| I didnt watched it until rencent days due to huge streotypes lot of people when portraited it so bad, starting from MC Pedophile, OP MC, Mid Isekai, MC didnt did anything for 2 seasons, gross anime, etc from here i will start discuss it each First from MC Pedophile, before i want to tell that when entered 30 yo mc has been died in his original world and transferred to another world, in another world he starts his life as baby but he can think normally like normal adult as well as anos in mahou gakuin. After some moment his pervert still on like usual eg finding another pantsu, starring on booba, etc ofc he is really pervert but his desire not only towards to children only but also refer to adult one like he did on his maid in the house, greyart mom, etc not to mention he is still kids in another world so its normal thing if towards on his peers Second OP MC yeah we all known he has another special ability where he can use his magic without recital but he is not really op in physical fight event his body power is very vulnerable like common people there like when he was defeated by his dad, by greyart, by his fury teacher, fury creature, mafia kidnapper in fury forest, etc so op word doesnt suit for him Mc didnt did anything for 2 seasons, its huge fail assumption ever i cant tell it about further but if u remember about scene when he met again with his dad in water city u will know what i mean about it Gross anime is red topic since its really forbidden to talk about with. Idk how to describe it but i just wanna say this anime really perfect to portrait imperfect chars with imperfect situations in every imperfect scene. Its really rare things when u see full of gray aspect in both sides either from protag or antag but mostly important from here they were really developing as well their limitness in see another POV beside themselves not really stop them in stagnant ways. They are keep moving forward whatever the result in the end since mostly important for them whats best thing they will do in current situation ? So thats why gross, taboo, forbidden plot which they through it so far containing another intention, message, explanation, behind it In final words Mushoku Tensei really one of best isekai that i watched so far, the most important requirements which u should have are learning current situations and watching in overal persfective thus u will know how to deal with it in the end |
 |
| I wouldn't say it's the best because 12 kingdoms exists but yeah, it's good, it has its issues but in the end it's not a chore to watch it and it is beloved by a large audience of people, can't argue with that |
    |
| If Mushoku Tensei is one of the best, I don't want to watch one of the worst. |
| If you're a fanboy, please don't waste my time. Watch more movies, please. Perhaps, this is hell. |
| "Is Mushoku Tensei one of best isekai anime so far ?" Uhh, not really imo. :( |
 |
| It has an extremely strong narrative, but I can see why people might dislike it. Calling it outright bad though? Questionable. |
| I for one can´t think of a better one rn. |
 |
| I´d would say ITS the best. Nevertheless, outside the anime media, Yu-No visual novel is almost on the same level and I would place the epilogue slightly above. |
MichaelJacksonJul 20, 2023 11:44 AM
| :v |
| it's the best isekai i've seen. then comes rezero. both excel at everything that makes an isekai. the protagonists weren't the best of people at the start which makes their character development really great, both the animes are made with passion, their plot and world building are insane and not to mention such great cast. the animation is top-notch, the music is unforgettable especially in the case of mushoku tensei. i always skip the songs from these 2 animes during my playlist because their songs are so beautiful that i only want to listen to them on special occasions as they create such beautiful imagery in your mind while listening to them, sometimes reminding of some scenes from the anime or just making you tear up. these are exceptional animes for me and i feel so grateful to be able to watch season 2 of mt while it airs and season 3 of rezero is also announced. as an anime fan i'm really happy. remembering all the sequels and all the new animes that are announced it makes me feel this is certainly the greatest time to be alive for an anime fan. |
 The end of an era. Thank you Wit, Mappa and Isayama. Feeling half happy, half sad. Kawaii waifus and precious best girls <3333 |
| Definitely the best I've seen. It's actually really good and the bar for a good isekai couldn't get any lower when 99.9% of them don't even have a plot outside of the three sentence long title. |
| In terms of only modern isekai (which is what most people think of when they hear isekai), it's one of the better ones, but that really isn't saying much. Most isekai are so bad it baffles me that anyone watches them. Mushoku Tensei is a pretty good show with a ton of problems and a fanbase worse at selling it than Monogatari, but modern isekai as a whole is utter garbage, so it's able to be in the upper echelon by being just a bit less bad in certain departments. Again, that really isn't saying much. |
FrosteekJul 20, 2023 11:53 AM
| If we talk about the most basic kind of reincarnation adventure isekai, the formula that has been copied so much that I'd gladly watch Reincarnated as a Vending Machine over another basic power fantasy, Mushoku Tensei is indeed the best. The controversies are exaggerated, I really have no idea where the people who seethe with anger every time Mushoku Tensei is mentioned have been living or if they ever touched grass. If we talk about any kind of isekai, I'm not sure if I'd put it in my top 5 of the genre but it's still pretty close; it will probably depend on how well the subsequent seasons will be adapted (s2 already seem slightly worse than s1). |
