corwin_r said: it's almost 10K IIRC.. but they only realease blue-ray box, not separated volume...Joker Game being higher than others (or rather on the list at all) does trigger me somewhat. I kind of remember the show having abysmal DVD/BD sales, guess that can be irrelevant too sometimes. |
 "If taking responsibility for a mistake that cannot be undone means death, it's not that hard to die. At least, not as hard as to live on." |
corwin_r said: bruhFujos going strong. Well, at least a good chunk of the shows are decent to great. Joker Game being higher than others (or rather on the list at all) does trigger me somewhat. I kind of remember the show having abysmal DVD/BD sales, guess that can be irrelevant too sometimes. Joker game was one of the best selling anime of his season |
STOP SLEEPING ON ODD TAXI |
Oh, my bad then, judging on memory alone, I was pretty sure it flopped. |
 |
| yeah, it was only two blu-ray sets but they sold around 8k - 9k copies for each volumes if i remember correctly. |
| STOP SLEEPING ON ODD TAXI |
CodeBlazeFate said: I'm quite concerned that UBW beat Fate/Zero (especially Second Season). The less we say about SAO beating it too, the better. I need my sanity in tact. Stay/Night is far more popular in Japan. Despite being an average adaptation, I wasn't the least surprised it managed to beat its prequel. Zero is more like a cute little sidestory for them. |
 |
| Huh didn't know Tiger and Bunny was that popular. One of my favs as well, but I'm pretty surprised. Nice to see Code Geass and Madoka Magica there as well. |
| Tiger & Bunny was trash. How did that get top spot? |
| SAO beat both Fate & Bakemonogatari, I'm so triggered rn |
 |
Tenshi_Shura said: CodeBlazeFate said: I'm quite concerned that UBW beat Fate/Zero (especially Second Season). The less we say about SAO beating it too, the better. I need my sanity in tact. Stay/Night is far more popular in Japan. Despite being an average adaptation, I wasn't the least surprised it managed to beat its prequel. Zero is more like a cute little sidestory for them. A "cute little sidestory" that sold more and made more money than the original VN adaptation? |
Rei366 said: @cure_potato Tomino often argued that his first public (during the original broadcast) was essentially feminine (there was more to his sayings but I don't remember them). Where did you find the separate tables? I see only some japanese TV people's own choices on the page. I'm not sure if this is visible on the Crunchyroll page "thingy" since I can't access Crunchyroll from my country so I took a look at the Japanese source - where you can pick a female & male poll result beside the normal one. |
 |
| The list looks great. It's got more variety than MAL's top list. I'll dare say I prefer their list too. |
Rei366 said: Isn't Osomatsu-san rank a bit weird? I would have expect some older title from this franchise to be higher than the last iteration. Osomatsu-san gained a huge female audience that wasn't necessarily interested in the older titles. And these girls are completely crazy about it, I went to Japan this autumn and all the anime shops were filled with Osomatsu-san merch, more than any other mainstream or moe anime. |
| Well, I'm im pretty satisfied that Eva and Conan are in the top 20. I also think there is a good mixture of genres in general in this list. |
 |
| @Yarrowia Ooh, in other words what the first episode "predicted" eventually happened. @cure_potato Thank you, after several random clicks, I discovered them behind the ani-report link. It makes me realize that most of the top ranked titles (Joker, etc) only got through thanks to what I presume to be a massive female participation. Actually, most of the titles who make the list more "diverse" are only due to female voters, making this result a bit less positive. |
Rei_IIIJan 29, 2017 4:33 AM
Z4k said: Tenshi_Shura said: Stay/Night is far more popular in Japan. Despite being an average adaptation, I wasn't the least surprised it managed to beat its prequel. Zero is more like a cute little sidestory for them. A "cute little sidestory" that sold more and made more money than the original VN adaptation? - Sequel effect (even though it's not technically a sequel) - DEEN poisoning - The price is just much higher compared to Zero - A story divided into 3 routes. Should I buy UBW for $400 or just wait for my favorite route HF to come out and spend on it? - Overall Miura's shitty directing screwed it over F/SN is far more popular in Japan. |
|
| >Joker Game Fujos pls, you know this show was bad. |
