DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Ok, this is way better than I thought it would be. |
| Ok so this is really interesting to me because the score for this so far is really low, but the manga has a great score and seems to be really well received. Was this a bad adaptation or something? The Op is def ass(visually) but other than that I thought the ep was OK. I thought this felt like an old school show we’d watch back in the day on fox kids or 4Kids. Had a bit of early 2000s anime charm to it. |
Marinate1016Jul 8, 2022 7:05 PM
 |
| i don't like samidare's voice |
| Though I feel the animation could maybe be a better, This episode has definitely hooked me. I think this is gonna be a hidden gym of a series of done right. I was constantly laughing through the entire episode. I look forward to see where this series goes. |
 |
| It’s so sad that one of my favourite manga is getting screwed over by this crappy studio. Well, at least I like the VAs |
| God, that was ugly to watch, everything was passable until they actually started to move lol |
| Should've just let her fall lol |
| This show reminded me of Gibiate. Not enough awfulness to "so bad that it's good" stuff, not enough quality to treat it like something serious. Just an extremely boring cartoon where 20 minutes feels like an hour. |
Dukino said: Worse things existing is probably the worst praise you can give anything. If it even qualifies as praise and not just as some absurd mental gymnastics. Unowen said: Bottom of the barrel. Infinitely worse looking shows that this. Y'all are such whiners 😂😂 But yeah a whiner anyday over having non-existing standards. |
 |
Marinate1016 said: I thought this felt like an old school show we’d watch back in the day on fox kids or 4Kids. Had a bit of early 2000s anime charm to it. Well that's the absolutely correct feeling to have, since this manga ran from 2005 - 2010 lol |
| What's with modern anime being cowards with fan service? The manga had a bunch of panty shots in chapter one. The anime? None. |
 |
| The style of the story seems a product made for kids before crappy isekai trend. But, reading the synopsis on Wiki, the source material seems an isekai story in terms of the key words. Anyway, watching some more episodes will tell the truth. |
| Crescent is adorable, when Samidare was holding onto him like a stuffed toy, I couldn't help but appreciate his adorableness lol. I'm surprised Amamiya was able to so easily swear loyalty to Samidare after seeing that little imagery of his trauma from his grandfather, it didn't feel believable that he would easily go along with it if his grandfather's teaching were that of not trusting enemy or friend. Amamiya using his telekinesis to lift Asahina's skirt was completely unexpected, I didn't think he was going to be a pervert. |
 |
| very good episode, it was very emotional for me cause the manga is in mu heart since 2015, they removed the panty shots but it's ok, it's just panty shots. The people who complain about animation and stuff are just trolls, in hxh gon punches a ball and it's a still image, people love it, here Sami punches a golem, still image but the watchers complain. Well, people are dumb |
    |
| Man gains godlike powers with a talking lizard and the first thing he does is flip skirts lmao. Watching Sir Crescent get chucked out the window and repeatedly coming back was pretty hilarious lol. He's a big goof! Asahina/The Princess seems pretty adorable, I like her very cheerful and bubbly personality. Shes a bit wild, but I dig it! and ofc she would be the teacher's kid sister haha. Amamiya seems to have a lot going on. I'm wondering what that was with his grandpa, he seems to have some inherent mistrust of people. Looking forward to explore that a little more as the show progresses. Great first ep overall, looks like another weekly. |
| Lol I love how there's not a glimpse of surprise on the MC's face when the lizard starts talking. He's just like yeah yeah whatever stfu already. |
| Noticeable low production value which is a disappointing since this was one of my favourite manga of all time but at the same time, I still enjoyed it. Yuuhi's attitude towards his new partner was funny and Samidare's recruitment speech at the end gave me chills. |
 |
| Wait why are people hating this? LOL. I guess the only con of this episode is they skipped Samidares panty shot. To me it was a fine first ep |
| It wasn't in my plan to watch list but still decided to give it a shot cuz I didn't have anything to watch. So, it's actually quite interesting, I like the plot about that humongous hammer destroying the Earth and especially I find that little princess intriguing since she's planning to destroy the earth instead. Also how could I skip when there's TsudaKen voicing a lizard XD I Like the OP and ED. After seeing the ED visuals I was like “Did this studio animate Sabikui Bisco” to think I would be right XD I guess they didn't have time to think of a different design so they probably decided to go with Sabikui Bisco style since both of them has this biscuit and bisco thing. |
| Yeah, idk why I expected the animation to be good. I like how they avoided the panty shots still preserving amamiya's personality, that was... nice, I guess. Also I think they already fucked up showing the chains and his reasons to not get involved, it kinda ruins the reveal towards that. Yeah, its not great but its here. And with zero panty shots. |
