| what Toei and Deen were and what they've became..XD Top 10 Studios with the most number of titles: (maybe there are some mistakes) Sunrise: 48 Madhouse: 41 Toei: 32 Production I.G: 20 Nippon Animation: 15 Pierrot: 13 A-1/Deen: 12 Ghibli: 11 Brain's Base/Bones/Artland: 9 Gainax: 8 |
kanarazukarasuJun 22, 2016 2:07 AM
| Last time my AOTS was in MAL's top 3 was back in 2012, huh? |
| There is no such thing as shit taste. Only idiots who think everyone should have the same taste as they do. |
| Glad to see Haikyuu 2 and Bakemono no Ko as AOTS :') |
  |
| I've watched most of these except the movies lol. Wouldn't mind trying them out lol. |
| Gintama peaked in season 2 and has gone downhill ever since. The story has become tedious and repetitive |
| It is so dense. Every single image has so many things going on. |
Vicci said: Well it's pretty obvious... The AOTS listed are only based on MAL Ratings, which Haikyuu excels at with 8.94.Glad to see Haikyuu 2 and Bakemono no Ko as AOTS :') |
 Hisoka said: True love is finding someone whose demons play well with yours. Illumi said: . |
kuuderes_shadow said: >showa rakugo wasn't his aotsLast time my AOTS was in MAL's top 3 was back in 2012, huh? topkek |
 |
| So much Madhouse and so little Kyoani I approve of this list |
 Nico- said: Conversations with people pinging/quoting me to argue about some old post I wrote years ago will not be entertained@Comic_Sans oh no y arnt ppl dieing i need more ppl dieing rly gud plot avansement jus liek tokyo ghoul if erbudy dies amirite |
| One Piece Movie beat Inuyasha Kanketsu Hen? The fuck is this piece of shit taste. As expected of MAL~ |
| This proves once again that I should not watch stuff that's high rated on MAL. My taste differs a lot from the general taste :P |
| well, that list is the proof that most people in MAL or reddit like that kind of show. i wonder what would be in the list if this list was based on japanese viewer >_> and i wonder when people will respect each other opinion and taste..... OH! i forgot. this is internet. |
YizelTroJun 22, 2016 3:39 AM
 |
| Monogatari Series: Second Season's presence in the top makes me happy :) |
 |
| all that sailor moon in some of the 90s seasons pleases me :> |
 |
Tevens said: 1986 to 2006 would be full of Mecha like Gungdam and Eva..well, that list is the proof that most people in MAL or reddit like that kind of show. i wonder what would be in the list if this list was based on japanese viewer >_> 2006 to 2014 would be full of LN/VN adaptions like Suzumiya Haruhi, Bakemonogatari, Clannad and S;G... 2014 to present would be full of "cute girls doing something" anime like Love Live and GuP.. |
Illyricus said: Monogatari Series: Second Season's presence in the top makes me happy :) i was like 1/10 no harem/ecchi, not even any of the monogatari series, then i saw that and it bumped it to 1.5/10, cause still only one.... |
     |
malki said: Tevens said: 1986 to 2006 would be full of Mecha like Gungdam and Eva..well, that list is the proof that most people in MAL or reddit like that kind of show. i wonder what would be in the list if this list was based on japanese viewer >_> 2006 to 2014 would be full of LN/VN adaptions like Suzumiya Haruhi, Bakemonogatari, Clannad and S;G... 2014 to present would be full of "cute girls doing something" anime like Love Live and GuP.. well, i thought there wouldn't be much of cute girls tho. instead it would be something that would pissed MAL/reddidt people off like Erased, Charlotte, SAO, Guilty Crown, or sometype of anime like that xD |
|
Tevens said: I won't blame them for getting pissed by guilty crown tbh..XDmalki said: 1986 to 2006 would be full of Mecha like Gungdam and Eva.. 2006 to 2014 would be full of LN/VN adaptions like Suzumiya Haruhi, Bakemonogatari, Clannad and S;G... 2014 to present would be full of "cute girls doing something" anime like Love Live and GuP.. well, i thought there wouldn't be much of cute girls tho. instead it would be something that would pissed MAL/reddidt people off like Erased, Charlotte, SAO, Guilty Crown, or sometype of anime like that xD |
| No Charlotte for AOTS summer 2015? Fail m8, fail! |
 |
paraze said: I don't have any opinion on SEL or Erased, but yes. Majority wins even if you hate it. I didn't call anything 'worse'. I can only say that Erased did better on MAL.One said: Numbers don't lie. Well, at least this'll keep the '90s anime were so much better' people shut. I'm out. What? I'm not sure to understand... do you somehow think a 7.98 on MAL (Serial Experiments Lain) or a 8.32 (Evangelion) means it's worse than a 8.74 (Erased)? |
