Normal Game V10: Rainbow Six Siege (Red Faction Wins!) Epilogue out!

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

wen294 said:

AbuHumaid said:

does it have to be 3? Cuz i don't town read that many right now

Dude the numbers aren't really what's important here, we want stuff to work with concerning you. We haven't really gotten anything like that from you.

get em...let the roast begin.

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 12:28 PM

#1752

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

SuzakuTsubasa said:

yurkin said:

pfft lol maybe what i said d2 wasnt clear enough for you tsubasa?

"pfft"? Indeed seems like it wasn't.

Do you mean this?

can you explain what you mean here in having a hard time grasping what you're getting at?

SuzakuTsubasa said:

yurkin said:
@logic340
Why vote yamin right away after the start of phase? He's probably not even here to answer similar to yesterday.

It's the only post I found on day 2 telling a bit about what you think. With a couple saying how he's going to get replaced anyway.

Vote lynch: yurkin
Then let me ask another question: the usual "who are your top 3 towns and top 3 scums?"

I feel like yurkin made a valid point when's honestly part of the reason I move my vote. That player has done nothing and my vote there was doing exactly that. What's the issue?

logic340Jun 10, 2017 12:55 PM

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 12:45 PM

#1753

yurkin

Offline

Jul 2009

8537

I really want to answer right away but i wanna take some sleep as well. I'll do it in the morning.

Jun 10, 2017 12:48 PM

#1754

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

@AbuHumaid you never answered my question bro?
@Shinichi-kun where are you? You got me doing this yurkin ISO but what are you doing? Also back to Coelestin and Penta why would scum push a survivor lynch so hard when it doesn't seem to benefit their win condition to do so? The more I think about it the more I feel you and I had the anti-town stance there and you not coming to a similar conclusion to that is bothering me?
@Suzune-chan your thoughts on Coelestin please? Shinichi as well?
@grrr what have you learned from your role fishing this game? Who is scum?
@Militus why wont you play with us?
@PTYamin <_<

Also would anyone like to comment or share thighs on my Militu ISO?

logic340Jun 10, 2017 12:55 PM

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 1:17 PM

#1755

Pyromaani

Offline

Jan 2014

9272

Anonymous: RE and Denja are trying to create a lynch ironace as they believe that the mafia will join in. They are trying to narrow down their list of possible suspects by doing so. I believe colestin's thoughts are the better ones and ironace is just fodder right now. I would like to advise not to waste so much of your attention on him. He is basically living his last few breaths. Focus on others for now.

~I am just one sadist who supports friends~

Jun 10, 2017 1:20 PM

#1756

SuzakuTsubasa

Offline

Feb 2014

1628

Sure, I'm not in a hurry. Good night~

logic340 said:

SuzakuTsubasa said:

"pfft"? Indeed seems like it wasn't.

Do you mean this?

can you explain what you mean here in having a hard time grasping what you're getting at?

SuzakuTsubasa said:

It's the only post I found on day 2 telling a bit about what you think. With a couple saying how he's going to get replaced anyway.

Vote lynch: yurkin
Then let me ask another question: the usual "who are your top 3 towns and top 3 scums?"

I feel like yurkin made a valid point when's honestly part of the reason I move my vote. That player has done nothing and my vote there was doing exactly that. What's the issue?

I feel weird that she stayed on him for the whole day 1 and now she says there's no point voting him but doesn't say anything more about what she thinks when we're around half the day phase.
I honestly do feel like she's waiting for the day to pass, since she gives nothing it makes me think of her as a scum. I guess my vote is half pressure too since I really want to hear what she thinks.

Jun 10, 2017 1:29 PM

#1757

Offline

Nov 2008

8506

Not bad anon.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .anime . manga . updates . ♫♪ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Jun 10, 2017 1:52 PM

#1758

Offline

Jan 2014

5989

SuzakuTsubasa said:
Hi~

logic340 said:
@Militus, @SuzakuTsubasa, @PTYamin
Hi I'm logic. I've never played with you 3 before. Do you have any prior mafia experience? Any thoughts on the players who have posted to this point?

I have played several games before, haven't played in a while though.
Since I don't know you either, what is your experience? I don't recall seeing you before so I could assume you started during my break, but I could be wrong.

Right now I'm not too sure.
Shinichi makes me think he's answering posts as he's reading them, which is as usual as far as I can remember.
I see you poking and asking questions to everyone, which of course is a way for town to get info, but I also think that it's easy for scum to look townie day 1 that way, but since no one seem to find it unusual I guess it's your way of playing.
Penta deceived me many times so I'm wary of him.
I don't agree with Grr's idea of mass claiming that early, right now he's neutral to me.
Ironace is new, so his behaviour isn't unexpected, but it's easy for a newbie to hide behind that reason later in the game so I'll be watching what he does starting day 2.

