| Going to bed but a quick take on the new profile look... What I like:
What I don't like:
Suggestion: Move the about section below the favs / the stats. People tend to have really long ones and I'd think most are more interested in the stats/favs than the about section. Overall, nice work Xinil and team! |
iwubanimeOct 15, 2015 10:57 PM
| sorry, I appreciate the effort but I don't like it. The old design was simple but more organized, much better ... also this colorful looks like a mess for my eyes x.x please make a option to use the old design, MAL for me is a forum/database and not a social network like facebook :( |
| At least give us an option to choose the classic or the new one. Sigh I don't like the new design. Welp time to leave MAL |
 |
Oiacz said: yhunata said: I also agree an option to revert it to the old format would be nice for some time... at least till we get accustomed to this layout. And how would we get accustomed with the new layout if we'll be using the old one? Well... not everyone will be using the old one. What I'm saying is that simply springing this out of nowhere is what caused the ruckus. Give an option, let them start using it and then generally let them simply forget about the old one in time. |
 |
Hibbington said: Taking off Not Specified... I'm guessing we'll get to see more gender stats in the future.Lewd said: Not Specified is gone, I can only choose Male or Female now. Muh Genderqueer!!!11! :/ Hey look finally a part of the update that I do like! That is 1 out of like 10 MAL >.>. |
| Not bad, I liked the old one better but I guess I'll get used to it. I think an option to customize the profile would be a good idea ( i.e where to place favorites and such ) |
 |
So if your favorite is from an anime with a long title its picture gets stretched also the size for all the favorites and last list updates pictures is bad. They should be kept at the smaller 21px × 32px or be changed to the bigger Panel size of 50px × 75px At their current size the pixilization is awful. and for side by side comparisons if anyone wants it http://i.imgur.com/C7jz6NV.png |
MettyOct 15, 2015 10:50 PM
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Could you add the 'Animelist/Mangalist' views back on our profiles plz?!? |
 Active Military, Prior Service and Veteran's Anime Club do not forget the sound of my voice until the day we reunite |
| Why do you fix what is not broken? Well shit. |
 |
| I am disappointed. |
| This new profile design is ugly. Please change it back. |
 |
Cool_DuDE said: Hibbington said: Yeah and half of the MAL community is sleeping right now so they are going to have a rude awaken in the morning. This thread is going to be like 4,000 replies when I wake up tomorrow. In US it is night right?? Well even in U.K and France a lot of people are still sleeping. But yes a lot North America is either asleep or going to sleep soon. Pacific Coast would still be awake but there is still Canada, South America, The Caribbean. |
  |
What... my simple profile? what.. what's going on? Uhh....UUUUUhhhhhwaaaaa |
 |
| the only thing I like about this is that we can have 10 anime, manga and people favorites |
 |
yhunata said: Oiacz said: And how would we get accustomed with the new layout if we'll be using the old one? Well... not everyone will be using the old one. What I'm saying is that simply springing this out of nowhere is what caused the ruckus. Give an option, let them start using it and then generally let them simply forget about the old one in time. "So, today I feel like using the new profile version." If I had an option, I would choose the old one and forget that they ever created the new one. And if they removed completely the old one, I would make a ruckus again. |
 [size=300][b]Unbalanced |
 |
| I hate the design so much. Dafuq is up with it? For fuck's sake, my favourites are in the middle and I can't see my Anime and Manga list views. >.> |
 |
| i like it, minus the fact that the favorites pictures are a bit blurry... |
| wat Didn't we already talk about this a few pages back? |
 |
| Well, it fucked my profile, but I guess I'll change it, it's not that bad actually. |
| Looks nice so far imo. Finally more favs, thanks! |
♪♪ All you touch and all you see is all your life will ever be ♪♪  |
Lewd said: Cool_DuDE said: wat[size=300]Unbalanced Didn't we already talk about this a few pages back? [b]just found proof of it..a completed manga..but still the bar is not filled up completely |
|
| you can add new more 5 favorite anime and manga pretty neat nice. |
| Fav's pictures are blurry, the title of what anime/manga a character comes from is nonexistent if it's a manga-only character for some reason, took off not-specified as gender for whatever reason, took off list views... For whatever reason, customized comments are now not customized.... But hey at least we can have up to 10 favorite anime and manga now. That's the only plus I see so far. |
