Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (5) « 1 [2] 3 4 » ... Last »
Jun 5, 2014 11:20 AM

Offline
Jan 2014
3077
sibbo7 said:
all those crybabies on here lol.. this episode is shit that episode is not good this episode is bad.. and still you keep watching.

or at least you're here week after week to continue trolling

all those crybabies on here lol.. this comment is shit that comment is not good this post is bad.. and you still keep posting.

or at least you're here week after week to continue fanboying
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jun 5, 2014 11:27 AM

Offline
Dec 2012
24355
I've finally have some context for this:

http://oi59.tinypic.com/25in5ax.jpg

LOL
Jun 5, 2014 11:34 AM

Offline
Mar 2014
4231
The animation sucked.. I think this and the poor dialogues prevented me from being moved by Neji's death, even though I really liked him in the past. The last few episodes must be way better in the manga, both in action and dialogues. Also, I don't read the manga but it seemed very fast paced. I wish they slow down a little because if the gap closes too much we will have fillers again.

Anyways, I saw in the preview of the next episode Sasuke, I hope he has enough screen time and gets involved in the battle.
Jun 5, 2014 11:51 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
2367
Shikaku's and Inoichi's death was portrayed brilliantly, it had more impact for me than in the manga.

Neji's death though..... I expected it to be more dramatic but it felt flat compared to the manga.

That being said, overall it's a fantastic episode. That Naruto x Hinata moment was just HNNNGGGGHHHHH!!
Jun 5, 2014 11:57 AM

Offline
Jun 2011
702
I'm not sure if I felt nothing thanks to the fact that my friends spoilt it for me thanks manga readers or because the animation was terrible/ lack of foreshadowing whatsoever.

RIP Neji.
Jun 5, 2014 12:11 PM

Offline
Dec 2011
6101
I agree that Neji's death should have had more impact through using animation and choice of music. They rushed this episode with 3 chapters in it. They could have done it with just two chapters.

Although, I really like Obito rubbing salt to Naruto's conviction, that not everything you want goes the way you want it... and of course I like Hinata's speech to Naruto too.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jun 5, 2014 12:18 PM

Offline
Dec 2012
1511
More than perfect episode. Very touching. The only thing I didn't like was how Neji was pierced off screen. 5/5
Jun 5, 2014 12:31 PM

Offline
Oct 2011
9390
Shikaku, Inochi and Neji T_________________T

When Shikamaru and Ino knew their fathers were killed. I just.... OMG TwT

Neji's words and Hinata saved Naruto from his despair.

RIP TwT
Jun 5, 2014 12:51 PM

Offline
Oct 2013
201
Them feels... :'(
Jun 5, 2014 1:09 PM

Offline
Aug 2013
15793
Neji </3

LCWS | SCS | TCO | NC | DNC
Jun 5, 2014 1:40 PM

Offline
Jan 2012
487
The death of the people on the base could of probably been done a bit more dramatically. I did like Naruto's expression when Obito was giving him that speech about how his words are false.


I'm glad we finally get to see more NaruHina moments.

Also that jutsu that held the 10 tails was huge, though it felt like it should of been able to escape that easily. The power levels in this series gets a bit confusing.
Jun 5, 2014 1:56 PM

Offline
Feb 2012
6821
My main man Neji tho, just why? :(
Jun 5, 2014 2:16 PM

Offline
Jul 2007
6167
Just previous quotes:



sibbo7 said:
all those crybabies on here lol.. this episode is shit that episode is not good this episode is bad.. and still you keep watching.

or at least you're here week after week to continue trolling


It is not so much the content that we are complaining bout but rather the way it was handled. The studio really dropped the ball this time around and im not proud of it.

For those who want to see how this depicted in the manga, click here:



ArtimesGamerJun 5, 2014 2:49 PM



Jun 5, 2014 2:40 PM

Offline
Mar 2014
338
Neji :'(
Jun 5, 2014 2:50 PM

Offline
Sep 2013
9
They should have paced this far better. Neji barely had screentime in the war arc, so him suddenly showing up, getting ten minutes of screentime, then dying was just kind of eh. It was handled much better in the manga (not exactly well - just lots better.)

However, Shikaku and Inoichi's deaths were pretty well executed. I liked how they handled that.

