| Can someone explain to me how anyone took a look at episode 1 and went? "Yah this is good enough to a 10 or 9." The demon was a CGI monstrosity Any sense of urgency from the manga is just gone. And the episode somehow pacing that's schizoid but somehow manages to feel like it's wading through waist-high water. The hunter looks like a goofy cross between bondrwd's furry form and slender man with his legs cut off. I need to know why. Please help me understand this. |
| I've surpassed your limit! |
| I cannot really tell what is good CGI or not. I do not know the sense of urgency from the manga. I do not know the pacing in the manga as I have not read the manga. I do not see a problem with the hunter. I gave the first episode a 7. Others gave it an 8+. |
| While I haven't rated it I will say that it was interesting imo, not boring, CGI looked fine, I don't know anything about the manga, pacing seemed was fine for me, hunters design also looked fine imo. |
| >Taking MAL scores seriously Stop worrying about glorified opinions and just like what you like m8. |
 |
iorn said: Can someone explain to me how anyone took a look at episode 1 and went? "Yah this is good enough to a 10 or 9." I need to know why. Please help me understand this. No. Use your brain and think for yourself. |
iorn said: The demon was a CGI monstrosity Says someone who gave aot final season a 9. |
❝Kabo-chan is ran by the MAL staff team and does not respond to individual comments made on her profile.❞ I was immensely devastated. |
| [ Fine, you got me there. |
| I've surpassed your limit! |
| Once again, finding out that MAL users are unable to properly use 1-10 scale (even though meaning of each number is explained). I simply assume that if anime is rated x it can be anywhere between x-3 to x to me and I recommend it to you as well. |
| Just focus on what you like smh, everyone has different opinions |
| idk what to say about this yet. I think I need a good 3-5 episodes to judge it. So far it's okay. A fair score based on how high the last season was. to be fair to op, aot's cg is way better than the demon in ep 1. |
 |
| I was actually pretty disappointed with the whole demon thing, because horror with demons isn't really horror, more action. I wasn't impressed by the first episode except for the visuals of all the children and music. But it did get a lot better towards the end. |
| You jump to the right and you shake that hand You jump to the left and you shake that hand Meet new friends Tie that yarn And that's how you do the Scarn Woo |
| i don't rate things until i finish them, but bad cgi monsters are kinda a staple in anime today since it's more cost-effective. the cgi in aot isn't good either, but i still think the show's amazing. unless the cgi takes center stage, i think this season will be pretty good from the little i've read in the manga. |
 |
jaiveer_ said: maykennay said: i don't rate things until i finish them, but bad cgi monsters are kinda a staple in anime today since it's more cost-effective. the cgi in aot isn't good either, but i still think the show's amazing. unless the cgi takes center stage, i think this season will be pretty good from the little i've read in the manga. The cgi in aot is way better than that the stuff by mappa definitely, the colossal titan in previous seasons, however, was not amazing. at the same time, mappa is putting more cg in than before, so i'm not a fan of it. the cgi monster in this episode didn't look good, but they're also probably not going to use a lot of cg, so it doesn't really bother me. |
|
Slick-Mick101 said: The CGI in AOT has been pretty trash tbhAttack on titan is actually good tho |
| You watched it with the perspective of a manga reader. Not everyone read the manga. I personally thought it was enjoyable throughout and nothing was off. Don't worry too much about average scores. There are many anime that I personally think deserve a higher score, but in the end people have different perspectives and standards. |
Opticflash said: I cannot really tell what is good CGI or not. I do not know the sense of urgency from the manga. I do not know the pacing in the manga as I have not read the manga. I do not see a problem with the hunter. I gave the first episode a 7. Others gave it an 8+. u should watch berserk than u can compare with this one haha |
 |
| I liked the cgi,didn't feel off and i'm a no no cgi normally There's much much worse cgi in higher budgets animes so i don't really care for it. |
| Deep dark fantasies |
| You basically are frustrated in one way or another and are presenting your point of view to others as facts. Nothing new here on MAL though. |
 |
| Bruh why do u guys care soo much about cgi like daym |
 |
| I gave the first episode a 5/10 just for Ray and Emma interaction. All of the manga's vibes is kinda gone. CGI monster was a total disaster. And new opening is pretty bad imo |
| Can someone send me a picture and or gif of this cgi monstrosity? I am too lazy to scroll through the entire episode and am just curious. |
 |
| Yea it really isn't an 8 right now. I loved the first season but that whole first half was BORING. Second half upped it a little but it's just too stupid. Realistically 90% of these literal fetuses would have died already. |
| the score is so incomprehensibly high because this show itself is overhyped |
iorn said: It's because of a bandwagon effect. Big shows always get very high scores in just 1-3 episodes (JJK, Dr Stone, AoT, etc.) even if we can't yet gauge how good the season will be. I honestly thought the pilot to this season was pretty underwhelming and deserving of a 6/10 at most, but MAL scores are usually either too generous with big shows, or too low on unpopular shows. For this reason I don't take a series' MAL score that seriously. This isn't as good of an indicator as, say, Rotten Tomatoes. Can someone explain to me how anyone took a look at episode 1 and went? "Yah this is good enough to a 10 or 9." The demon was a CGI monstrosity Any sense of urgency from the manga is just gone. And the episode somehow pacing that's schizoid but somehow manages to feel like it's wading through waist-high water. The hunter looks like a goofy cross between bondrwd's furry form and slender man with his legs cut off. I need to know why. Please help me understand this. |
