| A masterpiece, with real meaning and emotional impact, and that is spectacularly good in every regard (art & animation above all, but also story, voice acting, music, etc.). |
 |
UnoPuntoCinco said: 10/10 = 5/5 = 1 oh that's horrifying :( |
 All credit goes to Sacred. |
| Utsu Musume Sayuri is definition of 10/10, everything else is 9/10 or lower. |
TheAbstract said: that show doesnt grip me at all. ive been stalled on ep 15 of the second season for like a month.10 means mushishi |
| Kenjataimu mode status: 恒久 |
| 10/10 for me is a master piece one must watch and is worth rewatching, like FMA Brotherhood or Gintama for example. |
 |
| Masterpiece/Must watch at some point. |
 |
| If it entertained me and kept me interested from start to finish 10, and that's not that hard to do with me, I'm easy to please |
| What would be the point of 10/10 meaning perfect if perfect can never be achieved? Instead i rate my animes by how much I enjoy watching them, and which ones I would recommend to my friends. 10/10 for me is not perfect, it's an anime I'll remember forever, for one reason or another, it's one I will rewatch someday (and I rarely rewatch something), and that I'd surely buy a fancy collector's edition, should the opportunity rise. |
| close to perfection, very memorable, amazing experience, has some message great soundtrack is a must too sadly only 2 such shows so far and I doubt it will ever change |
| It deserves a 10? Meh, dunno 10/10 |
| I must be stunned with amazement after viewing it. |
| stands out from genre + personal favorite is a 10. 9 is one of the above. |
| To me, 10/10 is perfect in terms of quality, humor, attractive/appealing appearances and the small things in general. It doesn't apply for every single anime out there if the humor or romance makes up for everything else, but if I loved every single episode, it's an automatic 10/10 |
Ko_Panda said: A 10/10 anime is one that I enjoy so much that I want everyone to watch it. Pretty much this. |
 |
| Romance, lots of love and ends in marriage. No yuri/yaoi. |
#CHEXIT |
| Rewatchability. If i watch an animu a year, or 5 or more from now and still feel roughly the same way then i think it deserves a 10. |
| I think the only ones that I've given a 10/10 to that aren't harem or ecchi are OreImo and SAO, but tbf those, especially the former and the latter depending on who you ask, can very easily pass as being of one or both of those genres. In fact, I don't know why OreImo isn't listed as a harem at the very least. Of course, being from those two genres aren't required or anything, but honestly, the quickest way to my heart is through my pants and the kind of stuff that tends to get a 10/10 from me usually does that very well. Mmm...I doubt I'll ever give a perfect score to something that takes itself too seriously, even if there's no room for comedy to begin with, like in Monster - where it would've worked against it heavily to have a bit of dumb humor here and there, but I still couldn't consciously give it above an 8 because it was too dark and serious for my tastes, even though I liked it, so things were basically rigged against it from the start. Things tend to be rigged against anything too serious from the start for me. I don't ever see myself giving a 10/10 to something that doesn't make me laugh or smile at some point. So good comedy and good pantsu, pretty much |
 |
| Quote from my profile: "10: Works of apparent brilliance. These shows do not need to be perfect (there's no such thing), but they must plainly stand apart from their peers. These shows will have a message and present it in a way that is spectacularly entertaining, convention destroying, thought provoking, heart wrenching, or some or all of the above." |
| TEN COMMANDMENTS: 1) If Evangelion and Psycho-Pass are his only 10s, he probably also worships Tool and smells like cheesy puffs 2) Freudian psychosis =/= good writing 3) Moe blob art style is only ok in pure slice-of-life comedy 4) It's ok to enjoy shounen. Having fun is allowed 5) It is not ok to enjoy isekai (jk, it is, I just fucking hate it) 6) Creator breakdown =/= good writing 7) A story does not have to be wrapped up with a bow. Life is messy, why would a good story need to be tidy? 8) InuYasha is proto-Twilight 9) Ecchi CAN be good, but is almost always an abomination 10) If God is real, They allowed Super Kid to happen, so fuck Them |
| A 10/10 anime is not a perfect anime. It is a masterpiece anime. Masterpieces can be imperfect. When you watch an anime and go: This is everything anime is meant to be to me. Or- This is everything this genre is meant to be to me. Or- I think this anime is very special and an artist's best work. I give 10/10 for that. I think I get more comfortable with giving them as time goes on. Modifying if they didn't hold up over time. Because being memorable is also part of being a 10/10 masterpiece anime. |