Klad said: I guess the only con of this episode is they skipped Samidares panty shot. To me it was a fine first ep That's like, the only thing they did right. |
secondshelpJul 9, 2022 7:44 PM
DominusStult said: Marinate1016 said: Ok so this is really interesting to me because the score for this so far is really low, but the manga has a great score and seems to be really well received. Was this a bad adaptation or something? The Op is def ass(visually) but other than that I thought the ep was OK. I thought this felt like an old school show we’d watch back in the day on fox kids or 4Kids. Had a bit of early 2000s anime charm to it. Just going to stick with putting the first five minutes side by side with events in the manga. I think it says most of what I want to say about the difference in Yuuhi's character itself. In the manga the first time Noi returns Yuuhi is stunned by Noi returning, looking between him and where he'd just thrown him. His immediate response is one of confusion for fairly obvious, natural reasons. When Noi keeps trying to tell him what to do he gets pissed and holds him in the air by the tail, stating the following "This is my house which makes you an uninvited guest. You barge into my room then start orderring me around. Don't you have any manners, sir knight?" He then proceeds to hold him up in the air, making it perfectly clear that this is entirely a power play and he's not going to let Noi down until he begs for it. Afterwards he calmly leaves, telling Noi not to follow him or sit on his shoulder to which Noi explains that nobody else can see him. In the anime, the first time Noi returns Yuuhi backs up against the wall with his arms raised. His immediate response is one of not just shock but a small amount of fear. While he then holds Noi in the same way, rather than forcing his point and having Noi beg to be put down, he throws Noi out the window again. He then freaks out when the same thing as just happened five seconds before happens again and then freaks out when he tries the exact same thing a third time leading to him crashing his bike. Originally, I was most concerned about the animation, figuring that the story and characters would be kept roughly the same with the author of the manga working on it. That is not what happened and I have to say that I'm genuinely disappointed. My hopes had been sinking but I'd always thought that the writing would be a high point and that this would at least be a fun bit of nostalgia. It was not. The best thing this did was make me reread the manga. Maybe if I hadn't read the manga I wouldn't be as disappointed as I am. Having read the manga though and having an actual comparrison... This just makes me sad. Understandable. Basically me with Tate no yuusha |
|
secondshelp said: … so why are you asking what’s wrong with me again? Are you anti panty shots or something?Klad said: I guess the only con of this episode is they skipped Samidares panty shot. To me it was a fine first ep That's like, the only thing they did right. what's wrong with you? |
secondshelp said: Klad said: I guess the only con of this episode is they skipped Samidares panty shot. To me it was a fine first ep That's like, the only thing they did right. what's wrong with you? That's your opinion. Your opinion isn't objectively correct. They're allowed to like panty shots, and they're allowed to be disappointed that a panty shot was removed from the adaptation. |
ShengudJul 9, 2022 10:44 AM
 |
| Man. The character designs sucks. The color palette sucks. The post-processing sucks. The soundtrack absolutely sucks. Even a cheap, rushed adaptation should accidentally be fine in some minor ways, but they really went out of their way here. What is this shit? |
| I was very disappointed by this first episode. I loved the manga for its energy, dynamic characters and the actions. But this episode had non of it. Even Samidare's punch didn't appear as striking nor did she have that dominating pose when declaring Yuuhi to become his knight. Yuuhi's dislike of the earth was also not mentioned so his loyalty feels awkward if anything. The opening doesn't fit the series either. Just a slide show for a show that suppose to be full of badass moments. Meh... |
Klad said: … so why are you asking what’s wrong with me again? Are you anti panty shots or something? Panty shots don't add anything to any story, so i guess you could say i'm against them. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Hoshi no Samidare Episode 6 DiscussionStark700 - Aug 12, 2022 |
48 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
May 25, 3:43 AM |
|
Poll: » Hoshi no Samidare Episode 5 DiscussionStark700 - Aug 5, 2022 |
43 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
May 25, 3:30 AM |
|
Poll: » Hoshi no Samidare Episode 4 DiscussionStark700 - Jul 29, 2022 |
30 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
May 25, 3:14 AM |
|
Poll: » Hoshi no Samidare Episode 3 DiscussionStark700 - Jul 22, 2022 |
39 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
May 24, 11:27 PM |
|
Poll: » Hoshi no Samidare Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jul 15, 2022 |
53 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
May 24, 11:14 PM |