New
Feb 15, 2016 12:32 AM
#1
| Source: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/feb/08/downfall-japan-tv-becky-industry-sexism From nightly appearances on TV to persona non grata of Japanese show business in a matter of weeks, the drama of Rebecca Eri Ray Vaughan’s fall from grace was matched only by how much it revealed about Japan’s harsh treatment of its female entertainers. Until news of her alleged affair with a married man surfaced earlier this month, Becky – as she is known – was one of the most popular people on Japanese television, with regular appearances in 10 commercials and on at least half a dozen variety shows. Viewers liked her unthreatening, breezy manner and carefully crafted image as the girl next door. As the daughter of a Japanese woman and British man – her haafu (half) status brought a touch of exotica to their evening viewing. Yet all it took was a leaked text message – seized upon by the tabloid media – to bring to a halt a 15-year career whose upward trajectory seemed guaranteed. Her predicament has also ignited a debate over the vice-like grip Japan’s powerful talent agencies have on female singers, actors and TV celebrities. While the 31-year-old ponders the sudden withdrawal of TV appearances, commercial endorsements and her own radio programme, she may be asking herself why she has been singled out for media vitriol while her alleged lover, a pop singer, carries on, his career apparently unaffected. Discuss. -edited- |
dftyjdfgyjdgyFeb 15, 2016 2:06 AM
Feb 15, 2016 1:37 AM
#2
| When your job is all about image and you ruin said image I don't think it's unfair to be treated harshly by your bosses or the public. They know the consequences and are happy to sign the contracts. Young men have these contracts too so it's hardly a gender issue. If it's your talent that's selling and not your image you can be as slutty as you want. |
fuck everything and rumble |
Feb 15, 2016 1:47 AM
#3
| Japan's gender equality gap? OK, someone help me out here cuz last time I heard, being a female Has more advantages when talking about the entertainment industry. There are much more female voice actors who earn more money than men. Idol groups are obviously insanely more popular if they are women. Japan is very western in many aspects and yet still very "traditional" in others... There is a LOT more pressure for men to earn money in order to support the family then women. And because of this pressure, it is no wonder why suicide is so fucking sky high in Japan. And yeah...you guessed it, just like seemingly everywhere on this goddamn planet...more men commit suicide then women. That number was more than double compared to women in Japan. So yeah...women have it so much harder...the poor delicate flowers... |
Feb 15, 2016 1:56 AM
#4
| bullshit. beccky is all about likable clean character to general public and the man is only known for music talent and people either like music of the band or have no interest in them. If gender were opposite,result Would be opposite. |
Feb 15, 2016 1:59 AM
#5
gallivant said: you're right. i should state that this is not necessarily a gender gap issue in this context.When your job is all about image and you ruin said image I don't think it's unfair to be treated harshly by your bosses or the public. They know the consequences and are happy to sign the contracts. Young men have these contracts too so it's hardly a gender issue. If it's your talent that's selling and not your image you can be as slutty as you want. quick note, becky's official website got taken down as well http://www.becky-music.jp/ |
Feb 15, 2016 2:03 AM
#6
JustALEX said: 1 This article is totally bullshit in the first place . If the male was all about likable character to general public and Job is involving public image and the female were some profession be it rock singer or sports player,result would be opposite 2 Male idols tend to have higer sales but less numerous Top 5 sales by artists 2015 are 3 Joneys idol groups(male idols) and akb(female idol ) and 1 boys band |
umashikanekoFeb 15, 2016 2:40 AM
Feb 15, 2016 3:35 AM
#7
| I don't know if this is a gender gap issue considering that popular male idols tend to get the same treatment (e.g. Mamoru Miyano) and, as someone mentioned in the comment section of the article, the reason why Kawatani's carrier hasn't been affected is because he's an indie rock artist "whose image not one of a moral upright person – such an image does not sell rock records" Though I do think Japan really need to get their shit together when it comes to the idol industry and their purity issues but that's a different topic |
Nico- said: Conversations with people pinging/quoting me to argue about some old post I wrote years ago will not be entertained@Comic_Sans oh no y arnt ppl dieing i need more ppl dieing rly gud plot avansement jus liek tokyo ghoul if erbudy dies amirite |