| One of the best in terms of storytelling and worldbuilding, not to mention the high quality of its audiovisuals. I get the controversy around MC's perverted side (i can't recommend the anime for most people i know irl because of that), but i wouldn't want a watered-down version of MC either just to avoid backlash, if the whole personality of Rudeus has been what the creator truly envisioned it to be. The other side of that is, i would consider dropping the series if i ever find out that the creator purposefully made Rudeus that way with the primary intention to gain popularity via controversy. |
XavionJul 20, 2023 12:20 PM
   To keep learning is wise. To avoid action is fear pretending to be wisdom. |
| The light novel is pretty good, and the anime is decent too |
 |
| I just woke up and i need to piss on Rudy pooprat.. I named the toilet rudus |
 |
| No way. It has all the typical problems of its subgenre. It does at least have basic storytelling competence unlike many of its peers. But it's about a super-powered baby with the mind of an adult in a world built with priorities such that despite being pre-industrial, it has to have modern underwear. The only way to get "good" out of that is not to take it seriously. And it does take itself seriously. |
| Its not my favorite that goes to konosuba but its probably in top 3 isekais |
 |
| It's tied with Re:Zero as peak isekai for me |
  |
| Yes, I've got to enshrine Shisho no Pantsu, pray to such holy relic every morning and sniff it in time of anxiety. |
Help! I need somebody. Help! Not just anybody. Help! You know I need someone. Helpppppp!  |
| Yes, of course. Mushoku Tensei is the best isekai anime easily, even if it wasn't as well written as it is it would still have better animation than all others, but it has both great writting and incredible production values, there's no other isekai that can hold up to it. |
| No since other isekai exist Digimon Tamers Digimon Adventure (og) Escaflowne Re Zero GGO alt NGNL Tensura Mushoku tensei is not bad though just not at the top imo. I think when people say that is more so concerns the animation quality of s1 instead of the story and characters. |
 |
| It's better than most isekai anime but not the best. Clearly NGNL is better. |
"Nobody could laugh at someone who's trying their hardest" -Machio- |
| Only watched 5-6 episodes of it. I'd give it 7/10. And even that it's no better than say the first 5-6 of Now and Then, Here and There or .hack//Sign. The impression i got was that it's just a typical isekai anime + ecchi (or just perversion idk) with great execution and production as well as a well-written but otaku-pandering mc. |
| I definitely wouldn't say it's the best, I still think No Game No Life and Re:Zero are far better, but it's up there. I would say that it's one of the best. (I haven't read the light novels, and I haven't started watching season 2 yet, so my opinion is subject to change) |
| Its either Digimon or Spirited Away, no contest. But for modern isekai, Id say yes it is. I like it when they play the reincarnation escapism trope with actual baggage from the past life straight instead of ignoring it. |
| Keep scrolling |
| Rewatching it rn and yeah I'd say it definitely is. It's on a whole nother level compared to some of the other isekai I've seen like Shield Hero or Slime. |
| Best isekai Anime: probably Best isekai Web novel: nope |
| yes and for one reason only; sugita tomokazu. |
 |
| "Is Mushoku Tensei one of best isekai anime so far ?" 1. It has almost all the negative traits of contemporary isekai because everybody copied from its source...that's a really bad thing in my book. 2. My favorite contemporary iskais Youjo Senki and Isekai Ojisan are nothing like it. So - naaah. |
| It objectively is one of the best. But wether it is THE best would be subjective. |
 |
| "Best" Isekai and most popular one are certainly two different things. And hey, Mushoku Tensei is popular for a reason, I won't deny that. There has to be something it's doing pretty well, for it to be as highly rated as it is. For me, that is just a slightly bigger budget, than most Isekai-Show's and a lot of spice. But that's just my opinion. But when I watch something like Re:Zero, Konosuba or Devil is a Part-Timer I can't help but feel that these are supirior in writing and overall enjoyment. They're just missing the whole "Looser get's reincarnated into a fresh, new Life, where everybody loves him and he get's laid" -Part that makes Mushoku Tensei what it is. (In my opinion :) ) |
 |
The best one to me is tensura, mushoku isn't that great in comparison. |
 |
| Thread moved to the correct board + cleaned, uncivile and off-topic posts have been removed removed. I'm not a big isekai watcher, but from the ones I've seen I'd say it was one of the best. |
-DxP-Jul 21, 2023 6:33 AM
| I'd say Mushoku Tensei is one of the best anime but I wouldn't say it's one of the best isekai anime. For me, Mushoku Tensei isn't even an anime that comes to mind when I think about Isekai anime. I think most of it's appeal comes from its character design, backgrounds, just the art direction in general and also the music. Since it has a distinct style when compared to the average light novel adaptation style, it doesn't seem fair to compare it to other Isekai. When thinking about the best isekai, anime like Kage no Jitsuryokusha and Handyman Isekai come to mind instead of Mushoku Tensei. |
