Erased
icelizardman said: I think One Punch Man is a much higher quality show in every single aspect compared to this, and many more shows on top of that. As others stated I believe it will do what SnK did in terms of popularity and over inflated scores only to be more fairly and realistically evaluated after the show is over. One Punch Man was purely action with a little comedy. While this show is entirely story focused with a lot of drama. They are completely different in every aspect. |
| I'm a bit worried now that they won't be able to keep up the quality of the visuals, I mean episode 5 looked pretty bland compared to the first 4 |
LauraBirdie said: I'm a bit worried now that they won't be able to keep up the quality of the visuals, I mean episode 5 looked pretty bland compared to the first 4 Episode 5 was made by a 2nd tier studio with a contract, that explain the quality of the episode. For the next the staff will be back, the animation quality will rise.. |
| already top 10 it is unstoppable, can't believe Monster is 20 places behind |
| Already went past Gintama, but im guessing it won't stay up for long, hell, I need to watch it myself. |
 |
gabrielrroiz said: m still trying to figure out why people are on this shows nuts i mean, its not really that unique @___@ yes, i give it an 8/10 story wise, but people are acting as if this shit has never been done before. its kinda just a combination of different elements from this kind of anime but i guess when you've seen as many anime titles as i have its hard to be impressed, and i know most of this site hasn't Dafuq you mean ''a lot'' lol. |
In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. | You know what I hate the most? People who aren't free. They're no more than cattle. |
gabrielrroiz said: rsc-pl said: That 4 episodes already beats in every aspect anime on 1st position :p so yes, especially that most (but not all, there are exceptions of course) anime in top 50 are not worth watching imo. Fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is better than erased in every way and there is no way in hell the remaining episodes will change that Am I the only one that doesn't like FMAB? lol dafuq the show so bad I ain't even watching it anymore |
| In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. | You know what I hate the most? People who aren't free. They're no more than cattle. |
SasukeUchiha said: gabrielrroiz said: Fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is better than erased in every way and there is no way in hell the remaining episodes will change that Am I the only one that doesn't like FMAB? lol dafuq the show so bad I ain't even watching it anymore you most likely like naruto more that is indeed a way better shonen than fmab |
gabrielrroiz said: SasukeUchiha said: Am I the only one that doesn't like FMAB? lol dafuq the show so bad I ain't even watching it anymore you most likely like naruto more that is indeed a way better shonen than fmab I don't like naruto, to be honest I think it's kind of bullshit... but I do like sasuke XD :/ but FMAB is just... what is the right word for this to not piss off people.. it's just fucking terrible. |
| In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. | You know what I hate the most? People who aren't free. They're no more than cattle. |
SasukeUchiha said: I don't like naruto, to be honest I think it's kind of bullshit... but I do like sasuke XD :/ but FMAB is just... what is the right word for this to not piss off people.. it's just fucking terrible. What is so terrible about it? |
gabrielrroiz said: SasukeUchiha said: I don't like naruto, to be honest I think it's kind of bullshit... but I do like sasuke XD :/ but FMAB is just... what is the right word for this to not piss off people.. it's just fucking terrible. What is so terrible about it? The characters are bad, I don't like the magic/Supernatural theme of it, the comedy tries too hard to be funny, The drama between the brothers doesn't make any sense, the stupidity of the characters is damn too high.. like that episode |
| In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. | You know what I hate the most? People who aren't free. They're no more than cattle. |
SasukeUchiha said: The characters are bad, I don't like the magic/Supernatural theme of it, the comedy tries too hard to be funny, The drama between the brothers doesn't make any sense, the stupidity of the characters is damn too high.. like that episode how is the drama between the brothers stupid? they went through one of the most traumatic experiences anyone can pass with the failed transmutation of their mother whom was the only person they care in the world and in the process they lost their bodies so the drama between them is great also the alchemy theme of the series is great it gives a more grounded aspect to the hability various characters have in the series it also important to see how alchemy works as the equivalent of science in the setting and the alchemy unlike the power sistems of other shonen has a fair share of limitations that make asspuls impossible to happen and just because the characters acepted the apologies of the thif forgave and befreind him later that does not make any of the characters stupid as they are not |
