018 |
443 |
by JoestarEISH_020
»»
Mar 31, 6:23 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Oct 7, 2018 |
243 |
by JoestarEISH_020
»»
Mar 31, 5:46 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Sep 23, 2018 |
214 |
by Apreggi
»»
Mar 19, 4:41 AM |