| Proud founder of The Official Anti-Ging Freecss Fan Club Join now! Kellhus said: GuusWayne said: there is a limit to the suspension of disbelief And it's the fan that did it. Not the smoking porn reading rubik cube genius rape ape with a magic boat. |
Rei366 said: @cure_potato Tomino often argued that his first public (during the original broadcast) was essentially feminine (there was more to his sayings but I don't remember them). I'm not surprised, Char is husbando material. Maybe the love triangle Amuro, Char and Lalah Sune also helped. |
 |
Rei366 said: Fujo support for the shows ranking high on this list is extremely strong: Tiger Bunny, Joker Game and Osomatsu-san were all very successful with this part of the anime fandom and it shows in rankings dominated by women (fujos being the primary targets of most shows aimed at women). Osomatsu in particular sold incredibly well, averaging no less than 65k+ disc sales per volume.Cardcaptor was an obvious winner, I thought that it would be this NHK anime at the first place. Tiger and Bunny is pretty, I don't know... limited in term of audience or target, no? Isn't Osomatsu-san rank a bit weird? I would have expect some older title from this franchise to be higher than the last iteration. Joker Game? So recent and yet so high? Is the novels trilogy this relevant in Japan? As for the Tomino bit, I have to wonder why his female characters are so despicable when he claims his work has feminine sensibilities (especially considering how filled with dated machismo Zeta and 0079 were). I wonder what this quote truly meant. I would agree that a certain mask-wearing blond character would have all the ladies at his feet if he existed in real life, though.  |
| Proud founder of The Official Anti-Ging Freecss Fan Club Join now! Kellhus said: GuusWayne said: there is a limit to the suspension of disbelief And it's the fan that did it. Not the smoking porn reading rubik cube genius rape ape with a magic boat. |
DanHellSing said: Hunter x Hunter is 38th in women's top 50Hmmm. No Hunter x Hunter 2011? Or DBZ? http://www.nhk.or.jp/anime/anime100/ani_report/ just ctrl + F "Hunter" |
| Proud founder of The Official Anti-Ging Freecss Fan Club Join now! Kellhus said: GuusWayne said: there is a limit to the suspension of disbelief And it's the fan that did it. Not the smoking porn reading rubik cube genius rape ape with a magic boat. |
xull said: The online poll results have been revealed.  Top 20 Crunchyroll has posted about this here Source EDIT: + Forgot to mention, voting is open till the 31st of March. What is NHL.. and how Death Note isn't in it.. |
Tenshi_Shura said: - Sequel effect (even though it's not technically a sequel) In that case, Fate/Zero should have sold even less than the DEEN adaptation since it came after it. - DEEN poisoning What is that even supposed to mean? - The price is just much higher compared to Zero By only 1k yen. Fate/Zero BD box 1: ￥ 41,040 https://www.amazon.co.jp/%E3%80%8EFate-Zero%E3%80%8F-Blu-ray-Disc-Box/dp/B005ZOPANI Fate/Stay Night UBW BD box 1: ￥ 42,120 https://www.amazon.co.jp/night-Unlimited-Blade-Blu-ray-I/dp/B00OUQWA76 - A story divided into 3 routes. Should I buy UBW for $400 or just wait for my favorite route HF to come out and spend on it? Is that why the "cute little side story" sold more than both Deen and Ufotable's verson of the UBW? - Overall Miura's shitty directing screwed it over I didn't see any VN readers complain about the first cour but it still didn't sell as much as F/Z. F/SN is far more popular in Japan. The TV anime? Not really. |
| Second season of Tiger & Bunny, WHEN T_T Loved the show, and I had no idea it was this popular in Japan! |
  |
| Kill la Kill, Hunter x Hunter, One Piece and Tatami Galaxy only on women's list No Ping Pong at all :( But we can see Madoka, LOGH, and surprisingly Utena up there (yay), I guess its not that bad. |
| @NipunSinha99 NHK, not NHL ! It's the main (only?) public national broadcaster in japanese television. Sorry about the stray here but: @Sapewloth But... what about Sayla ? even though she gained a lot in Yasuhiko's version, she was already quite something for the year of the first gundam TV broadcast. (Mirai only happened to succumb to stress for a short moment but she was good overall) What about Lalah ? Emma ? What about Reccoa ? Zut, strike this one. I know a few more - cuff, Ple, kuff - up to 0153 that are far from despicable. And to anyone bringing Miss Paraya on the table, she was in "this age"... and she was misguided (+ her male "equivalent" on the other side was not shinier than