| Edited for better explanation. This is a discussion out of curiosity. Does those anime deserve to be there? What are the ones overrated? What are the animes that deserve a higher rank? What will be your top 10? And any thing related to it ... |
6cmdeepMar 4, 2015 3:40 AM
 |
| 4 of my favourites are in top 200 so I guess there's something about it |
 |
KLKfanboy said: thanks4 of my favourites are in top 200 so I guess there's something about it |
  |
| I barely care about the top anime. High School DxD BorN is #11 for example and stuff like Gintama is so praised due to the 1/3 rule and people who dropped the first series would not watch the rest. How else would Gintama' have a 9.40 score? |
| added the fourth most popular anime onto this site |
| I just want to see High school DxD takes Code geass S2's spot in the rankings. |
EvenJellyOn said: I barely care about the top anime. High School DxD BorN is #11 for example and stuff like Gintama is so praised due to the 1/3 rule and people who dropped the first series would not watch the rest. How else would Gintama' have a 9.40 score? what is that? also respect for dxd being #11 |
|
| We need to get Highschool DxD Born to number 1. |
| mal 200 is great coz theres Mushishi, Natsume Yuujinchou, and Baccano in it |
| Twitter and it's consequences had been a disaster for the human race |
EvenJellyOn said: I barely care about the top anime. High School DxD BorN is #11 for example and stuff like Gintama is so praised due to the 1/3 rule and people who dropped the first series would not watch the rest. How else would Gintama' have a 9.40 score? High School DxD is still entertaining in its own rights. Although Gintama... I'm not too fond of the humor so... skip :3 |
KLKfanboy said: EvenJellyOn said: I barely care about the top anime. High School DxD BorN is #11 for example and stuff like Gintama is so praised due to the 1/3 rule and people who dropped the first series would not watch the rest. How else would Gintama' have a 9.40 score? what is that? You need to watch one third of the series for your score to count. Gintama' had #1 and a really high score when it aired. KyubeySensei said: High School DxD is still entertaining in its own rights. Although Gintama... I'm not too fond of the humor so... skip :3 High School DxD BorN isn't a top 50 tier series though. It also hasn't aired. |
| added the fourth most popular anime onto this site |
| I have watched a few anime in the top 200. It is kind of nice to see what the 'top' anime on MAL are. I don't pay much attention to it though. |
KyubeySensei said: High School DxD is still entertaining in its own rights. Although Gintama... I'm not too fond of the humor so... skip :3 High School DxD BorN isn't a top 50 tier series though. It also hasn't aired.[/quote] Lol, didn't see the born part; just talking about DxD in general F0XFIRE said: We need to get Highschool DxD Born to number 1. That's some great ambition. The day you do, tell me, I'll be crying Remv_quevav said: mal 200 is great coz theres Mushishi, Natsume Yuujinchou, and Baccano in it Baccano <333 They should make more animes like that Durarara!! tried but isn't quite there :'( |
EvenJellyOn said: uhh no it's 1/5KLKfanboy said: what is that? You need to watch one third of the series for your score to count. Gintama' had #1 and a really high score when it aired. in Gintama's case it's 201/5=40.2 => at least 41 episodes for your vote to count OT: I've watched 123 of the top 200 as far as I can count at least |
  |
| Thanks. But I mean, why is that certain anime great? If it is because of the plot, then why as well. Yeah, I pick on which anime to watch base on the MAL Top Anime list, I haven't watch tons of great animes so.. I am not familiar on most of the anime part of 200, like monongatori (?) , samurai champloo. etc.. So, Idk what makes it great |
|
| What makes it great? 1 word ENJOYMENT Those top 200 anime gave a sheer enjoyment to their viewers |
 (っ◔◡◔)っ 𝓘 𝔀𝓲𝓼𝓱 𝔂𝓸𝓾 𝓪𝓵𝓵 𝓱𝓪𝓿𝓮 𝓪 𝔀𝓸𝓷𝓭𝓮𝓻𝓯𝓾𝓵 𝓭𝓪𝔂 ♥ |
KyubeySensei said: +1 Remv_quevav said: mal 200 is great coz theres Mushishi, Natsume Yuujinchou, and Baccano in it Baccano <333 They should make more animes like that Durarara!! tried but isn't quite there :'( I agree |
| Twitter and it's consequences had been a disaster for the human race |
Remv_quevav said: Sadly true.KyubeySensei said: +1 Baccano <333 They should make more animes like that Durarara!! tried but isn't quite there :'( I agree |