SuzakuTsubasa said:

AbuHumaid said:
vote: logic
knowing how you play, i can't help but distrust you

"Knowing how you play" does that mean he's acting weird or is he just hard to read?

SuzakuTsubasa said:

Karote said:
Vote: SuzakuTsubasa

Name me one scum and one town (not me)

Obviously naming you as town would be too easy.
For now he has only been catching up the thread, but I think Shinichi is acting as usual with his regular posts so I would say he's my best town read.
As for a scum, I'm far from being sure. Grr's mass claim idea still floats in my head as weird. Denja has only posted once and just fluff. These two are the ones I'm the most suspicious about.

logic340 said:
@SuzakuTsubas - What did you learn about me or Abu from your question to him?

I was mostly trying to get info about you from players who might have played with you. Seems like it was quite unsuccessful though since they all say you're "hard to read."
So I guess you're acting as usual since no one raised any suspicion, so back to neutral.
By the way you didn't answer my question about your experience in mafia, or I just missed it?

SuzakuTsubasa said:

Militus said:
Welp, I'd go with the majority on this one.

lynch: Shinichi-Kun

Wasn't this majority mostly made during RVS though?
It doesn't seem like you care about who gets lynched.

SuzakuTsubasa said:

Militus said:

Welp, Shinichi was picked out very quickly and with a majority, second being Abu who people find suspicious because of previous games. If Shinichi dies and is a townie, we can place the people who voted him first and started the trend under mafia suspicion, if he is scum we can clear those people of suspicion for the time being, narrowing our mafia search.

I don't agree with you here.
Town is blind, so when lynching a townie you can't blame everyone on the train.
Scum can jump on a bus against one of their buddies if they're sure he can't be saved.
If scum see a train against a townie is going well, they don't need to jump on it.

Which means you can't blame a train for a mislynch and you can't clean everyone from a successful lynch.

SuzakuTsubasa said:

Militus said:

Pardon me if I don't get the rules? Doesn't the mafia have their own secret chat?

Yes they do. I'm not sure how that makes it different though.
Town can be in a train against a townie, since they don't know who is townie.
If scum see town going for a townie, why would they jump on the train? Even more when you say you're going to be suspicious of the people on the train if the lynch flips town.
If town is going for a scum and nothing can be done about that, why would they stand out trying to defend him?

SuzakuTsubasa said:

logic340 said:

3 out of these 5 have posted a bit. I would like to know why all of are you not voting as yet.
@ironace you have had 22 hours to feel people out and make observations. I need you to tell us what you feel you have learned thus far.
@Shinichi-kun please do not go the entire phase without voting.
@SuzakuTsubasa No one worth voting for yet?

I don't have any real scum feeling here yet.
I rarely vote on day 1, mostly because I don't feel confident enough on my reads. If one of my suspicions grows enough I may vote, or if there's a tie to break (even more when the tie leads to a no lynch.)

wen294 said:
C'mon Tubacabra, use your voting powers!

Haha so the name is decided.
I have to agree that seeing "Suzu" in a post can be confusing.
When you say it that way it makes me feel a bit guilty to not have voted yet. xD

SuzakuTsubasa said:

wen294 said:
Ah ohkey Pyro, thanks for answering that. That's one worry less.

Yeah i know, but i'm finding Mil's play so far to be so extremely weird that i'm having my reservations. It feels less like intentionally going under the radar and more.... idk.... just messing around. He just gives of the feeling that he's not serious at all. I don't really feel comfortable voting him, allthough i do really want to.

The last time I remember playing with scum!mil he was completely inactive (actually the whole scum team was.) I find his behaviour quite suspicious too, but what bothers me is that he tried to give an idea, which he didn't do last time.
Since I'm not sure how experienced he is in mafia I don't know if he's always lurking like that.

SuzakuTsubasa said:

logic340 said:

3 out of these 5 have posted a bit. I would like to know why all of are you not voting as yet.
@ironace you have had 22 hours to feel people out and make observations. I need you to tell us what you feel you have learned thus far.
@Shinichi-kun please do not go the entire phase without voting.
@SuzakuTsubasa No one worth voting for yet?

I don't have any real scum feeling here yet.
I rarely vote on day 1, mostly because I don't feel confident enough on my reads. If one of my suspicions grows enough I may vote, or if there's a tie to break (even more when the tie leads to a no lynch.)

SuzakuTsubasa said:

Karote said:
@Shinichi-Kun, @AbuHumaid, @DenjaX, @Sleipnirr, @Suzune-chan, @grrr, @PTYamin, @Floofs, @Militus, @PentaFlare, @RE1031, @yurkin, @SuzakuTsubasa, @ironace, @Rinto-kun, @reiynii, @wen294, @Coelestin

Give me your top 3 suspects and I'll possibly put them in a list tomorrow depending which 3 gets the most votes.

