DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Not every production is a masterpiece even if it's done by a master. So, this is Maeda's worst one? Okay then. I think he deserves another chance. But 12 episodes are not enough. Maybe 13... Or 24, screw it. --- The mistake on this show, IMO, was the following: things a little bit apart from reality. People get touched by things that can happen to them. Or, at least, things that can happen commonly. I mean in the sense of physical things. Spirituality is another thing and works well. Brain chip... wut. |
niko_sbDec 26, 2020 1:12 PM
 |
Fario-P said: Oh my god I had the same thoughts too! Legit thought Hina was gonna get killed off and the whole episode just reminded me of Air... god I should get to rewatching that soon, so underappreciated. I KNEW YOU WOULD. XD For reals, that whole scene with Youta and Hina was EXACTLY like Then I thought she might die as she ran to Youta, I thought she might die as she walked to him during the filming scene....and they kept faking us out. xD |
  |
| Wow... Maeda and Key sure hit a new low with this anime. I'm not sure if Maeda wanted to use his personal experience (if I remember correctly he did a heart transplant?), but it didn't work. They shold go back writing Visual Novels with the appropriate time to build the story. |
AdrianRubinskyDec 26, 2020 1:24 PM
Chiibi said: Fario-P said: Oh my god I had the same thoughts too! Legit thought Hina was gonna get killed off and the whole episode just reminded me of Air... god I should get to rewatching that soon, so underappreciated. I KNEW YOU WOULD. XD For reals, that whole scene with Youta and Hina was EXACTLY like Then I thought she might die as she ran to Youta, I thought she might die as she walked to him during the filming scene....and they kept faking us out. xD FMmatron said: @Chiibi @Fario-P That comparison with Air is very legit, was low-key kinda afraid as well. LEGITTTTTTTTTTT!!! That scene still makes me feel hurt. Those damn fake-outs too, wasn't scared but I was very sure they were gonna pull an Air on us lmao |
 |
| the trainwreck never stopped after izanami's story ended. totally a waste of some great character designs such as izanami and Hikari Jinguuji whom was utilized on plot only once in a ridiculously boring episode. |
ButtSlapperDec 26, 2020 1:35 PM
Rocksterrock said: or he just can't work in this 12-13 episode format where it seems like he can't write to his best in. This show was the only single cour show he wrote that didn't work for me, though. Some people on this site hate Charlotte...but it was very well-received by its target audience. Kanon, Air, and Angel Beats did fine with just 12 episodes...so I don't think that's an issue for him. Mod Edit: Removed quote of deleted post. |
anime-primeDec 28, 2020 7:11 AM
|
| Emotional final episode. I do wish the build up to this was better. I still wish Yota and Hina's love was more of a sibling relationship because they were practically family with Hina being quickly accepted into the Narukami household. Also, it wouldn't have wasted the episodes building up Yota's long crush over Izanami along with her backstory. Whoever did the music for this anime did a wonderful job. Takaramono Ni Natta Hi definitely gives off an emotional vibe. |
 |
| Yeah, I'm not gonna question this shit anymore and just consume like a happy customer. 5/10, good start but what made it good (the comedy and SoL) went off a cliff in the last few episodes |
ByniavoDec 26, 2020 2:10 PM
 |
| Honestly, this show was great up to like episode 9, after that it didn't feel the same at all. I am glad that Hina got some of her memories of her friends back, she was able to call them by name by looking at the drawings. So atleast we got sort of a happy end. Just don't like how forcefull Yota was in the final 2 episodes. Visuals were good, voice acting was also superb. 6/10 from me, just didnt hit the same as other Jun works for me. |
 |
| The way it's so easy to take Hina from the facility. The way the officer just given up and not even kicked out Yota straight away when they finally realized he was conning them all along. The way Hina suddenly remember Yota's name and her surrounding. The way no one feels anything weird for having dissability person playing a role in an indie movie. Oh Maeda you are having a laugh. |
| I'm too weird to live but much too rare to die. |
2077 said: this anime is definitely my pick for worse this season Really? I think Noblesse was so much worse for being insufferably boring from the first episode. :/ Kami-tachi ni Hirowareta Otoko is kinda boring too. |
|
