Forum Settings
Forums

Why all-male sports anime are not yaoi, and the discussion of it.

New
Pages (5) « 1 2 [3] 4 5 »
Oct 8, 2016 4:44 AM

Offline
Feb 2013
5532
Tsukkimaru said:
JustALEX said:
Does this mean K-ON is a yuri anime?

No, but there ARE undertones and many fans are OK with that.


The thing is the hypocrisy, a lot of male fans will be completely happy and onboard with all-female casts and 'yuri bait', but as soon as the gender is reversed it's 'gross' and they won't touch it with a ten foot pole. Although, I'm not saying everyone is like this, I've seen quite a few male anime fans that have seen things like Free! Or are watching Yuri on Ice this season.


This. And also you wont see female acting like "ew this is so lesbian iw wont watch it because Im straight female and I dont like lesbian stuff" actually I know many straight female friends who likes Love Live and are all okay with the Yuri ships.

Oct 8, 2016 4:45 AM

Offline
Sep 2010
3230
the replies on this thread trigger me so much

It's funny how most people that complains about manservice in this thread love fanservice. remember that not all anime are made to suit your tastes, the industry has to adapt to all the audiences not jsut the male population.

Plus has it was shown in Osomatsu-san sales, the fujoshi are the ones that are spending more in anime merchandising with hints of shounen ai, so ofcourse the industry is starting to produce more anime with fujobait. If you fell unconfortable with it there's still plenty of ecchi and shounen anime for you to see this season (ajin, keijo, okusama seitokaichou, touken ranbu)



"Be who you are and say what you mean, because those who mind don't matter, and those who matter don't mind" - Dr. Seuss
Oct 8, 2016 4:46 AM

Offline
Sep 2012
3599
@Pullman

I used a pic from YoI because that was the main anime in the discussion.I also agree about Haikyuu and Kuroko.

Also @Xykko

sasalx said:
Gaelenmyr said:
I swear we didn't have these discussions when 2000s were full of ecchi/yuribait/moe shows. Now it is balanced. Want to watch manservice anime? Or you prefer ecchi? Now you have both options.

Your insecurities are showing, straight guys. Let people enjoy their anime. There are still moe/ecchi fanservice anime for you every season. Stop complaining like a little, insecure child.


Like I said in many many many many many times.Watching them is fine ofc.You can watch whatever you want.Balance is also good.Problem is just accepting the genre.Even the watchers don't want to accept that and that's the main problem.
Oct 8, 2016 4:48 AM

Offline
Dec 2015
7395
Yet people rarely ever point out the strong homo erotic undertones in Berserk and JoJo's Bizarre Adventure.
Oct 8, 2016 4:50 AM

Offline
Feb 2010
34616
sasalx said:
@Pullman

I used a pic from YoI because that was the main anime in the discussion.I also agree about Haikyuu and Kuroko.

Also @Xykko

sasalx said:


Like I said in many many many many many times.Watching them is fine ofc.You can watch whatever you want.Balance is also good.Problem is just accepting the genre.Even the watchers don't want to accept that and that's the main problem.


You still haven't replied to my edit:

Pullman said:

Or to put it differently, imagine your favorite anime having a few spread out scenes that could be seen as gay undertones (just that, nothing official) but nothing else changes in the remaining 99,9999% of the anime. Would that make that show worth bashing, ignoring, calling fujoshit and avoiding it like the plague? Because that's the behaviour I see all the time. Often from the same people who will defend extremely fanservice-heavy ecchi shows who dedicate much, much more time to their fanservice, because these shows 'have much more to offer than just their ecchi'. But obviously a show with 2 seconds of gay undertones per episode is absolutely unwatchable for any self-respecting, heterosexual male. That leap of logic is just baffling to me.


If someone literally only watches anime for the male-targeted fanservice and ecchi then sure, anything devoid of that is not of interest to them. But that's not even limited to shows with 'gay undertones' if that's the case. Anyone who can also appreciate good characters, development, plot, drama, comedy, whatever should not be prone to avoid a show like the plague just because of 2 seconds of 'undertones' in every other episode. Just like 2 seconds of ecchi each episode shouldn't turn anyone away as long as the rest of the show is good.
AlcoholicideOct 8, 2016 4:56 AM
I probably regret this post by now.
Oct 8, 2016 4:51 AM
Offline
Apr 2013
12542
Can someone please tell me what is wrong with someone not liking something due to x reasons?
Oct 8, 2016 4:53 AM

Offline
Sep 2010
3230
Bobby2Hands said:
Yet people rarely ever point out the strong homo erotic undertones in Berserk and JoJo's Bizarre Adventure.


come on don't you think Avdol x Polnareff or the Caesar x Joseph otp are the best thing ever?

And lets not forget about the flamboyant/sexual dubious characters in Hokuto no Ken. Like at least 2 of the villains ahve the hots for kenshiro, but no one ever talks about that



"Be who you are and say what you mean, because those who mind don't matter, and those who matter don't mind" - Dr. Seuss
Oct 8, 2016 4:55 AM

Offline
Apr 2011
1453
worldeditor11 said:
Can someone please tell me what is wrong with someone not liking something due to x reasons?

Is it possible to dislike the supposed homoerotic content in these anime, while they do not actually display any? Question yourself that. These titles are entirely void of homosexual romance or sexual relationships — and as mentioned earlier, it is concocted by fans and anti-fans themselves that these series portray shounen ai or yaoi. The amount of homosexual fan-art and fan-fiction on characters whose sexual orientation is straight or not otherwise defined, is what inspires thoughts of the general dislike and these 'reasons', while they are not actually present in the anime itself.

