list the Worst male protagonists (in your opinion)

Saekosannn said:


how is he a poor written character? just because he shouts a lot doesn't mean he's the worst.
do you know what's like to be betrayed?
eren literally watched his own mother get eaten by a titan, infact many close people he watched died.
he's been through so much, he has a goal

czarus111 said:

And I gave them an answer. What's the matter?

Attackonfiller said:
Some people mentioning Eren...

Can't be helped for now I guess. S1-S3 is basically the grand setup for his character. His change and developments will no doubt be just as rewarding as it was for manga readers.

CuteAssTiger said:


because that isnt an answer to the question

you said he is poorly writter

people ask why he is poorly written

and you said you just hate him

but those things arent connected

if i say "this banana is red "

and somebody asks me
"why do you think this banana is red ? it looks pretty yellow to me based on its color code "

and i say "i dont care about colour codes . i hate the banana"

then that doesnt explain why the banana is supposedly "red" when it isnt red and somebody made a good argument for why it is yellow

Ty-Foo said:
That dude from isekai smartphone. I don't remember anything about him except that he had a smartphone and I think that's telling enough

Saekosannn said:
Optional: you can say what you hate about them

Mines would me:

Kazuya Kinoshita( rent a girl friend)
Yukiteru Amano (mirai nikki)
Rito Yuuki (To-LOVE-Ru)
Issei Hyoudou (Highschool dxd)
Hajime Nagumo (Arifureta Shokugyou de Sekai Saikyou)

Nefelupitou said:
Lelouch
That guy from No Game No Life
That guy from Kami no Tou
Naruto

Saekosannn said:


how is he a poor written character? just because he shouts a lot doesn't mean he's the worst.
do you know what's like to be betrayed?
eren literally watched his own mother get eaten by a titan, infact many close people he watched died.
he's been through so much, he has a goal

ReegrezSNK said:


But the problem is hatred its not only Eren motivation and people cant even see it, like from the first episode his best goal was to escape the walls which he consider as cage, he was mad on almost everyone because they couldn't undertstand him, he compared humans to animals living in cage that had given up long time ago. He was little bit annyoing maybe but I can relate to this, he became what he hated ( titan) and then whole world started to use him as weapon.

czarus111 said:
Eren Yager is the poorest written MC I've ever seen. I hate this guy with passion.
Also MC from Mirai Nikki is terrible character.

SSS-AmyArts said:
I’m gonna have to say Kirito. Why? Well, I have a few reasons for that.
Number 1: He’s ridiculously OP.
Now, I get it, he’s a beta tester for the first season. However, you still should have a limit on how OP you wanna make characters (Unless you’re one character that I’ll mention later). He should have no experience when he first enters the game, like, none. I get it, he worked hard for around 1 to 2 years, but others have worked harder. For example, lets look at Ainz from Overlord. Yes, he did gain his power through hard work and he’s even more OP than Kirito. However, it took him even more time to gain respect in the game and power. When he’s no longer able to leave the game, Ainz still keeps his power level. Overlord is supposed to be a show about overpowered characters taking over the world. SAO is supposed to be about fighting the bad guys and being a hero like most other shows. Also, Kirito is shown to know about the entire code for the game without being a developer. He just wipes out his knowledge out of nowhere to save Yui. This shows that Kirito can do just about anything because he’s the main character.
Number 2: He’s boring.
Kirito has no personality whatsoever. He’s just that black haired guy who gets all the ladies (Even his own sister!) just because he’s the protagonist and saves people. Yes, he lost his comrades and ended up being distant with his emotions, but other protagonists have dealt with worse and are still interesting characters. Lets look at Tanjiro for example. He lost his entire family, his only surviving family member turned into a demon, she was almost killed by a demon slayer, and was mentally scarred for the rest of his life. However, he still has a better personality than Kirito. He actually shows his emotions and hides all of his pain through a smile. While Kirito barley shows any emotion while in a sad scene. If Kirito at least showed a smile more often, he’d be a more likely character.
Number 3: The whole sister ordeal.
The one of reason why most people don’t like the second season of SAO is because that Kirito’s sister feel in love with him. This is already a problem to begin with. However, it’s even more of an issue when it’s a main stream anime. Sure, those weird incest animes have appeared, but they weren’t main stream. However, SAO is a big franchise that should set an example on problems people face. Incest is not a huge problem, and even if someone had that issue, they should go to therapy for something like that. His sister doesn’t even go to a professional to ask for help. All it took was one episode and it wasn’t talked about. She still is in love with him and still hasn’t gotten help by a legal professional. This problem wouldn’t happen if the creator didn’t write this part for the story, because it isn’t need to develop that particular character.
I could go on and on about Kirito’s problem, but we’d be here all day. Overall, he isn’t interesting to watch and he makes me lose interest in watching the show.

Returnbywaifu said:
Natsu Dragneel from Fairy Tail.

I never liked screaming protagonists. You know the ones I'm talking about: the Luffy's, the Naruto's, the Gon's etc.

Natsu is even worse than the aforementioned players, though. Why? The power of friendship in his fights is up to eleven. Power of friendship is not an alien concept for other shounen protagonists, but he is in another level: it doesn't matter what skills or tactics his opponents use or the difference in power level, a surge of strenght that comes from his friends will always save his ass no matter what. Second, no reedeming qualities. Naruto, as annoying as he can be, at least has a tragic backstory that can be relatively believable, you can sympathize with his situation to a certain, even if you have seen that a million times in the damn flashbacks. Gon has the moral code of a drunken teenager, but at least undergoes character development. Luffy is awful since it takes all the dramatic tension out of every situation he's in but at least compensates with some epic scenes here and there. But Natsu? He screams like an idiot even by shounen progatonist's standars, he is not combat smart, he can't plan, he can't do anything without the power of friendship. I guess you could say he's the embodiment of stupidity being rewarded. I mean, not that any other character in Fairy Tail is remotely interesting, but still.

Animaniaig said:
Eren Yeager (the final arc won’t change this)

RapidShadow said:
Mine would probably be the mc of Mahouka dude literally has such a bland personality and a sister fetish.