Militus, DenjaX, Logic.

wen294 said:
I want Tubacabra to have more of a presence.

That's probably one of my biggest problem in mafia game, I only talk when I have something to say.
I may end up voting this day though, to me Mil was clearly anti-town in his posts. I think a townie acting anti-town is like a scum.

SuzakuTsubasa said:
Since Logic claimed do we continue with the idea and pressure someone else?
I don't mind putting my vote if you think it'll help.

SuzakuTsubasa said:
I don't see the point in voting Logic as long as no one counter claim
Vote lynch: reiynii

SuzakuTsubasa said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

wrong cause in an open setup no ones gonna counterclaim this early its suicide and stupid for town to out themselves to catch mafia.

But I still don't see the point in voting someone who claimed as long as there's nothing to prove it wrong. If the claim is fake it'll be revealed sooner or later.

wen294 said:

Hm? Why? Did you get what you wanted? If so what was that? Cause i haven't noticed much that could sway your opinion tbh so i don't get where this is coming from.

I was voting him because of his vote on logic.
As long as nothing comes to say he lied, I don't see any reason to lynch him.

Vote lynch: Militus
I'm not sure if I'll be back around phase change so I'm placing it here like I said. His posts were clearly anti-town to me. And he doesn't seem to come back today.

SuzakuTsubasa said:

logic340 said:

those two and PTY.
Also I know Suzaku has posted some but I don't really have an impression. Offering their vote for claims is about all I remember?

I guess I didn't do much more day 1.
I offered to vote to help put pressure on people if we followed Penta's plan (though I never intended to end the day with a pressure vote.)
I voted for Reiynii when he voted for you.
Then I voted Mil.

wen294 said:

Yeah Tubacabra has been amazingly underwhelming so far :
I mean i haven't played with him in a year or so but from what i remember he was pretty okey?
Well that was my first game and like i said long ago so yeh not like that holds much water. I can't really meta read him unfortunatly.

I may not be as active as I used to be, even though I'm trying.
I haven't played mafia in half a year, my last game was in October. I may be a bit slower to read and react.

logic340 said:
RE asked a question yesterday that I'd like to revisit. ironace was leading the vote and garnered suspicion from most yet no one had him in their "Captain's list" why is that?

Maybe they thought he was going to get lynched anyway? When Karote asked for the list, Iron's train was quite big if I remember correctly.

logic340 said:
@AbiHumaid, @Militus, @PTYamin, @SuzakuTsubasa, and @ironace I don't do this often but I want reads from you five. Top 3 Town and top 3 mafia. They dying have to be correct but I want to know who you feel the easy you do about each. We need to see how you all are thinking.

@Rinto-kun cine bake some observations and then drift back into obscurity.
@Suzune-chan thoughts on my #1556 and the ensuing conversation with Shinichi?
@DenjaX your needed on segregation duties stat!

Sure. I'm excluding Karote from any "top town" obviously, and you as long as nothing comes up I don't see why we would suspect you.
My top towns are:
Shinichi, he spent the first day catching up, I was wondering how would day 2 be, to me it's starting good. I don't see him acting in an unusual way.
Coelestin, she seems to be really scumhunting since day 1, her reactions give me a town feeling.
Penta, it's more of a gut feeling, but he feels different from what I remember of scum!penta (I haven't played with him in a while though.)

Top scums are:
Yurkin, has voted PTYamin around the beginning of day 1, then went for quite some time talking about mechanics. When asked about her vote she only said "I don't see a reason to move it" but never gave any reason to have it to begin with. Seems extremely focused on PTY.
Mil, he posted a bit day 1, but nothing useful, just fluff and vague stuff. I'm not even convinced that he has read the thread. I know, as Coelestin said, anti town =/= scum, but I think they can be a threat to town too, since they can take people's attention. Voting for him could be a waste though since we don't know when he'll come back or how he's going to play. I wonder if a night action wouldn't be the right thing to not waste a lynch, like vig shot or cop (maybe cop would be better investigating active players.)

Third one would be Denja, but since he's playing now I'd like to see how he goes day 2 since we haven't seen him day 1.

And I don't think any of grr's claim will be real, so maybe we shouldn't spend too much time on them.

RE1031 said:

I need Militus to post asap. I don't exactly like his gameplay but I think he may be town which is a bad combination.

What makes you think he's town? Is it just because he's "too scummy to be scum"?

Oh, the post ended up bigger than I thought. Sorry about that.

SuzakuTsubasa said:

yurkin said:

pfft lol maybe what i said d2 wasnt clear enough for you tsubasa?

"pfft"? Indeed seems like it wasn't.

Do you mean this?

yurkin said:
@logic340
Why vote yamin right away after the start of phase? He's probably not even here to answer similar to yesterday.

It's the only post I found on day 2 telling a bit about what you think. With a couple saying how he's going to get replaced anyway.