Also, the animation was kind of meh. I see no problem with the cones, though? It's not that big of a deal.
Jun 5, 2014 3:22 PM

Offline
Feb 2014
1126
RIP Neji, Shikaku, Inoichi... T_T
If you don't like me, acquire some taste
Jun 5, 2014 3:38 PM

Offline
Mar 2013
2839
The Ino, Shikamaru and Neji scenes :'(

Sasuke & Orochimaru in the next episode, hell yeah!
Jun 5, 2014 3:45 PM
Offline
Jun 2014
1
Can't believe they killed Neji they could have given him a better death atleast. in the preview for next episode they showed Sasuke and Orochimaru in the hidden leaf village right? so is it not destroyed or is that some other villege?
Jun 5, 2014 3:53 PM

Offline
Mar 2014
3893
Thawitchking said:
Can't believe they killed Neji they could have given him a better death atleast. in the preview for next episode they showed Sasuke and Orochimaru in the hidden leaf village right? so is it not destroyed or is that some other villege?


It's been partly rebuilt at this point.
Jun 5, 2014 4:00 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
1563
Never really felt bad for Neji in the manga either to be honest. I remember seeing the splinters going towards Naruto, Hinata jumping in front of him, seeing a blood splatter and freaking out because I thought Hinata had died. Then it turned out to be Neji, and I was like "Thank god, it's only Neji".
judals said:
sibbo7 said:
all those crybabies on here lol.. this episode is shit that episode is not good this episode is bad.. and still you keep watching.

or at least you're here week after week to continue trolling

all those crybabies on here lol.. this comment is shit that comment is not good this post is bad.. and you still keep posting.

or at least you're here week after week to continue fanboying
Kind of like you and Hunter x Hunter, hey?
MinagatachiJun 5, 2014 4:07 PM
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jun 5, 2014 4:01 PM

Offline
May 2014
137
I also agree about the animation. The previous episode was so much better animated. I am still in shock that Shikaku, Inoichi and Neji died, but it didn't had a huge impact. I loved the conversation between Obito and Madara and of course I loved the NaruHina moment.
The Ten Tails is really creepy by the way, it only had one arm for example.
Just Monika.
Jun 5, 2014 4:17 PM

Offline
Oct 2013
2234
One of the most interesting fights in shounen as a whole.
Jun 5, 2014 4:30 PM

Offline
Jul 2007
6167
Thawitchking said:
Can't believe they killed Neji they could have given him a better death atleast. in the preview for next episode they showed Sasuke and Orochimaru in the hidden leaf village right? so is it not destroyed or is that some other villege?


I don't think kishimoto meant to give neji a dramatic death. He basically wanted to show the harsh realities of war and for basic shock value. Knowing that anyone can die at any given time, this is war and i think that was handled ok, and what better character then neji to choose of the konoho 11. That only intern strengthens the bond between naruto and hinata.

Also something that decreased the shock value during this death, was the fact that studio censored it and it only shown neji being speared off screen, where as in the manga its full center.



Jun 5, 2014 5:13 PM
Offline
Sep 2013
2
I don't read manga. And I am sick of people making comparisons to it. Maybe it was better, maybe it wasn't. But I personally had so many feels this episode I 5/5 loved it and I'm not embarrassed to say it. The animation could have been better, but it was good enough that it didn't ruin anything, and if it did for you then I'm sorry. The sound track was PERFECT. Spot on. No other complaints at all from me, period. I was so touched by this episode I took like 24 screenshots and sent them to my gf so she could understand the feels!!!! xp All this after just finishing Btooom!...too much moop. Endurethefeelsnojutsu!
Jun 5, 2014 5:38 PM

Offline
Jun 2012
604
NaurutoxHinata set in stone
Jun 5, 2014 5:45 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
1171
MoeGod said:
Neji's death though..... I expected it to be more dramatic but it felt flat compared to the manga.


Even though I don't care for Neji I still felt something from the manga.
Jun 5, 2014 5:58 PM

Offline
Jan 2014
3837
And Neji bites the dust, sad episode. As much as I enjoy Obito being a crybaby bitch, I can't wait to see Sasuke again!!!
Jun 5, 2014 6:36 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
2367
link9us said:

I don't think kishimoto meant to give neji a dramatic death. He basically wanted to show the harsh realities of war and for basic shock value. Knowing that anyone can die at any given time, this is war and i think that was handled ok, and what better character then neji to choose of the konoho 11. That only intern strengthens the bond between naruto and hinata.

