Statistics
All Anime Stats Anime Stats
Days: 136.2
Mean Score:
4.96
- Watching2
- Completed486
- On-Hold11
- Dropped123
- Plan to Watch59
- Total Entries681
- Rewatched70
- Episodes7,850
All Manga Stats Manga Stats
Days: 24.4
Mean Score:
5.93
- Total Entries158
- Reread0
- Chapters3,774
- Volumes419
Manga History Last Manga Updates

Umineko no Naku Koro ni Chiru - Episode 5: End of the Golden Witch
Dec 4, 12:12 AM
Reading
22/27
· Scored
8

Umineko no Naku Koro ni - Episode 4: Alliance of the Golden Witch
Nov 19, 4:11 AM
Completed
29/29
· Scored
8

Umineko no Naku Koro ni - Episode 3: Banquet of the Golden Witch
Oct 24, 2:41 PM
Completed
22/22
· Scored
8
All Comments (1737) Comments
I feel like limiting it to only series and movies makes more sense, unless we're talking about fully ova series.
Idk, I'll think about it, thanks for the suggestion!
I will add it to the stack right away, would you recommend the show?
I agree about it being engaging, but for me the series was better in the beginning than in the later arcs (like, WAY better). For me it just went downhill after each new season. It's very complicated when something that is based entirely in questions don't have satisfying answers (and I would consider that an euphemism for AoT)
I don't think the shonen/nekketsu tropes by themselves are the problem, but how everything is executed. The show is constantly melodramatic and the characters are constantly screaming... over nothing. Sometimes, it's so exaggerated that makes the scene comical (especially in the manga, there it seems that you don't have a single normal conversation without the characters screaming). Like, in the very first episode when that woman knows about her son death. The characters scream a lot, the screen shakes, like it's the most important twist in the entire story, but... you just don't care, you don't know who these characters are, at that point you don't even know what a titan is. It's a lot of melodrama over something that the spectator doesn't care about. Very different than Eren's mom death scene (and way more exagerated btw).
I think the audiovisual qualities where amazing in Wit studio, but got weaker when mappa started adapting it (most because they used the same and horrible character design from the manga, that makes the thing just more caricatural than it was)
Completely agree about the character writing. Especially in this kind of story, characters need to be well written, otherwise, you won't care a bit when they die. Still, I like some of them, but I wouldn't consider them "good" by any means.
I don't think the problem of the ending is necessarily what happens, but how the work portrayed it. Besides being based on a sea of bullshit, plot holes, ex machinas and a lot of plot armor in a Darling in the Franxx and Another level, I also think it uncharacterized some of the cast and dealt with its themes in a very poor way. I mean, it's not cool when you relativize a global genocide saying it was for his friends and, by the work's vision, justifies his acts, with every important character forgiving what he did. "Thank you for becoming a mass murder for us" - the biggest pacifist in the entire story. It's just off character for me (although I think they changed this in the anime).
And not to mention Mikasa's character conclusion, everything involving Ymir's past, the final fight, everything being just a big time paradox, how horrible that group was formed and "only Ymir knows". All of this makes, not just the ending, but this entire final arc a big bag of dogshit for me. I agree about it having good ideas and being brave, but of good ideas, Hell is full.
And that's sad, since I used to love this thing some years ago (and I still like the first seasons a lot, even not finding then as good as before)
how are you?
Yesterday, 5:32 PM
Completed 2/2 · Scored 5
Have to say, I thought you would give this a lower score.
Did you already know how the ending was?