Vote lynch: yurkin
Then let me ask another question: the usual "who are your top 3 towns and top 3 scums?"

How the heck did I miss all of these posts from Suzaku? Just look at these posts guys, they feel sooooo smooth. Suzaku is like town's silent helper. You, I like you.

Jun 10, 2017 2:18 PM

#1759

RE

Offline

Sep 2016

8394

Fine,
vote: Shinichi-kun
Not that I don't think ironace is scum, because I do. He's being seriously uncooperative. Has a vote on me and is now ignoring me. Plus I don't get how a newbie would ever town read yurkin.

@Shinichi-kun , you need to vote. I liked your response to Pentaflare's 'those in danger of being lynched should claim' plan, while I townread Penta, I don't think scum would reject the plan by voting for whoever proposed it (in fact, that was my initial reaction, before I decided to not act on it.) Everything else is too vague for me to use as an alignment indicator.

And now I have a paper to work on, I don't even like my vote right now, but there are some people that require way more time than I have to take down.

...better to be hated for what you are than loved for something you are not.

Jun 10, 2017 2:20 PM

#1760

Offline

Jan 2014

5989

Those are the possibly relevant posts by AbuHumaid which I found which weren't about him saying that his internet sucks. There were also some posts I think where he asked more people whether they think if he's lurking, eh... .-.

Jun 10, 2017 2:26 PM

#1761

Offline

Jan 2014

5989

RE1031 said:
Fine,
vote: Shinichi-kun
Not that I don't think ironace is scum, because I do. He's being seriously uncooperative. Has a vote on me and is now ignoring me. Plus I don't get how a newbie would ever town read yurkin.

@Shinichi-kun , you need to vote. I liked your response to Pentaflare's 'those in danger of being lynched should claim' plan, while I townread Penta, I don't think scum would reject the plan by voting for whoever proposed it (in fact, that was my initial reaction, before I decided to not act on it.) Everything else is too vague for me to use as an alignment indicator.

And now I have a paper to work on, I don't even like my vote right now, but there are some people that require way more time than I have to take down.

Yay, let's vote for Shin-chan
Vote: Shinichi-kun

Jun 10, 2017 2:33 PM

#1762

Grrr

Offline

Feb 2014

4455

I am too tired. I will try to catch up later. But I agree with choine on this one.

lynch: Shinchi He has to be stopped!

Jun 10, 2017 2:51 PM

#1763

Offline

Jan 2014

5989

grrr said:
I am too tired. I will try to catch up later. But I agree with choine on this one.

lynch: Shinchi He has to be stopped!

Just kidding.
Vote: grrr

I think I get it now why your behavior seems so different than in Bungou Stray Dogs. In Bungou Stray Dogs, you were really forceful with your plan. Here, you were just aimlessly trying to get people to claim. There's a big difference.

Jun 10, 2017 2:52 PM

#1764

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

DenjaX said:

logic340 said:

This game mechanic about Perks messes up VCA big time.

I want to promote voting for someone they suspected with reasons because late game will be very difficult. Well Karote can do what he wants lel.

I want trains to be small so we can catch mafia but apparently thats alot to ask for.

Jun 10, 2017 2:53 PM

#1765

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

logic340 said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

I always end up tunneling on him lol and i didn't start seeing him as scum until he went full commando on the survivor

I really see your point because I was on your side of that argument but step back now that it's done and think about it. Go back and look at how much time was left I just don't see this making I'm or Coelestin scummy? If you dot see anything else that says scum I say move along for now we can always come back or I can even hide e behind one of them?

Ur welcome to hide behind one of them to test a theory and i do see your point.

Jun 10, 2017 3:02 PM

#1766

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

logic340 said:
Alright I have reached a stopping point.
I have collected all of yurkin's posts up to here I will finish summarizing, then analyze, and ask questions tomorrow.
I already did a ISO on Militus that no one has commented o or spoke to me about? I wouldn't mind seeing some discussion about that by the time I come back.

@Karote Capitao....what are your thoughts on the players in my D1 town block? And the bubble players grrr and Rinto?

If u can link me the post ill comment on it but i wont go out of my way to ssearch 30 pages for it XD.

Jun 10, 2017 3:03 PM

#1767

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

Coelestin said:
Omg Shin got summoned. I missed your critical posts, hell yeah, that's what this game needs.

His posts struck to me as town instantly from my quick re-read.

I haven't re-read RE's and my conversation but I feel like I understand him much more now. Last night's conversation felt really good.

I am town reading them both now as well @logic340.

Vote: PentaFlare

Gonna answer to all the posts later.

Lol clearly u dont because RE is a she :P

Also why the sudden vote on penta?

Jun 10, 2017 3:04 PM

#1768

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

wen294 said:

Also grrr is full of sheet. Don't believe any of his claims. He already claimed 4 different roles so far if i've counted correctly.
Not sure why Mafia or SK would want to get rid of inactives either. They usually end up as lynch fodder sooner or later.