Also something that decreased the shock value during this death, was the fact that studio censored it and it only shown neji being speared off screen, where as in the manga its full center.


I think a lot of people missed the point of Neji's death. Naruto has been fighting this war by clinging to the words "I won't let my comrades die". This is the exact word that Obito taught to Kakashi, who then taught it to Naruto. Neji didn't die simply because he's a casualty of war, not even for the shock value (although it was quite shocking in the manga when it happened). He died so Obito can have a reason to shake Naruto's resolve because Naruto is similar to how he was when he was young. He wants Naruto to realize that he's naive just like when Obito was young, that you can't always protect all of your comrades. Obito is bitter about not being able to protect Rin and he wants Naruto to experience the same thing.

Why Neji then? it makes perfect sense because among everyone in that battlefield Hinata is the only one who can snap Naruto back and make him realize that his words was not just empty words, that everyone believes the same thing and that's why Neji sacrificed himself. Sakura isn't nearly as kind or as calm as Hinata and you can argue that no one understands Naruto better than Hinata, the one who has watched him for the longest time. Neji was chosen because his death should've impacted Hinata just as much as Naruto yet while Naruto was crumbling because of Obito's words, she remained unwavering and that's how Naruto is able to realize that his believe was not just empty words. This definitely wouldn't work with Sakura, Kakashi, or even Lee. Not only that, Neji's death also pretty much gave him a conclusion of finally understanding how his father felt when he sacrificed himself for the Hyuuga. Pretty much two birds with one stone.

The way Neji's death was executed certainly can be better by giving him more screen time but in all intents and purpose, it fulfilled what it's supposed to do.
Jun 5, 2014 6:42 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
1563
MoeGod said:
link9us said:

I don't think kishimoto meant to give neji a dramatic death. He basically wanted to show the harsh realities of war and for basic shock value. Knowing that anyone can die at any given time, this is war and i think that was handled ok, and what better character then neji to choose of the konoho 11. That only intern strengthens the bond between naruto and hinata.

Also something that decreased the shock value during this death, was the fact that studio censored it and it only shown neji being speared off screen, where as in the manga its full center.


I think a lot of people missed the point of Neji's death. Naruto has been fighting this war by clinging to the words "I won't let my comrades die". This is the exact word that Obito taught to Kakashi, who then taught it to Naruto. Neji didn't die simply because he's a casualty of war, not even for the shock value (although it was quite shocking in the manga when it happened). He died so Obito can have a reason to shake Naruto's resolve because Naruto is similar to how he was when he was young. He wants Naruto to realize that he's naive just like when Obito was young, that you can't always protect all of your comrades. Obito is bitter about not being able to protect Rin and he wants Naruto to experience the same thing.

Why Neji then? it makes perfect sense because among everyone in that battlefield Hinata is the only one who can snap Naruto back and make him realize that his words was not just empty words, that everyone believes the same thing and that's why Neji sacrificed himself. Sakura isn't nearly as kind or as calm as Hinata and you can argue that no one understands Naruto better than Hinata, the one who has watched him for the longest time. Neji was chosen because his death should've impacted Hinata just as much as Naruto yet while Naruto was crumbling because of Obito's words, she remained unwavering and that's how Naruto is able to realize that his believe was not just empty words. This definitely wouldn't work with Sakura, Kakashi, or even Lee. Not only that, Neji's death also pretty much gave him a conclusion of finally understanding how his father felt when he sacrificed himself for the Hyuuga. Pretty much two birds with one stone.

The way Neji's death was executed certainly can be better by giving him more screen time but in all intents and purpose, it fulfilled what it's supposed to do.
Well said.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jun 5, 2014 6:42 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
2367
SlushyCoffee said:
Does anyone know what volume and chapter this episode take place? Really appreciate the help :)


613 to 615
Jun 5, 2014 7:36 PM

Offline
Jan 2014
17169
link9us said:


I don't see much difference between the manga and anime depictions. If anything, the anime was better because of greater clarity.
"Let Justice Be Done!"

