| Denied: Sfumare (21175) - Korean web comic that does not meet the database guidelines. Utsuro no Hako to Zero no Maria (21181) - Light novel that does not meet the database guidelines. Dogs - Hardcore Twins (21184) - Collected here |
adamantineAug 3, 2010 2:06 AM
 ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| Denied: Marshmallow (21187) - FMA doujinshi not by original author/ copyright holders. Seishun Gakuen Paradise (21188) - Prince of Tennis doujinshi not by original authors/copyright holders. Crazy Cat (21189) - Prince of Tennis doujinshi not by original authors/copyright holders. Jet Coaster Romance (21186) - Prince of Tennis doujinshi not by original authors/copyright holders. Boku ni natta watashi (21190) - Already here. Samvoue (21192) - Can't find any evidence it exists. Samvoue Kinaru (21191) - ditto. Katekyo Hitman Reborn! (21200) - Already here. Sfumare (21201) - webcomic, doesn't meet database guidelines. |
EphidelAug 3, 2010 9:33 PM
| Denied: Dogs - Hardcore Twins (21207) - Included in Vol.2 of Dogs: Bullets & Carnage. Also, onemanga is not an official website. Maybe if you bought the manga instead of reading it online you'd know it was in the book. Vějíř (21205) - Czech OFL, not published in english/japanese, doesn't meet database guidelines. Drainage City 2 (21194) - both volumes are part of the same series, it can share the Drainage City entry. NEET Girlfriend (21210) - duplicate submission. Sub-audio (21216) - part of Groove Tube. Cherry Break (21217) - duplicate submission. Also, wrong picture. Carnivorous Fujoshi Hikikomori (21218) - duplicate submission. Sub-audio (21220) - still part of Groove Tube. Trip Trap (21219) - duplicate submission. Noblesse (21221) - korean webcomic, doesn't meet database guidelines. |
EphidelAug 4, 2010 3:54 PM
| Denied: Calling (21224) - Already here Noblesse (21229) - Does not meet the guidelines, Korean web comic, etc Noblesse (21230) - see above |
adamantineAug 5, 2010 6:04 AM
ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| Denied: Noblesse (21267), Noblesse (21268), and Noblesse (21271) - Korean web comic with no print release. Stop submitting it. Dark Seed (21265) - Duplicate Submission |
ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| Denied: Noblesse (21276) - webcomic, doesn't meet database guidelines. If I close my eyes will it go away? Crossfire (21278) - Included in the first three vols of Hellsing. |
| Denied: noblesse (21285) - webcomic, doesn't meet database guidelines. I wish people actually read this thread. 노블레스 (21288) - no, submitting Noblesse with its original korean title will not get us to add it by mistake. It actually makes it stand out more. Tie Breaker (21287) - original doujin by an unpublished author. BB Project (21289) - OFL with no english release. |
EphidelAug 8, 2010 5:57 AM
| Denied: Noblesse (21300) - webcomic not meeting database guidelines. |
     |
| Denied: 2008 Xmas Present Stories (21302) - this was a furoku / magazine freebie. It isn't an actual manga volume (furthermore, the Love So Life story was compiled into the volume release, and I think the Cyboy one was too. Chances are that the other two, 'Heart of Mary' and 'Memories of Heaven', were compiled into the back of some Sora Asuka/Ikemi Runa volume at some point as well) |
EphidelAug 9, 2010 3:19 PM
| Denied: Noblesse (21324) - So, we meet again. Evangelion - Retake (21326) - Doujinshi not meeting the database guidelines. |
    |
| Merged: HenKoi (21251) with Yuuhi no Ochiru Jikan Iwa and Izaemon (8433) into Korokoro Soushi Barrier Free (17076) into Sarashi Ai Tsumiyori Amai Ai ni Oborete (5181) with Tsumiyori Amai Ai ni Oborete A Daughter's Promise with Father (16471) into Triple Sex HHH A Special Person (7041) into Voiceful Melancholic Trickster (14214) into Katekyo! Amane no Uta (17277) with Amaoto no Uta Hatsukoi mo Naka (17278) into Amaoto no Uta BLAME!2 (21087) into Blame Gakuen! And So On |