Feb 15, 2016 3:50 AM
#8
| note the fact that femle idold are less controlled over all alot of jimusho are not even allowed social media to comminatce with fans yes female idold are contoal but not the that extent cause famle idold manger dont want another yukko style happening |
| "If you tremble with indignation at every injustice, then you are a comrade of mine" When the union's inspiration through the workers' blood shall run There can be no power greater anywhere beneath the sun Yet what force on earth is weaker than the feeble strength of one For the Union makes us strong |
Feb 15, 2016 8:15 AM
#9
| Jimusho culture is tyranny to the max and often makes Hollywood look like angels in comparison also there is no privilege in it and often comes with human rights violations. Also, the fans can easily ruin them over false things not even an assumption or something out of context just straight false rumors with no ability at all to defend themselves, debunk the rumor or apologize since they almost have no rights. If just one fan does not like them 100%, they're gone. |
Feb 15, 2016 8:37 AM
#10
| She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. |
Feb 15, 2016 8:41 AM
#11
hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. It's not sexism but my god no one deserves their career ruined over a simple affair, especially since in the US said affair wouldn't do a thing to a star's career. |
Feb 15, 2016 8:46 AM
#12
Hoppy said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. It's not sexism but my god no one deserves their career ruined over a simple affair, especially since in the US said affair wouldn't do a thing to a star's career. Different countries different cultures. |
Feb 15, 2016 8:50 AM
#13
hoopla123 said: Hoppy said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. It's not sexism but my god no one deserves their career ruined over a simple affair, especially since in the US said affair wouldn't do a thing to a star's career. Different countries different cultures. Corrupt, illegal, and draconian business practices =/= culture |
Feb 15, 2016 8:53 AM
#14
Hoppy said: hoopla123 said: Hoppy said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. It's not sexism but my god no one deserves their career ruined over a simple affair, especially since in the US said affair wouldn't do a thing to a star's career. Different countries different cultures. Corrupt, illegal, and draconian business practices =/= culture An affair ruining someone's career (which is entirely her fault) isn't corruption or an example of an illegal business practice. She was a scumbag and got what she deserved. |
Feb 15, 2016 9:01 AM
#15
Hoppy said: you are talking about idol culture? actually she is rather polar opposite of idol. becky has few avid fans but generally positively perceived individual regardless of gender or generation. Her value as TV personal mainly lies on being "cheerful/clean girl generally giving positive impression to everyone" that is why her career as CM talent hit hard. She was popular to companies who want their goods to be associated with "clean" image of her. |
Feb 15, 2016 9:13 AM
#16
umashikaneko said: Hoppy said: you are talking about idol culture? actually she is rather polar opposite of idol. becky has few avid fans but generally positively perceived individual regardless of gender or generation. Her value as TV personal mainly lies on being "cheerful/clean girl generally giving positive impression to everyone" that is why her career as CM talent hit hard. She was popular to companies who want their goods to be associated with "clean" image of her. Still an affair causing all of this is a bit much, you're talking about a punishment that typically happens with drug possession or trafficking, you know actual crimes in Japan. |
Feb 15, 2016 9:24 AM
#17
hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. B-but...she's oppressed cuz she's a womyn... |
Feb 15, 2016 9:28 AM
#18
Hoppy said: Still an affair causing all of this is a bit much, you're talking about a punishment that typically happens with drug possession or trafficking, you know actual crimes in Japan. It is not punishment but more of market value as CM TV personal.She was not model nor actress nor commedian nor singer nor idols She was boasting clean/cheerful/straightforward/tom-boyish character whom no one hate (opposite of idols) thus many companies want her to be in ads. affair is seen extremely negatively in Japan,especially from people of older generation and already married people,and it is indeed illegal If she was dating goody boy actor who are single her market value as CM queen had not been affected |
umashikanekoFeb 15, 2016 10:28 AM
Feb 15, 2016 9:57 AM
#19
