| i can appreciate anime that looks really good, handrawn etc but a good story will always keep me hooked |
 |
| Visuals mean nothing to me. |
 |
| Why not both? |
 |
| Neither. Best experience/enjoyment. Story if I really had to pick. |
ok000Aug 3, 2015 2:46 PM
| Angel Beats! had beautiful visuals Does that mean Angel Beats! is a good anime? No |
 Nico- said: Conversations with people pinging/quoting me to argue about some old post I wrote years ago will not be entertained@Comic_Sans oh no y arnt ppl dieing i need more ppl dieing rly gud plot avansement jus liek tokyo ghoul if erbudy dies amirite |
| Beautiful visuals will never save an anime with a mediocre story. So I prefer a great story. |
 |
| GLASSLIP GLASSLIP GLASSLIP GLASSLIP |
KumaAug 3, 2015 2:32 PM
 "If taking responsibility for a mistake that cannot be undone means death, it's not that hard to die. At least, not as hard as to live on." |
iNoto-san said: In a perfect world we would always get both. But I also want to see what others would prefer if they had to choiseWhy not both? |
|
| visually stunning tits |
 |
| Visuals are definitely a big factor in my decision of watching the show or not, a good story isn't bad either though. |
 |
Comic_Sans said: Angel Beats! had beautiful visuals Does that mean Angel Beats! is a good anime? No Angel Beats wasn't that bad, though. OT: Visuals don't mean much unless they help to visualize the story in a way, like using symbolism and imagery. So story gets my vote. |
AltoRoarkAug 3, 2015 2:29 PM
| Visuals can aid the way the story is presented. That's about it. So I prefer an anime which has a solid plot. |
| I will fall on the side that says that a "good" story is not necessary to make good anime, and as a visual medium, I'd prioritize having good visuals over the story. DGrimreaperD said: I never buy this argument. If visuals don't mean anything, then in my mind there's almost no reason to watch anime.Visuals mean nothing to me. |
| Story>visuals |
 |
mochabearbruh said: iNoto-san said: In a perfect world we would always get both. But I also want to see what others would prefer if they had to choiseWhy not both? Well if i had to choose, i would go with the story. Sorry but the story is more important than visuals. Just think about it for a second. You get this godly visuals (for example Fate stay night UBW by ufotable) but you get a shit story. It's going to suck because the plot suck and the character suck so what's the point of watching an anime like that? Anime with great story would give you great characters, great plot,etc. Take a look at higurashi. Many people don't like the visuals but the anime has a gooddam story. |
|
Lancehot said: Eh. I think what Lucas says sounds nice, but it's really only relevant because we are so caught up in the idea of a story or characters being the crux of a work. I imagine for many stories, visuals should be a means to an end, but we've seen a number of works that exist purely for the sake of achieving some sort of visual end, which I think is important in its own way.ykmZp5cgbkU |
iNoto-san said: I agree with you. mochabearbruh said: In a perfect world we would always get both. But I also want to see what others would prefer if they had to choise Well if i had to choose, i would go with the story. Sorry but the story is more important than visuals. Just think about it for a second. You get this godly visuals (for example Fate stay night UBW by ufotable) but you get a shit story. It's going to suck because the plot suck and the character suck so what's the point of watching an anime like that? Anime with great story would give you great characters, great plot,etc. Take a look at higurashi. Many people don't like the visuals but the anime has a gooddam story. Some people as the guy a few posts above sees anime as a visual medium so the visuals should be the most important. Would manga also be apart of visual medium? |
|
| i will always take a great story over pretty visuals |
| Well... I enjoyed ping pong the animation a lot and it looks horrible so story I guess |
mochabearbruh said: Yes. Manga is extremely dependent on its visuals. Blame could not be told any other way but in its silent and haunting visual imagery, and the same can be said of Nihei's other works. There's a certain magical nature to Urushibara Yuki's manga too, as seen in Suiiki and Mushishi. Art style is arguably even more important in manga because unlike anime, where voice actors, sound, and special effects can cover for paltry designs, manga has none of those elements to really carry it if the visuals fall apart.Some people as the guy a few posts above sees anime as a visual medium so the visuals should be the most important. Would manga also be apart of visual medium? |
