I'm not the sort of person who can spot many flaws, plot holes or general mistakes unless I'm at the point where watching a show just makes me annoyed, although I actively try to avoid that nowadays.
When I'm watching something, I usually try to find stuff that I can think about even after the show ends, so I can come back to them and get something positive out of that, as well as things that can inspire me and help me elevate myself as a human being.
I try to enjoy my own style of watching, I'm extremely biased and lenient. This doesn't mean I won't change though. I can be hypocritical and I often change opinions, even on a whim. Ultimately all that matters to me is that I enjoy things as much as possible without acting fake, squeeze the most out of everything, as well as hopefully share positives without doing a disservice to the product.
As to what my scores mean, it's sort of a "how much would I recommend watching this show" thing. I know what I think about the show, and I'm sure as hell not trying to explain everything through a number. You can always ask me if you want a more detailed explanation of it. This matters most in the 4-6 area, where it gets really close and there's realistically only a few things that differentiate one from another. If you just come on my profile and check my scores, I'd say you can still have a pretty good idea of my preferences though.
Every score has its own story.
I've achieved this insane number on the 4th of June 2017:
Biggest Anime marathon (watched in one sitting): The entirety of Baka to Test to Shoukanjuu, Baka to Test to Shoukanjuu Ni and Baka to Test to Shoukanjuu: Matsuri, 28 episodes total.
100th anime completed: Shokugeki no Souma: Ni no Sara
150th anime completed: Super Danganronpa 2.5: Komaeda Nagito to Sekai no Hakaimono
200th anime completed: Mobile Suit Gundam
250th anime completed: Sword Art Online Movie: Ordinal Scale
300th anime completed: Paulette no Isu
350th anime completed: Super Mario Brothers: Peach-hime Kyuushutsu Daisakusen
400th anime completed: Daishizen no Majuu: Bagi
450th anime completed: Yama no Susume
-Tales Of Zestiria
-Mass Effect 3
-Zelda The Minish Cap
-Zelda: Ocarina of Time
-Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory
-Prince Of Persia 2008
-Any Pokemon game
-Megaman Battle Network series
-Portal and Portal 2
-Mario And Luigi Superstar Saga
-A Hat In Time
-Slay The Spire
-Enter The Gungeon
-Dark Souls I, II and III
I also watch others, but I watch these channels the most currently.