What why not? Its obvious one of those roles is his, so if u ignore all of them thats not really a town driven action. As town you should be looking into both the town and scum reasons for all his claiming. Maybe then you will figure out which role is his.

Jun 10, 2017 3:12 PM

#1769

Offline

Jan 2014

5989

Shinichi-Kun said:

Coelestin said:
Omg Shin got summoned. I missed your critical posts, hell yeah, that's what this game needs.

His posts struck to me as town instantly from my quick re-read.

I haven't re-read RE's and my conversation but I feel like I understand him much more now. Last night's conversation felt really good.

I am town reading them both now as well @logic340.

Vote: PentaFlare

Gonna answer to all the posts later.

Lol clearly u dont because RE is a she :P

Also why the sudden vote on penta?

I assumed gender, oh crap (<.< ) ( >.>) (°-° ) ( °-°) (._. ) ( ._.) don't scold me pls

I was going to do "I will judge you scummy until you prove me otherwise" to see what happens because I wanted to see what he does when he's under pressure of being suspected but turns out that I don't even know where to start so yeah that was kind of useless

Jun 10, 2017 3:12 PM

#1770

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

Shinichi-Kun said:

logic340 said:
Alright I have reached a stopping point.
I have collected all of yurkin's posts up to here I will finish summarizing, then analyze, and ask questions tomorrow.
I already did a ISO on Militus that no one has commented o or spoke to me about? I wouldn't mind seeing some discussion about that by the time I come back.

@Karote Capitao....what are your thoughts on the players in my D1 town block? And the bubble players grrr and Rinto?

If u can link me the post ill comment on it but i wont go out of my way to ssearch 30 pages for it XD.

you should run into it soon I've linked it like 3 times now.?
edit: fyi.It's one of the first posts on D2 click the D2 link on page 1 and scroll down. It's that simple no need to search 30 odd pages.

logic340Jun 10, 2017 3:16 PM

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 3:20 PM

#1771

Offline

Nov 2008

8506

Shinichi-Kun said:
I want trains to be small so we can catch mafia but apparently thats alot to ask for.

Confirmed town should be the one to get the lynch train.

There is a proposal that I want to share about how the lynch works:

Confirmed town should be the only one to lynch a player, the rest should not vote. If anyone tries to get cute and get those perk, they should be lynched.

This is the flaw that I found about this set-up if we want to focus on monopolizing perks. Town outnumbers everyone so this should be implemented. Since this is still day 2, tombstone is still not in set and we want scum to not get that perk as much as possible.

@Karote what do you think?

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .anime . manga . updates . ♫♪ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Jun 10, 2017 3:21 PM

#1772

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

SuzakuTsubasa said:
Sure, I'm not in a hurry. Good night~

logic340 said:

can you explain what you mean here in having a hard time grasping what you're getting at?

I feel like yurkin made a valid point when's honestly part of the reason I move my vote. That player has done nothing and my vote there was doing exactly that. What's the issue?

I feel weird that she stayed on him for the whole day 1 and now she says there's no point voting him but doesn't say anything more about what she thinks when we're around half the day phase.
I honestly do feel like she's waiting for the day to pass, since she gives nothing it makes me think of her as a scum. I guess my vote is half pressure too since I really want to hear what she thinks.

I'll be fine with this ISO later. I see what you're getting at about her vote. Though to where in at with this iso I wouldn't say she hasn't shared thoughts as I've found a few things that ping me for town yurkin D1. Her interaction with me last night didn't seem like someone who was waiting for the game to pass but I'll keep that thought in mind as I cover over those posts here shortly.

logic340Jun 10, 2017 3:27 PM

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 3:23 PM

#1773

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

DenjaX said:

Shinichi-Kun said:
I want trains to be small so we can catch mafia but apparently thats alot to ask for.

Confirmed town should be the one to get the lynch train.

There is a proposal that I want to share about how the lynch works:

Confirmed town should be the only one to lynch a player, the rest should not vote. If anyone tries to get cute and get those perk, they should be lynched.

This is the flaw that I found about this set-up if we want to focus on monopolizing perks. Town outnumbers everyone so this should be implemented. Since this is still day 2, tombstone is still not in set and we want scum to not get that perk as much as possible.

@Karote what do you think?

me likey. Who do you consider confirmed besides Karote tho?

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 3:28 PM

#1774

Offline

Nov 2008

8506

logic340 said:
me likey. Who do you consider confirmed besides Karote tho?

Karote, you(hider), Perkaholic and 2 who are willing to claim.

So there should be a maximum of 5 confirmed town because it already outnumbers scum combined.

I should have thought about this since day one but i was inactive but I am sure it is still not too late to propose it.