her). And even among the unlikable or indifferent ones, there were several who ended up quite interesting. (characters don't have to be liked to do their things) Also, I don't remember reading Tomino saying his works have feminine sensibilities (at least up to where I am). Not that I feel obligated to defend the man. ^^" edit @Sapewloth : ok, you won. Beltorchika - 2 I must admit I wanted to erase her existence less than a few episodes in. Though, seeing the "future" Beltorchika in Beltorchika's Children, I wonder how much of how she appeared to be in Zeta was due to Tomino's "anime idiocy" (or inability to convey certain things) and how much was due to external forces. Well, now that you're in Victory, I bet you will be able to add more names on your list (besides Shakti). |
Rei_IIIJan 29, 2017 12:57 PM
| Joker Game?! Hmmmmmmmm .......... |
| I'm surprised that LogH is even in there. I always thought, that it's even more obscure in Japan than it is here. |
Rei366 said: Alright alright, it wasn't all that bad, I admit. BUT, those that were were so bad I can't seem to get them off my mind (Reccoa, Rosamia, freaking Beltorchika, Quess, Shakti, even Fa to a certain extent etc.). I would also argue that PIe or Lalah aren't exactly the best example either, but I can let that one pass. It's almost like Tomino's women became worse with time when I think about it, since 0079 wasn't so bad in that regard despite the sexism.@NipunSinha99 NHK, not NHL ! It's the main (only?) public national broadcaster in japanese television. Sorry about the stray here but: @Sapewloth But... what about Sayla ? even though she gained a lot in Yasuhiko's version, she was already quite something for the year of the first gundam TV broadcast. (Mirai only happened to succumb to stress for a short moment but she was good overall) What about Lalah ? Emma ? What about Reccoa ? Zut, strike this one. I know a few more - cuff, Ple, kuff - up to 0153 that are far from despicable. And to anyone bringing Miss Paraya on the table, she was in "this age"... and she was misguided (+ her male "equivalent" on the other side was not shinier than her). And even among the unlikable or indifferent ones, there were several who ended up quite interesting. Also, I don't remember reading Tomino saying his works have feminine sensibilities (at least up to where I am). Not that I feel obligated to defend the man. ^^" I'm afraid I might have misinterpreted the quote though, sorry about that. |
| Proud founder of The Official Anti-Ging Freecss Fan Club Join now! Kellhus said: GuusWayne said: there is a limit to the suspension of disbelief And it's the fan that did it. Not the smoking porn reading rubik cube genius rape ape with a magic boat. |
| Love how Joker Game triggers people over here. |
| Well some of my favorites made it, but still this is a shit list lol (having joker game on there makes you lose all credibility). Tiger and Bunny was a snooze fest, and it made the #1 spot lol Also seeing the separate male and female lists is odd. |
GokuJan 29, 2017 1:07 PM
| Yeahh Cardcaptor Sakura <3 Btw since the poll is still going, Can we also participate in this poll? Or this is only for Japanese people? |
| "To some, online is more important than seeing friends, eating and even breathing." <!--link--><a href="http://myanimelist.net/animelist/kuruta_tribe&sclick=1">  |
| joker game on the top 10 of this list puzzles me to no end i have no idea what kind of audience the show could appeal to and how can anyone end up watching the series and loving it i am not saying it sucks though i just kind of can not say one thing that stands out about the show evangelion is obviously still way too low in the list |
| I'm glad.. this list is so bad that not a single anime deserves to be there |
| I Havent Seen Most Of Them............... |
 |
| But where is Welcome to the NHK? I expected it to be on this list..... |
 |
| Jus find it funny that Utena is popular with males and the first Gundam with females... |
More topics from this board
» What are you watching right now??Nashiro18 - Apr 21 |
41 |
by Horshu
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » is anime an escapism for you?deg - Apr 21 |
29 |
by Horshu
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Anime Misandry ( 1 2 3 )ColourWheel - Apr 21 |
133 |
by APolygons2
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Legs or arms?Absurdo_N - 2 hours ago |
16 |
by mentalmondai
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Things you are jealous of in animeIpreferEcchi - Apr 20 |
47 |
by Horshu
»»
7 minutes ago |