My Theme
Fight again, fight again for justice!
Jun 5, 2014 8:00 PM

Offline
Oct 2013
23
10/10 ep. also, very sad... looking forward for thursday.

R.I.P. Neji, Shikaku, Inochi and Ao
TheScarecrowJun 5, 2014 8:03 PM
Jun 5, 2014 8:21 PM

Offline
Mar 2013
523
Funny how last week everyone was saying that they loved the episode and now all the so called "professional critics" are back on a roll. animation was bad. but i've seen worse. pretty cool seeing all their deaths animated.
EL PSY KONGROO!!!
Jun 5, 2014 8:29 PM

Offline
Dec 2013
2598
I almost forgot how Hinata sounded like. Great episode. Love that NaruxHina moment.
Stay in yesterday 時を止めて
Jun 5, 2014 10:23 PM

Offline
Jan 2014
28
Those who have read the manga have no right to judge the episode,, You all spoiled yourselves so ofcourse you will not like it, your reviews are pissing me off duh.....it was an awesome episode......AWESOME!!
even though i knew neji will die but still i was almost crying when he was dying and those flashbacks......hinata helped naruto!! she proved that she deserves him ofcourse <3 <3
superb!!
Jun 5, 2014 10:52 PM

Offline
Jan 2014
3077
MoeGod said:
link9us said:

I don't think kishimoto meant to give neji a dramatic death. He basically wanted to show the harsh realities of war and for basic shock value. Knowing that anyone can die at any given time, this is war and i think that was handled ok, and what better character then neji to choose of the konoho 11. That only intern strengthens the bond between naruto and hinata.

Also something that decreased the shock value during this death, was the fact that studio censored it and it only shown neji being speared off screen, where as in the manga its full center.


I think a lot of people missed the point of Neji's death. Naruto has been fighting this war by clinging to the words "I won't let my comrades die". This is the exact word that Obito taught to Kakashi, who then taught it to Naruto. Neji didn't die simply because he's a casualty of war, not even for the shock value (although it was quite shocking in the manga when it happened). He died so Obito can have a reason to shake Naruto's resolve because Naruto is similar to how he was when he was young. He wants Naruto to realize that he's naive just like when Obito was young, that you can't always protect all of your comrades. Obito is bitter about not being able to protect Rin and he wants Naruto to experience the same thing.

Why Neji then? it makes perfect sense because among everyone in that battlefield Hinata is the only one who can snap Naruto back and make him realize that his words was not just empty words, that everyone believes the same thing and that's why Neji sacrificed himself. Sakura isn't nearly as kind or as calm as Hinata and you can argue that no one understands Naruto better than Hinata, the one who has watched him for the longest time. Neji was chosen because his death should've impacted Hinata just as much as Naruto yet while Naruto was crumbling because of Obito's words, she remained unwavering and that's how Naruto is able to realize that his believe was not just empty words. This definitely wouldn't work with Sakura, Kakashi, or even Lee. Not only that, Neji's death also pretty much gave him a conclusion of finally understanding how his father felt when he sacrificed himself for the Hyuuga. Pretty much two birds with one stone.

The way Neji's death was executed certainly can be better by giving him more screen time but in all intents and purpose, it fulfilled what it's supposed to do.

And that plot has been beaten over our heads for a decade now. Its execution was terrible too.
There is another anime right now dealing with 'failing to save a friend', look at how brilliantly it did that.

Let us put your point under the microscope: he wanted to show someone trying to destroy naruto's beliefs or convictions... By killing someone who had been absent since the war started, and even his last appearance was extremely minor? And before that his last major story was him vs Kidomaru?
Gaara was right there, he was the one who was most similar to naruto as well.
That's just terrible writing.

"Hintata is the only one who can snap back naruto" rewind a couple of arcs and all she did was make him snap and go 6/8 tails.

Besides, she never gad any actual characterization establishing how she'd react, so her being the speech giver was forced and didn't make any sense.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jun 5, 2014 10:59 PM

Offline
Sep 2011
9882
What a pathetic way for Neji to go out. Even the HQ getting blown was really stupid, but someone important/known had to die soon, I guess.
Jun 5, 2014 11:36 PM

Offline
Oct 2013
9
Very touching episode with a lot of content. Its a shame Neji's death didn't have a really big impact. If he was a more important character in the story, his death would be on a Jiraiya/Itachi level.