| @cymbalino >The Guardian >Sexism Before you talk about "sexism", think about why you are looking at The Guardian. The agenda driven news outlet that still houses Jessica Valenti. Anyway, we all know Japan has a culture around romantic and sexual relationships. They're pretty stupid standards (they have a collectivist mentality), but it's neither one-sided, nor is this case a case of "oppression of womyns", more like, she fucked up knowing fully well what this would have done to her image if anyone would have found out. His image is different, that's why nothing happened to him, no one actually CARES about the dude. |
Play League of Legends here! Autocrat said: Hitler was good, objectively. |
Feb 15, 2016 10:18 AM
#20
Feb 15, 2016 10:26 AM
#21
Hoppy said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. It's not sexism but my god no one deserves their career ruined over a simple affair, especially since in the US said affair wouldn't do a thing to a star's career. the us is apit of moral degration in some places |
| "If you tremble with indignation at every injustice, then you are a comrade of mine" When the union's inspiration through the workers' blood shall run There can be no power greater anywhere beneath the sun Yet what force on earth is weaker than the feeble strength of one For the Union makes us strong |
Feb 15, 2016 10:42 AM
#22
Hoppy said: ikr it's pretty niceIt's not sexism but my god no one deserves their career ruined over a simple affair, especially since in the US said affair wouldn't do a thing to a star's career. Have an affair in the US and your face will be plastered all over the media and then eventually nobody will give a shit. Have an affair in Japan and you'll be blacked out of recognition. Another reason why US > Japan. |
PeenusWeenusCaimFeb 15, 2016 10:46 AM
Feb 15, 2016 10:46 AM
#23
hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. This. Sometimes you have to understand the cultural context of how these things work, think about what people are doing to dig their grave through the whole process. Also Hoppy, just how is this tyranny? Bitch got what she deserved, LOL |
Feb 15, 2016 11:44 AM
#24
| The only reason you would find this overdone is if you are viewing it from a western mindset, but you really shouldn't, this is Japan. If she didn't want something like that to destroy her career, she should have worked in the west where she knew she could get away with something like this, or just not do something that is inappropriate to japanese culture. |
Feb 15, 2016 11:53 AM
#25
Salad said: The only reason you would find this overdone is if you are viewing it from a western mindset, but you really shouldn't, this is Japan. If she didn't want something like that to destroy her career, she should have worked in the west where she knew she could get away with something like this, or just not do something that is inappropriate to japanese culture. i'd say it would also damage your career in the west. but one thing this article said was true, those tv personalities and idols have no talent all together and therefore are easily replaceable. i have never heared of becky, but as a 31- year old woman her career was nearing its end anyway....better bow out with a big bang |
Nigami_ShinFeb 15, 2016 11:57 AM
Feb 15, 2016 11:57 AM
#26
Rinshansan said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. This. Sometimes you have to understand the cultural context of how these things work, think about what people are doing to dig their grave through the whole process. Also Hoppy, just how is this tyranny? Bitch got what she deserved, LOL The punishment didn't fit the crime. |
Feb 15, 2016 12:36 PM
#27
| They treat these women like shit. Its super fucking creepy. |
Feb 15, 2016 12:46 PM
#28
| Isn't sleeping with married people kind of a really big deal breaker over there. This isn't so much a sexism thing as a simple culture thing especially when your image is supposed to be clean. Sexism is just thrown in there because if a woman is ever on the ass end of a bad deal call sexism! |
Feb 15, 2016 3:20 PM
#29
TR-8RCaim said: Hoppy said: ikr it's pretty niceIt's not sexism but my god no one deserves their career ruined over a simple affair, especially since in the US said affair wouldn't do a thing to a star's career. Have an affair in the US and your face will be plastered all over the media and then eventually nobody will give a shit. Have an affair in Japan and you'll be blacked out of recognition. Another reason why US > Japan. no that is backward this is girl was not a politician idols are role models for young girls so is that the exmaple you shpuld give young girls no its not fucking about is not that a goot role model ot set yes i not in the model of saying waring tight cloths or what not leads ot rape |
