Forum Settings
Forums

One person's trash, is another person's treasure

New
Jun 10, 8:45 AM
#1

Offline
Aug 2017
44
So, someone already asked for a list of HIDDEN GEMS vs MOST OBSCURE, so let's give them the next up... THEY HATED IT, I ENJOYED IT vs THEY LOVED IT, I DIDN'T list.


(Try to give a brief snippet explaination of the anime if you can)


In my lists so far, are the following:

LOVED IT (others didn't)
Level 1 dakedo Unique Skill de Saikyou desu
An isekai where the protagonist has an OP skill while being unable to level up and abuses it to find happiness

Jidou Hanbaiki ni Umarekawatta Ore wa Meikyuu wo Samayou
Another isekai, except the protagonist is reborn as a vending machine and has to communicate with others using a very small list of pre-determined voice lines and a huge variety of skills while being unable to physically move on their own

ODD TAXI
A bunch of anthropomorphic animals in a "Sin City"-like universe where a taxi driver is the main protagonist and gets caught up in a series of conflicts adjacent to his lifestyle

Seoul-yeok
Your standard zombie survival experience. It wasn't really amazing, but I enjoy zombie stuff, so yeah

Kami-tachi ni Hirowareta Otoko
Yet another isekai, except the main protagonist ends up running a cleaning service using slimes



HATED IT (others loved it)
Ijiranaide, Nagatoro-san
A guy with no spine gets bullied by some chick and falls in love with her. Honestly, this just seems like cuckoldry but for people with the "kicked puppy dog" syndrome

Chiyu Mahou no Machigatta Tsukaikata
Pretty standard isekai, except the protagonist uses healing magic as a weapon and spends most of the time getting harassed and beaten up by some hot woman

Psycho-Pass
I actually don't even remember watching this.

Mushoku Tensei: Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu
Yet another isekai, where the main protagonist is a huge pervert, and his dad is an even worse pervert, and the protagonist is also a hypocrite. Honestly, while I did enjoy this anime, the main character and his dad are both complete and utter dickheads

NOTE
Only listed 4 because the 5th one was season 2 of Nagatoro-san, which is basically the same as the first.


So yeah, join in. Feel free to absolutely trash the anime you don't like and praise the one you do... or not, whatever works.
JaaShooUhhJun 10, 8:48 AM
Jun 10, 8:58 AM
#2

Offline
Sep 2016
4560
They hated it, I loved it: https://myanimelist.net/anime/51265/Inukai-san

They loved it, I hated it: https://myanimelist.net/anime/48926/Komi-san
This dance is the pinnacle of human achievement.
Jun 10, 9:15 AM
#3

Offline
Aug 2013
1024
They hated it, I enjoyed it
Chained Soldier - Always loved strong women in anime and this one is full of them so yeah easy 10.
Naruto movie - After the disappointment of Boruto, I started watching the Naruto movies and highly enjoyed seeying young little Naruto. Not sure why people hate it, it was an ok movie.
Sigrdrifa - I'm an aviation fanatic so I'm always hyped to see anime featuring combat planes.
Too Cute Crisis - Wacky humor about aliens having heart attacks out of cuteness for Earth's animals. I highly enjoyed it, had some good laughs.
Area 88 - same as Sigrdrifa, since it has combat planes as the stars of the show, I rated it higher then I would normally.


WARNING! Feelings might get hurted! Read at your own risk...

They loved it, I didn't
Onimai - A dude gets transformed forcefully without consent into a girl by his little 'genius' scientist sister and he never demands, asks nor requests to be changed back into a dude. No, he fully embraces being a girl now, explores all kind of womenly things & loves to hang out with his sister and her friends. THE END... Wauw, what a F trash.
Puella - this dates back from my newbie days when I finished everything I started. I never got it why this is so popular and good. I didn't like it, very boring & annoying.
Midori - another trash I watched during my newbie days. The genre tags are a lie, it's no comedy and there's no ecchi, it's just utter trash. What a waste of time that has been.
Devilman - I never liked it, what a weird show. The fact it was popular is truly an enigma I'll never be able to solve nor understand. Gore was the only thing that escorted me till the end of this hellride.
Anohana - during my newbie days this was recommended by many and I don't understand why. Very boring & I can't really trash on it, because I forgot what it was all about. Not worth mentioning and not worth your time.
I don't know who quotes me and then deletes the comment, but know that you make my day.