R.I.P The Hyuga Genius and ofcourse Ao,Inoichi and Shikaku
Jun 5, 2014 11:45 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
2367
judals said:

And that plot has been beaten over our heads for a decade now. Its execution was terrible too.
There is another anime right now dealing with 'failing to save a friend', look at how brilliantly it did that.

Let us put your point under the microscope: he wanted to show someone trying to destroy naruto's beliefs or convictions... By killing someone who had been absent since the war started, and even his last appearance was extremely minor? And before that his last major story was him vs Kidomaru?
Gaara was right there, he was the one who was most similar to naruto as well.
That's just terrible writing.

"Hintata is the only one who can snap back naruto" rewind a couple of arcs and all she did was make him snap and go 6/8 tails.

Besides, she never gad any actual characterization establishing how she'd react, so her being the speech giver was forced and didn't make any sense.


I assume you're talking about those hunters. Surely raging & getting power up after failing to save a friend is very original *cough* every shounen ever *cough*. Not to mention the one who died was a guy who appeared on the first arc and barely did anything until he was killed during the beginning of the current arc about 50 episodes or so ago. Don't bother to reply this one paragraph because I can predict what you're gonna say, I'm not here to hate on other series because I love both so you can shove your double standards up your ass back where it belongs. Despite his insignificance in this arc Neji is still Naruto's friend & a guy he really respects other than Sasuke (as if that flash back about Naruto calling Neji a genius wasn't clear enough).

And sure, Gaara would definitely be reaaaaally sad to see a guy who he met once many years ago when he was a kid died before his eyes. Did you even bother to think about my point why it was Neji & Hinata and not anyone else or you just simply let your hate blinded you and jumped to the comment section? Don't twist my word as you wish, there are plenty of definition of the word "snap", do you even English? ever heard the term "snapped back to reality"?

That you think she never had any characterization to give that speech was more than enough prove you didn't even bother to look at the bigger context. Hinata was and is always Naruto's biggest believer since this series started. If anyone would STILL believe in Naruto's words even after it was crushed right before their eyes, it's her. Anyone else would be swayed by Obito's words or give Naruto some lip service, and even if they don't it won't sound as believable, why? because they're not close to Neji. In fact Neji is the perfect choice to die precisely because he's the one thing that both Naruto and Hinata have strong binds to. It's almost like you intentionally ignored past developments between Neji's and Hinata's relationship or even Neji's & Naruto's.
MoeGodJun 5, 2014 11:56 PM
Jun 5, 2014 11:54 PM

Offline
Sep 2013
110
It's actually been a while since a Naruto episode gave me goosebumps. Last time it did, it was the episode where Naruto & Kurama fist-bumped each other. I did like this episode, but it felt rushed. They cramped 3 manga chapters in 1 episode, which is IMO a little too much.

The OST they used could have been a little better too. I knew that in this episode Neji would die, so I was actually predicting some OST's which would play when he died. I expected "Scene of a Disaster" or "Despair", but if I recall correctly neither of them made it. Which annoyed me, since I absolutely love the OST.

I also loved the scene where Naruto and Hinata were holding hands, my inner NaruHina fanboyism was going crazy xD
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jun 5, 2014 11:55 PM

Offline
Dec 2012
24355
MoeGod said:

That's exactly how I interpreted, and what I meant by different layers. I was quite surprised when someone said it was for shock value, because quite honestly it didn't really shock me, at least not in the anime, and it's purpose was clearly not that.

That's why Obito is irritated with Naruto because he reminds him of his old self, and he wants to mentally crush him, in a way to validate his ideology and to feel he is right in what he is doing, and that he is plan is the only right course of action.


Tyrel said:
Even the HQ getting blown was really stupid

Ehh. Why?
tsudecimoJun 5, 2014 11:58 PM
Jun 6, 2014 12:05 AM

Offline
Jan 2014
3077
MoeGod said:
judals said:

And that plot has been beaten over our heads for a decade now. Its execution was terrible too.
There is another anime right now dealing with 'failing to save a friend', look at how brilliantly it did that.

