| no |
Clebardman said: RayAdha said: No, none at all I hate it-----> drop it ASAP-----> rate it low Implying that you can rate something you didn't watch. The notion that you have to watch the complete series to rate it is ridiculous. If a series is bad after 3 episodes I drop it and rate it 4 or below. There have been a few series I dropped after less than 3 episodes and they received even worse ratings. |
 |
| clannad AS as a 7/10 will never rewatch. hate the characters. |
| Angel Beats! and Koi to something Chocolate actually deserved 4 and 2 However Megumi Ogata AKA The seiyuu goddess AKA The legend voiced the characters I liked the most in both series so I gave them +1 mayukachan said: I still haven't watched Clannad and its sequelclannad AS as a 7/10 will never rewatch. hate the characters. Tell me moar mayu |
 Nico- said: Conversations with people pinging/quoting me to argue about some old post I wrote years ago will not be entertained@Comic_Sans oh no y arnt ppl dieing i need more ppl dieing rly gud plot avansement jus liek tokyo ghoul if erbudy dies amirite |
KendiKong said: sebaf74 said: The notion that you have to watch the complete series to rate it is ridiculous. If a series is bad after 3 episodes I drop it and rate it 4 or below. There have been a few series I dropped after less than 3 episodes and they received even worse ratings. Yeah, but imagine if you do that to an anime like Steins;Gate. Drop a show way too early. Bad review, I'd say I said rate, not review. Bad reading comprehension I'd say. |
|
| No. I rate anime and manga very impulsively, based on my enjoyment. |
| Rating anime takes too much effort, because my scale would only really be on enjoyment factor like it should be, because a rating should be personal. If i were to rate, id have no anime lower than 7 really, aside from a few, and most would be at least 8-9, probably too many 10's |
"Make it flashier!" -Maid Chou Anime List |
Comic_Sans said: mayukachan said: I still haven't watched Clannad and its sequelclannad AS as a 7/10 will never rewatch. hate the characters. Tell me moar mayu everyone has gigantic moe eyes and are walking stereotypes (a tsundere, a shy sickly girl, a kuudere, a comic relief loli etc.) but i gave it a decent score because of a 4ish episodes out of 25 that were well done the rest of the episodes were like 3/10 |
| Since I attempt to rate largely on my perception of success or failure compared to what I think the show is trying to achieve, it is theoretically possible for this to happen. So far, I can't think of any that I truly hate but have received high scores from me, but there are some that have elements that I hate, and there are some that bother me in some way, such as sensory overload from too much action. Additionally, some very old shows have poorly preserved prints and can be bothersome to watch as a result, but since I try to rate on content, poor preservation should be irrelevant to the score. Sometimes, I personally hate a character while also appreciating how that character is constructed and operates within the show. It is hard not to hate Makoto in School Days, but the series couldn't make its point without him. Making the audience despise him so much is one way in which the series is successful in pursuing its purpose. |
| It is pitch black. You are likely to be eaten by a grue. |
| None. Some get an average rating even if I hate the story and characters like 5 cm per second because of the art/animation. |
mayukachan said: Sounds painfulComic_Sans said: I still haven't watched Clannad and its sequel Tell me moar mayu everyone has gigantic moe eyes and are walking stereotypes (a tsundere, a shy sickly girl, a kuudere, a comic relief loli etc.) but i gave it a decent score because of a 4ish episodes out of 25 that were well done the rest of the episodes were like 3/10 I guess I should start watching it as soon as I've finished the anime watching challenge 2015 then |
Nico- said: Conversations with people pinging/quoting me to argue about some old post I wrote years ago will not be entertained@Comic_Sans oh no y arnt ppl dieing i need more ppl dieing rly gud plot avansement jus liek tokyo ghoul if erbudy dies amirite |