 |
| Because it just continuation from a Great Series... Simple as that Also don't stress too much about MAL score, even the shittiest Anime you will see people rate it 10 or 9 |
 |
Blblblbl said: Once again, finding out that MAL users are unable to properly use 1-10 scale (even though meaning of each number is explained). I simply assume that if anime is rated x it can be anywhere between x-3 to x to me and I recommend it to you as well. Nah, that score is definitely not for me. Anything that is a 6 is something I would watch but only if I was bored, and since we have so many choices, I do say the same for most 7s. I m not in the business of putting my time here and only mildly enjoying shit, would rather not watch anime then. Would have to go after literal garbage, to give something lower than 5-6. Anything below a 6 for is something I would only watch if I literally had zero stuff else going on, or zero worries in my life. |
 |
~ Trolling Content Thread is always successful ~ |
 |
iorn said: Can someone explain to me how anyone took a look at episode 1 and went? "Yah this is good enough to a 10 or 9." You say that and gives attack on titan final season a 9 if this isnt supposed to be a troll thread then its sad |
 |
praisethevillain said: >Taking MAL scores seriously Stop worrying about glorified opinions and just like what you like m8. This is the perfect reply. Its hilarious that people go out of there way to cry over scores and ratings online like it somehow changes absolutely anything. |
 |
| why is it so difficult for you to comprehend the concept of having opinions? what makes your opinion of this season actually matter? why are you getting so mad that someone enjoyed something more than you? |
| E3 2077 The elderly Todd Howard waddles on stage, he's breathing heavily, he looks like he could die at any moment. He presses a button and whispers "enjoy fallout 5". He collapses. Suddenly warning sirens go off, the conference hall closes off. A explosion is heard in the distance. 200 years later... The first residents of vault E3 are long dead, but their descendants open the doors, it was exactly like Todd had promised. |
| Em, nothing new on MAL tbh. Just look at aot fans clicking 10 after 1 ep xD and other series starting with high score and ending with 1-1.5 lower one. Just wait... |
HypJii said: why is it so difficult for you to comprehend the concept of having opinions? what makes your opinion of this season actually matter? why are you getting so mad that someone enjoyed something more than you? Comprehension of the opinion not having the opinion. Since I have a colorful collection of people on this thread I decided I'll answer them all here. Aside from the statements I really don't care about. I'll 6 words at max for each. praisethevillain said: >Taking MAL scores seriously Stop worrying about glorified opinions and just like what you like m8. That's an assumption. I don't care. HelProcks said: Just focus on what you like smh, everyone has different opinions I know that and I do. rizqy96 said: You watched it with the perspective of a manga reader. Not everyone read the manga. I personally thought it was enjoyable throughout and nothing was off. Don't worry too much about average scores. There are many anime that I personally think deserve a higher score, but in the end people have different perspectives and standards. Some standards are low. Pro_Bokuto_simp said: just rate it what you think it should be rated. If someone else rates it a 10, well then that’s just them. It’s not like scores matter that much anyway, if you like the show, you like it, if you don’t like the show, you don’t like it. Why do people have to make these stupid threads in the first place?? I see them with aot s4 as well For discussion. kirb45623 said: iorn said: Can someone explain to me how anyone took a look at episode 1 and went? "Yah this is good enough to a 10 or 9." You say that and gives attack on titan final season a 9 if this isnt supposed to be a troll thread then its sad It's sad that you would respond. Kinhyouzoku said: Em, nothing new on MAL tbh. Just look at aot fans clicking 10 after 1 ep xD and other series starting with high score and ending with 1-1.5 lower one. Just wait... Not my argument. HypJii said: why is it so difficult for you to comprehend the concept of having opinions? what makes your opinion of this season actually matter? why are you getting so mad that someone enjoyed something more than you? -kicks todd in the mouth- ------------------ Sadly the six-word rule keeps me from further expressing myself. If only it didn't exist. Mod Edit: Merged duplicated posts; please use the edit button. Mod Edit: Removed quote of deleted post. |
KuniiJan 21, 2021 6:18 PM
| I've surpassed your limit! |
praisethevillain said: >Taking MAL scores seriously Stop worrying about glorified opinions and just like what you like m8. this ^ and also i'm pretty sure once the anime ends the score will be at around where season 1 was maybe a bit lower because people who have watched s1 will most likely also like s2 so there will be lesser people in general who will give it a bad rating. another thing is judging from episode 2 pacing will be normal most likely so that won’t be an issue. maybe you should’ve not watched it from the start if you’re that critical about it that you created a fucking thread about the series' score. Jeez some peoole don't know what to do with their spare time. |
More topics from this board
» Does this anime have the most wasted potential?aod-kun - Mar 10, 2023 |
25 |
by 7k72
»»
Apr 11, 6:19 AM |
|
Poll: » Yakusoku no Neverland 2nd Season Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )KANLen09 - Jan 28, 2021 |
419 |
by chocomayu
»»
Mar 7, 1:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Yakusoku no Neverland 2nd Season Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Mar 18, 2021 |
244 |
by Yanarsen
»»
Mar 5, 3:27 PM |
|
Poll: » Yakusoku no Neverland 2nd Season Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Mar 4, 2021 |
220 |
by Yanarsen
»»
Mar 5, 2:45 PM |
|
Poll: » Yakusoku no Neverland 2nd Season Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 25, 2021 |
505 |
by Jiborjas
»»
Feb 15, 2:28 PM |