Metacritic For Anime

IMPORTANT NOTE: From this point on, we're going to exclusively use club member reviews (or reviews by people who have given us permission to use their reviews) DISCLAIMER: These scores should not be taken seriously (yet), as we only have 4 or 5 reviews for most of the shows, so there's not much diversity so far. Perhaps when a show has 30-40 reviews, the scores will be more accurate.
--------------> Full List of All Currently Aggregated Anime <--------------
The purpose of this club is to try and create a community of talented writers who would like to make an alternative scoring system compared to the one currently provided by MyAnimeList. Instead of a show being scored by a hundred thousand no-names, we would have the scores for a show coming from well-written reviews by anyone who is willing to participate. All of these reviews will be able to be accessed through our forums, so the mean score for each show will be more personal since you'll know who's contributing and who isn't. FOR THE SAKE OF ORGANIZATION, SUBMIT ALL REVIEWS HERE FROM NOW ON Keep in mind, this doesn't mean you have to be an incredibly critical thinker to contribute, all I ask of you is to have a coherent, grammatically correct review which is at least moderately long. I don't care if you absolutely despise the most loved anime of all time, and I don't care if you love the most hated anime of all time, as long as your review follows the criteria below, it will be accepted. Here's a list of criteria we'd like the reviews to go by: While not required, we recommend at least 800 words per review. If you believe your review is perfect being short, and there's really nothing else you feel you can add, then there's no need to add pointless filler, just send it to us and we'll see if it works. It must be grammatically correct. It should talk about the anime, don't write about anything irrelevant. Try not to ramble. I can let some punctuation errors slide, but make sure it's not too obvious. Provide explanations for your opinions, and do so coherently. Try not to have too much filler or redundant tangents. Try to make the review look professional, jokes are welcome, but no emoticons or slang please. If you're not sure why your review was denied, send an admin a private message and we'll explain. If you believe an accepted review is of poor quality or does not match up to the above standards, don't be afraid to express this opinion, as we're willing to hear your arguments. Your review does NOT need to be on MyAnimeList for it to count, that's only if you want it to be. These ideas are based off of the site Metacritic, which aggregates professional reviews for film, television, video games, and music. Their site: This is pretty much what each thread will look like If you want your current score for a show to change, let us know. MAL only lets you score using whole numbers, and there is no 0/10 option. However, we won't restrict you like that. If you see a review you made, and want your score to say 7.5/10 rather than 8/10, or if you want it to show 0/10 rather than 1/10, let us know. Weekly Review Shows: Inactive Current Panel: AndoCommando Artrill CodeBlazeFate NothingReally RoryBurrows Werty800 ZephSilver If you see your review somewhere on these forums and do not want it to be there, please contact us and we will remove it immediately.

Club Members

Club Pictures
No pictures have been uploaded

Displaying 5 of 417 topics | See All
Club Discussion
Koe no Katachi Aggregation
NothingReally - Sep 13, 2017
2 replies by Rawa_Rauf »»
Feb 16, 2021 5:58 AM
Sticky: Review Submissions
PrincessMomonoke - May 21, 2017
26 replies by Plasmatize »»
Jun 6, 2020 3:55 PM
Sanctuary Aggregation
FrozenRoy - Jan 31, 2019
2 replies by RoryBurrows »»
Feb 1, 2020 8:33 AM
Boku no Hero Academia 3rd Season Aggregation
CodeBlazeFate - Jun 26, 2019
0 replies by CodeBlazeFate »»
Jun 26, 2019 8:24 PM
Gosenzo-sama Banbanzai! Aggregation
CodeBlazeFate - Jun 9, 2019
0 replies by CodeBlazeFate »»
Jun 9, 2019 12:33 PM

Club Comments
LIQfilms | May 2, 8:05 PM

LaLeLuLiLo | May 2, 5:52 PM
fell off

CodeBlazeFate | Mar 29, 2021 8:04 PM
At this point, most of us really burnt out on this and honestly, there are almost no decent reviewers left. Everyone kinda left and/or stopped reviewing altogether.

TK8878 | Mar 29, 2021 5:31 PM
With the current state of reviewing on MAL I see clear value in reviving this club, but frankly I don't get why everyone seemed to have floated away or what would get them to come back.

RebelPanda | Mar 6, 2021 2:28 PM
oh first message in a while

@Ikan1a I think most of the members have moved onto Anilist or have gotten too busy to write reviews. If you like this club's idea you should make your own.

Hydre_Ito | Mar 6, 2021 8:08 AM
Konnichiwa everyone! I will definitely start writing reviews soon!
Nice club idea

"DISCLAIMER: These scores should not be taken seriously (yet), as we only have 4 or 5 reviews for most of the shows, so there's not much diversity so far. Perhaps when a show has 30-40 reviews, the scores will be more accurate."

I think 30-40 reviews is pretty unachievable considering the low engagement level this club has...

Hydre_Ito | Mar 6, 2021 8:05 AM
Konnichiwa everyone! I will definitely start writing reviews soon!

Nice club idea

RoryBurrows | Oct 4, 2020 2:43 PM

Club Stats
Members: 352
Pictures: 0
Category: Anime
Created: Apr 29, 2017

Club Admins and Officers
BigSleepMan (Admin)
FrozenRoy (Admin)
Pitzer (Admin)
RoryBurrows (Admin)
Werty800 (Admin)

Club Type
This is a public club.
Anyone can join and invite others to join. Club details, pictures, comments and club discussions can be viewed by any user, regardless of whether they are a member of the club or not.

Club Admins can change the Club Type at any time. For more information on Club Types, click here.

Anime Relations