» "Mercy is for losers..." «

⍏⍏⍏⍏⍏

inspector @ MAL's anime watching challenge
Oct 8, 2016 4:57 AM

Offline
Feb 2016
617
worldeditor11 said:
JustALEX said:


OK, that is a very fair and good point.

Maybe Asians are closer?

I don't know.


No, they are not.

Now you know.

Jesus Christ this thread.

Asians aren't even close between male and female to be close between male and male . ( Also putting the whole BL manga aside , japan like other asain country aren't open minded about the whole gay thing , at least not the same in the west . Sex itself is a tabboo there )
"This is my father's crime against me, which I myself committed against none" Al-ma'arri
Oct 8, 2016 4:57 AM

Offline
May 2015
4449
worldeditor11 said:
Can someone please tell me what is wrong with someone not liking something due to x reasons?
I don't think it is a problem avoiding (like I do for free and yuri on ice) or disliking the anime for the undertones but calling them Yaoi when they are not is simply a lie.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Oct 8, 2016 4:58 AM

Offline
Oct 2015
336
worldeditor11 said:
Can someone please tell me what is wrong with someone not liking something due to x reasons?


It's a very debatable topic. But, I think one of the main reasons is if your not liking something that 'represents' an irl group of people or community. To put it in context, if I said I don't like X anime because it's horror or SoL then that doesn't really affect or hurt anybody, and if it does it's not to a massive extent. However, if I said I don't like X anime because it's got a black character or has a canon gay/lesbian character then that would be seen as bigoted, since it means I perhaps don't see these people as equal or having a 'right' to be represented, if that makes sense?
Oct 8, 2016 5:00 AM

Offline
Sep 2012
3599
@Pullman

Didn't saw that because of new page sorry.

First of all I never said something with gay elements is "absolutely unwatchable for any self-respecting, heterosexual male."I am looking for acceptance.I also stated that that was just an example and I was talking about spoilers.

Now for your question.We have a good example for this.Shokugeki no Souma.This show have fanservice for both males and females.I absolutely love this show.Having two different fanservice also adds diversity.I am not enjoying the female fanservice moments but they are not bothers me either.So even if it my favorite anime or not I don think I will "bash, ignore, callfujoshit and avoid it like the plague."

I hope this will satisfy you about my opinions on this matter.
Oct 8, 2016 5:00 AM

Offline
Feb 2010
34616
Mlala said:

Gay refers to homosexual relationships and there isn't any of them in Free!. They're all friends at most. It's fans that interpret their interactions as romantic or sexual sometimes. As for Yuri!!! on Ice, it's also devoid of homosexual relationships so far. It's not gay.


And that's part of what annoys me about this topic. Just because something can be seen as having gay undertones doesn't mean it has to be seen that way. But the people in this thread always treat it like it's a fact and if you don't agree they get hostile/condescending. Just like obnoxious fujoshi when you don't agree that their favorite pairing is actually not confirmed to be gay in any way. Undertones are just that, open to interpretation if you want to see things that way, but they are far from being actual gayness. Their gayness lies in the eyes of the viewer.
I probably regret this post by now.
Oct 8, 2016 5:01 AM

Offline
Aug 2015
3777
They might not be Yaoi, but almost of them has some gay undertones...

Not that I care anyway.., I (we) just don't like Sports anime in general.
Oct 8, 2016 5:02 AM

Offline
May 2015
4449
Bobby2Hands said:
Yet people rarely ever point out the strong homo erotic undertones in Berserk and JoJo's Bizarre Adventure.
In Berserk Griffith does have an ambiguous relationship with Guts but it is clear that for Guts it is only friendship/respect.

Many muscular males being fabulous are easy material for yaoi fanfics but I still didn't got those gay undertones in the source material. However the author like to draw them in dubious positions on the covers or other pages that are not part of the story thus contributing to the fanfics.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Oct 8, 2016 5:05 AM

Offline
Feb 2010
34616
sasalx said:
@Pullman

Didn't saw that because of new page sorry.

First of all I never said something with gay elements is "absolutely unwatchable for any self-respecting, heterosexual male."I am looking for acceptance.I also stated that that was just an example and I was talking about spoilers.

Now for your question.We have a good example for this.Shokugeki no Souma.This show have fanservice for both males and females.I absolutely love this show.Having two different fanservice also adds diversity.I am not enjoying the female fanservice moments but they are not bothers me either.So even if it my favorite anime or not I don think I will "bash, ignore, callfujoshit and avoid it like the plague."

I hope this will satisfy you about my opinions on this matter.


Other people (even in this thread) will do just that tho. It seems your main point in this thread is about the undertones in Yuri on Ice (I still don't know if you hate the show because of it or if you are just arguing for the sake of it) so my initial post probably doesn't even apply to you since I was mostly talking about other shows and the kind of people who do 'bash, ignore, call fujoshit and avoid them like the plague' just based on a few seconds of barely existing undertones.
I probably regret this post by now.
Oct 8, 2016 5:07 AM

Offline
Nov 2012
9736
IIT JustAlex and tragedydesu trying to justify their hackneyed homophobia.
Oct 8, 2016 5:11 AM

Offline
Sep 2012
3599
@Pullman

I don't hate YoI and I don't think I will hate a show because of it's genre or "undertones."