| Denied: Dogs (21329) - already here. Kageki ni Ren'ai Kakumei (21320) - Russian entries are fun. It's also a part of this. I added synonyms for the stories in it now, as they weren't there before. rave (21332) - already here. Sore ga kanojo no seigi nara (21331), Sore ga Kanojo no Seigi nara (21333), Sore ga kanojo no seigi nara (21334) - Duplicate submissions. |
EphidelAug 11, 2010 11:03 AM
| Denied: Husky and Medley (21341) - web doujin, no print release, etc. Husky and Medley (21354) - same as above. Noblesse (21347) - denied for the same reasons as before. Luca no ita natsu (21336) - duplicate of (21342), which was the better entry. watashini xx shinasai!! (21351) - already exists Scott Pilgrim vs The World (21357) - not manga |
avrcAug 12, 2010 12:14 PM
|
| Denied: Chikyuu Misaki (21360) - already here. Hourou Musuku (21364) - that description was... bland, but the series is already here. tsurugi no joou to rakuin no ko (21356) - Light novel written by Sugii Hikaru and illustrated by 夕仁. I don't know how to translate that, but I've seen some forums call the illustrator Uni. Either way, the LN doesn't have an anime/manga adaption and as far as I can tell, neither author nor illustrator have worked on manga or have anything in the database already, so it doesn't meet database guidelines. Tower of God (21377) - webcomic with no print release, doesn't meet database guidelines. |
EphidelAug 13, 2010 3:37 AM
| Denied: Noblesse (21358), Noblesse (21382), and Noblesse (21397) - Korean web comic with no print release. Scott Pilgrim (21395) - Not manga. |
adamantineAug 14, 2010 2:55 PM
ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| Denied: Gaku: Minna no Yama (21348) - http://myanimelist.net/manga/13358/Gaku_Minna_no_Yama Mare (21367) - inappropriate image, naked little girls should be censored >.> Teiden Shojo to Hamushi no Orchestra (21386) - http://myanimelist.net/manga.php?id=21380 Tower of God (21388) - webcomic, etc |
shinkeikakuAug 14, 2010 3:33 PM
| Denied: Noblesse (21416) - Korean web comic with no print release. Pig Bride (21423) - Already here: http://myanimelist.net/manga.php?id=9614 |
adamantineAug 15, 2010 5:41 AM
ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| Denied: Tokyonin (21408) - webcomic not meeting the database guidelines M×0 (21428) - already here Noblesse (21431) - webcomic not meeting the database guidelines |
dollie_mixturesAug 16, 2010 3:36 AM
|
| Denied: Legend of the Sun Knight (21442) - duplicate submission Shadow Star Narutaru (21444) - already exists Starry☆Sky ~in Spring~ (21437) - duplicate submission Noblesse (21458) - denied for the same reasons as before Millenium Snow (21459) - already exists Sword Art Online (2145) - Light novel by without an anime/manga adaptation, as well as the author/artist not having worked on an existing entry in the database. That was still in the queue when you reported it, so no worries. Anyways, denied. |
avrcAug 17, 2010 6:07 PM
|
| Denied: Sfumare (21435) - webcomic with no print release, doesn't meet database guidelines. Utsuro no Hako to Zero no Maria (21447), Utsuro no Hako to Zero no Maria (21468) - light novel with no anime/manga adaption, that isn't illustrated by a published mangaka. Doesn't meet database guidelines. 20 year old girl x 30 year old maiden (21453) - part of Rakuen no Jouken / Conditions for Paradise Yves Piaget (21461) - One Piece doujinshi not by the original authors or copyright holders. |
EphidelAug 18, 2010 9:49 AM
| Denied: Kaichu! (21477) - already exists D. Gray-man dj - Classic (21470) - doujinshi not meeting the database guidelines D. Gray-man dj - Classic (21471) - same as above |
avrcAug 19, 2010 12:38 AM
|
Why? Besides being by the same author Dandelion and Shirokuro are completely unrelated to Gintama. |
| Touka I am not sure but if those stories where published in volumes of Gintama that would be why they were merged into Gintama. We merge all one-shots and such into the same volume when a published volume comes out. Denied: Noblesse (21487) - As it is a web comic, it does not meet DB guidelines. See here and here. |