lezerman said: LauraBirdie said: I'm a bit worried now that they won't be able to keep up the quality of the visuals, I mean episode 5 looked pretty bland compared to the first 4 Episode 5 was made by a 2nd tier studio with a contract, that explain the quality of the episode. For the next the staff will be back, the animation quality will rise.. Its only that episode? If that is true ill be so happy |
gabrielrroiz said: SasukeUchiha said: The characters are bad, I don't like the magic/Supernatural theme of it, the comedy tries too hard to be funny, The drama between the brothers doesn't make any sense, the stupidity of the characters is damn too high.. like that episode how is the drama between the brothers stupid? they went through one of the most traumatic experiences anyone can pass with the failed transmutation of their mother whom was the only person they care in the world and in the process they lost their bodies so the drama between them is great also the alchemy theme of the series is great it gives a more grounded aspect to the hability various characters have in the series it also important to see how alchemy works as the equivalent of science in the setting and the alchemy unlike the power sistems of other shonen has a fair share of limitations that make asspuls impossible to happen and just because the characters acepted the apologies of the thif forgave and befreind him later that does not make any of the characters stupid as they are not That's your opinion, and I have mine. I respect people for liking it, but it's just not my type of beef. and beside that the extend of what I've seen is 12 episodes. I hope it gets better tho, and not stay this terrible IMO |
| In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. | You know what I hate the most? People who aren't free. They're no more than cattle. |
| I do like the show alot, but its ratting is WAY too high. I see it more as a 8.60 |
 |
MiziTami said: davinci12 said: Doubtful,but itll be nice to see some fucking variety in the top ten. Not half of them being gintama. Unfortunately it'll be rallied with a hoard of fake accounts and artificially lowered by butthurt individuals similar to what is/was happening to after story. Or they could fuck up the second half or the ending which will really damage its score. I SO agree with your post. ~After Story was lowered by fakes? Really? Yeah if you've been around MAL for awhile it's hilariously obvious. |
| I don't think this show even deserves the 9.00 rating. Its really good but lets be real this is not FMAB/HunterxHunter/Gintama level |
Extreme3708 said: Yeah, it'd be like, a low 5 if that was the case.I don't think this show even deserves the 9.00 rating. Its really good but lets be real this is not FMAB/HunterxHunter/Gintama level |
 |
Extreme3708 said: I don't think this show even deserves the 9.00 rating. Its really good but lets be real this is not FMAB/HunterxHunter/Gintama level Don't worry the rating will easily fall as fast as it went up at the end. Not because of the show though. |
 |
| It will be like top 20 or something, but #1 I really doubt. |
LauraBirdie said: I'm a bit worried now that they won't be able to keep up the quality of the visuals, I mean episode 5 looked pretty bland compared to the first 4 Episode 5 was largely outsourced |
Siul-08 said: lezerman said: Episode 5 was made by a 2nd tier studio with a contract, that explain the quality of the episode. For the next the staff will be back, the animation quality will rise.. Its only that episode? If that is true ill be so happy Probably yes, the same happened with Sword Art Online and other animes by A1 Pictures, when a studio don't have time they send for other studios, when one of those studios is bad the quality drop. |
| Anything is possible when Steins;Gate has an average of 9.17 and Noein 7.76. But I saw mention of a NTR ragequit twist and the end predictably disappointing, so probably not. I kinda-sorta understood the OPM insanely high ratings when looking beyond hype excitement. As a superhero comedy-parody, it was something a little different, and it had some nice action animation bits. Less so with Boku Dake-whatever. Especially after ep5, with the average still rising. Nice visuals but uneventful and with some shoddy writing in ep1&5; a deathblow to any murder mystery. I don't care much given I long ago accepted most users of this site are preteen/early teens that 9-10/10 anything remotely decent (and recent/airing, ofc), tho. |
AironicallyHumanFeb 6, 2016 9:09 AM