Technically I am just saying because of those I think this has gay elements.Just that.Personally I don't watch sport animes that much.So I am not a fan or hater.I just have one point and talking about that.
Oct 8, 2016 5:14 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
4624
it seems if i dont like shounen ai stuff im "homophobic" and "bigot"

im not talking about sport anime, but anime with shounen ai vibe like yuri on ice and free

please throw more buzzword

lol

the current year is so strange

i'm glad at least it's only happening in western society
CrossAnge

Hey guys check my profile for current airing season anime recommendation (guaranteed best taste)
Oct 8, 2016 5:24 AM

Offline
Mar 2012
8740
These type of anime themselves are not shounen-ai (let alone yaoi) but even the tiniest hint of two boys getting along is good enough to trigger the fujos' rainbow colored imagination and start with the shipping by writing fanfics, making fanart, doujinshis etc. and start spreading it; sometimes even adding their own interpretations saying that the character's are actually intended to be gay you just have to read between the lines as to what the creators actually intended thus labeling their ship as "canon". Things will only get worse if the fan-translation group responsible for that series is made up of fujos because normal people usually blindly believe them thinking they make the best interpretations because they know Japanese. If others watch it while it's still ongoing well and good. For the normal viewers who find the series later, they might have already seen pics with misleading info or fanart or extracts from fanfics or simply fujos fangirling over how "canon" their ship is shared somewhere or the other and end up thinking that it's gay without even ever trying it.

On the other hand, most male viewers would be put off just seeing the entire male cast, they just prefer more females or at least some badass action or OP MCs which such series generally lack.

And once someone's mind is set on a certain opinion it's not very easy to change that.

I think most people don't even know what the term "gay" even means, they'll just label anyone gay even if they just talk to another guy. Looks like there's this misconception that all anime have romance and it's about the MC falling in love with someone irrespective of the genre or themes thus leading them to think that the lack of a prominent lead female implies that the guys are gay.

Believe me though, it doesn't happen with just sports anime but even with any other anime which has mostly male characters.
Oct 8, 2016 5:32 AM

Offline
Aug 2015
2468
Don't mind me,i'm just here to read these glorious post.
Oct 8, 2016 5:33 AM

Offline
Jun 2016
38
You overestimate the male gender intellect LOL. It's easier than you think. Most of these anime shows a smart/handsome/athletic kind of guy, what they are not so watching them would be frustrating rather than an enjoyment.
Selecta91Jan 27, 2017 12:33 PM
Oct 8, 2016 5:47 AM

Offline
Aug 2014
1425
Lestat- said:
3. You are suffering from some sort of distorted body image of yourself and fear that others will laugh at your naked self.


yeah, it's not like i was actually bullied and laughed at in grade and high school bc of my body. people didn't laugh at me and constantly pointed out how i looked bad and still do so when they see pictures of me ("boy you sure were fat and ugly"). sure

Either way, what are you expecting from western audiences? Men are literally raised into avoiding physical contact with other males and expressing as few as possible emotion. We're being raised by a generation who thought homosexuality was sin, and end up relating the both of them.
Personally I just don't have any interest in sports anime and the only thing I ever see about these anime are tumblrs headcannoning everyone as gay, so like how am I not supposed to see gay undertones?

What's wrong with seeing gay undertones either way, if the characters don't have explicitly stated sexualities? Are we supposed to default everything as straight then?
Oct 8, 2016 6:18 AM

Offline
Mar 2016
1075
I'm so sick of this discussion already. Seriously. Even IF, and I mean IF a sports anime shows some kind of "gayish undertone", what's the problem with that? Why does it seem so impossible to reach at least a little bit of tolerance for storytelling like that? Why is it canon, that Free! "must be yaoi" because it features a few fanservice shots (the heaviest was btw. one of totally unrelated bodies recognized by the female trainer, remember?)? Yeah, it must be hypergay, seeing all those trained bodys in their slinky swimsuits. Oh my. For real, get over it or call every ecchi you see from now on the equivalent of yuri. This onesided mentality of the discussion really sickens me.

It is totally okay, if your attitude makes it impossible to deal with those things or you're simply not interested in watching sports anime in general. But then please, stop calling that stuff gay, just because it features sportscomrades who get along really well. That's the mentality of sports.
Or get another term for gay, because that word get's so washed, like Namae_nashi wrote.
Oct 8, 2016 6:21 AM

Offline
Feb 2013
17583
this thread is best visualised as an all male gay sports team

where teh sport is internet arguing
Oct 8, 2016 6:21 AM
Offline
Apr 2013
12542
Lestat- said:

Is it possible to dislike the supposed homoerotic content in these anime, while they do not actually display any?


Yes. Simply because the subject of liking or disliking is subjective to the person.

Lestat- said:

Question yourself that.


It seems that our roles are reversed.

Lestat- said:

These titles are entirely void of homosexual romance or sexual relationships — and as mentioned earlier, it is concocted by fans and anti-fans themselves that these series portray shounen ai or yaoi.


Might be true.

Lestat- said:

The amount of homosexual fan-art and fan-fiction on characters whose sexual orientation is straight or not otherwise defined, is what inspires thoughts of the general dislike and these 'reasons', while they are not actually present in the anime itself.


A plausible theory but suffers from too many assumptions to treat this theory more valid than say, K-On is not a yuri anime. Or Free is not a gay anime either. Please read my response below to zal on what I was trying to say by posting the question earlier.

zal said:
I don't think it is a problem avoiding (like I do for free and yuri on ice) or disliking the anime for the undertones but calling them Yaoi when they are not is simply a lie.


Now, calling someone justifying a reason of his preferences as lying is disrespectful and bigoted don't you think? Is like calling me a liar when I don't like Pepsi just because it's a poor man's version of Coca-Cola. If telling my true feelings why my preferences are so as straight up dishonest, then I am lying to myself for telling people otherwise.