Hisoka said: True love is finding someone whose demons play well with yours. Illumi said: . |
| I have no idea how snk one of the biggest series of this current decade didn't get anime of the season in spring 2013, I'm going to guess that person that made this list simple like the steins gate movie more than snk, I'm pretty sure when the year ended most people agree that snk was anime of the year. OK never mind, I just realise that sao didn't make the list, even though it was the biggest thing in 2012, I guess this person only include series that he likes. |
| This could be a good reference for me for my next plan to watch, regardless it means nothing as people claim it since it is based on MAL. |
 Tobacco Causes Severe Health Problems, Smoke Moderately While Respecting Others. |
One said: paraze said: I don't have any opinion on SEL or Erased, but yes. Majority wins even if you hate it. I didn't call anything 'worse'. I can only say that Erased did better on MAL.What? I'm not sure to understand... do you somehow think a 7.98 on MAL (Serial Experiments Lain) or a 8.32 (Evangelion) means it's worse than a 8.74 (Erased)? Well, of course it did better on MAL. It's not a very surprising information, at all. People who think "90s anime were so much better" are very aware of that. Your point? keragamming said: I have no idea how snk one of the biggest series of this current decade didn't get anime of the season in spring 2013, I'm going to guess that person that made this list simple like the steins gate movie more than snk, I'm pretty sure when the year ended most people agree that snk was anime of the year. OK never mind, I just realise that sao didn't make the list, even though it was the biggest thing in 2012, I guess this person only include series that he likes. SAO is very controversial, despite being super popular, its score is pretty low: 7.92. And SNK simple has a lower score than S;G the movie. |
| Mix of TV and movies.. I wish that the list were separated. @j0x You can sort them by score for each season. He just compile them. http://myanimelist.net/anime/season/2015/spring |
| This salad is salty favored |
paraze said: Point is that objectively speaking, 90s anime are lower rated than the next couple of decade's anime.One said: I don't have any opinion on SEL or Erased, but yes. Majority wins even if you hate it. I didn't call anything 'worse'. I can only say that Erased did better on MAL. Well, of course it did better on MAL. It's not a very surprising information, at all. People who think "90s anime were so much better" are very aware of that. Your point? Also I dislike people who argue about how '90s anime were better'. If they're better, then simply stop watching this decade's anime. Same goes for vice versa, if you dislike 90s anime, then don't watch it. No one's forcing you. |
Hisoka said: True love is finding someone whose demons play well with yours. Illumi said: . |
Ecchi_Hater_9000 said: keragamming said: OK never mind, I just realise that sao didn't make the list, even though it was the biggest thing in 2012, I guess this person only include series that he likes. It's determined by score. Not his fault that SAO has a shit score... something rated by 550 000 is not like something rated by 50 000 |
 |
keragamming said: They're just sorted by score.... AoT is rated less than the S;G movie, hence he put S;G at #1.I have no idea how snk one of the biggest series of this current decade didn't get anime of the season in spring 2013, I'm going to guess that person that made this list simple like the steins gate movie more than snk, I'm pretty sure when the year ended most people agree that snk was anime of the year. OK never mind, I just realise that sao didn't make the list, even though it was the biggest thing in 2012, I guess this person only include series that he likes. |
Hisoka said: True love is finding someone whose demons play well with yours. Illumi said: . |
Diuturnus said: Gintama peaked in season 2 and has gone downhill ever since. The story has become tedious and repetitive Dunno what you are saying considering Gintama's latest season got the highest rating of all. How can something that doesn't have a strict plot become repetitive? What's special about Gintama is the plot of an episode can be about anything. |
