Hi, I'm Ion, I've loved watching anime since I was a kid. I mostly rate anime compared to others of its genre, so I don't necessarily think a comedy action and a political drama in the same rating are comparable, but comparing them is kinda futile as they go for completely different things. Dragon Ball and Pokémon are basically the series that defined my taste, so I tend to be pretty biased towards them. I just drop anime I find awful and that would probably get a lower score if I finished them, but I'm more prone to drop manga because of less investment in them and because they consume more time. I never delete comments so feel free to leave whatever you want.
1: An anime that I not only found effectively without redeeming aspects, but that I outright hated and/or felt insulted by on a personal level
2: A really bad anime with only minimal redeeming aspects, being so bad that I'm unable to take it seriously and/or be engaged to it on any level
3: A bad anime with major flaws that, unlike a 2, actually manages to make me feel engaged and/or take it seriously on some level, so I can at least respect they tried
4: An averagely bad anime, it can have good scenes and/or ideas, but I ultimately failed to find it good, and in many cases they're plain boring
5: A meh anime that doesn't leave much of an impression and/or bores me immensely despite me not finding it actually bad, or one I'm so conflicted about I'm not sure what to think of it
6: An averagely good anime, an anime that I actually found to qualify as properly good, in which I engaged enough to truly like it, but that I still didn't find outstanding
7: A good anime that I truly enjoyed, not only achieving me considering them good but also outstanding in some way, being considerably above a 6 but still not masterful enough to be a 8
8: A really good anime that excels masterfully in a couple of aspects, being extremely good in quality and getting me to truly engage to the deepest level with it. These can be considered honorary mentions to my favorite anime
9: A really good anime with only minimal flaws, or at least not any flaws I feel are worth considering for what it aimed to do, with practically everything about them being of a masterful quality. These can be considered the lower part of my favorite anime
10: An anime that I found practically perfect, going above and beyond at everything it tried, these anime are such great constructed works of art that I find them fitting of the title of masterpiece. These can be considered the upper part of my favorite anime
How is Ubukata treating you so far, or is it too early to say? I tried a few minutes of BBE, but with limited expectations and so many things on my list, I was hesitant to commit to it. It seems like a story of "Sigh... I wish I could find someone without animal ears that are cuter than mine to talk to."
this account gotta be satire. these are some of the worst takes i have ever seen. not liking AOT is one thing, but to give that shit a 1 is just ridiculous. also fate zero get a 1???
You have some of the absolute worst media comprehension I have ever seen. I have had more in depth conversations about Dragon Ball Z with elementary schoolers.
Yeah, most of what I added are just things to try that I suspect I'll drop. I've added some of those. Isekai Shikkaku seemed too goofy to me from the beginning, but it honestly looks a fair bit better than I'd expect for an isekai with an odder than usual concept. Hahaha, I'm rooting for Ubukata. X)
"If you told me that this season I would find 2 series which are basically shows that look like they were written in 2015 and that I would have them as some of my favourites shows in 2023, then I wouldn't believe you, but here we are, and while I had no plans on writting a review about Temple because I can barely think of what to say besides that "it was a very fun show", on the other hand there is Eiyuu Kyoushitsu."
what do you mean by "look like they were written in 2015"?
if you explain what that means i think we can have a very interesting conversation
i think it might just be a grammatical error when you said they LOOK like they were WRITTEN but this could create an interesting discussion about how japanese animation styles have changed over the years and if the animation of the past can be replicated in the modern day
i watched temple and classroom for heroes when they aired but i didnt finish them because they are ecchi
i might try to finish them but if the ecchi is too much for me i will drop them
classroom for heroes is created by shin araki and he is my favorite light novelist of all time
he created GJ CLUB which is technically my favorite anime of all time but when i eventually finish YUYUSHIKI that will take its spot as #1
Good review on Yuru Camp S3, it's kinda sad that it's probably going to rain Confuse and Funny votes on it, but generally speaking it was a clear downgrade.
It fumbled even harder for me, because I watched the movie before starting Season 3 with the available episodes, and I couldn't help but think "Was a third season really necessary?"
Oh, so he was the animator (or one of) for most of the main (visual) scenes that stood out for me in MT. Looking forward to it. It's always interesting to see how CGI pans out in these scenarios too.
All Comments (380) Comments
Looking forward to anything from the new season?
Although there are other ones that are higher priority for me, I'm curious about this one:
https://myanimelist.net/anime/56348/Dungeon_no_Naka_no_Hito
you either score honestly or dishonestly
"If you told me that this season I would find 2 series which are basically shows that look like they were written in 2015 and that I would have them as some of my favourites shows in 2023, then I wouldn't believe you, but here we are, and while I had no plans on writting a review about Temple because I can barely think of what to say besides that "it was a very fun show", on the other hand there is Eiyuu Kyoushitsu."
what do you mean by "look like they were written in 2015"?
if you explain what that means i think we can have a very interesting conversation
i think it might just be a grammatical error when you said they LOOK like they were WRITTEN but this could create an interesting discussion about how japanese animation styles have changed over the years and if the animation of the past can be replicated in the modern day
i watched temple and classroom for heroes when they aired but i didnt finish them because they are ecchi
i might try to finish them but if the ecchi is too much for me i will drop them
classroom for heroes is created by shin araki and he is my favorite light novelist of all time
he created GJ CLUB which is technically my favorite anime of all time but when i eventually finish YUYUSHIKI that will take its spot as #1
It fumbled even harder for me, because I watched the movie before starting Season 3 with the available episodes, and I couldn't help but think "Was a third season really necessary?"