| I'm so happy about the BokuMachi hype! I really love the Manga and let's be honest, this is an amazing Drama Mystery and the Manga really deserves it's hype by it's anime adaption. There are so many Anime which tried to entertain you. But often I don't like the mix of Drama and Comedy in one Anime. That's why I dropped after 14 Episodes Fullmetal Alchemist (2003). Maybe I will try FMA Brotherhood anytime in future. There are some Anime which are really gems in Anime history like Mushishi, Shinsekai yori, SEL, Madoka Magica and Steins;Gate. I hope BokuMachi will stay being a Masterpiece till the last Episode. And if that's the case then it's irrelevant it's not number 1 in MAl Top Anime list. I hope there will be more serious seinen Anime in future. Maybe a Punpun Adaption? But I'm not sure if any studio could handle such a project. Sorry if my english is not that great. |
| I haven't started watching it, but it looks good. I don't think it'll beat Brotherhood... but I'm hoping it beats Gintama & Steins;Gate, lol. :P |
::End of Transmission:: What have I been watching? Click here and find out on my viewing blog, "Vigorous Viewing" |
AironicallyHuman said: Anything is possible when Steins;Gate has an average of 9.17 and Noein 7.76. Suffice to say that's your opinion, right? Why not keep it that way? Either way, I don't get why bring in and unnecessarily bash S;G on a thread that has nothing to do with it. |
 |
| I don't think so. It's plot heavy and a lot of people seem upset with where the plot goes later on. It'll probably end up like Gangsta. When the final episode comes around, people will be upset the plot didn't live up to what it could (though, hopefully not at bad) and tank lower in ratings. |
 |
| The dialogue for this show feels so bland and unimaginative. "I said that out loud" and "What are you, stupid?" repeated ad nauseam. Really? Also, it feels like the characters offer no commentary on anything beyond the immediate plot. Which is strange given how slowly the plot manages to progress anyway, so it's a loss on both fronts. |
TheDeedsOfMen said: u realize repetition is a common literary deviceThe dialogue for this show feels so bland and unimaginative. "I said that out loud" and "What are you, stupid?" repeated ad nauseam. Really? Also, it feels like the characters offer no commentary on anything beyond the immediate plot. Which is strange given how slowly the plot manages to progress anyway, so it's a loss on both fronts. i feel like if ppl were more educated in literature it would help them understand certain writing styles more |
moodie said: I'm not categorically against repetition, only when it's used badly. The lines felt awkward the first time they were used, and trying again isn't helping.TheDeedsOfMen said: u realize repetition is a common literary deviceThe dialogue for this show feels so bland and unimaginative. "I said that out loud" and "What are you, stupid?" repeated ad nauseam. Really? Also, it feels like the characters offer no commentary on anything beyond the immediate plot. Which is strange given how slowly the plot manages to progress anyway, so it's a loss on both fronts. i feel like if ppl were more educated in literature it would help them understand certain writing styles more |
| According to people there's maybe 3 episodes before the controversial stuff starts happening. So if it continues being well received up to that point it potentially reach Steins Gate #2 position before it starts to drop. |
Ramboll said: Suffice to say that's your opinion, right? Why not keep it that way? Either way, I don't get why bring in and unnecessarily bash S;G on a thread that has nothing to do with it. You are on the internet where people express their opinions. SG is in the top ten. He feel's it is a show that shouldn't be there. If a show like SG can get there, then this show has a chance. SG was the first show I came across that had me wonder why it's so up there. It's an opinion though, take it or leave it. |
| you sound poor |
| I never heard of it. |
Kaioshin_Sama said: LauraBirdie said: I'm a bit worried now that they won't be able to keep up the quality of the visuals, I mean episode 5 looked pretty bland compared to the first 4 Episode 5 was largely outsourced Well that explains it. I wonder why though, I guess four shows in one season is too much for one studio. But then why would they outsource this show (probably their most popular one right now) and not a different show. Let's hope they won't have to do it again, the fact that I'm already invested in the story and characters made up for the lack of atmosphere, but it's moments like the meeting with the foxes and the christmas tree that make the show special for me |