| "If you tremble with indignation at every injustice, then you are a comrade of mine" When the union's inspiration through the workers' blood shall run There can be no power greater anywhere beneath the sun Yet what force on earth is weaker than the feeble strength of one For the Union makes us strong |
Feb 15, 2016 7:16 PM
#30
hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. Its sexist to blame her and not the person who is actually fucking married. Not saying she didnt do something wrong but the fact people are blowing up on her instead of him shows the level of sexism at play. |
Feb 15, 2016 8:07 PM
#31
| Actually the case of Becky highlights nothing. Becky's entire career is based on her personality, that she was likable. She has no real talent, she is not a musician, a comedian, nor a good actress. She was famous entirely because of her image, and she benefited greatly from that image. As such it is not surprising that when the image collapsed, her appeal collapsed. She had nothing else to fall back on. The same is true of AKB48 "singers", they benefit from the marketing machine of AKB48, it compensates for a lack of talent (the talented AKB48 members usually land on their feet). As such, when these placeholders smear the image, of course they are going to pay a price. To compare such images to people with actual talent is ridiculous. To compare a mainstream star to some third tier "rock" musician even more so. Becky also did not help things when she lied about the affair when it was first exposed. As the old saying goes, its the cover-up that will get you. |
Feb 15, 2016 10:20 PM
#32
megahobbit said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. Its sexist to blame her and not the person who is actually fucking married. Not saying she didnt do something wrong but the fact people are blowing up on her instead of him shows the level of sexism at play. It's not sexist. It's her fault for being a homewrecker and an idiot. Stop crying about sexism at every moment you get. And people wonder why feminists are the joke of society today. |
Feb 18, 2016 5:27 AM
#33
| She had a affair with a married man so I don't really care. |
Feb 18, 2016 6:22 AM
#34
megahobbit said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. Its sexist to blame her and not the person who is actually fucking married. Not saying she didnt do something wrong but the fact people are blowing up on her instead of him shows the level of sexism at play. Ridiculous. It's not that people aren't blaming him, they just don't care because he's in a band and a large portion of his fans aren't obsessive otaku. Her stock falls with this news, his doesn't, that's why there's been a different response by their managers. Nothing to do with gender. |
fuck everything and rumble |
Feb 18, 2016 3:09 PM
#35
megahobbit said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. Its sexist to blame her and not the person who is actually fucking married. Not saying she didnt do something wrong but the fact people are blowing up on her instead of him shows the level of sexism at play. Stop polluting your Western "it's my body and i can use it wherever i want" ideals onto ones that have no time to take in account to them. She willingly put herself in this situation, she's just like your normal "other woman" that give people who initially want nothing to do with her, the bad one all along. |
Feb 18, 2016 3:22 PM
#36
Rinshansan said: megahobbit said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. Its sexist to blame her and not the person who is actually fucking married. Not saying she didnt do something wrong but the fact people are blowing up on her instead of him shows the level of sexism at play. Stop polluting your Western "it's my body and i can use it wherever i want" ideals onto ones that have no time to take in account to them. She willingly put herself in this situation, she's just like your normal "other woman" that give people who initially want nothing to do with her, the bad one all along. Don't defend the often sleazy, overtly draconian jimusho culture, it's almost if not 100% harmful to all but the top execs, and needs to change no matter where it's at. Although I wish people didn't think these terrible business practices are sexist because it's not actually true. |
Feb 18, 2016 3:26 PM
#37
