| Many of you may shy away from hentai, but for those like me who fap proudly into beat of our own drums may know that most hentai ratings are substantially lower than anime ratings. But I dont believe that its simply due to hentai being shit. I believe the recently relieved and possibly heavily relaxed mal poster who is rating said hentai might make a more open minded and objective decision. Most hentai probably hovers from the 4-6 point range, whereas I bet most anime on mal hovers from 7.5->9.2. Are hentai fap masters a more objective crowd? |
| Figuratively screw hentai anime. Everybody knows doujinshi is where it's at. |
| ratings, objective. lol |
| if fapability is objective, then yes |
 |
| There's no such thing as objective ratings, just conflations of consensus opinion as fact. |
kingcity20 said: Oh for the love of -_- nvm gotta love MAL |
| Is there anything that proves that hentai raters are not simply using a different rating scale? I wouldn't even know what to rate by (story vs fappability) |
Yuschzhie said: Is there anything that proves that hentai raters are not simply using a different rating scale? I wouldn't even know what to rate by (story vs fappability) overall enjoyment id guess. |
| I heard people rate hentai for the story, not me. |
| Ratings can be objective, or at least intended to be objective. I dont see many people rating hentai 9.5 because "Really smart animes changed my life, would recommend" |
Valaskjalf said: ratings, objective. lol |
| How does one rate Hentai? I wouldn't even know where to start. Teach me your secrets. |
| Actually now that I think of it, hentai is quite amenable to objective ratings. I'm sure we could devise some sort of system based on how long it takes to do the deed while watching each hentai. |
fst said: Actually now that I think of it, hentai is quite amenable to objective ratings. I'm sure we could devise some sort of system based on how long it takes to do the deed while watching each hentai. yeah but thats subjective. everyones faps are different. |
| 1-5/10 That's how I rate porn (and it should be less). Also: mayukachan said: Valaskjalf said: ratings, objective. lol |
 |
Danpmss said: 1-5/10 That's how I rate porn (and it should be less). Also: mayukachan said: why cant porn be better than a 5? |
SolviteSekai said: Danpmss said: 1-5/10 That's how I rate porn (and it should be less). Also: why cant porn be better than a 5? Because is fucking porn, it's totally irrelevant to me and I use it for self-pleasure only. Do you have a better reason to fap other than orgasming? |
|
Danpmss said: SolviteSekai said: why cant porn be better than a 5? Because is fucking porn, it's totally irrelevant to me and I use it for self-pleasure only. Do you have a better reason to fap other than orgasming? that doesnt mean it can only be average at best lol |
| there's definitely plenty of hentai that deserve over a 5 |
  |
hybreezy said: Start throwing some titles thenthere's definitely plenty of hentai that deserve over a 5 |
| Oni ChiChi: Rebuild 8.39 I don't get it PoRo's moeblob character designs are a turn off for me. |
SolviteSekai said: Danpmss said: Because is fucking porn, it's totally irrelevant to me and I use it for self-pleasure only. Do you have a better reason to fap other than orgasming? that doesnt mean it can only be average at best lol Now that you mentioned, I have a few exceptions that I actually don't consider as hentai since they focused on story, messages and other elements (I treat them like I would treat good eroges). But no, I don't think something that only serves to make you jerk off even deserves to be rated seriously. It would be rather strange give a 10/10 (5/10 in my porn rating) to... Oni Chichi for example, while I have Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu with the same rating. So I basically did this: Just for "fun" and highly "entertaining"? It's like an enjoyable flat trainwreck or a stupid but funny ecchi series: 5/10 : Really Enjoyable Hentai Bellow this there are good, regular, bad and horrible hentai series. And then, I treat those as I would treat normal series on MAL. |
|
| Sometimes I pause my fap just so I can watch the story lol. |
FloatsBoats said: Sometimes I pause my fap just so I can watch the story lol. pausing your fap is probably bad for you. im not a dick doctor though. |
SolviteSekai said: FloatsBoats said: Sometimes I pause my fap just so I can watch the story lol. pausing your fap is probably bad for you. im not a dick doctor though. You never have hour long faps of stopping when ur close and then resetting... no... just me then? >.> |
FloatsBoats said: SolviteSekai said: pausing your fap is probably bad for you. im not a dick doctor though. You never have hour long faps of stopping when ur close and then resetting... no... just me then? >.> i did that when i was a teenager and one time my weiner got all inflated and it scarred me from it for life. |
SolviteSekai said: FloatsBoats said: You never have hour long faps of stopping when ur close and then resetting... no... just me then? >.> i did that when i was a teenager and one time my weiner got all inflated and it scarred me from it for life. o.O |
|
Danpmss said: SolviteSekai said: i did that when i was a teenager and one time my weiner got all inflated and it scarred me from it for life. o.O yeah it was terrifying. |
SolviteSekai said: FloatsBoats said: You never have hour long faps of stopping when ur close and then resetting... no... just me then? >.> i did that when i was a teenager and one time my weiner got all inflated and it scarred me from it for life. ROFL i'm glad that didn't happen to me. |