| They have been published in volumes of Gintama but were published in one of the various Jump magazines before that. I just think it is a bit silly to merge them with Gintama when they're completely unrelated. Sorachi's other oneshot will probably be included in a volume of Gintama sooner or later, will that be merged as well even though it made its debut in Jump Square? |
| Touka, yes it will be merged if it ends up in a volume of Gintama. This is how we have been doing one-shots for a very long time now. If you feel this should be changed please start a new thread for this topic. |
| Thing that Drifted Ashore (20603) into Ito Junji Kyoufu Manga Collection Kata Kutsushita no Otoko (13536) into Amane no Uta I Cannot Speak English~! (17060), Crime Scene Investigation (17044) into Takuhai Spirits!! Bloody Little Circus (18735), Chouritsushi (21183), Mizugi no Sekai (17831), Ko Mori Uta (18398) into Gelatin |
| Denied: blue friend (21492) - duplicate submission Mamotte! Lolipop (21495) - already here Sfumare (21496) - webcomic not meeting database guidelines |
dollie_mixturesAug 20, 2010 4:43 AM
|
| Denied: Idol (21500) - german ofl published in the german daisuke mag (not the japanese one), no english release, doesn't meet database guidelines. Vampire Girl (21501) - http://myanimelist.net/manga.php?id=586 Noblesse (21503) - for being noblesse webcomic, no print release, doesn't meet database guidelines. Record Of Fallen Vampire (21506) - http://myanimelist.net/manga.php?id=976 PUREBLOOD+BOYFRIEND (21507) - http://myanimelist.net/manga.php?id=20843 |
| Denied: Tower of God (21518) (21524) - webcomic, etc. Noblesse (21526) (21527) (21528) - wecomic, etc. |
|
| Denied: Kedamono Shounenshoujo (21530) - Already here Collected in Devil's Bride - added synonym Ware wa Ken-ou!! (21415) - Already here The Boyfriend Behind Me (21434) - Collected here |
adamantineAug 23, 2010 9:51 PM
ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| Denied - Kuroshitsuji Comic Anthology Part 2 (21436) It's actually called Kuroshitsuji Anthology Comic Nijishitsuji 2 (黒執事アンソロジーコミック 虹執事 2), meaning it's a second volume of this and doesn't get it's own entry. |
| Denied: Bishounen Shichihenge (21551) - collected in http://myanimelist.net/manga.php?id=5905 Sakkabasu no Yoru (21545) - doujinshi not published by authorized copyright holders Historys Strongest Disciple Kenichi (21552) - already exists A Special Person (21553) - collected in http://myanimelist.net/manga.php?id=5248 Boys Next Door (21554) - already exists Thing that drifted ashore (21557) - collected in http://myanimelist.net/manga.php?id=3156 1½ darling (21563) - collected in http://myanimelist.net/manga.php?id=16647 GTG (21569) - TogaInu doujinshi not by the original authors |
avrcAug 25, 2010 5:28 PM
|
| Denied: Please! Mr. Bear! (21562) - webcomic not meeting database guidelines MYth: My Seasons (21570) - webcomic not meeting database guidelines MYth: Eternal Gift (21571) - webcomic not meeting database guidelines Futanari Bokki Otome (21574) - duplicate submission |
|
| Denied: Classic (21586) - Doujin not by the original author/copyright holders. Kami ka Akuma ka (21592) - Not enough information provided. |
ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| Denied: Noblesse (21604) (21612) (21616) - webcomic, etc. Jyuu Yoku Egoism (21580) - collected in http://myanimelist.net/manga.php?id=3556 G-Maru Edition (21607) - duplicate submission Inakano (21623) - duplicate submission Golden Time (21624) - already exists |
avrcAug 29, 2010 6:32 PM
|
| Denied: Noblesse (21660) (21672) - webcomic, etc. Tower of God (21663) - webcomic, etc. Dakishimete Noir (21647) - already exists |
avrcAug 31, 2010 12:43 PM
|