Comic_Sans said: mayukachan said: Sounds painfuleveryone has gigantic moe eyes and are walking stereotypes (a tsundere, a shy sickly girl, a kuudere, a comic relief loli etc.) but i gave it a decent score because of a 4ish episodes out of 25 that were well done the rest of the episodes were like 3/10 I guess I should start watching it as soon as I've finished the anime watching challenge 2015 then it's pretty painful when it's not focused on the main story, which is like 90% of the 50 episodes-- but the only reason to finish it is because it's one of the most popular on this site |
mayukachan said: Yeah I knowComic_Sans said: Sounds painful I guess I should start watching it as soon as I've finished the anime watching challenge 2015 then it's pretty painful when it's not focused on the main story, which is like 90% of the 50 episodes-- but the only reason to finish it is because it's one of the most popular on this site I am mostly interested because I've heard there are some homoerotic whatshisfaceMC x blonde best friend moments |
Nico- said: Conversations with people pinging/quoting me to argue about some old post I wrote years ago will not be entertained@Comic_Sans oh no y arnt ppl dieing i need more ppl dieing rly gud plot avansement jus liek tokyo ghoul if erbudy dies amirite |
KendiKong said: sebaf74 said: I said rate, not review. Bad reading comprehension I'd say. Doesnt matter, holy shit. Way to miss the point. Bad rating then I did not miss the point. It is just a bad point. If only people that complete the series rated the series, you would get inflated ratings. Not many sane people would watch the full season of a show they hate. |
|
Kuroi-Akuma said: No. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
| Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann. |
 |
| if u hated it, u hated it, whether its innocent or whatever. if its shit, then give it the shit it deserves. |
| You get what you deserve? Nope. Who decides what you deserve? Does that person even get to deserve deserving what others deserve? And who decided that that person deserves do that? Exactly. Complete bullshit. Only one thing I know that everyone deserves. And that is the right to watch good anime and drop the shitty ones. Have a nice day(you probably don't deserve that :P) |
| If I like something, I have clear reasons for doing so. I don't rate stuff that I find crap highly. Even if it's supposed to be 'critically' good but it doesn't work, I try to figure out why. |
| WEAPONS - My blog, for reviews of music, anime, books, and other things |
absentminded said: so trueUsagi Drop. pls. the manga ruined all. |
 |
| I rate on enjoyment so no. |
 |
| NGE is a masterpiece, but it is also disturbing |
| It is so dense. Every single image has so many things going on. |
HaXXspetten said: What? Why the hell would I do that? Talk about not making sense.. |
| Nah. |
 |
| I tend to give boring anime that are still good (Spice and Wolf) a pass. But, if I hate an anime, it's getting a very low rating. |
| No. |
"You either die an Ashita no Joe, or you live long enough to see yourself become a Naruto."  |
| I gave K-On! a 1 |
 |
TheBrainintheJar said: If I like something, I have clear reasons for doing so. I don't rate stuff that I find crap highly. Even if it's supposed to be 'critically' good but it doesn't work, I try to figure out why. |
 |
| What the fuck? No, of course not. |
 |
| No, I rated my anime mostly on enjoyment, so anime i hate deserves low rating from me. |
| This is so retarded! I'm sorry I just can't understand this logic. Maybe if I have split personality I could understand this phenomenon. |
| I don't give anime I hate a high score O_O |
TheBrainintheJar said: If I like something, I have clear reasons for doing so. I don't rate stuff that I find crap highly. Even if it's supposed to be 'critically' good but it doesn't work, I try to figure out why. If you don't enjoy action, are action-based series automatically bad? I think the point of the question is if your critical values and what you find !fun! are different, which do you default to when they conflict? OT: This hasn't happened to me much. If it's something that I'm not enjoying despite it meeting my standards, I would likely just drop without rating. I actually separate my standards from my enjoyment within my list; enjoyment level goes in the tags. |
McGibletz said: You know what, you're right. K-ON is a great show and you're a fucking idiot for not liking it.I gave K-On! a 1 |
|