mochabearbruh said: iNoto-san said: I agree with you. Well if i had to choose, i would go with the story. Sorry but the story is more important than visuals. Just think about it for a second. You get this godly visuals (for example Fate stay night UBW by ufotable) but you get a shit story. It's going to suck because the plot suck and the character suck so what's the point of watching an anime like that? Anime with great story would give you great characters, great plot,etc. Take a look at higurashi. Many people don't like the visuals but the anime has a gooddam story. Some people as the guy a few posts above sees anime as a visual medium so the visuals should be the most important. Would manga also be apart of visual medium? Visuals should be important but STORY should be more important than visuals. I'ma make another example. Take for example maken-ki two! the visuals were good but the story was terrible! oh my god.. I don't hate ecchi/harem type of animes but maken-ki two just was terrible! The visuals were good but the story lacked. Story > Visuals any day of the week. As for manga, I'm the same. Sorry but whenever I read a manga, i'm looking for a story and ok draw or good draw. Angel Densetsu starts ''ok'' visuals but the story makes up for it. Later on the visuals gets better. |
|
| Both? Story is obviously more important most of the time though |
  |
masterofgo said: mochabearbruh said: Yes. Manga is extremely dependent on its visuals. Blame could not be told any other way but in its silent and haunting visual imagery, and the same can be said of Nihei's other works. There's a certain magical nature to Urushibara Yuki's manga too, as seen in Suiiki and Mushishi. Art style is arguably even more important in manga because unlike anime, where voice actors, sound, and special effects can cover for paltry designs, manga has none of those elements to really carry it if the visuals fall apart.Some people as the guy a few posts above sees anime as a visual medium so the visuals should be the most important. Would manga also be apart of visual medium? Could you provide me examples of what bad visuals is for you. |
|
| Both but if I had to choose probably great story. For example Ares the art sucks (to me, maybe not to you) BIG TIME, it took me awhile to get past it but the story sucks you in and doesnt let go. I fail to understand why every manga/manhwa cant be like Saver, great art and story. jk I know why lol |
| NatalieS |
AltoRoark99 said: It was mediocreComic_Sans said: Angel Beats! had beautiful visuals Does that mean Angel Beats! is a good anime? No Angel Beats wasn't that bad, though. OT: Visuals don't mean much unless they help to visualize the story in a way, like using symbolism and imagery. So story gets my vote. |
Nico- said: Conversations with people pinging/quoting me to argue about some old post I wrote years ago will not be entertained@Comic_Sans oh no y arnt ppl dieing i need more ppl dieing rly gud plot avansement jus liek tokyo ghoul if erbudy dies amirite |
masterofgo said: Ahhh I see. Those are really good points. That's when things would start getting tricky about which I would choose is more important. mochabearbruh said: Yes. Manga is extremely dependent on its visuals. Blame could not be told any other way but in its silent and haunting visual imagery, and the same can be said of Nihei's other works. There's a certain magical nature to Urushibara Yuki's manga too, as seen in Suiiki and Mushishi. Art style is arguably even more important in manga because unlike anime, where voice actors, sound, and special effects can cover for paltry designs, manga has none of those elements to really carry it if the visuals fall apart.Some people as the guy a few posts above sees anime as a visual medium so the visuals should be the most important. Would manga also be apart of visual medium? iNoto-san said: I get what you're saying. If they're about even (the visuals and story) in manga the visuals would probably first need to pull me in unless the story is GREAT from the beginning or it's intresting enoughmochabearbruh said: I agree with you. Some people as the guy a few posts above sees anime as a visual medium so the visuals should be the most important. Would manga also be apart of visual medium? Visuals should be important but STORY should be more important than visuals. I'ma make another example. Take for example maken-ki two! the visuals were good but the story was terrible! oh my god.. I don't hate ecchi/harem type of animes but maken-ki two just was terrible! The visuals were good but the story lacked. Story > Visuals any day of the week. As for manga, I'm the same. Sorry but whenever I read a manga, i'm looking for a story and ok draw or good draw. Angel Densetsu starts ''ok'' visuals but the story makes up for it. Later on the visuals gets better. |
|