The anime community in a nutshell.  |
| If I have fapped to it at least 10 times. |
 |
You said: If I have fapped to it at least 10 times. This is clearly the most objective way to figure out if it deserves a 10/10. |
| The anime community in a nutshell. |
| The idea behind it and how that idea resonates with me. "Idea" being a vague construct in which many criteria flow into. Basically a mix of the Messages each aspect of the anime conveys to me (eg. art style, animation, story, authors intention, symbolism aso.). So if i like the idea of an anime and the idea resonates with my own thoughts to a high degree i rate it a 10. Note: This rating method is very subjective and does not represent my oppinion on whether the anime overall is good or bad. |
 The lights in the sky are stars♥ |
| I'm of the mindset that an anime has objective aspects that everyone interprets in subjective ways. There's no single path to being well-made, and there's no single path to appeasing everyone: it's easy to say that a show should have interesting characters, but exactly how they're interesting can change wildly between shows and be interpreted differently between people. That is to say, it's all opinion-based and means bugger all. |
 |
| No show that I have rated 10/10 is an actual 10/10, they are just there as a Troll, it is like OP said 10/10 is perfect and I have yet to see something that is perfect. |
| ^_^ |
| 10 doesn't mean perfect. It says right there on rating drop down menu , "10 - Masterpiece" |
| "In this world, wherever there is light – there are also shadows. As long as the concept of winners exists, there must also be losers. The selfish desire of wanting to maintain peace causes wars, and hatred is born to protect love." -Madara Uchiha  |
| Anything that made me feel good, same goes for manga. |
| I rate mostly based on how good the fap was |
 |
| I don't give out 10s nor 9s and my mean score is 3.5. I'll be honest with you, I didn't enjoy most of the anime I watched, I literally watched them to kill time and because of that sad approach to anime my interests in anime are now almost non-existent. |
 |
| 10/10 for me means I enjoyed it from the start up to the very end without a chance of boredom. |
on 
| For me to give an anime a 10, it not only has to have no possible flaws I can think of, but it also needs to make me feel emotionally invested. It needs to have made me feel so much love for its characters. It needs to have made me cry at times, to get me to care. It needs to get me excited everytime I hear its name. It needs to be something that will stay close to my heart for a very long time. For me, the difference between a 9 and a 10 is how much I enjoyed it and how totally flawless I believe it to be. |
| I'm a filthy casual, so if I give an anime a 10/10, then it means I really enjoyed it more than the rest |
 [center]My Profile | MyAnimeList | MyMangaList | |
| Relatable characters in an exceptionally strong and unique story. Those two elements offer a series a lot of potential. |
 |
| A fragment of my hyper rating system extracted from my profile: |
| You are not your body, you are your brain, the "self" that emerges from within it. |
| Purely on how much I enjoyed watching it FAM, it can have a few faults |
| All the fools who go around hating on everything should stick to them eighties anime. After all isn't that the golden age of TV anime. |
| To me a 10/10 is a show that transcends what's great to the point of finding myself thinking about the themes it brilliantly tackled many times in the future, and possibly even had an impact in me as a person. Or, in numerical terms, > 9,5/10+ |
 |
| There is no 10/10 anime because every anime has a flaw. |
The word elitist is stupid since it's just used by people who can't defend their favorite shows and use it on people who criticize their favorite shows.  |
| 10/10 = Something equal to or better than Cowboy Bebop It's actually more like a 10/10 resonates with me personally, in emotional and thematic terms. D-Niyu said: The idea behind it and how that idea resonates with me. "Idea" being a vague construct in which many criteria flow into. |
| The statement below is true. The statement above is false. |
More topics from this board
» Are some anime more or less deserving of a better quality adaptation than others ?tchitchouan - 48 minutes ago |
2 |
by Catalano
»»
6 minutes ago |
|
» Crunchyroll Accused of Making their Subtitles Worse? ( 1 2 )LSSJ_Chloe - Oct 1 |
93 |
by griddyweeb
»»
12 minutes ago |
|
» Why is dandadan rated 18+ (TV-MA) literally every streaming site i go? Outside of north america, its between 14-16, even in middle east.mg1109 - Yesterday |
9 |
by ktg
»»
19 minutes ago |
|
» Favorite stand from each JoJo part?Fukoku - Yesterday |
11 |
by Szczelajo
»»
45 minutes ago |
|
» Any figures you would like to see as a Fate Servant?Fukoku - Yesterday |
24 |
by FZREMAKE
»»
1 hour ago |