Hoppy said: Rinshansan said: megahobbit said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. Its sexist to blame her and not the person who is actually fucking married. Not saying she didnt do something wrong but the fact people are blowing up on her instead of him shows the level of sexism at play. Stop polluting your Western "it's my body and i can use it wherever i want" ideals onto ones that have no time to take in account to them. She willingly put herself in this situation, she's just like your normal "other woman" that give people who initially want nothing to do with her, the bad one all along. Don't defend the often sleazy, overtly draconian jimusho culture, it's almost if not 100% harmful to all but the top execs, and needs to change no matter where it's at. Although I wish people didn't think these terrible business practices are sexist because it's not actually true. No, you too, don't get it. You just don't snoop around like that. Hell, even outside Japan it should be unacceptable. It takes a fucking brain to not do such damaging things like that. Don't blame the victims. You're doing that right here with your "anti-corporate tyranny" agenda. Forget that for a second and look at what one person willingly did. |
Feb 18, 2016 3:37 PM
#38
Rinshansan said: Hoppy said: Rinshansan said: megahobbit said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. Its sexist to blame her and not the person who is actually fucking married. Not saying she didnt do something wrong but the fact people are blowing up on her instead of him shows the level of sexism at play. Stop polluting your Western "it's my body and i can use it wherever i want" ideals onto ones that have no time to take in account to them. She willingly put herself in this situation, she's just like your normal "other woman" that give people who initially want nothing to do with her, the bad one all along. Don't defend the often sleazy, overtly draconian jimusho culture, it's almost if not 100% harmful to all but the top execs, and needs to change no matter where it's at. Although I wish people didn't think these terrible business practices are sexist because it's not actually true. No, you too, don't get it. You just don't snoop around like that. Hell, even outside Japan it should be unacceptable. It takes a fucking brain to not do such damaging things like that. Don't blame the victims. You're doing that right here with your "anti-corporate tyranny" agenda. Forget that for a second and look at what one person willingly did. It would be a non-issue even if there weren't any shady, crooked agencies around or she was affiliated with an agency that doesn't have all of those bad practices, I would just change my tone and all to a company overreacting. It's something you can just sweep under the rug, people will forget affairs for the most part. |
Feb 18, 2016 3:38 PM
#39
Hoppy said: Rinshansan said: Hoppy said: Rinshansan said: megahobbit said: hoopla123 said: She's a fucking scumbag who had an affair with an already married person. Her career deserves to be ruined. Sexism? Lmao. Pls. Its sexist to blame her and not the person who is actually fucking married. Not saying she didnt do something wrong but the fact people are blowing up on her instead of him shows the level of sexism at play. Stop polluting your Western "it's my body and i can use it wherever i want" ideals onto ones that have no time to take in account to them. She willingly put herself in this situation, she's just like your normal "other woman" that give people who initially want nothing to do with her, the bad one all along. Don't defend the often sleazy, overtly draconian jimusho culture, it's almost if not 100% harmful to all but the top execs, and needs to change no matter where it's at. Although I wish people didn't think these terrible business practices are sexist because it's not actually true. No, you too, don't get it. You just don't snoop around like that. Hell, even outside Japan it should be unacceptable. It takes a fucking brain to not do such damaging things like that. Don't blame the victims. You're doing that right here with your "anti-corporate tyranny" agenda. Forget that for a second and look at what one person willingly did. It would be a non-issue even if there weren't any shady, crooked agencies around or she was affiliated with an agency that doesn't have all of those bad practices, I would just change my tone and all to a company overreacting. It's something you can just sweep under the rug, people will forget affairs for the most part. That still doesn't change what she did to rub them in a worse way. |
Feb 18, 2016 3:49 PM
#40
| I dont know who she is, but as an Idol weeb I would always say the whole "purity" image with dating bans, should just die, I really freaking hate that. even more when it comes to female seiyuus getting death threats whenever they get married wtf Japan wtf (I know I few males seiyuus got them too which is obviously unnaceptable) again, I dont know who she is and what her job was, she did wrong dating a married man? yes, but I dont think just for should lost her job, idk |
| |
Feb 18, 2016 3:54 PM
#41