So I actually want the Perkaholic to claim too to confirm that none of the players day 1 got the double voting perk today and make sure they dont attempt to get cute this phase in case they were scum.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .anime . manga . updates . ♫♪ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Jun 10, 2017 3:32 PM

#1775

Offline

Nov 2008

8506

Also, I don't want the Cop, Interrogator, Doc, Bodyguard and Vig to claim.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .anime . manga . updates . ♫♪ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Jun 10, 2017 3:33 PM

#1776

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

DenjaX said:

logic340 said:
me likey. Who do you consider confirmed besides Karote tho?

Karote, you(hider), Perkaholic and 2 who are willing to claim.

So there should be a maximum of 5 confirmed town because it already outnumbers scum combined.

I should have thought about this since day one but i was inactive but I am sure it is still not too late to propose it.

So I actually want the Perkaholic to claim too to confirm that none of the players day 1 got the double voting perk today and make sure they dont attempt to get cute this phase in case they were scum.

I really like this plan. It limits mafia and SK to doing their work at night? I see no reason scum Denja would propose such a plan? Possibility of being best town increases..n

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 3:33 PM

#1777

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

DenjaX said:
Also, I don't want the Cop, Interrogator, Doc, Bodyguard and Vig to claim.

+1 more equity.

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 3:35 PM

#1778

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

Coelestin said:

grrr said:
I am too tired. I will try to catch up later. But I agree with choine on this one.

lynch: Shinchi He has to be stopped!

Just kidding.
Vote: grrr

I think I get it now why your behavior seems so different than in Bungou Stray Dogs. In Bungou Stray Dogs, you were really forceful with your plan. Here, you were just aimlessly trying to get people to claim. There's a big difference.

hmm....after yurkin I should look into this. I thought he felt off early. It might be time to revisit those posts and his?

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 3:38 PM

#1779

Offline

Nov 2008

8506

@Shinichi-Kun @AbuHumaid @Sleipnirr @Suzune-chan @grrr @PTYamin @Militus @PentaFlare @RE1031 @yurkin @SuzakuTsubasa @ironace @Rinto-kun @wen294 @Coelestin

If you are town, you should see my proposal very enticing. If you are scum, you can at least pretend lel xDD

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .anime . manga . updates . ♫♪ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Jun 10, 2017 3:40 PM

#1780

Offline

Nov 2008

8506

logic340 said:

DenjaX said:
Also, I don't want the Cop, Interrogator, Doc, Bodyguard and Vig to claim.

+1 more equity.

That means 2 of either Anon, Rook, Stalker, Blocker, and Omniscient. And we get these replacement in case sheet happens.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .anime . manga . updates . ♫♪ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Jun 10, 2017 3:41 PM

#1781

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

@DenjaX if you guess who I hid behind correctly I'll tell you the truth. Have any guesses?

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 3:41 PM

#1782

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

grrr said:
I am too tired. I will try to catch up later. But I agree with choine on this one.

lynch: Shinchi He has to be stopped!

lmfao freaking grrr honestly if ur town something is seriously wrong with you.

DenjaX said:

Shinichi-Kun said:
I want trains to be small so we can catch mafia but apparently thats alot to ask for.

Confirmed town should be the one to get the lynch train.

There is a proposal that I want to share about how the lynch works:

Confirmed town should be the only one to lynch a player, the rest should not vote. If anyone tries to get cute and get those perk, they should be lynched.

This is the flaw that I found about this set-up if we want to focus on monopolizing perks. Town outnumbers everyone so this should be implemented. Since this is still day 2, tombstone is still not in set and we want scum to not get that perk as much as possible.

@Karote what do you think?

THis i'm willing to do.

RE1031 said:
Fine,
vote: Shinichi-kun
Not that I don't think ironace is scum, because I do. He's being seriously uncooperative. Has a vote on me and is now ignoring me. Plus I don't get how a newbie would ever town read yurkin.

@Shinichi-kun , you need to vote. I liked your response to Pentaflare's 'those in danger of being lynched should claim' plan, while I townread Penta, I don't think scum would reject the plan by voting for whoever proposed it (in fact, that was my initial reaction, before I decided to not act on it.) Everything else is too vague for me to use as an alignment indicator.

And now I have a paper to work on, I don't even like my vote right now, but there are some people that require way more time than I have to take down.

U dont like ur vote on me yet you choose to vote me smh.

Let me fully catch up im still on page 34

Jun 10, 2017 3:42 PM

#1783

Offline

Nov 2008

8506

logic340 said:
I really like this plan. It limits mafia and SK to doing their work at night? I see no reason scum Denja would propose such a plan? Possibility of being best town increases..n

Are you disappointed that you might not be able to catch me as scum this time? xDD

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .anime . manga . updates . ♫♪ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Jun 10, 2017 3:42 PM

#1784

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

Coelestin said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

Lol clearly u dont because RE is a she :P

Also why the sudden vote on penta?