Let us put your point under the microscope: he wanted to show someone trying to destroy naruto's beliefs or convictions... By killing someone who had been absent since the war started, and even his last appearance was extremely minor? And before that his last major story was him vs Kidomaru?
Gaara was right there, he was the one who was most similar to naruto as well.
That's just terrible writing.

"Hintata is the only one who can snap back naruto" rewind a couple of arcs and all she did was make him snap and go 6/8 tails.

Besides, she never gad any actual characterization establishing how she'd react, so her being the speech giver was forced and didn't make any sense.


I assume you're talking about those hunters. Surely raging & getting power up after failing to save a friend is very original *cough* Fairy Tail *cough*. Not to mention the one who died was a guy who appeared on the first arc and barely did anything until he was killed during the beginning of the current arc about 50 episodes or so ago. Don't bother to reply this one paragraph because I can predict what you're gonna say, I'm not here to hate on other series because I love both (and FT) so you can shove your double standards up your ass back where it belongs. Despite his insignificance Neji is still Naruto's friend, tbh it could be anyone close enough to Naruto and it would still destroy his conviction.

And sure, Gaara would definitely be reaaaaally sad to see a guy who he met once many years ago when he was a kid died before his eyes. Did you even bother to think about my point why it was Neji & Hinata and not anyone else or you just simply let your hate blinded you and jumped to the comment section? Don't twist my word as you wish, there are plenty of definition of the word "snap", do you even English? ever heard the term "snapped back to reality"?

That you think she never had any characterization to give that speech was more than enough prove you didn't even bother to look at the bigger context. Hinata was and is always Naruto's biggest believer since this series started. If anyone would STILL believe in Naruto's words even after it was crushed right before their eyes, it's her. Anyone else would be swayed by Obito's words and even if they don't it won't sound as believable, why? because they're not close to Neji. It's almost like you intentionally ignored past developments between Neji's and Hinata's relationship.
Havent watched the last few eps but every time someone tries to link HxH to FT, I think it's cowardly argumentation at best. I'm referring to episode 116. Layers upon layers of reasons on what happened, as opposed to 'lol your motto is gone, now what? Another overused speech.
Besides, even without knowing he appeared before, they still built him up for 10 episodes, that's almost a cour.

I don't see a reason for your ad hominem outburst. Nor do I see any double standards. Similar situations, different execution and writing.

It's true that anyone could have replaced neji, but 1) neji was still the worse option so far 2) his conviction was barely touched before another scene rolled in.

Hahaha, you seem to forget that Gaara died once, and Naruto reacted about that in a more... Emotional way.
I wasn't trying to twist your words, but to call you out on the contradiction.
Your claim: hinata is the best option to snap him back to reality
Truth: last time we saw her she was the reason he snapped/webt crazy/got a nakama power.

So, your claim needs more insight.

It's not that I didn't look at the bigger context, but I tried to look a bit further into it.
You claim she believes in him, and I know that, i'm questioning her ability to talk in such a convinciny way all of a sudden to save the moment. Right now it seems like anoter TnJ tbh.

Oh and what was that about others being swayed? Because everyone else was watching and pretty sure Neji wasn't the only one who died.
We're talking about an army where one speech made them easily forget all the wars. This doesn't make any sense.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jun 6, 2014 12:09 AM

Offline
Jan 2014
3077
Also, need I remind you that this WAS NOT the first time he failed to save someone?
Yet, we saw no build up of his convictions being shaken slowly, until he reaches a boiling point, which is now. No. It just happened within the context of this particular scene. And was resoved then too.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jun 6, 2014 12:22 AM

Offline
May 2013
796
Neji's death pissed me off in the manga and it pissed me off in the anime. He gave up his life to protect his cousin who's wetting her panties 3 seconds later because her crush is holding her hand. Neji should have died in part 1, his death would have had a much bigger impact.. Obito is not done whining, he will find another way to bicker with Naruto.
''We don't know what kind of people we truly are until the moment before our deaths. As death comes to embrace you, you will realise what you are. That's what death is, don't you think?'' - Uchiha Itachi
Jun 6, 2014 12:25 AM

Offline
Jan 2014
3077
The way it seems: kishimoto is trying to force a belief clash between tbe two, and have tobi give in (with TnJ) in the end. That seems the only explanation for it.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jun 6, 2014 12:32 AM

Offline
Dec 2012
24355
SaSa-Zoldyck said:
Neji's death pissed me off in the manga and it pissed me off in the anime. He gave up his life to protect his cousin who's wetting her panties 3 seconds later because her crush is holding her hand. Neji should have died in part 1, his death would have had a much bigger impact.. Obito is not done whining, he will find another way to bicker with Naruto.

