Maou_heika said: Did you read the Manga all the way to the end?999 said: Ratings don't really make a difference to me, the characters and animation looked so horrible I dropped it after the 1st episode and read the manga instead.You're wrong, though. They outdid themselves adapting the background, and Aku no Hana was the best show of its year. What good marketing, even if the show only caught 400 or so disc sales. |
 |
This is the truest thing I've seen. It was terrible |
| Food is the way to a mans heart. Food wars is the way to mine. 'So long as this world stays nonsensical, there'll be room in it for a nonsensical person like me.' |
| so where's one piece? didnt saw it in this thread? toie shit :D hehehe |
The world is cruel, ugly and pitiful. Let's watch anime and make it colorful |
zal said: I recognize studio Pierrot's name pretty much for shit adaptations. yu yu hakusho was pretty well adapted though even if that is old as fuck it is still worth the mention |
| i could swear this was going to be another berserk topic so i give you props for the surprise op |
gabrielrroiz said: zal said: I recognize studio Pierrot's name pretty much for shit adaptations. yu yu hakusho was pretty well adapted though even if that is old as fuck it is still worth the mention That's why people should learn stop labeling anime with studio for quality. Check the staff's name and the number of artists. Check also the sponsors. |
| Had a feeling this would be a Kingdom thread lol JonasTheJay said: Deknijff said: the manga doesn't really look that nice to me sure its detailed but still not that nice looking also instead of focusing on how good the art looks compared to the manga you should focus on if the story of the anime is good or not because thats what truly matters They skipped entire story arcs in the Kingdom anime... Only one, and it wasn't even really detrimental to the story, which was overall handled really well. Kingdom is the one anime I can think of whose story will make up for any amount of bad CG. |
 |
bottle said: gabrielrroiz said: yu yu hakusho was pretty well adapted though even if that is old as fuck it is still worth the mention That's why people should learn stop labeling anime with studio for quality. Check the staff's name and the number of artists. Check also the sponsors. Weird you commented that because i agree with the labell sure it is a generalization but it is not there are not like thousands of way more inacurate generalization being used constantely Labelling studios is important because of how simple and usefull it is barely anyone will look for information in the entire production before picking a show but having a little information about the studio can be helpfull in the case |
| Anime studio's ruining great manga's it's nothing new. |
Brb said: Most beautifully drawn manga?? Nah, Otoyomegatari has that position. Kaoru Mori is really good but Hiroaki Samura and Ikegami Ryoichi are in a different league. |
 |
Sucks that we'll never have that season 2 adaptation due to the alternative route the anime took. |
    |
gabrielrroiz said: I mentioned it in another reply and I do think it is the best adaptation I've seen of the studio. However those epileptic light sequences were annoying and questionable.zal said: I recognize studio Pierrot's name pretty much for shit adaptations. yu yu hakusho was pretty well adapted though even if that is old as fuck it is still worth the mention |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Johnnyd3rp said: Brb said: Most beautifully drawn manga?? Nah, Otoyomegatari has that position. Kaoru Mori is really good but Hiroaki Samura and Ikegami Ryoichi are in a different league. ...Nah. They're good with realistic and detailed+profound drawing styles respectively, but I wouldn't consider their works "most beautifully drawn". They're artistic, yes (probably more so, but that's a matter of taste) but realism and what not isn't really what's the most beautiful style in 2D. |
zal said: gabrielrroiz said: I mentioned it in another reply and I do think it is the best adaptation I've seen of the studio. However those epileptic light sequences were annoying and questionable.yu yu hakusho was pretty well adapted though even if that is old as fuck it is still worth the mention the epilepctic light sequences were not that bad though if any their usage is one of the reason hiei final fight agains the guy from toguro team who i do not remeber is so memorable |
| Tokyo Mew Mew has gorgeous, adorable art in the manga. But the anime's art isn't so great :/ Then again, the anime came out in 2002 so I guess it is forgivable. |
flannan said: Kerozinn said: kingdom has some truly amazing art. click if you dont care for spoilers kingdom and berserk are prime examples. From these pictures, I'd say Kingdom is just as ugly as a manga as it is as an anime. Not a single cute girl in sight. well there are a few good looking girls but that is simply not that kind of manga |
     Only BERSERK can be compared side by side against KINGDOM arts but, unlike BERSERK this is weekly release consistently since chapter 1. Only HK comic Ravages Of Times is level above KINGDOM AND BERSERK    |
flannan said: Kerozinn said: kingdom has some truly amazing art. click if you dont care for spoilers kingdom and berserk are prime examples. From these pictures, I'd say Kingdom is just as ugly as a manga as it is as an anime. Not a single cute girl in sight. Kingdom has a cute girl though |
 |
| Same old things here. It's not about screwing up adaptions, it's about namecalling anything that looks different than the norm (mostly rotoscoping and 3dcgi). Maou_heika said: 999 said: Ratings don't really make a difference to me, the characters and animation looked so horrible I dropped it after the 1st episode and read the manga instead.You're wrong, though. They outdid themselves adapting the background, and Aku no Hana was the best show of its year. Pippyh said: Aku no hana was ruined by the anime. The manga was beautiful but the anime is just terrible. You can blame the mangaka, it was his vision for the anime to look like this, he insisted on using real actors and rotoscoping because he wanted to achieve a certain atmospheric realism which imo worked out perfectly. I think reducing his work to cute character designs does not do it justice, that's not what it really is about. It's more about the characters, emotions and atmosphere. If the story has nothing of interest to offer to you once the cute designs are gone, I'm not sure you were into it for the right reasons from the start. Personally the appeal of the show was deeper for me than just the surface level of how the characters look. Long story short, the studio didn't screw up the adaption, on the contrary they went out of their way to make the authors vision come true even if it required unconventional means like rotoscoping. I'll never get how people can hate the anime and worship the manga so much, they are both part of the same vision from the same person, just adjusted to their respective mediums. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| I've very rarely seen both the anime and read the manga for something. So far I have nothing to complain about, in fact the anime usually looks much better, especially if we include the rubbish art illustrations in some of the light novels I've read. |
KruszerDec 31, 2016 1:32 PM
| "The name's Gambit. Remember it." -Gambit "X-Men '97"  |
| at least s2 animation wasnt as bad an animation compared to that |
| Sonic X is basically an isekai |
| That... is not beautiful. I just wanted to say that. |
| Not every anime can be (barely) moving art~ Oh, and, uh, Thread Locked "Please refrain from creating threads that do not encourage discussion; e.g. random "xx vs. yy", picture collecting, simple listing, etc." - Rule 2, Anime/Manga Discussion Rules |
More topics from this board
» What makes an anime "Must Watch" for you?TheBlockernator - 3 hours ago |
14 |
by JaniSIr
»»
23 seconds ago |
|
» japans 3dcg aka 3d animation especially mecha should remove choppy framerate like china doesdeg - 57 minutes ago |
6 |
by tchitchouan
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Are there any anime criticism cliches that you always pay attention to?RobertBobert - 8 hours ago |
29 |
by RobertBobert
»»
14 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » In regards to battle shounen, do you want skinny waifus or thick waifus?Catalano - Yesterday |
13 |
by UberBat
»»
15 minutes ago |
|
» Have you ever been to cinema to watch anime movie? How was it compared to watching anime via PC/laptop/TV?Rinrinka - 6 hours ago |
26 |
by themasterseaso
»»
16 minutes ago |