Kotonoha no Niwa

I was completely bewitched by this movie. Sure, it's quite short so the story is rather simple and concise but for me it's like a signature of director. Makoto Shinkai once again proved that he is a genius of short forms.

Writing review for something that you love is fun, but may be not very interesting for a reader. I could just write "everything was perfect". Because for me it was. Of course not everyone might enjoy the show. Its completely normal. Each of us has different perception. But if you like slow pace, stories focused on conversations and nuances then you will love it, ... too.

I read many reviews and I must confess that I am surprised how often people write that the age gap between protagonists is distasteful.
I believe it is a mark of our times that each relationship is sexsualised. There is absolutely nothing in the movie that would suggest that kind of relation between main characters and yet it's an issue that appears frequently. For me it's only natural that two lonely souls might find consolation in each other company. Just as natural that 15 year old boy can fall in love for it.

What I like most in Shinkai's movies is ending that doesn't serve us all the answers on the silver tray but leaves viewer with the situation that is open. We can interpret the story freely since its not closed. Each of us can imagine different scenario for their future.

In my opinion the best Shinkai's creation. If I had written this 10 years ago, I would have written that I am waiting for more works like this.
Unfortunately, it's 2024 and I know that no such thing has happened. Movies that followed this one are different and I can't say I like that change in Shinkai's direction. I hope he will yet return to creating enchanted worlds like the one he invited us to in Garden of words.

The garden of words is an anime with a beautifully animated environment which along with its sound can make watching it into quite the experience. The story however I liked less and is the reason is can't recommend it to everyone.

The story is a story is 40 minutes long and you experience along with the characters. There is no clearly defined goal or purpose but you just follow the characters and their interactions, simply experiencing where the story goes. The story is mostly about two people meeting in a garden on rainy mornings where they then interact. Initially you barely know anything about the ... characters which can make this interesting to watch. The story ends in a somewhat inconclusive manner.

The characters are interesting, both clearly having their own life going on. Them meeting and interacting can be fun. Some of the actions the characters take in the later part of the movie are human but not well thought out and I didn't enjoy watching it.

The animation of the environment was, as stated before, beautiful. The art of the characters however didn't match this at all and was pretty standard animation. The characters also sometimes had weirdly coloured outlines which was occasionally slightly jarring. The music and sound were good but didn't always match the scenes, though I guess that's a good thing considering how much it rains in the anime and how deafening the rain can be.

Overall this is a pretty beautiful anime that can be unique experience and may resonate with certain people. Personally I didn't like the story, romance, actions of the characters and inconclusiveness at the end which is why I can't recommend it to everyone.

A vapid portrayal of forbidden love and loneliness, paired with hollow imagery and feet for some reason.

You've gotta love Shinkai and his obsession with establishing shots. If "Your Name" was any indication that he lacks the skill of directing meaningful imagery, then "Garden of Words" is a full on confession that he absolutely has no idea what he's doing. His writing in Your Name was completely absurd and out of touch, but here it's just non-existent.

There's a lingering feeling of chronic loneliness that follows our two main characters. The rain itself symbolizes loneliness. The irony of the film is that these characters only seem to ... find each other's company during the rain. The problem arises when the film has no idea how to develop these ideas on screen. Even if this is an understated, character-driven narrative, there always has to be some sort of conclusion or a culmination of sorts. The closest thing to a climax is that the guy makes her a shoe in the end, which he doesn't even give her.

This is Shinkai at his most amateur and aimless. The final scene is supposedly an emotionally charged one, but the lack of any proper build-up, the sappy nature of Shinkai's writing, and the sudden melancholic soundtrack just make it one of the most unintentionally funny/annoying scenes I've seen in an anime. ("you saved me" ugh just kill me please). The girl (I can never remember any of Shinkai's characters) never has a proper arc and neither does the guy. We're just left at the end with a brief understanding of their situations. The girl has moved back to her home town and is teaching again, and the guy is still trying to make shoes. We end up exactly where we started. There's no progression at all. There is a hint that the guy will try and meet her again once he learns to walk, but what's stopping Shinkai from actually showing emotional growth rather than implying it? This is such a poor excuse for the "audience creates their own meaning" situation.

The only reason why I would consider this above Your Name is because it's short and isn't as much of a torture to sit through. There's also the questionable morality that Shinkai depicts in a 27 year old teacher and a 15 year old boy falling in love with each other. Of course, you could argue that they don't sleep together, so it isn't as bad, but still, what's the idea behind including this? If the main idea is about these characters finding each other and giving comfort during their low times, why include romantic elements? If he wanted to show how love comes unexpectedly and in different shapes, sometimes outside of societal norms, why not pursue it further instead of giving it a half-baked conclusion?

The visuals are stunning. There are so many random shots of rain, skyscrapers piercing the skies, trees and lakes greener than green, people cutting up vegetables, and SO MUCH GREEN. Every shot is either of Tokyo drenched in rain or a 4K resolution shot of someone's feet. The visuals quite literally overshadow the characters, which only take up about 30% of the screen time. Aside from the animation, what Shinkai manages to capture so well are the little details of living alone. When you're up past midnight studying and the only company you have is the table lamp. For food, preparing cheap meals like ramen or rice is the go-to. Commuting the distance by train and noticing how someone distinctly smells. It's these moments where Shinkai shines. Not the overt, mawkish romance. He has a perceptive understanding of how normal people live from day to day, especially those in isolation. His worlds are a mimicry of reality, but obviously heightened. Unfortunately, inanimate objects feel more real and believable than actual characters in Shinkai's works.

Too bad nothing actually means anything in this 45-minute trailer of a film.

2/10