 |
| Based from the novels alone, I'd say it is THE BEST ISEKAI. For an anime, I've had mixed feelings for the recently aired episode/s. So I cannot say that is the best isekai anime, yet. |
 |
Catalano said: can u tell plus ponts of twelve kingdoms than mushoku ? like more complex world building, gigachad male, best development char, great direction, beautiful artstyle, etcI wouldn't say it's the best because 12 kingdoms exists but yeah, it's good, it has its issues but in the end it's not a chore to watch it and it is beloved by a large audience of people, can't argue with that nishant0 said: for konosuba we cant tell it as serious show but re zero and mushoku i think both of them quite balance in head to head matchWell it certainly not your average isekai, it has great story, world building and i like the characters but I don’t think its the best because i like konosuba and rezero more. |
|
ISeeLifePeople said: can u tell plus ponts of twelve kingdoms than mushoku ? like more complex world building, gigachad male, best development char, great direction, beautiful artstyle, etc in the end everything is from my POV, so yeah - mc is a girl and I like the fact that she doesn't have unlimited mana like rudy, I like stories where the mc goes from 0 to hero - yoko is a beauty compared to all chicks in mushoku who are either lolis or plain annoying - the world building is more complex in 12 kingdoms (not that it matters for enjoyment), they tell us the world kingdoms, the races, the language, teh scale of teh map, how magic works - the battles are more impactful in 12 kingdoms and it actually has stakes and I like those kinda stories, mushoku is just rudy overpowering anyone because he has unlimited mana - art is debatable, I like the look of 12 kingdoms more than the moe in mushoku but others will like mushoku more, mostly people in their early 20s there are literally 0 points in where mushoku wins against 12 kingdoms for me but like I said, it doesn't matter if it's beloved and no one will change his opinion because of what I wrote. What I do expect are some hateful and idiotic replies to this |
|
Catalano said: ISeeLifePeople said: can u tell plus ponts of twelve kingdoms than mushoku ? like more complex world building, gigachad male, best development char, great direction, beautiful artstyle, etc in the end everything is from my POV, so yeah - mc is a girl and I like the fact that she doesn't have unlimited mana like rudy, I like stories where the mc goes from 0 to hero - yoko is a beauty compared to all chicks in mushoku who are either lolis or plain annoying - the world building is more complex in 12 kingdoms (not that it matters for enjoyment), they tell us the world kingdoms, the races, the language, teh scale of teh map, how magic works - the battles are more impactful in 12 kingdoms and it actually has stakes and I like those kinda stories, mushoku is just rudy overpowering anyone because he has unlimited mana - art is debatable, I like the look of 12 kingdoms more than the moe in mushoku but others will like mushoku more, mostly people in their early 20s there are literally 0 points in where mushoku wins against 12 kingdoms for me but like I said, it doesn't matter if it's beloved and no one will change his opinion because of what I wrote. What I do expect are some hateful and idiotic replies to this Rudy also from zero tho but he get advantage since beginning like casting spell directly without mantra / pronounciation Beauty is subjective i see her more likely badass girl than beauty Maybe i will gonna try it to see how its complexity in it Rudy not really op. his op only release spell without mantra / pronounciation since his move so slow and his body not really strong unlike mostly fighter there For artstyle and animation pretty sure newer anime always win defaultly And sadly u dont get hateful or idiotic reply from mine, not sure with op lollllll |
|
| I heard many people loved this anime. I had tons of high expectations,, but Surprisingly it was Bland to me. I completed season 1 pt. 1* recently, and there's no valid Reason for it to have a 8.3 rating from my perspective. I found it interesting at some moments n very stupid at other, and it happened across every episode. I didn't find Rudeus any special, tbh his character in s1* is very similar to Meliodas, even so, his character was far better & CHARMING* compared to Rudeus. Idk many people might* relate to his character but I'm No BUM, so idk how people say he's good, especially** when his arguments with adults are Stupid and lack commonsense n the adults agree to it so easily. I found certain points about this anime, like normalising Polygamy and open cheating + child sex....... it's really Off to me. Can't say I hate it n also can't say I enjoyed it enough. A 7/10, not a single decimal more. Btw, this is about S1 part 1 only*, don't misunderstand. |
Anayan_KashyapApr 24, 2024 4:43 AM
| WISHED I COULD ALSO GET TRANSPORTED TO A WORLD FULL OF MAGIC And DUNGEONS, please take me there too if you could ( ◜‿◝ )♡ |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )MegamiRem - Dec 31, 2020 |
433 |
by InferGilgamesh
»»
4 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 21, 2021 |
498 |
by Bashy935
»»
Oct 8, 5:05 AM |
|
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Mar 14, 2021 |
241 |
by HiljainenSipuli
»»
Oct 4, 8:38 AM |
|
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 7, 2021 |
341 |
by HiljainenSipuli
»»
Oct 4, 8:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Feb 28, 2021 |
452 |
by HiljainenSipuli
»»
Oct 3, 7:18 PM |