| Denied: Hanako to Guuwa no Teller (21657) - already exists here. Snow Love (21674) - already exists here. Lovesick Dead (21669) - Yet another part of the Museum of Terror. Star Fox 64 (21634) - I'm not even convinced it was OEL, but if it was it wasn't by one of our approved OEL companies (see database guidelines). Narikiri Lovers (21667) - hentai submission in italian. Unfortunately I couldn't make much sense of it, but feel free to resubmit in english (and with a more censored image). Replay (21678) - duplicate submission, approved this version instead (the submissions were identical. I just hit approve on the later one by mistake when my cursor jogged). Sis-Con (21679) - duplicate submission, approved the other one. Dekotsun (21692) - As far as I can tell, this wasn't written/illustrated by a published mangaka, and definitely not by one in our database, and so doesn't meet database guidelines. Refugee Detective (21691) - It's a novel, not a light novel. ANATA NO CHEF (21689) - ... you even wrote it in the synopsis. A oneshot from Hizamazuite Ai ni Kogarero. Onikirisama no Hakoiri Musume (21704) - already here. Noblesse (21706) - webcomic, no print release, etc. There was another noblesse I refused yesterday but I guess something ate that edit as it isn't listed here anymore. Tower of God (21711) - webcomic, no print release, etc. Herrscher aller Welten (21712) - German OFL with no English release, doesn't meet database guidelines, sorry. Jibun Jishin (21713) - Also German OFL with no English release that doesn't meet database guidelines. |
EphidelSep 2, 2010 9:30 AM
| Merged: Safari (13124) into Tour Shangri-La Forever Honey (2140) into Hitori-tachi Cold Rain Of Happiness (2878) into Beef Jam |
| Denied: WHAT IS FATE...? (21731) - Collected in Snow Drop vol 5 Koi no Hana (21717) - Duplicate Submission Fujimura-kun Meitsu (21730) - Duplicate Submission ETA: Noblesse (21781) - Korean web comic. Elfquest (21759) - American comic. Hana Yori Dango: Ore no Hanashi wo Shiyouka (21762) - This is volume 37 of Hana Yori Dango. |
adamantineSep 6, 2010 4:34 AM
ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| Denied: Life is Full of Happiness and Sorrow (21735) - I don't know WHAT this is. The character names are all from Inazuma Eleven (the plot might be too, I've never played/watched/read it) but I can't find any reference to any Inazuma novels or anything with this name or the synonyms. Fanfic maybe? :| Mars (21737) - already exists here. Please! Mr. Bear! (21754) - webcomic. Hi no Kagutsuchi (21752) - duplicate submission. |
EphidelSep 6, 2010 3:53 PM
| Denied: Blame! 2 (21782) - Collected here Koi no Hana (21789) - Duplicate Submission Inuneko (21796), Inuneko (21799), Inuneko (21800) - Duplicate Submission Shuuichi no Yakata (21797) - Duplicate Submission Shuuchi no Jikan (21801) - Duplicate Submission Yuuwaku Celebrity (21798) - Duplicate Submission |
ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| Denied: Personal Paradise (21787) - German OFL with no English release. Ikinari Osana Najimi (21790) - duplicate submission. This one was filled in better (added the synonym though). Koma-tan (21813) - duplicate submission. Wild Cats (21827) - duplicate submission. Reijin na Hito (21828) - duplicate submission. Target (21829) - duplicate submission. Togainu no Chi (21843) - doujinshi not drawn by or authorised by copyright holders. |
More topics from this board
Sticky: » Manga DB - Post Modifications/Duplicates Here ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Aarana - Jan 4, 2009 |
8388 |
by Adnash
»»
5 hours ago |
|
Sticky: » Manga DB - Post Genre/Theme Requests Here ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kineta - Mar 28, 2022 |
257 |
by eblf2013
»»
Dec 13, 8:20 AM |
|
» Single Volume selectionHachijuusan - Dec 12 |
0 |
by Hachijuusan
»»
Dec 12, 2:43 AM |
|
» Would anyone mind creating a page for the manhua Bao Jin Wo De Xiao Majia aka Everyone's Darling?no_eyes_sight - Dec 9 |
1 |
by deg
»»
Dec 9, 1:01 PM |
|
» Missing Tezuka MangaRory - May 1, 2022 |
9 |
by romagia
»»
Dec 7, 3:01 AM |