I know what OP, you and proponents of his trying to convey; It is just that you guys are too zealous in your "movement" that it even turn me off. I mean, you guys are arguing semantics of yaoi, yuri, their undertones and what have you when nobody are even referring to them context wise. And bashing people for disliking something due to reasons that you guys think unreasonable which is just plain silly and uncomfortably opinionated to an extent.

"People don't like Yuri on Ice or Free because they are gay/yaoi/fujoshi anime."

The context here is NOT these people avoiding the stated anime because they do have physical homoerotic content, IT IS BECAUSE of the anime itself having gay undertones or any characteristics however small that may be, to be translated as homo undertones for these people. Confusing isn't it! But most of the time, that's exactly what they actually meant. It is a hyperbole. Just like someone says he will kill his best friend for stealing his taco bell. Did he actually mean it? Of course not. But some do, only they are the outliers.

Do you see what I am trying to say here? There are people in this very thread saying the same thing but somehow, their thoughts don't really get through. Then, some of you might say that they are being serious which means they don't like the anime because IT IS GAY. Sure, you could prove these group of people as wrong but to what end? He still will continue to label these shows as gay and the majority won't even bat an eyelid. Because the meaning of gay and yaoi encompasses their undertones as well in anime culture. So much so that people sort of understand what the reason is, although the usage of the term is incorrect as you and others have stated earlier. But they are not alone. The usage of otaku is another term that most people seem confused about its intended meaning. But most people will make it out the true implications just be looking at the context where the word is used, not just the word alone.

Of course, educating someone about something is a noble cause by itself. I have no problem with that. I do however have a problem when some of you in here start labeling people as homophobic, fujoshits, bigots or whatever negative labels you have under your keyboard just because of someone reasoning a personal preference. Preference as you know, is subjective! Not objective. Come on guys, it is 2016, why we differing opinions still?

Tsukkimaru said:

It's a very debatable topic. But, I think one of the main reasons is if your not liking something that 'represents' an irl group of people or community. To put it in context, if I said I don't like X anime because it's horror or SoL then that doesn't really affect or hurt anybody, and if it does it's not to a massive extent. However, if I said I don't like X anime because it's got a black character or has a canon gay/lesbian character then that would be seen as bigoted, since it means I perhaps don't see these people as equal or having a 'right' to be represented, if that makes sense?


Correct me if I am wrong, but doesn't that mean this problem only exists because of SJWs making a mountain out of a molehill?
Oct 8, 2016 6:30 AM

Offline
Aug 2014
1425
Schlopsi said:
I'm so sick of this discussion already. Seriously. Even IF, and I mean IF a sports anime shows some kind of "gayish undertone", what's the problem with that? Why does it seem so impossible to reach at least a little bit of tolerance for storytelling like that? Why is it canon, that Free! "must be yaoi" because it features a few fanservice shots (the heaviest was btw. one of totally unrelated bodies recognized by the female trainer, remember?)? Yeah, it must be hypergay, seeing all those trained bodys in their slinky swimsuits. Oh my. For real, get over it or call every ecchi you see from now on the equivalent of yuri. This onesided mentality of the discussion really sickens me.

It is totally okay, if your attitude makes it impossible to deal with those things or you're simply not interested in watching sports anime in general. But then please, stop calling that stuff gay, just because it features sportscomrades who get along really well. That's the mentality of sports.
Or get another term for gay, because that word get's so washed, like Namae_nashi wrote.


if you were sick of this thread you wouldn't comment something that you obviously consider the opposing side. Because the only possible follow-up to that is either someone arguing against you, or everyone ignoring you.

Ecchi is either aggressively heterosexual (harems, mostly) or has explicit yuri undertones or even lesbian characters, so that's a pretty bad comparison.

Have these characters ever said "I am 100% straight"? If not I have all right to call them gay.
Oct 8, 2016 6:44 AM

Offline
Jun 2008
25970
Ok, I tried to be nice and I personally feel I gave good responces, but it all boils down to this...

I don't want to watch any anime featuring gay male characters or implied homosexuality , or yaoi undertones like "Free" or "Yuri on Ice" or whatever...

I can't relate to that, I don't find the topic enjoyable or entertaining.

NO, I am not a bigot or homophobe.

A REAL homophobe would literally go out of his way to bash these shows and anyone that likes them.....they would also want this type of anime banned or whatever.

I think it's great we have anime that suit so many tastes, the more people watch anime the better.

Just don't bring your gay shit near me.




(hopefully, your sense of humor is not gone, seriously, relax.)
Oct 8, 2016 6:45 AM

Offline
Mar 2016
1075
demonskul777 said:

Ecchi is either aggressively heterosexual (harems, mostly) or has explicit yuri undertones or even lesbian characters, so that's a pretty bad comparison.

Well, touché. It was rather considered to be used as an comparison regarding fanshots, etc. You can use SoL stuff instead, like K-On! which would feature the same "lesbian undertones" (storytellingwise) Oh my... and no ones get het up about it. Wonder why? Because it's girls?

Have these characters ever said "I am 100% straight"? If not I have all right to call them gay.


Thanks, that's the most childish answer I could find on this thread. (Read your second post seconds later, I still have some humour left though ;) )
Oct 8, 2016 6:48 AM
Offline
Apr 2013
12542
JustALEX said:
Ok, I tried to be nice and I personally feel I gave good responces, but it all boils down to this...

I don't want to watch any anime featuring gay male characters or implied homosexuality , or yaoi undertones like "Free" or "Yuri on Ice" or whatever...