 |
| It's not that great. My favorite and second favorite of all time aren't even in the top 200. |
| Honobono Log - best slice of life short -------------------------------------------- most kawaii loli overlord ---------------------------- Donquixote Doflamingo AMV - Control |
| lowest common denominator anime and various sequels/movies/etc only fans will watch |
 |
| Those animes in the top 200 list are collectively likable. They are the one's that mostly don't divide people's opinions, so they don't get low rates. So, they are not taking many risks or going all out in anything. They are generally really enjoyable, but sometimes play it too safe. |
 |
| Thread edited for better explanation |
|
| All of my favorites are in the top 200. Gintama deserves its high rating in my opinion. Few shows come close to what Gintama has achieved with being both extremely funny and serious at times. |
EvenJellyOn said: I barely care about the top anime. High School DxD BorN is #11 for example and stuff like Gintama is so praised due to the 1/3 rule and people who dropped the first series would not watch the rest. How else would Gintama' have a 9.40 score? Top 10 gogogo |
 |
| out of the 20 10s I've given out as of yet, 17 of them are in the top 200 so yeah I guess in the grand scheme of things it's pretty good Kagami_Hiiragi said: even the novels are barely top 100, don't get your hopes up :sEvenJellyOn said: I barely care about the top anime. High School DxD BorN is #11 for example and stuff like Gintama is so praised due to the 1/3 rule and people who dropped the first series would not watch the rest. How else would Gintama' have a 9.40 score? Top 10 gogogo |
| |
HaXXspetten said: out of the 20 10s I've given out as of yet, 17 of them are in the top 200 so yeah I guess in the grand scheme of things it's pretty good Kagami_Hiiragi said: even the novels are barely top 100, don't get your hopes up :sTop 10 gogogo Well, a man can dream. :{ |
|
| Out of the 17 shows I've rated a 10/10 9 shows are in the top 200, but those include multiple seasons so I have rated about 5 different shows a 10/10. |
 |
quentariel said: Those animes in the top 200 list are collectively likable. They are the one's that mostly don't divide people's opinions, so they don't get low rates. This. From experience the ones I rate 10/10 tend to be the ones that are also in the 200 (or just outside of it), which is not that surprising. If it's something that most people like, then the chances that I'll like it too is also bigger. Generally I have a good experience with the top 200. I think out of those I saw, there were only a handful I rated less than 5. |
 |
| clearly the most people wanted rated those the highest. So I guess that means they deserve to be there. Id probably choose differently, but that's just my bias versus other peoples. |
| https://combosmooth.itch.io/ - I make free-to-play browser games for PC and I sell pixel art animation here |
| Some are part of it because they are liked by the majority of their members on this site. Some are there because of the sequel effect. |
| The top 200 series got many elements that satisfy all the watchers demographic. So they got unaminity |
 |
| I think the reasons why certain titles are in the top list are much more interesting. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
| Does those anime deserve to be there? In a way, yeah. They're the anime the majority chose, of course there are other variables. But I of course can think they are overrated or underrated. What are the ones overrated? I don't feel like going though all of them but I can maybe do the top 50. Hunter x Hunter (2011) Gintama: Kanketsu-hen - Yorozuya yo Eien Nare Ookami Kodomo no Ame to Yuki Mononoke Hime Great Teacher Onizuka Kiseijuu: Sei no Kakuritsu Kara no Kyoukai 5: Mujun Rasen Ano Hi Mita Hana no Namae wo Bokutachi wa Mada Shiranai. What are the animes that deserve a higher rank? Luckily all of my favorite anime are in the top 200 so I'll just use those instead of going through the list again. One Piece Hajime no Ippo Nodame Cantabile Ping Pong The Animation Tsumiki no Ie What will be your top 10? Probably my favorites: One Piece Hajime no Ippo Nodame Cantabile Ping Pong The Animation Tsumiki no Ie then probably: Mushishi Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Cross Game Nichijou Natsume Yuujinchou |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