jayss said: hybreezy said: Start throwing some titles thenthere's definitely plenty of hentai that deserve over a 5 I'm not here to help you find hentai titles to fap to friend |
|
| http://myanimelist.net/anime/2135/Sora_no_Iro_Mizu_no_Iro top shelf hentai |
| this is objectively better than your favorite anime http://myanimelist.net/anime/21097/Oni_Chichi:_Rebuild |
Zeally said: this is objectively better than your favorite anime http://myanimelist.net/anime/21097/Oni_Chichi:_Rebuild i didnt really like oni chichi |
| Anything wrote by Fuuga is almost like a hentai masterpiece. |
|
| How I rate any kind of porn tits 10 no tits but ass 7 neither 0. |
 |
| If you fap ten times, then it's a ten. If you fap nine times, then it's a nine. Anything below five faps is shit, and anything above ten is ... Trust. |
 |
SolviteSekai said: Are hentai fap masters a more objective crowd? Maybe that's because fap masters don't like edgy hentai. |
| Definitely. People are gonna give bad hentai bad ratings and vice versa but when it comes to anime theres fanboys who will religiously give a 10 to everything that has to do with the anime no matter how bad/good it is. Doesnt work the same with hentai imo |
| hentai a. still suffers from sequel syndrome (sequel is higher rated than the original cause people who didn't like the original didn't check the sequel durr hurr), tho the only example i know of is Oni ChiChi Rebuild b. doesn't seem to attract users with top heavy lists (just like ovas and other short anime in general actually) but this poster gets it right: Valaskjalf said: ratings, objective. lol |
 |
| Most hentai are shittier in terms of characterization, production values, so on and so forth, making the viewing experience worse in turn, and thus are usually rated lower on average, at least in my opinion. There were some good ones with higher ratings, but they remain few and far between. For the record: H manga > H anime |
| Any rating decided upon with my second head probably shouldn't be worth much. >objective ratings< ^tf is this tho...? |
 |
Cyaegha said: Most hentai are shittier in terms of characterization, production values, so on and so forth, making the viewing experience worse in turn, and thus are usually rated lower on average, at least in my opinion. There were some good ones with higher ratings, but they remain few and far between. For the record: H manga > H anime implying that hentai anime is intended to have characterization. |
| All ratings are based on your personal enjoyment and thats why these are based on opinions and are subjective. It will be hard to have an objective rating, because then you really need a base of rating. You need criteria where you can look at and which you can compare with the anime media. Thats said it will always be a subjective thing. |
 |
| yes but the overall scope of the ratings can be more realistic. anyone who thinks an average rating of 7.5 on mal is "normal" is quite honestly an idiot. |
Aerodust said: Animation, Sex Scenes and Voice Acting is all that matters to make the review.How does one rate Hentai? I wouldn't even know where to start. Teach me your secrets. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Schwarzitgiest said: Aerodust said: Animation, Sex Scenes and Voice Acting is all that matters to make the review.How does one rate Hentai? I wouldn't even know where to start. Teach me your secrets. Some hentai has a bit of story thrown in. |
SolviteSekai said: Cyaegha said: Most hentai are shittier in terms of characterization, production values, so on and so forth, making the viewing experience worse in turn, and thus are usually rated lower on average, at least in my opinion. There were some good ones with higher ratings, but they remain few and far between. For the record: H manga > H anime implying that hentai anime is intended to have characterization. implying in the first place |
SolviteSekai said: Doesn't really matter for the most part. I'd get it if it were VNs but it isn't.Schwarzitgiest said: Animation, Sex Scenes and Voice Acting is all that matters to make the review. Some hentai has a bit of story thrown in. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Schwarzitgiest said: SolviteSekai said: Doesn't really matter for the most part. I'd get it if it were VNs but it isn't.Some hentai has a bit of story thrown in. I dont understand the difference. |
SolviteSekai said: VNs have more characterization and plot than hentai anime.Schwarzitgiest said: Doesn't really matter for the most part. I'd get it if it were VNs but it isn't. I dont understand the difference. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Schwarzitgiest said: SolviteSekai said: VNs have more characterization and plot than hentai anime.I dont understand the difference. Yeah adding an extra 60 hours does that for you. Are you aware that not all VNs have sex in them? And a lot of the ones that do barely have any in them? |
More topics from this board
» Is the anime community like the Roman Empire?thewiru - Yesterday |
17 |
by Lucifrost
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» Are Ganguro Girls (Black Gyarus) Finally Back in Anime ? ( 1 2 )tchitchouan - Aug 15 |
54 |
by ComeTail
»»
12 minutes ago |
|
» Why is Gundam possibly the only mecha series today that survived extinction? ( 1 2 )fallout45 - Sep 23 |
59 |
by JaniSIr
»»
14 minutes ago |
|
» water magician and silent witch continuationRealityChanges - Yesterday |
4 |
by Sheol01
»»
46 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » "when in rome do as the romans do" and anime touristsdeg - Yesterday |
49 |
by Centsicles
»»
47 minutes ago |