I can't relate to that, I don't find the topic enjoyable or entertaining.

NO, I am not a bigot or homophobe.

A REAL homophobe would literally go out of his way to bash these shows and anyone that likes them.....they would also want this type of anime banned or whatever.

I think it's great we have anime that suit so many tastes, the more people watch anime the better.

Just don't bring your gay shit near me.




(hopefully, your sense of humor is not gone, seriously, relax.)
You should really watch Yuri on Ice though as the animation is exquisitely beautiful.
Oct 8, 2016 6:57 AM

Offline
Jul 2015
6206
JustALEX said:
Ok, I tried to be nice and I personally feel I gave good responces, but it all boils down to this...

I don't want to watch any anime featuring gay male characters or implied homosexuality , or yaoi undertones like "Free" or "Yuri on Ice" or whatever...

I can't relate to that, I don't find the topic enjoyable or entertaining.

NO, I am not a bigot or homophobe.

A REAL homophobe would literally go out of his way to bash these shows and anyone that likes them.....they would also want this type of anime banned or whatever.

I think it's great we have anime that suit so many tastes, the more people watch anime the better.

Just don't bring your gay shit near me.




(hopefully, your sense of humor is not gone, seriously, relax.)
Well said
The same for me I just can't stand that kind of anime
Oct 8, 2016 7:00 AM

Offline
Apr 2013
7288
They aren't.

But Fujoshi power ain't gonna let that shit slide.

Don't underestimate the most powerful fanbase in the fandom.
Oct 8, 2016 7:07 AM

Offline
Aug 2014
1425
Schlopsi said:

Have these characters ever said "I am 100% straight"? If not I have all right to call them gay.


Thanks, that's the most childish answer I could find on this thread. (Read your second post seconds later, I still have some humour left though ;) )


My second post? Are you confusing me with someone else, because I only posted twice and the thing you replied to was my second post

It's meant ironically, I just mean to say that people considering characters gay have all right to. I feel like defaulting everyone to heterosexual and telling people "no it's not gay, they never said they were" is the exact same as what I did there.
Not to say that you did that, but those are the usual arguments as to why things are not gay.
Oct 8, 2016 7:11 AM

Offline
May 2015
4449
worldeditor11 said:
zal said:
I don't think it is a problem avoiding (like I do for free and yuri on ice) or disliking the anime for the undertones but calling them Yaoi when they are not is simply a lie.


Now, calling someone justifying a reason of his preferences as lying is disrespectful and bigoted don't you think? Is like calling me a liar when I don't like Pepsi just because it's a poor man's version of Coca-Cola. If telling my true feelings why my preferences are so as straight up dishonest, then I am lying to myself for telling people otherwise.
You misunderstood me. I said that not liking a show for being fujoshi bait is fine, I don't like them myself. I am avoiding free and this new yuri on ice because I am mostly sure I won't like it.
What I said is that those shows are NOT yaoi or at least not yet. Calling it yaoi is a lie because they are not.
It's like saying moe is shit because it's paedophilia. I might even feel like some of them have paedophile undertones but it is not paedophilia. Saying it is it's a lie.

I know what OP, you and proponents of his trying to convey; It is just that you guys are too zealous in your "movement" that it even turn me off. I mean, you guys are arguing semantics of yaoi, yuri, their undertones and what have you when nobody are even referring to them context wise. And bashing people for disliking something due to reasons that you guys think unreasonable which is just plain silly and uncomfortably opinionated to an extent.
I didn't bash anyone not liking fujoshi bait/sport anime nor I remember anyone doing it here in this thread.

"People don't like Yuri on Ice or Free because they are gay/yaoi/fujoshi anime."

The context here is NOT these people avoiding the stated anime because they do have physical homoerotic content, IT IS BECAUSE of the anime itself having gay undertones or any characteristics however small that may be, to be translated as homo undertones for these people. Confusing isn't it! But most of the time, that's exactly what they actually meant. It is a hyperbole. Just like someone says he will kill his best friend for stealing his taco bell. Did he actually mean it? Of course not. But some do, only they are the outliers.
But the others and me are referring to the people that go out of their way in bashing fujoshi bait anime like DoctorSexy whom is a huge fan of ecchi which is almost the same as fujoshi bait anime therefore being quite the hypocrite. Or to the people that comment in the forum of said anime just to insult people that like the show. Or like this guy from another thread.
aratinga said:
The real problem this season has is the number of obnoxious fujobait trash.


Do you see what I am trying to say here? There are people in this very thread saying the same thing but somehow, their thoughts don't really get through. Then, some of you might say that they are being serious which means they don't like the anime because IT IS GAY. Sure, you could prove these group of people as wrong but to what end? He still will continue to label these shows as gay and the majority won't even bat an eyelid. Because the meaning of gay and yaoi encompasses their undertones as well in anime culture. So much so that people sort of understand what the reason is, although the usage of the term is incorrect as you and others have stated earlier. But they are not alone. The usage of otaku is another term that most people seem confused about its intended meaning. But most people will make it out the true implications just be looking at the context where the word is used, not just the word alone.
The thing is that IT IS NOT GAY unless there's a gay relationship between two or more characters. Having manservice is not gay nor showing a more feminine friendship between the characters. It might not be relatable nor likeable for some people but it doesn't make it gay.

Moreover it seems that most people calling everything gay have never went to a football/rugby/volleyball/swimming club/gym/course because in the long run there are situations that from outside might be seen as strange but they are normal and not gay for them. Footballers or trainers slap other mens butt from time to time just use google search. They do shower in the same large shower-room. They do hug each other. Some people, especially from less easy going countries like germany or those that never had this kind of experience might not understand it.
Calling fujoshi bait anime gay or yaoi is quite ignorant.