I assumed gender, oh crap (<.< ) ( >.>) (°-° ) ( °-°) (._. ) ( ._.) don't scold me pls

I was going to do "I will judge you scummy until you prove me otherwise" to see what happens because I wanted to see what he does when he's under pressure of being suspected but turns out that I don't even know where to start so yeah that was kind of useless

Penta doesnt really get pressured he just gets mad when people vote him for silly unjustified reasons or when town are blantly being idiots XD.

I still trying to see what he said about the survivor after i questioned his reaction to being ok voting the role.

Jun 10, 2017 3:43 PM

#1785

Offline

Nov 2008

8506

logic340 said:
DenjaX if you guess who I hid behind correctly I'll tell you the truth. Have any guesses?

Uhh. I am bad at guessing and I forgot your townreads xDD So if you confirmed a town from your ability of you hiding without dying, that would be better since that person does not need to claim.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .anime . manga . updates . ♫♪ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Jun 10, 2017 3:45 PM

#1786

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

logic340 said:
Militus

Thoughts:
#414 - These posts always rub me the wrong way no matter the alignment because D1 is actually the day that plays the biggest part in how the game progresses.
#416 - IDK how to read this move as it's something I would expect mafia not to want to do (drawing attention to themselves in this way) but the vote kind of is what I would expect mafia to do (get up on a lead train for easy reasons).
#424 - Similar to #414, I guess with the level of effort they aren't expecting much back.
#425 - Why does they have to jump up on the lead train to do this? No reasons of their own for voting this is a red flag.
#428 - Would be nice if he told us what he wanted to check at some point? Lets see if that happens
#433 - Tells wen he needs a sacrifice to confirm his suspicions, this is extremely anti town an I was sure willing to lynch him for it. If we need a sacrificed then it should be Militus he just tells us what his plan was and we carry it out for him if he flips town. This is how you deal with people who want to sacrifice other you turn their logic on themselves.
#448 and #468 - This is some serious white knighting of AbuHumaid in these posts with nothing to support it.
#482 - I will argue against this as mislynches have lead to very little useful information for town to this point in games I have played. Only good information from a lynch is when it's scum.
#485 - Logic read what they said multiple times and the motive isn't clear.
#503 - I don't like all this talk of lynching Shinichi and Abu when they haven't shared their own views on any of the player base. Sure we can go through the trains but what gives me more information is reading players actual thoughts. Something Militus has avoided doing to this point.
#532 - This confuses me if you though that Shinichi's train was made on purpose why are you voting there.
#536 - This one really chapped me as he answered Coelestin's question earlier saying "why me" and not says that he doesn't remember the question.

Questions @Militus:
In #410 you said you would contribute when you caught up. Am I to assume you never caught up D1? Have you caught up now? and are you going to contribute?
In #428 he says he wants to check something never follows up on it.
In #433 you say you need a sacrifice to confirm something. Was it confirmed with the lynch of reiynii? If not you can be today's sacrifice so tell me you plan so I can carry it out in your stead?
In #485 you asked me to read what you said again. I still don't see a clearly town motive in what you are doing. In fact most of us think it's scummy we just haven't figured out if it's truth in plain sight or just bad town play?
In 532 you said Shinichi's train looks organized and not natural if his train was organized (planned) doesn't that make him not the mafia? So why did you leave your vote on him?
I would really like you to answer #467, it's a big part of the reason I scum read you because you played around instead of answering the question then said in #536 you forgot due to too many other pinging you. While I do feel town take things more lightheartedly than mafia you attitude doesn't say town to me at all. Especially since when it was brought to your attention again you still didn't answer the question.
Are you ready to reveal your "master plan" or was that #601?
In #601 you tell Karote you might be 3rd part well since reiynii flipped frost that would make you the SK. Also if you are town trying to cause confusion and suspicion is what Mafia want to do so you will get yourself lynched quick if you continue. As of right now I have no issues lynching you and honestly feel you are SK or mafia due to your gameplay thus far.

@Shinichi-Kun @AbuHumaid @Sleipnirr @Suzune-chan @DenjaX @PTYamin @Militus @PentaFlare @RE1031 @yurkin @SuzakuTsubasa @ironace @Rinto-kun @wen294 @Coelestin

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 3:46 PM

#1787

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

DenjaX said:

logic340 said:
me likey. Who do you consider confirmed besides Karote tho?

Karote, you(hider), Perkaholic and 2 who are willing to claim.

So there should be a maximum of 5 confirmed town because it already outnumbers scum combined.

I should have thought about this since day one but i was inactive but I am sure it is still not too late to propose it.

So I actually want the Perkaholic to claim too to confirm that none of the players day 1 got the double voting perk today and make sure they dont attempt to get cute this phase in case they were scum.

Meh i like this plan alot so im actually ok claiming for it, I am the perkaholic aka IQ.I don't know what perk said person got but i do know how got the day 1 perk from the lynch.