 |
KaiserNazrin said: Diuturnus said: Gintama peaked in season 2 and has gone downhill ever since. The story has become tedious and repetitive Dunno what you are saying considering Gintama's latest season got the highest rating of all. How can something that doesn't have a strict plot become repetitive? What's special about Gintama is the plot of an episode can be about anything. The "serious arcs" are repetitive, the abused plot armor ruins everything. Also pretty much every villains have a change of heart when they are dying, i find this aspect a bit annoying. I enjoyed Gintama but it's a bit overrated imho, even the top anime movie is from Gintama. Seriously. |
Johnnyd3rpJun 22, 2016 5:45 AM
 |
| >Based on MAL scores >Fuck this shit.. *edit: A lot of these AOTS are legit but MAL scores are hardly even credible and barely indicate the quality of an anime.. |
| Motherf. Shigatsu is higher than Mushishi? No Shirobako? Yup MAL has shit taste. At least the 90s are semi consistent. |
| I saw it this morning and I was wondering... Is the highest rated anime in the season really the "AOTS" of MAL? Secondly, wouldn't these have "theoretically" been rated differently back in their own time? They're being judged as AOTS only based on their current Summer 2016 scores, not what their scores were at the time. |
Johnnyd3rp said: KaiserNazrin said: Dunno what you are saying considering Gintama's latest season got the highest rating of all. How can something that doesn't have a strict plot become repetitive? What's special about Gintama is the plot of an episode can be about anything. The "serious arcs" are repetitive, the abused plot armor ruins everything. Also pretty much every villains have a change of heart when they are dying, i find this aspect a bit annoying. I enjoyed Gintama but it's a bit overrated imho, even the top anime movie is from Gintama. Seriously. In what way are they repetitive? Every anime has plot armor, nothings new. Its not like an anime without plot armor is good. Perhaps because not all villains are pure evil and can't be reason with. Gintama is not battle shonen that only focus on crushing evil monsters. Anything that become remotely popular will be called overrated by others but it doesn't make it bad. Its just your opinion. |
|
KaiserNazrin said: That's subject to change over time. Somehow I don't see gintama circle's score being higher than the next season of gintama.Dunno what you are saying considering Gintama's latest season got the highest rating of all. KaiserNazrin said: Consider the perspective of someone who is actually using the list to get recommendations for new anime. In what way are they repetitive? The first time he sees Gintama as AOTS, he notes it down. The second time, he may begin to consider gintama as being quite popular. The third, he is tired of seeing gintama there again. Something unique and possibly interesting was denied a spot on the list because GINTAMA again. The next AOTS gintama is not significantly different from the previous, so it is tiresome to deal with repetitive representation of the same thing. |
| In what way is this supposed to be news exactly? Also you can find this yourself just by MAL's search engine or by using the seasonal chart and sort on score for as far back as it goes |
  |
nep-nep said: KaiserNazrin said: That's subject to change over time. Somehow I don't see gintama circle's score being higher than the next season of gintama.Dunno what you are saying considering Gintama's latest season got the highest rating of all. KaiserNazrin said: Consider the perspective of someone who is actually using the list to get recommendations for new anime. In what way are they repetitive? The first time he sees Gintama as AOTS, he notes it down. The second time, he may begin to consider gintama as being quite popular. The third, he is tired of seeing gintama there again. Something unique and possibly interesting was denied a spot on the list because GINTAMA again. The next AOTS gintama is not significantly different from the previous, so it is tiresome to deal with repetitive representation of the same thing. Its only like that because the dude never watch it and judge it based on nothing. You'll feel different when its your favorite anime.. There's a good reason why its popular and you can't accept it so it annoy you. By your logic, Mushishi is repetitive too. I never watch it though. |