STEAM's GOTY 2024 the Ghost of Tsushima

OMFG THE HYPE IS REAL!!! ELDEN RING SHADOW OF THE ERDTREE wOOt!! F YEAH LET'S F GOOOOOO!!!
Jun 10, 9:18 AM
#4

Offline
Feb 2020
77871
One otaku's trash is another otaku's treasure.

Jun 10, 9:34 AM
#5

Online
Jun 2021
244

I didn't like Grand blue because it was the most unfunniest comedy anime I have ever seen.

Except for Grand blue here, I don't remember why I hated other series in the list.
E-SatieJun 10, 9:47 AM

My doctor has always told me to smoke. He even explains himself: “Smoke, my friend. Otherwise someone else will smoke in your place.”

Jun 10, 9:49 AM
#6

Offline
Apr 2022
52
They hated it, I loved it-
ButaReba - unexpectedly, one with a pretty dumb premise, had a pretty serious story. Matsuoka as Pig's voice made it a little funny to me.

Gene of AI - I really loved the whole episodic moments. Some episodes were sad while others were fun and pretty interesting as well.

Futoku no Guild - no need to explain. peak ecchi anime

Scarlet Nexus - I watched this when I first started watching my anime journey (my second anime), and I enjoyed it alot.

KamiKatsu - just one of isekai of all time. amazing animation.

They loved it, I Hated it -

Arknights s2 - this one aired at midnight friday, and I'm always tired af so when I watched s1, I almost slept. same happened in s2. I also forgotten the story as well, because of this.

Solo Leveling - generic power fantasy. no good side characters. the main protagonist just gains a whole new body and chin in span of one (or more idk) day. not as good as I expected.

Doctor Elise - tbh I dont remember much of this. I think I gave it 6 because of the male mc not being shown much?

MASHLE s1 - yet again, this one aired at Saturday night, and I'm always tired af so I always sleep while watching it. I couldnt find the jokes funny. but I did I like s2.

SAO Ordinal Scale - I dont remember anything of this. I think I randomly rated this.
cute and funny 😭😭😭😭😭😭
Jun 10, 10:16 AM
#8

Offline
Mar 2021
16
They loved it, I didn't:
Frieren I know everyone on this planet loves this anime, but I just don't. I mean, it has very good animations, and the characters are nice and all, but that's it. The story is kind of blank; it's not going anywhere, and frankly, it's more like a slice-of-life anime than anything else. I'm not "hating" it; I just don't get the hype at all.
Wonder Egg Priority I feel like this is one of those Animes that you either like or don't. I personally thought that the topics are very interesting, but the way it played out...that was not it. Terrible, terrible execution.
Devilman: Crybaby I don't know why anyone on this planet would endorse this...
Undead Girl Murder Farce It started so well with the vampires and all that, and then it turned boring as hell...


They hated it, I enjoyed it:
Angels of Death I know this one is kind of controversial, but I loved the game. I played it countless times, and maybe that's why I was a little bit biased, but I can't change it. I love everything about that anime. It's the best trash. 
Digimon Savers I think this one only gets hate because the Digimon fandom can be very toxic and nostalgic. I never watched the anime as a child, and I thought I might give it a shot a few months ago. What can I say? I enjoyed it a bit!
WataMote: No Matter How I Look At It, It's You Guys' Fault I'm Not Popular! Idk, maybe because I can relate to the MC so much, but I loved it; it has a special place in my heart.
Prison School My guilty pleasure. I'm sorry, but this one is so so so so funny!
Jun 10, 10:32 AM
#9
Offline
Jul 2016
174
I was expecting it to have more controversial shows but here it is