Of course, educating someone about something is a noble cause by itself. I have no problem with that. I do however have a problem when some of you in here start labeling people as homophobic, fujoshits, bigots or whatever negative labels you have under your keyboard just because of someone reasoning a personal preference. Preference as you know, is subjective! Not objective. Come on guys, it is 2016, why we differing opinions still?
I didn't label anyone like that or at least I tried to. I don't enjoy the fujoshi bait but there are shows that don't even have it but still get called like that. It is not a matter of preference but of logic.
I am not trying to change anyone's opinion but rather show them the difference between what they are thinking and what they are saying.
zalOct 8, 2016 7:27 AM
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Oct 8, 2016 7:15 AM
Offline
Aug 2015
807
JustALEX said:
Ok, I tried to be nice and I personally feel I gave good responces, but it all boils down to this...

I don't want to watch any anime featuring gay male characters or implied homosexuality , or yaoi undertones like "Free" or "Yuri on Ice" or whatever...

I can't relate to that, I don't find the topic enjoyable or entertaining.

NO, I am not a bigot or homophobe.

A REAL homophobe would literally go out of his way to bash these shows and anyone that likes them.....they would also want this type of anime banned or whatever.

I think it's great we have anime that suit so many tastes, the more people watch anime the better.

Just don't bring your gay shit near me.




(hopefully, your sense of humor is not gone, seriously, relax.)


Well said
I agree I don't care if you like that type of show
As long as you keep your creepyness to your self and away from me I don't really care
DoctorSexyOct 8, 2016 7:29 AM
Oct 8, 2016 7:20 AM

Offline
May 2016
3008
Whatever, I just hate that people also call Haikyuu fujobait when there's NO sign of bait in it whatsoever... On the contrary, most of the cast just keep worshiping girls whenever they see one and there's a obvious ship between the MC and a girl since the second season...
You are not your body, you are your brain, the "self" that emerges from within it.
Oct 8, 2016 7:24 AM

Offline
Jun 2008
25970
HyperL said:
Whatever, I just hate that people also call Haikyuu fujobait when there's NO sign of bait in it whatsoever... On the contrary, most of the cast just keep worshiping girls whenever they see one and there's a obvious ship between the MC and a girl since the second season...

I mean....it technically IS fujobait, right?

There is a good amount of fujoshis that watch Haikyuu....this is evident by the massive amount of fanart and doujins that come out that is almost exclusively yaoi in nature.

I've never seen the anime, so all jokes aside, I really don't know, don't really care either...

But you can't deny facts.
Oct 8, 2016 7:31 AM

Offline
May 2015
4449
JustALEX said:
HyperL said:
Whatever, I just hate that people also call Haikyuu fujobait when there's NO sign of bait in it whatsoever... On the contrary, most of the cast just keep worshiping girls whenever they see one and there's a obvious ship between the MC and a girl since the second season...

I mean....it technically IS fujobait, right?

There is a good amount of fujoshis that watch Haikyuu....this is evident by the massive amount of fanart and doujins that come out that is almost exclusively yaoi in nature.

I've never seen the anime, so all jokes aside, I really don't know, don't really care either...

But you can't deny facts.
As pullman already said, just because there is fujoshi material of an anime doesn't make it fujoshi bait. There's fujoshi material for Erased, FMA, *insert anime with 2 male characters* yet no one calls them fujoshi bait.
Haikyuu has an appealing artstyle and cute guy that make it more liked by those groups but there aren't baits in it, not for now.
I never had the thought of being fujoshi bait while watching it but only heard about it online after and I still don't see why people call the show fujoshi bait.
However I do see why anime like free and yuri on ice are called fujoshi bait.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Oct 8, 2016 7:35 AM

Offline
May 2016
3008
JustALEX said:
HyperL said:
Whatever, I just hate that people also call Haikyuu fujobait when there's NO sign of bait in it whatsoever... On the contrary, most of the cast just keep worshiping girls whenever they see one and there's a obvious ship between the MC and a girl since the second season...

I mean....it technically IS fujobait, right?

There is a good amount of fujoshis that watch Haikyuu....this is evident by the massive amount of fanart and doujins that come out that is almost exclusively yaoi in nature.

I've never seen the anime, so all jokes aside, I really don't know, don't really care either...

But you can't deny facts.


By saying that, You're basically saying that what decides if a show is fujobait or not is the amount of fujoshi fans it has... I disagree...A show doesnt NEED to be fujobait for fujoshis to be attractived to it, if there's a bunch of fujos making fanart of it, it just proves that anything is enough for them as long as it has a large male cast...
HyperLOct 8, 2016 7:52 AM
You are not your body, you are your brain, the "self" that emerges from within it.
Oct 8, 2016 7:36 AM

Offline
Jul 2012
48259
"But you can't deny facts."

lmao this thread is ugly
Oct 8, 2016 7:49 AM

Offline
Jun 2008
25970
Ok....let me get this straight....

The anime Haikyuu has a big fujoshi fanbase, like several other all male sports anime.

How do we know they have a big fujoshi fanbase?

Because there is a good amount of fanart and doujins dedicated to yaoi which is what fujoshis are all about.

And yeah, I have the evidence to back this up....

https://nhentai.net/parody/haikyuu/

^(NSFM link) Here we have a popular Doujinshi site with Haikyuu as the tag....it is overwhelmingly yaoi doujins.....probably well over 90%

Yes, of course any series can have yaoi fanart and yaoi doujins....but in the case of Haikyuu it is overwhelming.