mochabearbruh said: masterofgo said: Ahhh I see. Those are really good points. That's when things would start getting tricky about which I would choose is more important. Yes. Manga is extremely dependent on its visuals. Blame could not be told any other way but in its silent and haunting visual imagery, and the same can be said of Nihei's other works. There's a certain magical nature to Urushibara Yuki's manga too, as seen in Suiiki and Mushishi. Art style is arguably even more important in manga because unlike anime, where voice actors, sound, and special effects can cover for paltry designs, manga has none of those elements to really carry it if the visuals fall apart. iNoto-san said: I get what you're saying. If they're about even (the visuals and story) in manga the visuals would probably first need to pull me in unless the story is GREAT from the beginning or it's intresting enoughVisuals should be important but STORY should be more important than visuals. I'ma make another example. Take for example maken-ki two! the visuals were good but the story was terrible! oh my god.. I don't hate ecchi/harem type of animes but maken-ki two just was terrible! The visuals were good but the story lacked. Story > Visuals any day of the week. As for manga, I'm the same. Sorry but whenever I read a manga, i'm looking for a story and ok draw or good draw. Angel Densetsu starts ''ok'' visuals but the story makes up for it. Later on the visuals gets better. Well you have a point there as well. Most of the mangas that I've encountered fits that criteria. Ok visuals Ok story. |
|
Blue said: Beautiful visuals will never save an anime with a mediocre story. So I prefer a great story. Pretty much sums it up. A visually good looking anime can only go so far without a story to back it up. |
 All credit goes to Sacred. |
| Characters. OT: F/SN is an example of an anime with good visuals but in reality, it's a heap of shit. |
"Hi!" |
YEEART said: You are a secondary, you don't get an opinion on F/SN.F/SN is an example of an anime with good visuals but in reality, it's a heap of shit. |
| Characters. Then the story. |
| I want something that is good. |
 |
| As long as its entertaining it doesn't matter. |
| Tells a great story. Trigun is a perfect example. It looks really dated and even ugly, but the story is fantastic. |
| Kino's Journey has minimalist visuals and no story of note. I'm not sure how to respond to this topic. Um, I suppose I'll say that story stopped meaning much to me a while back. I appreciate a good story, but it's not the end-all to a good anime. Shows can do without them. Visuals, however, will immediately give an anime its identity, style, tone, and general feel, which can make or break an anime. This ignores extremely pretty shows with crap writing, as the complaints over those types of anime go without saying. |
| A great story any time of day. Hoshin Engi manga has terrible body proportions but the story kept me through hundreds of chapters of Sonic-esque anatomy. |
| The most important things in life is the people that you care about |
iNoto-san said: I could give you examples of good visuals. Miyazaki films, Makoto Shinkai films, Satoshi Kon films. Kara no Kyoukai 5.Could you provide me examples of what bad visuals is for you. I think people have this misconception that visuals are just how clean something looks drawn or how good a character model is or how much fps the anime gets or how good the resolution is. There's so much more than that. |
| Both of 'em. Having a great story is the role of the source/original material and giving it a stunning visual is the role of the studio. It is not something that impossible to pull. If I had to choose then I would choose Visual since it's the first thing that I could see when started some anime. |
 |
| I love it when anime are visually stunning, but I won't watch it if it isn't well written. If it tells a great story, I will keep watching it till the end no matter how cheap the animation is. |
 |
| The obvious answer would be both but if I had to choose one, I would rather have a great story over visuals. |
 |
Xarvyn said: I love it when anime are visually stunning, but I won't watch it if it isn't well written. If it tells a great story, I will keep watching it till the end no matter how cheap the animation is. Dude, you have both Kuroko and Code Geass in your favorites and you wanna tell me that you won't watch if it isn't well written. I'd also name another one, if not for the backlash I'll receive and I'm not in the mood for that. |
|
| The genre is called legend of the galactic heroes no need to explain guys |
More topics from this board
Poll: » can anime influence your dark side?deg - 10 hours ago |
21 |
by Rinenka
»»
1 minute ago |
|
Poll: » Legs or arms?Absurdo_N - 38 minutes ago |
8 |
by Zarutaku
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
» Which, out of all your favorites, would you be least inclined to recommend to others?WatchTillTandava - 7 hours ago |
37 |
by Shirayukin
»»
5 minutes ago |
|
» Is watching a show for the cute girl weird?fallout45 - Yesterday |
24 |
by Rinenka
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Who are your enemies in the anime industry/fanbase?Catalano - Yesterday |
34 |
by MadanielFL
»»
9 minutes ago |