| It would be actualy good if it had some kind of buildup before maeda tried to turn this slice of life anime into a tear-jerker. The ending is good and satisfying but the lack of suspense and build-up basically killed every sad scene. The largest disspointment from Meade for now. Loved his previous work but god, this is just wasted potential. 6/10. Dunno why people have problem with Charlotte. I realy enjoyed it and my standards are pretty high |
| [url=https://myanimelist.net/animelist/Asdedix147&sclick=1] |
2077 said: Chiibi said: Really? I think Noblesse was so much worse for being insufferably boring from the first episode. :/ Kami-tachi ni Hirowareta Otoko is kinda boring too. yeah those were both boring but they're not as cringe as this shit. like, this show took itself wayyy to seriously, i was cringing and laughing so hard Idk I think a show that's so boring you don't wanna go to episode 02 is far worse than something I can actually watch the whole way through. |
|
| Dang what an ending, what a predictable ending... Honestly I loved this, I thought it was amazing until it hit the half way mark or so. When it hit that mark the shows quality started to downgrade and it was quite obvious to notice it. The only aspect of this show I looked forward to was it's music, every other aspect went Kaboom. I'm disappointed, very disappointed. Final score 5.5/10 > 6/10 I would rate lower but the music was just...amazing. |
 |
| Well, this was a show that happened. It started out pretty great, like a high diver at peak performance, but ended pretty crap, like that diver landing in an empty pool. It's pretty clear that Maeda was so preoccupied trying to make "his saddest work yet" that he didn't think about making anything work logically so it all came out forced. Like the final scene at the hospital. There was no reason for that woman to even have Hina out there. On better terms, maybe, but after Youta is forcibly escorted out by security? Nah... And then they just let him take her home! If they wanted that to be the final scene, why not just have it take place at the end of Youta's 2 weeks? They could have still had some kind of drama but just have it play out differently instead of ending with him being ejected early. They could have even played it up so it would be like she took Hina out there out of respect after Youta trying but failing to get through to her. There were a ton of logical ways to end up with the same outcome. Then Hina is just at Youta's house, surrounded by tons of active people, acting in a movie like it's no big deal when she could barely handle one person at a time at the hospital. Overall, some good characters and a decent premise made the first 75% pretty good but the ending was more annoying than anything else due to the way it tried to force an emotional response without even trying to make sense. 5/10 |
SilentCaayDec 26, 2020 4:00 PM
| Oh man. When that ending song started up, with just the singing - I knew I was in for a world of hurt when the credits began rolling. I don't usually go for the whole 'power of love' schtick but I'm willing to make this one of my few exceptions. With how shit 2020's been, this was the bittersweet, uplifting story I needed. I'm glad Jun Maeda didn't leave me a complete wreck, this time around. Just partially. |
| "The speck of fear grows in your eyes You'll meet your death in no disguise It may come as a small surprise There will be no compromise for you" - Nikopol Lyrics, Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann |
| This was actually the best episode since episode eight and I'm surprised they managed to end this series quite gracefully, even though there's a ton of things to say about that whole mess of a story. |
| Ok well that was the dumbest shit I've ever watched. I've never had to rate a show this low before but after watching this I'm sure in dropping this from a 5/10 to a 2/10. 2/10 because it at least had an interesting premise and some funny moments. I rated it a 5/10 because I thought it was going to have way more development like this... SHE DIDN'T EVEN DIE? Honestly when she fell asleep watching the movie I thought she fucking passed away LOL EDIT: Removed the sentence where I called the anime a waste of time. Was kinda running high off emotions when I first wrote this lol. It was ok to watch to be honest - just really predictable and boring all the way through. |
cryzwatchesanimeDec 28, 2020 4:50 PM
 "You... are truly slothful!" |