|
KaiserNazrin said: Johnnyd3rp said: The "serious arcs" are repetitive, the abused plot armor ruins everything. Also pretty much every villains have a change of heart when they are dying, i find this aspect a bit annoying. I enjoyed Gintama but it's a bit overrated imho, even the top anime movie is from Gintama. Seriously. Anything that become remotely popular will be called overrated by others but it doesn't make it bad. Its just your opinion. I wrote "imho" so it's pretty obvious that it's an opinion. I could care less if an anime becomes popular, they don't give me money for every dvd of a favorite anime of mine that they sell. |
|
| >fullmetal alchemist not AOTS >kill la kill not even 3rd Good confirmation on how shit everyone's taste is. |
| every single one of my forum posts is dumb and invalid except for 1, I don't claim them it was a different person it was all fake |
| Only watched 20 of them, woops... :') |
Ecchi_Hater_9000 said: keragamming said: OK never mind, I just realise that sao didn't make the list, even though it was the biggest thing in 2012, I guess this person only include series that he likes. It's determined by score. Not his fault that SAO has a shit score... If that's case snk should be #1 since it was the highest rated series in 2013, obviously the score has drop since then, but we are talking about how it perform during the year 2013. I'm pretty sure sao was rated pretty highly in 2012. paraze said: One said: I don't have any opinion on SEL or Erased, but yes. Majority wins even if you hate it. I didn't call anything 'worse'. I can only say that Erased did better on MAL. Well, of course it did better on MAL. It's not a very surprising information, at all. People who think "90s anime were so much better" are very aware of that. Your point? keragamming said: I have no idea how snk one of the biggest series of this current decade didn't get anime of the season in spring 2013, I'm going to guess that person that made this list simple like the steins gate movie more than snk, I'm pretty sure when the year ended most people agree that snk was anime of the year. OK never mind, I just realise that sao didn't make the list, even though it was the biggest thing in 2012, I guess this person only include series that he likes. SAO is very controversial, despite being super popular, its score is pretty low: 7.92. And SNK simple has a lower score than S;G the movie. If that's case snk should be #1 since it was the highest rated series in 2013, obviously the score has drop since then, but we are talking about how it perform during the year 2013. So are you guys telling me that if snk was at below 8+ it wouldn't be on the list even though it got a lot of positive reception in that season/year?? One said: paraze said: Point is that objectively speaking, 90s anime are lower rated than the next couple of decade's anime.Well, of course it did better on MAL. It's not a very surprising information, at all. People who think "90s anime were so much better" are very aware of that. Your point? Also I dislike people who argue about how '90s anime were better'. If they're better, then simply stop watching this decade's anime. Same goes for vice versa, if you dislike 90s anime, then don't watch it. No one's forcing you. If that's case snk should be #1 since it was the highest rated series in 2013, obviously the score has drop since then, but we are talking about how it perform during the year 2013. Not to mention this as well. Good point. Isterio said: keragamming said: I have no idea how snk one of the biggest series of this current decade didn't get anime of the season in spring 2013, I'm going to guess that person that made this list simple like the steins gate movie more than snk, I'm pretty sure when the year ended most people agree that snk was anime of the year. OK never mind, I just realise that sao didn't make the list, even though it was the biggest thing in 2012, I guess this person only include series that he likes. This must be the dumbest thing you´ve ever posted, if you think for a second, you can immediately conclude that what you´ve said is wrong. It´s MAL score based, which is a questionable way to rate a toplist, nonetheless it´s true when someone applies the rules he used. You could rationally argue against the list, by pointing out how the Mal system in itself has obvious flaws. Differentiating audience