Statistics
Anime Stats
Days: 128.7
Mean Score:
4.16
- Watching20
- Completed374
- On-Hold3
- Dropped196
- Plan to Watch204
- Total Entries797
- Rewatched28
- Episodes7,759
Anime History Last Anime Updates
Access to this list has been restricted by the owner.
Manga Stats
Days: 3.7
Mean Score:
6.33
- Total Entries50
- Reread0
- Chapters465
- Volumes71
Manga History Last Manga Updates
Access to this list has been restricted by the owner.
All Comments (619) Comments
I've wanted a low COTE review for a long time, and thank you for granting one onto the front page of MAL.
In my opinion, these are my opinions for putting it at a 2/10 for me:
First of all, to clarify something, I am reading both the manga and LN of Classroom Of The Elite, so to anyone who disagrees with me, I am fine with it, but I am only clarifying that so that I am telling any COTE anime lovers out there that I've read COTE and knows the standards of COTE
1. They really just botched the timeline, don't get me wrong, I understand some animes need to branch out from the source and expand the episode count a bit, but it's way different for COTE. COTE was meant to be watched/read in the order of how COTE handles it, especially since year 2 came out, messing up the timeline means messing up the history of the series, therefore, making the future adaptations probably way worse than they should've been
2. The "beach" episode, episode 7, the episode itself is a mistake, it was neither faithful to the LN nor does it serve a purpose as a nearly anime-only episode(It does make references to a certain extent, but it gives the feel of an anime-only episode due to the poor writing and direction)
3. Some parts were edited out(From what I can guess, it's probably due to time constraints of each episode), even though all the scenes that were not adapted were minor scenes that are not really important for the plot, that is where the problem lies, taking something away from the source means that the adaptation is already taking a different turn, or at least in a direction that isn't how the author viewed it. The plot without those scenes felt lacking, and overall the character development scenes just didn't give off the same power as the LN.
The only reason I even put it at a 2/10 is because of the opening, the opening was a banger tbh.
It fell short at some places but still pretty damm good nonetheless I respect your opinion
There's a reason why it's ln sales have been one of the highest in Japan
either this dude a massive fatty who drooling over waifus or he likes a whimpy tropes mc
Maybe you and those ppl drop animes after watching only 2/3 ep! lol