| Peoples just went crazy after seeing this last episode. But for me, its just utterly beautiful. It takes a lot of extra courage to accept people with special needs like Hina. As Youta perspective, and his current age, its really hard to received such an information. By that kind of ending, its confirmed how lovely their bonds could overcome anything. Thats the miracle, whatever its form, i appreciated it until the last second. However, i am still not denying any unnecessary stories elements that sometimes ruined most of the peoples mood. I can't described that much. You can already see it by some other peoples. However, i am still a rookie, that always came to a positive conclusion over this kind of show. And for me, that kind of ending, satisfied me much, no matter shit the rest of it. Describing this kind lines might be biased. So, i don't care for the rest of everyone else thinking: Story: 6 Art and animation: 8 Sounds depts: 8 Characters: 8 (Last scenes confirmed how much i am liking the main characters. No bullshit. Even the side characters were lovely, especially with Izanami. And one of the tools, Suzuki, was also quite respectable at the end of my last decision. At the end, for this kind of show, i am ignoring every shit and concluded the characters are simply lovely.) Enjoyment: 9 (Simply that kind of ending was the best route beyond everything. And him, walking through the landscapes, as how they accepted each others conditions, its just well received for me) Overall: its 8/10 for me (+1 bumped up, cause Hina's sick mode is too cute to resist >°<. Always happy, y'all. Then someone, please help Hina remembering that his name is YOTA not YOHA. God must be damn about that xd.) Kinda expect more epic conclusion. Guess, this is just too good to be true. So, its still enjoyable. My keynote is just two sentences: the saddest part of that was not its sad elements. But, to knowing how hard they accepted their lovely end. As far as i am concern, its a nice words, whoever made that lovely provocative sentences. I don't even know who, but its really affected. Its give this show lot of attention its needed xD. |
 Hide and seek is the best offline games on this fatamorgana-called-world-thing. Please comment nicely. I am newbie here. I'm level  on mal-badges. View my badges  |
This show in its end moment did the same thing while having an additional Karma MV integration as the movie in this show which did the rework on its predecessor. While this show may not have appeased to Jun Maeda's past masterpieces, it did shine on the redemption of Yota's way of living. I would have hoped if the plot would not just focus on a single pair of characters but delved into most of them (which they did with Izanami and Suzuki though failed on Jinguji's term). If the plot would have moved so, this show would have had an amazing conclusion. Though this ain't so bad either. 7/10 Mod Edit: Added spoiler tags; please hide plot details. |
anime-primeDec 28, 2020 7:06 AM
When someone asks me why I like anime, I'd say Just Because. |
| fucking called it and it really did turn out to be Charlotte 2.0 but somehow worse Jun needs to stick to doing comedy or a SoL its what hes been best at outside a few key works this show was a good time till it jammed what little plot it had brewing at the end and it's laughable calling this the saddest work yet really don't forcing your way onto someone that has suffered trauma or mental illness but our boy yota "proved" /s you can just yell and it'd work out in the end! 5/10 would only rate it a bit higher for my long PA works bias to their visuals and the character designs and music were nice |
 |
| Well, that was a bad ending. From episode 8 onwards the anime became cringey asf. That last scene where they show the movie, God that was awful, I was laughing so hard such a bad ending. Jun Maeda said that this would be the saddest anime he ever made but WTF this shit is trash and Cringey to watch. |
 . |
| Well it was fun, lots of problems in the story and characters but still fun. But.....welp, Jun Maeda you need to get your animes more lenght for the development or go back to do Visual novels. 6.5/10 |
 |
| This had to be the worst anime I have watched this year, and probably one of the worst period. Never once have I felt sad, how can I sympathize with these characters that I barely get to know? Plus so many random plot points, it is just overall messy. I forgot that the hacker man and CEO plot point is just so random, what was the purpose? What a waste of my time. I thought this series had potential when I watched the first episode but I was dead wrong lol. Anyways, saddest anime ever? Was that bait? Yep. |
 |
| And with this, the biggest disappointment in anime history is finally over. 4/10 Now we can focus on the good animes this and next season again. Higurashi, AoT, Nana :) Guess we can't expect any BIG animes from you anymore like Angel Beats or Clannad, Maeda-kun... |