They hated it, I enjoyed it
Sing "Yesterday" for Me
Takt Op. Destiny
Poupelle of Chimney Town
Fairy Gone
Puch line


They loved it, I didn't
Full Moon
Ghost Stories
Parallel World Pharmacy
Kuma Kuma Kuma Bear

Jun 10, 10:45 AM
Isekai Trucker

Offline
Oct 2015
1701
People didn't seem to care about Kono Healer, mendokusai but I loved it.
Great humor with also a very cute ghost girl who showed up in the later episodes.

People seemed to love Youkoso Jitsuryoku Shijou Shugi no Kyoushitsu e but that shit was just awful. One of the worst I've seen.
Today, I may be a weak little bug that gets tossed in the wind,
washed away by the currents, and drowns, but tomorrow,
I may become the butterfly that spreads its colossal wings and flies the open skies!

~ Oe Kintaro
Jun 10, 10:46 AM

Offline
Mar 2019
2664
I've been told that Mashle is a masterpiece of comedy, someone say that is much funnier than the anime itself haha.

Jun 10, 10:54 AM

Offline
Dec 2020
366
Well apparently I didn't enjoy any...

Jun 11, 2:01 AM

Offline
May 2018
10737
Coaghim said:
I'm an aviation fanatic

Check on Kouya no Kotobuki Hikoutai!
Ignore the horrible characters and the nonsensical story. Ignore the bad animation and 3D + 2D scenes outside of the air battles.

Just watch it for the planes and maybe for the worldbuilding.
Jun 11, 4:45 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
1024
Reply to alshu
Coaghim said:
I'm an aviation fanatic

Check on Kouya no Kotobuki Hikoutai!
Ignore the horrible characters and the nonsensical story. Ignore the bad animation and 3D + 2D scenes outside of the air battles.

Just watch it for the planes and maybe for the worldbuilding.
@alshu Thx 4 the recomm, I will check it out!
I don't know who quotes me and then deletes the comment, but know that you make my day.

STEAM's GOTY 2024 the Ghost of Tsushima

OMFG THE HYPE IS REAL!!! ELDEN RING SHADOW OF THE ERDTREE wOOt!! F YEAH LET'S F GOOOOOO!!!
Jun 11, 5:09 AM
Walpurgis

Offline
May 2023
411
They hated it, I loved it:

School Days - subversive masterpiece and I'm dying on that hill, School Days is so daring and I love it
Corpse Party: Tortured Souls - I wanted gore, I got gore. obviously the game is better but as a horror fan, I loved watching it even so
Mirai Nikki - fun show, was never bored watching it
Elfen Lied - it's pretty popular to dunk on it nowadays but I still think it set the bar for modern era guro

They loved it, I didn't:

Another - felt like if you'd ordered Higurashi off Wish x The Final Destination movies. not my kind of horror at all
Ergo Proxy - hated every second of watching it: blander than unseasoned oatmeal
Girls Last Tour - just not my thing
Jun 11, 5:19 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
4560
Coaghim said:
I'm an aviation fanatic so I'm always hyped to see anime featuring combat planes.
You might like:
https://myanimelist.net/anime/9000/The_Princess_and_the_Pilot
https://myanimelist.net/anime/416/Porco_Rosso
This dance is the pinnacle of human achievement.
Jun 11, 5:22 AM

Offline
Aug 2013
1024
Reply to Zarutaku
Coaghim said:
I'm an aviation fanatic so I'm always hyped to see anime featuring combat planes.
You might like:
https://myanimelist.net/anime/9000/The_Princess_and_the_Pilot
https://myanimelist.net/anime/416/Porco_Rosso
@Zarutaku Haha thx 4 these aswell, I'll check them out in a week probably. It's Steam demo festival, gotta try some games out first :P
I don't know who quotes me and then deletes the comment, but know that you make my day.