Can you at least worded in a better way...

Sigh
Jun 6, 2014 12:43 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
2367
judals said:


So basically you expect him to react the same way he did many years ago? ever heard the term "character development"? it's like you haven't even noticed that he has tamed the Kyuubi. Did you even hear/read what Obito was gloating about? or different situations were always the same context to you? I don't see how seeing unreasonable teenage angst all the time (like that episode you referred to) has to be the standard of reacting to someone's death because you know, humans are a lot more complex and also know something called "despair" instead of just "rage" all the way. I can also argue that if Hinata hadn't snapped him back to reality, Naruto might have just explode with rage but let's save all the hypothetical bullshit for now.

And also let's not be a hypocrite and expect Naruto to care as much about the countless nameless ninja as he did for Neji, just like that one whiny teenager barely cared about the dying girl being saved in front of him. I also can't stress enough how you ignored past developments. The way you talked is as if Hinata is still the same cowardly girl before Shippuuden started and even then she has grown a lot to be someone who's strong enough to give that speech to Naruto.

Let me just ask you this, who's a better choice than Neji & Hinata combination? Kakashi? Sakura? I bet whoever is with Naruto would just say "this is a war, people die" or something along the line "your conviction is naive" just like Obito. Ino-Shika-Cho would say something along those lines too if one of them dies. Any combination of Kiba & Shino wouldn't work because no one is as sympathetic as Hinata and if Hinata is the one who dies, Naruto would then just rage without being able to challenge Obito's point of view which would defeat the purpose of anyone close to him dying.

Hinata is also literally the only person in this series so far who's willing to sacrifice her life for Naruto aside from Naruto's dead parents. Would Sakura jump to protect him from those spikes? maybe, but it would be even more random than Hinata appearing to protect Naruto. Hinata has done this before so it's not weird and Neji's speech about Naruto's life not belonging only to Naruto won't have as much impact if it wasn't Hinata who jumped. Plus Neji didn't just die to protect Naruto, he also protected Hinata! It is his duty as part of the branch family.

judals said:
The way it seems: kishimoto is trying to force a belief clash between tbe two, and have tobi give in (with TnJ) in the end. That seems the only explanation for it


Again, you showed your ignorance (or lack of memory) here because that's pretty much the nature of Tobi and Naruto relationship even before the war started. Two people who used to have the same ideals yet chose a different path despite experiencing similar horror. If it was not clear enough, Nagato who is in effect a proxy of Obito also had similar clash of beliefs with Naruto. This thing has been foreshadowed since a long time ago.
MoeGodJun 6, 2014 12:46 AM
Jun 6, 2014 12:46 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
301
Hahahah he finally died
Jun 6, 2014 1:04 AM

Offline
Jan 2014
3077
MoeGod said:
judals said:


So basically you expect him to react the same way he did many years ago? ever heard the term "character development"? it's like you haven't even noticed that he has tamed the Kyuubi. Did you even hear/read what Obito was gloating about? or different situations were always the same context to you? I don't see how seeing unreasonable teenage angst all the time (like that episode you referred to) has to be the standard of reacting to someone's death because you know, humans are a lot more complex and also know something called "despair" instead of just "rage" all the way. I can also argue that if Hinata hadn't snapped him back to reality, Naruto might have just explode with rage but let's save all the hypothetical bullshit for now.

And also let's not be a hypocrite and expect Naruto to care as much about the countless nameless ninja as he did for Neji, just like that one whiny teenager barely cared about the dying girl being saved in front of him. I also can't stress enough how you ignored past developments. The way you talked is as if Hinata is still the same cowardly girl before Shippuuden started and even then she has grown a lot to be someone who's strong enough to give that speech to Naruto.