Sury said: People keep complaining about cliché and harm anime, yet when something takes a realistic route, they also whine. Seems like some people won't be happy whichever route a story takes. Kaioshin_Sama said: I still think it's a combination of elements that remind people of Steins;Gate, the teen melodrama (feels), Yuki Kajiura doing the music (MAL considers her and Hiroyuki Sawano to be the undisputed best composers of all time and are probably the only ones most people know or get so hyped up over) and Yuki Aoi (extremely popular heavily pushed seiyu) being the female lead and putting in a solid performance. Just combine all these elements and the fact that it's MAL and it almost makes sense why it's getting pushed this over the top. The show might as well have been designed from the ground up to be mega popular on MAL and with the under 20 demo especially. Quite interesting that Kanno Yoko, which is probably the most popular musician in Japan when it comes to anime isn't as popular as the others here, isn't it? Same goes for Yuuki Aoi. I'm aware she's a popular and award winning seiyuu in Japan, but here on MAL I usually see more people complaining about here voice acting than praising her. Thats cause most people dont even seem to know or acknowledge any composer besides Hiroyuki Sawano or Yuki Kajiura anymore. I never thought in the 90s I'd consider it an unusual event to be able to have a conversation about Kanno let alone literally any composer besides those two but like just nobody is interested in anime composers outside of them. Its ludicrous, like IMO Akagami no Shirayuki Himes soundtrack is outstanding but you'd never know it but you can guarantee Knocking at The Walls of The Fortress will be hailed as an outstanding achievement in anime soundtracks even if its just the same tired vocal riffs and motifs yet again. As for Yuki Aoi I'm not so sure, she seems plenty acknowledged here |
| i love this anime <3 road to #1 |
| honestly i say in a few more eps alot of peoples minds will change about this series |
| "one step at a time" |
| It's only 5 episodes in and it's already number 10. If it keeps getting progressively better like it has been the past few weeks I could see it climbing into the top 5 maybe. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
 This chocolate bar disagrees. |
 |
Ramboll said: AironicallyHuman said: Anything is possible when Steins;Gate has an average of 9.17 and Noein 7.76. Suffice to say that's your opinion, right? Why not keep it that way? Either way, I don't get why bring in and unnecessarily bash S;G on a thread that has nothing to do with it. Lol i know its deplorable butthurt behavior |
MetalxSoldier said: You are on the internet where people express their opinions. SG is in the top ten. He feel's it is a show that shouldn't be there. If a show like SG can get there, then this show has a chance. SG was the first show I came across that had me wonder why it's so up there. It's an opinion though, take it or leave it. Please read what I posted again. It's pretty clear from the words chosen that the the real reason to bring in SG isn't really to say that in comparison Erased has a chance, it is just to bash the show since t's rated higher than his fv. shows. Either way, I very clearly acknowledged it being his opinion. What I said was that it shouldn't really be said in an objective way. Lol, yeah. |
|
| it'll lower, Gintama will triumph once again. Sorachi pulls off more shit than u can handle. Boku Dake is a mystery so if it screws up once there's no turning back lol. Right now it's all hype and cliffhangers keep it up. Even tho I think it's doing pretty solid atm, I can't give it a rating cuz I don't know how it will end exactly. It's not even halfway through. I'mma lol so hard tho when all those 10/10 fanbois get salty at a rushed ending, it will come. But dw, it won't be as bad as Akame ga Kill. johnyjohny said: All those stupid people. Why can't they realize this is the kind of anime that can't be judge on a couple of episodes. The ending in this anime is going to decide everything so there is no use discussing this. |
GenocyberFeb 6, 2016 11:31 PM
 "For the sake of humankind, I forsake my humanity." - Cherry |
Looked at the Wayback machine as I was curious about this myself, but it doesn't look like it crawled it before 2016? Odd. Either way, it looks like it dropped 0.1 since the beginning of *February*, this February, so who knows what it rating was. But I'm pretty sure it was ranked #3 or #4 when I joined MAL. I'm also one of those who's kind of sick of all the battle shonens in the top 10. Okay, Fullmetal Alchemist was a great show, I'll give it #1. Steins;Gate, fine, it's quite different, let it have its spot. Great job for After Story. But what's with all these Gintama clones?? |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 24, 2016 |
1416 |
by Shubhammk21
»»
Today, 12:45 AM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 17, 2016 |
1114 |
by Sun_Chan
»»
Sep 14, 11:01 PM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 10, 2016 |
905 |
by Sun_Chan
»»
Sep 14, 10:41 PM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 3, 2016 |
504 |
by Sun_Chan
»»
Sep 14, 10:18 PM |
|
Poll: » Boku dake ga Inai Machi Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Feb 25, 2016 |
586 |
by Sun_Chan
»»
Sep 14, 9:52 PM |