TripleSRank said: TheBrainintheJar said: If I like something, I have clear reasons for doing so. I don't rate stuff that I find crap highly. Even if it's supposed to be 'critically' good but it doesn't work, I try to figure out why. If you don't enjoy action, are action-based series automatically bad? I think the point of the question is if your critical values and what you find !fun! are different, which do you default to when they conflict? OT: This hasn't happened to me much. If it's something that I'm not enjoying despite it meeting my standards, I would likely just drop without rating. I actually separate my standards from my enjoyment within my list; enjoyment level goes in the tags. Shouldn't your standard and your enjoyment be the same? Like seriously, shouldn't your standard be link with your enjoyment? You separating your standard with your enjoyment, means you're not being true to yourself? |
keragammingSep 16, 2015 12:04 AM
SeibaaHomu said: Didn't mean to hurt your feelingsMcGibletz said: You know what, you're right. K-ON is a great show and you're a fucking idiot for not liking it.I gave K-On! a 1 |
|
keragamming said: TripleSRank said: If you don't enjoy action, are action-based series automatically bad? I think the point of the question is if your critical values and what you find !fun! are different, which do you default to when they conflict? OT: This hasn't happened to me much. If it's something that I'm not enjoying despite it meeting my standards, I would likely just drop without rating. I actually separate my standards from my enjoyment within my list; enjoyment level goes in the tags. Shouldn't your standard and your enjoyment be the same? Like seriously, shouldn't your standard be link with your enjoyment? Not necessarily. It depends on how you define enjoyment. For example, the sensation of bliss is different from the sensation of catharsis, which is different from general mental stimulation disconnected from emotions, and so on. If you tried to define literally any "desirable" response as "enjoyment", then they might be the same. However, I find such usage to be needlessly vague and of little use. Even when separated, one's standards and one's taste are very broad categories within which people can have major differences. Maybe I and you both enjoy action sequences, but the specifics of how we prefer the action to relate to the story is different. Or maybe only one of us enjoys action sequences, but we both prefer to see them incorporated into the story in the same manner. Situations like these make differentiating between one's taste and one's standards desirable. |
TripleSRankSep 16, 2015 12:27 AM
TripleSRank said: keragamming said: Shouldn't your standard and your enjoyment be the same? Like seriously, shouldn't your standard be link with your enjoyment? Not necessarily. It depends on how you define enjoyment. For example, the sensation of bliss is different from the sensation of catharsis, which is different from general mental stimulation disconnected from emotions, and so on. If you tried to define literally any "desirable" response as "enjoyment", then they might be the same. However, I find such usage to be needlessly vague and of little use. Even when separated, one's standards and one's taste are very broad categories within which people can have major differences. Maybe I and you both enjoy action sequences, but the specifics of how we prefer the action to relate the story is different. Or maybe only one of us enjoys action sequences, both we both prefer to see them incorporated into the story in the same manner. Situations like these make differentiating between one's taste and one's standards desirable. I understand what you're saying. The point I'm making is that when we enjoy something, we should be able to tell why we enjoy it. Giving them break down on why you like the characters, the story ect should be easy since you enjoy it. I believe our emotion is link with our standards. Without your emotion a human could not distinct between good or bad. |
| No. I'm not going to give something I hated a 9. |
 |
More topics from this board
» Your Favourite Anime Quotes!on-luffy - Dec 2, 2023 |
32 |
by jcustcusj
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Going through shows you saw a decade ago, have they fell off?Dragevard - 9 hours ago |
14 |
by Iron47
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Which Anime do you think has the overall best OP+ED+OSTs ? ( 1 2 )NaRc0s_G - May 19 |
74 |
by Ex-Aid
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
» Anime that made you feel emotionalST63LTH - 2 hours ago |
5 |
by Codric
»»
49 minutes ago |
|
» Best bald guy?Serafos - May 19 |
22 |
by Serafos
»»
49 minutes ago |