Let me just ask you this, who's a better choice than Neji & Hinata combination? Kakashi? Sakura? I bet whoever is with Naruto would just say "this is a war, people die" or something along the line "your conviction is naive" just like Obito. Ino-Shika-Cho would say something along those lines too if one of them dies. Any combination of Kiba & Shino wouldn't work because no one is as sympathetic as Hinata and if Hinata is the one who dies, Naruto would then just rage without being able to challenge Obito's point of view which would defeat the purpose of anyone close to him dying.

Hinata is also literally the only person in this series so far who's willing to sacrifice her life for Naruto aside from Naruto's dead parents. Would Sakura jump to protect him from those spikes? maybe, but it would be even more random than Hinata appearing to protect Naruto. Hinata has done this before so it's not weird and Neji's speech about Naruto's life not belonging only to Naruto won't have as much impact if it wasn't Hinata who jumped. Plus Neji didn't just die to protect Naruto, he also protected Hinata! It is his duty as part of the branch family.

judals said:
The way it seems: kishimoto is trying to force a belief clash between tbe two, and have tobi give in (with TnJ) in the end. That seems the only explanation for it


Again, you showed your ignorance (or lack of memory) here because that's pretty much the nature of Tobi and Naruto relationship even before the war started. Two people who used to have the same ideals yet chose a different path despite experiencing similar horror. If it was not clear enough, Nagato who is in effect a proxy of Obito also had similar clash of beliefs with Naruto. This thing has been foreshadowed since a long time ago.


No but I have heard of the term character consistency. Being inconsistent along the story doesn't equate to development.
You really wanna start about tern angst, defending someone who hyperventilated?
Well, yes humans are complex, and to show rage in such depth reflected that perfectly. This half-assed situational despair with no build up, that happened within two scenes, was a failure in that regard.

Funny how you claim it isn't all about rage when he raged the same way Pain taunted him, (spare me the technicalities of the dialogue), in a very simple minded way.


I didn't say Naruto had to care about them, but other ninja must have. It's a good thing every one who lost someone had his own personal Hinata.

As for your question, I don't care for a 'better choice', I want better writing. With that ai'd probably be fine with Neji.



I know it's like that from the beginning. Here is the catch: kishi wants their beliefs to go head to head, but doesn't know how, so he forces moments like these to make it play out. No grace whatsoever. And quite unprofessional.

Another problem is how this is ALWAYS the plot of naruo, how is up against a parallel life-opposite decisions type of shit.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jun 6, 2014 1:17 AM

Offline
Sep 2008
1105
I read some previous comments and just wanna ask one thing.

How the hell are Obito and Naruto similar when it comes to life experiences?

Naruto had his mother & father die to 9-tails, he was bullied, beaten, hated, lived in solitude pretty much his whole childhood and has only gotten to be accepted by the rest of the village when he saved their sorry asses.

Obito on the other hand...had his crush die in front of him.


True, maybe they both boasted same ideals, protect all friends, never give up and be ready to sacrifice your life for the ones dear to you.
But that's where their similarities end.

Actually, I am wrong now that I think of it.
Remember the scene where Hinata got "killed" by Pain and Naruto went full 9-tails mode only to be saved by his father?
I guess they're both similar in that aspect as well.

But their life experiences are not similar, in any way.
Naruto went through hell and back while Obito lost one person before going full retard mode.
Pages (5) « 1 [2] 3 4 » ... Last »

More topics from this board

Poll: » Happy Birthday, Naruto!!!

tsubagakure - Yesterday

20 by Tinhooo »»
1 hour ago

Poll: » Naruto: Shippuuden Episode 346 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Jan 23, 2014

60 by NuancedNomad »»
9 hours ago

Poll: » Naruto: Shippuuden Episode 345 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Stark700 - Jan 16, 2014

208 by NuancedNomad »»
Today, 9:25 AM

Poll: » Naruto: Shippuuden Episode 344 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Stark700 - Jan 9, 2014

111 by NuancedNomad »»
Today, 8:22 AM

Poll: » Naruto: Shippuuden Episode 343 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Griffith - Dec 19, 2013

155 by NuancedNomad »»
Today, 5:42 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login