Jun 10, 2017 3:48 PM

#1788

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

Shinichi-Kun said:

DenjaX said:

Karote, you(hider), Perkaholic and 2 who are willing to claim.

So there should be a maximum of 5 confirmed town because it already outnumbers scum combined.

I should have thought about this since day one but i was inactive but I am sure it is still not too late to propose it.

So I actually want the Perkaholic to claim too to confirm that none of the players day 1 got the double voting perk today and make sure they dont attempt to get cute this phase in case they were scum.

Meh i like this plan alot so im actually ok claiming for it, I am the perkaholic aka IQ.I don't know what perk said person got but i do know how got the day 1 perk from the lynch.

they got double tap perk. Read the Phase Change post much?

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 3:48 PM

#1789

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

DenjaX said:

logic340 said:
I really like this plan. It limits mafia and SK to doing their work at night? I see no reason scum Denja would propose such a plan? Possibility of being best town increases..n

Are you disappointed that you might not be able to catch me as scum this time? xDD

I am quite dissapointed but still wary as always lol.

Jun 10, 2017 3:49 PM

#1790

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

logic340 said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

Meh i like this plan alot so im actually ok claiming for it, I am the perkaholic aka IQ.I don't know what perk said person got but i do know how got the day 1 perk from the lynch.

they got double tap perk. Read the Phase Change post much?

Oh i didnt read the phase change lol outside of the kill i didnt notice it stated who got the perk my bad XD.

Jun 10, 2017 3:50 PM

#1791

Offline

Nov 2008

8506

Shinichi-Kun said:

Meh i like this plan alot so im actually ok claiming for it, I am the perkaholic aka IQ.I don't know what perk said person got but i do know how got the day 1 perk from the lynch.

So you know who got the perk last day phase but don't know what kind?

If you were to point that said person, would they also attest that you are not full of sheet? We shall see. maybe that person will fess up.

@AbuHumaid @Sleipnirr @Suzune-chan @grrr @PTYamin @Militus @PentaFlare @RE1031 @yurkin @SuzakuTsubasa @ironace @Rinto-kun @wen294 @Coelestin

Anyone wants to counterclaim?

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .anime . manga . updates . ♫♪ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Jun 10, 2017 3:51 PM

#1792

Jackrito

Offline

Apr 2014

10939

Votes so far!

wen294 (1) - (PentaFlare)

ironace (2) - ( Rinto-kun, DenjaX)

RE1031 (1) - (ironace)

DenjaX (2) - (Karote, logic340)

SuzakuTsubasa (1) - (wen294)

grrr (2) - (Sleipnirr,]coelestin)

Yurkin (1)( SuzakuTsubasa)

Shinichi-kun (2) (RE1031,Grr)

Not voting: Shinichi-Kun, AbuHumaid, Suzune-chan, PTYamin, Militus, yurkin,

Time until Night 2!
TIMER!

Jun 10, 2017 3:52 PM

#1793

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

Shinichi-Kun said:

logic340 said:

they got double tap perk. Read the Phase Change post much?

Oh i didnt read the phase change lol outside of the kill i didnt notice it stated who got the perk my bad XD.

we don't know who got it, only IQ and the person who got it should? We hust know what was given out.

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 3:52 PM

#1794

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

The thing is they have a great perk if i out them and they''re town it kinda makes the perk useless don't you think @denjax

Jun 10, 2017 3:53 PM

#1795

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

logic340 said:

Shinichi-Kun said:

Oh i didnt read the phase change lol outside of the kill i didnt notice it stated who got the perk my bad XD.

we don't know who got it, only IQ and the person who got it should? We hust know what was given out.

I assumed that just be an unknown factor of the game welp, i mean atleast now ik what perk the first player got. Also did not even see that spoiler.

Jun 10, 2017 3:54 PM

#1796

Offline

Nov 2008

8506

Shinichi-Kun said:
The thing is they have a great perk if i out them and they''re town it kinda makes the perk useless don't you think denjax

I thought you don't know what kind of perk they received?

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .anime . manga . updates . ♫♪ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Jun 10, 2017 3:54 PM

#1797

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

unvote
Vote: grrr
Let's shake things up a bit
@Jackrito sorry :(

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Jun 10, 2017 3:55 PM

#1798

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

DenjaX said:

Shinichi-Kun said:
The thing is they have a great perk if i out them and they''re town it kinda makes the perk useless don't you think denjax

I thought you don't know what kind of perk they received?

I do lol logic pointed out that the perk given was stated in the night 1 phase post. It was the double tap.

Jun 10, 2017 3:56 PM

#1799

Offline

Dec 2013

17265

logic340 said:
unvote
Vote: grrr
Let's shake things up a bit
@Jackrito sorry :(

vote:grrr

I wanna know why u claimed 4 roles.

Jun 10, 2017 3:56 PM

#1800