| That was sad I guess since it finally ended but with a happy ending, we couldn't get to see Youta x Izanami lol. |
 |
Mohammadalmannai said: This had to be the worst anime I have watched this year, and probably one of the worst period. PFFFFFFT Everything you watched must have been a 10/10 then...this wasn't even that bad and I promise you many shows this year were way worse. |
|
Chiibi said: Mohammadalmannai said: This had to be the worst anime I have watched this year, and probably one of the worst period. PFFFFFFT Everything you watched must have been a 10/10 then...this wasn't even that bad and I promise you many shows this year were way worse. This guy surely never watched Gibiate, which aired during Summer 2020 season. Absolute worst shit of the year for sure. |
 |
| I actually really liked this show. Glad she didn't die at the end too. |
 |
| I can't feel sad, even at the lowest degree. This show was pleasant for its comedy aspect but the emotional part didn't convince me. A waste honestly, the overall construction just seems misbalanced, it never succeeded in giving that drama/tragic vibe. I'm still giving it a decent grade but surely not for the last 3 episodes. |
|
Chiibi said: Mohammadalmannai said: This had to be the worst anime I have watched this year, and probably one of the worst period. PFFFFFFT Everything you watched must have been a 10/10 then...this wasn't even that bad and I promise you many shows this year were way worse. Not OP but yeah it defintely wasn't the worst anime this year. Just incredibly underwhelming and mediocre if you compare it to Maeda's other works. That's why I rated this one so low. I usually rate by enjoyment so that ending completely killed off any enjoyment I experienced from the show LOL |
"You... are truly slothful!" |
cryzwatchesanime said: Just incredibly underwhelming and mediocre if you compare it to Maeda's other works. Can't argue with that part...."underwhelming" is a fitting word. |
|
| ok that was a meh ending in my opinion, was expecting something more sadder. i really liked story until the ending ruined it for me 6/10 |
 |
| Easily the worst Jun Maeda show I've seen to date. Calling it a mere disappointment is an understatement! 2/10 |
 |
| Touching... but not soo. This was like Charlotte 2.0, but not a good story one like Charlotte😔 I'm really cried for the last 10 minutes, but didn't get any sad end vibes like Jun Maeda sensei promise. Sad story, happy ending. a solid 8/10 Oh... 1 thing. They choose Takaramono ni natta hi as an ED was right to the spot. I can get the feel sad vibes. |
LegoloS21Dec 26, 2020 8:03 PM
 |
| Hina is alive and she is better than some unfortunate characters... Nope. not the saddest anime from Jun Maeda for sure. When Hina is calling for 'Yoha' name and started to speak more scene do made my eyes teary a bit but that's all. Youta said he wanted to become like Hina's grandfather, hope he won't create another chip or he will just repeating the same tragedy all over again. Youta and friends didn't mention about Hiroto at all, poor Hiroto when he's the one that telling Youta about Hina whereabout before... Overall, I only can say, this anime is not successful like Jun Maeda another works. |
 |
| I think that was a decent ending but, the episodes preceding it didn't really do a good of a job building up this ending properly. Hina was a good character as well as the other supporting characters, Yota is eh for me. If it had more episodes for proper build up and showcasing the characters more, I think it would have been better. It's not the saddest anime ever by a long shot but, it was still kind of sad. The show didn't do much of a good job in making us care for the characters, I like Hina but, not enough to be destroyed emotionally by her condition. Though I still somewhat enjoyed the show overall. 6.5/10 |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Kamisama ni Natta Hi Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Nov 7, 2020 |
196 |
by euphoricoddball
»»
Feb 1, 5:32 PM |
|
» Please give this Anime a Chance!RjtheGreat14 - Sep 6, 2022 |
39 |
by Daekesh
»»
Dec 30, 2023 6:53 PM |
|
» Why do people dislike this anime ? ( 1 2 )kaiki_fan_boy - Dec 29, 2020 |
92 |
by HabteG
»»
Nov 24, 2023 3:43 PM |
|
Poll: » Kamisama ni Natta Hi Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Dec 19, 2020 |
171 |
by ggultra2764
»»
Nov 21, 2023 11:26 AM |
|
» Does anybody else really hate Hina?BirbSMB - Jun 28, 2023 |
16 |
by kyuteillusion21
»»
Jul 1, 2023 7:21 AM |