Ok.....let's try this.

Can somebody here properly Define "Fujobait" and why Haikyuu despite being an anime filled with a large fujoshi fanbase does not fit the definition?
Oct 8, 2016 7:49 AM

Offline
Apr 2015
808
First time that I heard something like this. Never ones I felt while watching a sport-anime that something was getting too gayest/yaoi or anything like that. I do at times sense the heavy manservice in some of this sports-anime but that's it, now yaoi? nahh.

-Mastergold
Oct 8, 2016 7:51 AM

Offline
Mar 2008
2674
Schlopsi said:
I'm so sick of this discussion already. Seriously. Even IF, and I mean IF a sports anime shows some kind of "gayish undertone", what's the problem with that? Why does it seem so impossible to reach at least a little bit of tolerance for storytelling like that? Why is it canon, that Free! "must be yaoi" because it features a few fanservice shots (the heaviest was btw. one of totally unrelated bodies recognized by the female trainer, remember?)? Yeah, it must be hypergay, seeing all those trained bodys in their slinky swimsuits. Oh my. For real, get over it or call every ecchi you see from now on the equivalent of yuri. This onesided mentality of the discussion really sickens me.


^^^^^^ This. Most people who criticise "gay sports anime" never touch the ecchi/yuribait/moe subject. That's what irritates me. This is double standards. Otherwise I am okay with people discussing about these shows.

Also shows like K-On or Hibike!Euphorium or Love Live! have more fanservice than Haikyuu!! yet no-one complains about it. lol

Girls usually never complain about those shows, it's always guys when a female-audience show (or shows like Haikyuu, Kurobas etc) gets popular.

Of course people have right to criticise something, but do it without contradicting yourself.
Oct 8, 2016 7:52 AM

Offline
Mar 2008
2674
JustALEX said:
Ok....let me get this straight....

The anime Haikyuu has a big fujoshi fanbase, like several other all male sports anime.

How do we know they have a big fujoshi fanbase?

Because there is a good amount of fanart and doujins dedicated to yaoi which is what fujoshis are all about.

And yeah, I have the evidence to back this up....

https://nhentai.net/parody/haikyuu/

^(NSFM link) Here we have a popular Doujinshi site with Haikyuu as the tag....it is overwhelmingly yaoi doujins.....probably well over 90%

Yes, of course any series can have yaoi fanart and yaoi doujins....but in the case of Haikyuu it is overwhelming.

Ok.....let's try this.

Can somebody here properly Define "Fujobait" and why Haikyuu despite being an anime filled with a large fujoshi fanbase does not fit the definition?


I don't deny the amount of doujins or fanfictions but would you call, let's say Naruto, a fujobait show, because it's popular and it has lots of m/m doujins, artwork, fanfiction?
Oct 8, 2016 8:08 AM

Offline
Mar 2015
1287
Unfortunately there aren't that much animated BL titles out there. So fujoshi move on to non-BL works and start the shipping. That's the whole cause of the problem.
Oct 8, 2016 8:59 AM

Offline
May 2016
3008
JustALEX said:
Ok....let me get this straight....

The anime Haikyuu has a big fujoshi fanbase, like several other all male sports anime.

How do we know they have a big fujoshi fanbase?

Because there is a good amount of fanart and doujins dedicated to yaoi which is what fujoshis are all about.

And yeah, I have the evidence to back this up....

https://nhentai.net/parody/haikyuu/

^(NSFM link) Here we have a popular Doujinshi site with Haikyuu as the tag....it is overwhelmingly yaoi doujins.....probably well over 90%

Yes, of course any series can have yaoi fanart and yaoi doujins....but in the case of Haikyuu it is overwhelming.

Ok.....let's try this.

Can somebody here properly Define "Fujobait" and why Haikyuu despite being an anime filled with a large fujoshi fanbase does not fit the definition?


A fujobait , as the name says, cointain a decent number of baits...Which mean that very moments in the show will tease the fujoshis in various ways.

If you want to know what show can be considered fujobait or girlpandering, from my experience, they generally have the things below:

1) Manservice: There's nothing really gay about showing a man semi naked from a certain distance, I mean, plenty of movies do that no? What can be considered manservice is when they zoom on said naked bodies and/or do stuff like slowly moving the camera from bottom to top (or the inverse), slowly showing the man's body in it's entirety...

2) The representation of friendship: Friedship between man is one of the most common and not gay things in the world. But fujobait shows slightly alter the representation of a normal friendship to make it seem like something more is going on between them, even though is not. Things like when the two guys are talking to each other in a manner that is too sweet for normal male friends (almost like they're girls or something) or when the distance between them are too close for confort (A.K.A. invading their personal space) are just some examples...

3) Art style and character design: The show's art style is not really an indicator of this kind of padering...But generally for shows that ARE pandering, both the general arts style as well as each character design are specifically chosen to make the male characters fit the title of bishonen, the type of guy that girls (or at least japanese girls) are attracted to...So this can be used as the final nail on the coffin when deciding if a show is girlbait or not...

And there you go, most girlbait animes will have those three above...

As for Haikyuu, it doesn't have none of those, so it is not Fujobait...The reason it has so many fujofans its because on top of its popularity (Haikyuu is very popular, so it's no wonder it gets fans of all kinds), the fujos themselves distort the friendship showed in the anime for the sake of shipping (like any heavy shipper tend to do), cuz I assure you there's no weird vibe coming from the males of the show...
HyperLOct 8, 2016 9:06 AM
You are not your body, you are your brain, the "self" that emerges from within it.
Oct 8, 2016 9:22 AM

Offline
Apr 2016
290
I have to admit that fujsohi fandom has influenced sports anime over the years but NOT every sports anime with all male cast is fujoshibait.