sizes between the lists entries make a an "objective" rating impossible, the rating are further flawed because of the overall size of the Mal audiences compared to the worldwide audiences, who sing a different song. Instead you gave an unexplained rant about how your favorite Anime didn´t make it into the top lists. obviously, I'm bias here but snk was the most highly rated series and the most popular series in that season/year, so obviously he didn't consider that and just use his bias opinion to Steins gate movie over snk. But it seems he is ranking them by there current score, and not the score they were at during their airing, which I think should not be how he should've done it. I think I have a pretty good argument here. |
keragammingJun 22, 2016 7:07 AM
keragamming said: You acted like you knew nothing and started questioning the way the list was sorted, so everyone gave you an answer...If that's case snk should be #1 since it was the highest rated series in 2013, obviously the score has drop since then, but we are talking about how it perform during the year 2013. |
Hisoka said: True love is finding someone whose demons play well with yours. Illumi said: . |
Isterio said: keragamming said: obviously, I'm bias here but snk was the most highly rated series nad the most popular series in that season/year, so obviously he didn't consider that and just use his bias opinion to Steins gate movie over snk. But it seems he is ranking them by there current score, and not the score they were at during their airing, which I think should be how he should've done it. You still sound like a little kid whose mad that his football team lost in a tournament. Face reality, your team may be good, but there are better ones out there at the momment of judgement. If we use your loigc for this argument Naruto used to be the greatest shit from 2001-2012. Also if I go even farther with your argument I can easily say that Dragon Ball Z is the top Anime of all time because casuals No Anime has a fanbase as big and dedicated among hardcore fanboys and casuals alike as DBZ. Everything else loses by default and there are numbers out there that proof this. Aka worldwide sales that shit on everything outside of Japan where it merely loses to One Piece. Need more prove? The only mangaka that receives higher regards than Akira Toriyama is Osamu Tezuka, the guy who literally invented Anime. -_- I already admit that I'm bias towards snk, but I have a good point here, the difference between those series and snk is that snk was the highest anime in the spring 2013 on mal, you said he based the score of mal, yes? my argument is that he should have use the scores that the series got during its airing, and not 3-4 years after. that's all. smh One said: keragamming said: You acted like you knew nothing and started questioning the way the list was sorted, so everyone gave you an answer...If that's case snk should be #1 since it was the highest rated series in 2013, obviously the score has drop since then, but we are talking about how it perform during the year 2013. I looked at the list and made my conclusion off the list, I didn't see sao on the list for 2012, and that's what made me make that conclusion. I didn't go on reddit, so I didn't know he was using mal score. Anyways my point still stands that he should rank the series by the scores they had during that year/season to get a better representation of what was considered anime of the season during those times. So are you telling me 10 years later a lot of series will leave the list because their current scores have drop? So basically future anime fans would not be able to know what was considered anime of the season then, it will be changing all the time. |
keragammingJun 22, 2016 7:28 AM
More topics from this board
» 🍂 Fall 2025: OP/ ED of the Season ( 1 2 3 )nirererin - Jan 14 |
145 |
by Ricchan__
»»
39 minutes ago |
|
» Upcoming Dubbed Anime ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kenny_Stryker - Dec 17, 2017 |
4191 |
by anime-prime
»»
42 minutes ago |
|
» Am I evil for not liking mecha? ( 1 2 )Kiyomice - Jan 20 |
71 |
by Guilmon1
»»
44 minutes ago |
|
» Do you ever look forward to the possibility of fanservice? Do you save screenshots?fallout45 - 4 hours ago |
7 |
by Dogsmic
»»
50 minutes ago |
|
» Have fanbases ever been so diverse in any other time in history?thewiru - 3 hours ago |
5 |
by Aprilycan
»»
1 hour ago |