| What. Just. Happened. Some good ideas, mostly bad ones. Favs pretty much at the bottom and the "about me" section at the top is a big no-no. Also, no need for a "statistics" botton if the statistics are already in the profile by default. Not completely awful, so good job, staff. |
on Cool_DuDE said: shut up i found it firstjust found proof of it..a completed manga..but still the bar is not filled up completely |
| It's not bad, but I did prefer the previous layout. The best parts about this layout are the extended favorite lists, and the overall rearrangement of the page is a little odd, but I'd say it's more accessible overall. The main problems are that the images are a little buggy, and the placement of the about me section. I honestly think that it would be much better if it was left below the Anime stats and last updated. And the favorites should've remained in it's original place. In the side bar. |
"You either die an Ashita no Joe, or you live long enough to see yourself become a Naruto."  |
| Well, I can add more favorites now. xD There are a couple more things that I like about the new profile changes, but there are also a few things that I dislike about it. :/ I'll get used to this change, as long as there's a welcome addition. ;) |
mayukachan said: Cool_DuDE said: shut up i found it firstjust found proof of it..a completed manga..but still the bar is not filled up completely LOL..yours was a publishing(still on-going) manga right?? |
|
Cool_DuDE said: Stop spamming, scrub. just found proof of it..a completed manga..but still the bar is not filled up completely Cool_DuDE said: http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1439180&show=400#msg42664243LOL..yours was a publishing(still on-going) manga right?? |
|
Cool_DuDE said: no, i was confused because completed manga was halfwaymayukachan said: shut up i found it first LOL..yours was a publishing(still on-going) manga right?? |
| Okai miss..mayuka-chan found it first :-A |
|
| The option to customize would be nice. |
| :3 |
mayukachan said: Reizo_Da_Firenze said: You have to click on the arrow.... "What arrow?! O.o" |
I ♥ Two Syaorans from Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE and TRC!!! |
| Add the "Edit" button next to the anime/manga. |
| i love it very much better than before ^^ |
| Check out, MyAnime List |
| Some of the changes are good...some not so good. - Having to drop down to view all favorites is cumbersome. I honestly wouldn't mind if they were all capped at 5, but people would probably riot if that happened... - Instead of progress being color-coded in statistics, I think it would be more useful if rating distribution were reflected by the bars instead. For anyone who's watched/read over 100 days it ends up pretty much being a solid blue bar anyway... - Statistics doesn't need a link on the left when you're looking right at it already. - History links should be under the Anime Stats and Manga Stats respectively. - However much the "comparability rating" algorithm has been tweaked, it still doesn't seem very accurate. The fact that you still cant search for users based on affinity rating already makes it a pretty useless feature anyway. - I agree with other users that Statistics and Favorites should be above the "About Me" segment. Those are the things you look for first before reading someone's life story. Other than that I think the new design is pretty good. |
RakanishuOct 16, 2015 12:05 AM
| O.O This'll take some time to get used to.. |
  |
| I prefer the old design but change is always good. Of course, it'll take some time to get used to. |
 |
| now can you do auto-refreshing comments? |
  |
RoastyToasty said: now can you do auto-refreshing comments? Pls do..I am raping refresh button here |
|
Fooled around with it a bit in Paint and I definitely feel as though the order should be Stats, Favorites, and then About Me. Or maybe I'll need to cram this screenshot into my about me section to make it feel that way. |
 |
| Btw, why did they fix this first before review system? |
 |
More topics from this board
» Summer Stack Challenges 🧪 ( 1 2 3 4 5 )tingy - Jul 29 |
215 |
by localveggie
»»
11 hours ago |
|
» MAL Game "Fantasy Anime League" Opens for Fall 2025Kineta - Sep 10 |
12 |
by CeciliaAda
»»
Sep 16, 8:41 PM |
|
» TOUGEN ANKI 🩸 Profile Badge Event ( 1 2 )Kineta - Aug 20 |
81 |
by Kamuigan
»»
Sep 16, 7:18 AM |
|
» [Update May 8] MyAnimeList Acquired by Gaudiy Inc. ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kineta - May 7 |
353 |
by W3TFT
»»
Sep 11, 7:07 PM |
|
» Dark theme now available on Desktop! 🎉 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kineta - Apr 11, 2023 |
623 |
by RED-clover12
»»
Sep 4, 5:43 PM |