LucasRTS said: Of course, my favorite anime is #7 and my second one is #58. Mushishi is #12 and Bebop is #20. And LotGH deserves more than 9.12 honestly. More than Gintama and Clannad at least. And High School DxD is #11 wtf is this shit? dxd best animu |
|
LucasRTS said: Of course, my favorite anime is #7 and my second one is #58. Mushishi is #12 and Bebop is #20. And LotGH deserves more than 9.12 honestly. More than Gintama and Clannad at least. And High School DxD is #11 wtf is this shit? DxD is better than your favorite animu. |
 |
  Too bad its going to reset soon though. |
| GO GO GO DXD #1!!!! |
|
| Both seasons of Code Geass are in the top 20 and DxD, a sequel one of the worst ecchi I've come across (and hasn't aired to boot), is 11th.... there are areas where it can be improved severely, but it's the majority's vote. So yes, they deserve to be there... except for DxD. |
 |
G_Spark233 said: Remv_quevav said: Sadly true.+1 I agree |
| SAO and SnK are both more popular than my favourite animus, it's a shit list Taewan said: +666G_Spark233 said: Sadly true. |
 Nico- said: Conversations with people pinging/quoting me to argue about some old post I wrote years ago will not be entertained@Comic_Sans oh no y arnt ppl dieing i need more ppl dieing rly gud plot avansement jus liek tokyo ghoul if erbudy dies amirite |
| Umm, that's a lot of Gintama. Can we just condense that into the Gintama franchise? FMAB is good and has a wide range of appeal, so for reccomenation purposes I can understand putting it at the top, but if someone tried to tell me its the best anime I'd roflmao. Hunter x Hunter is like a crappy Tower of God. A really crappy Tower of God. Even if Tower of God isn't an anime, that doesn't make HunterxHunter good nor does it have that wide of an appeal. Clannad AfterStory? HahahahahahahhahahaahahhahahaahahahahahhaahahahohohoHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHA!!! No, haha, just no. Monogatari Series: Second Season is good but its a lit slower than the previous series. The dialogue often isn't as snappy and the plot isn't as tight. I'd say it makes no sense to put it above the Bakemonogatari, though I think Nisemonogatari is best. The whole list seems kinda random. Maybe it shouldn't be ordered. |
 |
| My top 5 Little Busters Refrain is in top 200.... its number 141 with a rating of 8.42 Boku wa Tomadachi ga sukinai is not in top 200..... its number 694 with a rating of 7.87 ToraDora is in top 200..... its number 92 with a rating of 8.52 Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso is in top 200..... its number 52 with a rating of 8.64 And Zankyou no Terror is in top 200...... its number 190 with a rating of 8.34 So i agree with alot of the top 200 but not all |
| I just checked, and not one thing on my completed list is in the Top 200. |
 |
| There are way too many overrated shows in the top 200, I find myself disagreeing way too often with the overall praising of highly rated shows. |
| Take out the shounen and it would be better. |
| Part from FMAB. It isn't really a ranking of how good something is just broad range appeal. |
 Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
| This might be relevant to the thread: MyAnimeList Top Anime list evolution since 2007 So is there any era (so to speak) which had a better top anime list? I think the Top 20 anime list was better when there weren't four Gintama entries. Sad that Death Note dropped off the list though :'( One Piece was number 2 in 2007 :O And FMA 2003 (along with HxH 1999) have really dropped with time |
More topics from this board
» Anime you scored harshly and whyIpreferEcchi - 6 hours ago |
34 |
by SuperAdventure
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» I don't understand why shoujo is so much more shunned than all other demographics. ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Fario-P - Apr 27, 2023 |
459 |
by JaniSIr
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Into the Spider-Verse’ Director Peter Ramsey Boards Pair of Anime Projects With N Lite Media and ‘Afro Samurai’ Producer Gonzo K.K.Old_School_Akira - 47 minutes ago |
3 |
by rohan121
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Catholic Church Accepts Anime ( 1 2 )rohan121 - Oct 29 |
67 |
by pk8list
»»
13 minutes ago |
|
» Do any of you watch random episodes of shows you have already watched?BustedBayou - Yesterday |
21 |
by Zayvex
»»
33 minutes ago |