First of all I don't understand why having a doujin makes the anime fujoshibait.Characters with no canon interaction at all also have doujins of them.I mean if an anime exists then it's doujin also exists.TRUST ME ON THIS.Even an anime like Berserk has doujins so Berserk is also fujoshibait?What I'm trying to say is doujins don't make an anime fujoshibait or something else.They are just there to satisfy the series' respective fandom (not only fujoshis) and also is a free promotion for the series but other than that doujins do not change an anime's reputation.

A perfect example of a fujoshibait bait all male cast sports anime would be free.Haru and Rin staying in a hotel room for couples...That's what I can call a fujoshi fanservice moment.The ''friendship'' in that anime definitely tries to imply ''more than just friendship going on'' that is a fujoshibait sports anime.

Haikyuu just does not fall into that territory I know there are a lot of friendship thingy going on but it's not in form of ''There is definitely something more than friendship.''.Not every friendship story between guys has to do with being gay grow the f*ck up.
JGUS-Oct 8, 2016 9:28 AM
Oct 8, 2016 9:24 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
561867
Don't think haikyuu falls into that category but I want to see how many people comes into this thread and telling that yuri on ice is not an obvious fujobait after second episode. Nvm, maybe I will post the pics lol.
Oct 8, 2016 10:11 AM

Offline
Feb 2016
311
zal said:
GangsterCat said:
you are the only one here feeling offended and being salty
just spamming word phobic phobic doesnt mean anything, you sound really annoying like those people who keep raining trump supporter with -phobic -ist -ist buzzwords
some people dont like gay stuff because they are not gay, simple, don't overthink
But which are gay anime?
Haikyuu? No.
All out? No.
Kuroko no Basket? No.
Ping pong the animation? No.
Hajime no ippo? No.
Ashita no Joe? No.


Let's add

Diamond in ace? No.
Baby steps? No.
Prince of tennis? No.
Slam dunk? No.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Oct 8, 2016 10:28 AM
Offline
Jan 2016
11
Rio_Pascua said:
Rivershield said:
Sports have nothing to do with gay stuff. Sports are about fun, perseverance, teamwork, friendship, and more important, competition. Men like competition, men are always competing. (ou course I'm talking about contact sports, I will leave the ballet in the ice thing out of the table)
That's the basic reason why manga and anime about sports are shounen in the first place.

Kuroko, Stride and Free have gone to this bromantic stuff to reach female audience, and added with the standard that most anime that has only male characters is gay (don't deny it, MOST are, indirectly or not), because men don't enjoy gayish stuff, as a consequence created this standard that anime sports nowadays are likely to be gayish.
And most of them really is for the purpose of reaching other audiences.

In the past a protagonist of a sport manga would have a crush in some girl, and his relationship with his teammates would never be mistaken as bromance. In anime sports nowadays characters are so attached to their teammates that they're behave almost like girlfriends, which is very unrealistic and unpleasant to the male audience. Characters are not acting manly at all anymore.

If you put yaoi stuff in it be sure it will not reach the target audience. It will go the oposite way.

Of course there are exceptions.


The "need to have a romantic interest in sports anime" is what annoys and detracts the series for me and usually makes me avoid series like that. You said it yourself, sports is about competition and dedication to the sports. If the sports is a team sport, you really can't remove "team bonding" to make it realistic or even ideal. Having a girl inserted just downplays the sport and the camaraderie.

That's why Haikyuu!, Diamond no Ace, OoFuri,Captain Tsubasa was also a god representation of the sports.

The problem with people is they automatically assume that the characters are gay, if they are all-male, dedicated to each other, serious and team-loving.


I was not saying that characters should, by standard, have a crush on some girl, I was just pointing a natural behavior that is just common sense and the reason why many sports anime before had better representation of male behavior. You can't separate men from their interest in women, specially when you're dealing with high schoolers.

The real problem though is that when you have a entire team of handsome dudes that goes on talking all the time how they care about their teammates and none of them has even talk about women then the least you will do is wonder about their masculinity. If you don't do that, maybe you're effeminate yourself.

There's several big differences between Slum Dunk and any other classical sport manga to any modern sport manga, that goes from the character design to the way friendship and teamwork are portrayed.
It is clear for someone who read both what is most appealing to men.

About Yuri on Ice... THIS THING IS GAY.
Common guys, its ballet on Ice, It should not even be called a sport, it is a fucking dance.
All these gracious moves, the sensitivity of the techniques, there's no way this can be male stuff.
Pages (5) « 1 2 [3] 4 5 »

More topics from this board

» What MMORPGs are VRMMO/Isekai anime based on?

thewiru - 6 hours ago

8 by aReviewer »»
3 minutes ago

» 🍉 Summer 2025: Anime of the Season (AOTS) ( 1 2 3 )

nirererin - Oct 9

148 by jh666 »»
18 minutes ago

» Do you actually want to marry your favorite VA?

Dragevard - 7 hours ago

10 by tchitchouan »»
28 minutes ago

» Outdated anime tropes and slang you don't really see much anymore

TheBlockernator - 11 hours ago

8 by Nirinbo »»
29 minutes ago

» Do you iss the Femme Fatale trope?

VabbingSips - 7 hours ago

4 by tchitchouan »»
29 minutes ago
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login