STEAM's GOTY 2024 the Ghost of Tsushima

OMFG THE HYPE IS REAL!!! ELDEN RING SHADOW OF THE ERDTREE wOOt!! F YEAH LET'S F GOOOOOO!!!
Jun 11, 5:26 AM

Offline
Jul 2019
733

Really, "THEY HATED IT?" it has a score of 8.6, lol, who are "they?"


Anyway, the biggest discrepancies on my list

Charger Girl Ju-den Chan - They gave it a 6.61 I gave it a 9, it's an absurd over the top ecchi, that made me laugh more then I expected. made it hard to fap too though.

Ishura - They gave it a 6.63, I gave it a 9, I loved the lack of any real main character, it really gives you the sense that anyone can die, so I literally had no idea who was going to survive in any given encounter, and many surprised me.

The Little Lies We All Tell - They gave it a 7.14, I gave it a 10. This was comedy gold, I don't know why this is rated so low, people cleary have trash taste when it comes to peak comedy.

Futoku no Guild - they gave it a 6.56 I gave it a 9. As someone above mentioned, peak ecchi, and it only get better with the bluray release, they expanded on every ecchi scene, and added several more that were missing.

Kaguya-sama: Love is War - The First Kiss That Never Ends - They gave it a 8.77 I gave it a 6, it completely undoes the fantastic finale of the 3rd season.

Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works - They gave it a 8.18 I gave it a 6, definitely the most by the book shounen of the fate series. Magical girl Illya had a more interesting plot. And that one was ridiculous.

Steins;Gate - They gave it a 9.07 I gave it a 7, a solid time travel story if not a bit predictable. Great cast of characters.


velveteenvamp said:
Mirai Nikki - fun show, was never bored watching it

I like how this is in one persons "they loved it I hated it" and another person's "they hated it I loved it" lists.
Jackson1333Jun 11, 5:40 AM
Jun 11, 5:32 AM

Offline
Aug 2021
148


                                                                                                                       
Jun 11, 6:19 AM

Offline
May 2018
122


Kamisama ni Natta Hi: Jun Maeda, Key; two things that I really appreciate. This anime has only 1 problem, too short :)
Friends: Mononoke Shima no Naki: I don't know why this movie is rated below 7. I really like this, both as my childhood and as me now.
16bit Sensation: Another Layer: Simply really enjoy this anime, with some Easter eggs from some Bishoujo games. Uguu~
The iDOLM@STER Million Live!: I was not a fan of iDOLM@STER before watching this anime. And yes, this anime makes me really want to go deeper into iDOLM@STER, especially in the Million Live branch (I played the game after the 7th episode aired until now)
Prima Doll: Key. Also really enjoyed the story

Lucky☆Star: I love some KyoAni works, but this anime is different for me. I can't really enjoy it and ended "hold" at episode 12. Also bored
Boku no Hero Academia 2nd Season: I don't want to continue. kind of bored
Nanami Hiromachi  Anna Mochizuki 
Jun 11, 7:03 AM

Offline
Apr 2011
1520
For those who don't know, you need to click "All Anime Stats" on your profile.

IKKIsamaJun 11, 7:06 AM

More topics from this board

» Imagine sites exactly like MAL, but for other media ( 1 2 )

EterTC - Jul 10, 2020

71 by APolygons2 »»
2 minutes ago

» What anime would you like to see another season of?

doctor - 5 hours ago

7 by AE-2 »»
3 minutes ago

» If an anime needed great animation to be good, it was never good to begin with

18927 - 4 hours ago

17 by Zettaiken »»
4 minutes ago

» What was an anime that sucked compared to their original source?

zkl - 3 hours ago

6 by Zowabo »»
15 minutes ago

» Seiyuus who are everywhere?

Mattenan - 4 hours ago

14 by tchitchouan »»
30 minutes ago
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login