badwolf45f said: yes, but I dont think just for should lost her job, idk But that is the point, she didn't HAVE a job. She had endorsements. As for the "idols". Remember there is a difference between an "Idol" and a "Musician". The latter, of both genders, can get away with things because they actually have talent and fans; the former are famous solely because they are viewed as "cute". So, if the "purity" image went away, then the whole idol business would go away. |
Feb 18, 2016 4:00 PM
#42
Takuan_Soho said: badwolf45f said: yes, but I dont think just for should lost her job, idk But that is the point, she didn't HAVE a job. She had endorsements. As for the "idols". Remember there is a difference between an "Idol" and a "Musician". The latter, of both genders, can get away with things because they actually have talent and fans; the former are famous solely because they are viewed as "cute". So, if the "purity" image went away, then the whole idol business would go away. cute =/= pure and pure =/= cute A milf can be considered cute, it's extremely subjective. |
Feb 18, 2016 4:07 PM
#43
Takuan_Soho said: badwolf45f said: yes, but I dont think just for should lost her job, idk But that is the point, she didn't HAVE a job. She had endorsements. As for the "idols". Remember there is a difference between an "Idol" and a "Musician". The latter, of both genders, can get away with things because they actually have talent and fans; the former are famous solely because they are viewed as "cute". So, if the "purity" image went away, then the whole idol business would go away. already said I dont know who she is, so sorry whatev and about Idols what you say I agree, Im a fan of AKB48, and so far from what I've seen I can tell there's more on those girls than just "cuteness" that's why I complain, because if and Idol does her job well, that is entertain you, it pissed me off that just because she falls in love and hangs out with a guy her whole career is done... Yeah, I know is what they accepted, the purity is what about idols are... I know I know, Im just stating what pisses me off about idol industry. gladly, at least in AKB, fans (some of them) are starting to be more open minded with the whole thing, Sashihara Rino even tho she had a big scandal with her ex saying everything about their relation, fans supported her and she is still very popular, so I have faith. |
| |
Feb 18, 2016 4:14 PM
#44
Hoppy said: cute =/= pure and pure =/= cute If we were talking about something outside of "pop idols" then yes, you would be right. However we are not talking about a universal truth, nor even are we talking about musicians or even idols in general. For the subgroup we are talking about cute = pure. This goes back to the point I made above about talent. Talented idols (i.e. the one's with real charisma or real singing ability) can survived the cute /= pure, but the one's who exist solely because of the cute = pure belief (most of AKB48 members and Becky) and who would never have been famous except for it, can't complain about their falling out of favor when they violated the one thing that made them famous. |
Feb 18, 2016 4:27 PM
#45
badwolf45f said: Sashihara Rino even tho she had a big scandal with her ex saying everything about their relation, fans supported her and she is still very popular, so I have faith. Thanks for that example, hadn't heard of that one before. There are 2 things different though. The first is that there was no evidence that she did anything, her "boyfriend" really had no proof allowing her to deny that it occurred (and on this having an ex come out is very different than being "caught"). Even then she was demoted. Second, and more importantly, she has real talent. This was evident before with her own tv show and other acting gigs, outside of the AKB48 network. Fair or not, talent is its own excuse, that was the point I made above. The AKB people obviously knew this before her demotion, because they quickly released a single by her, and wanted to test to see if there was damage. It was the third solo #1 hit by an AKB singer ever. That itself is a sign of talent. |
Feb 18, 2016 4:41 PM
#46
Takuan_Soho said: badwolf45f said: Sashihara Rino even tho she had a big scandal with her ex saying everything about their relation, fans supported her and she is still very popular, so I have faith. Thanks for that example, hadn't heard of that one before. There are 2 things different though. The first is that there was no evidence that she did anything, her "boyfriend" really had no proof allowing her to deny that it occurred (and on this having an ex come out is very different than being "caught"). Even then she was demoted. Second, and more importantly, she has real talent. This was evident before with her own tv show and other acting gigs, outside of the AKB48 network. Fair or not, talent is its own excuse, that was the point I made above. The AKB people obviously knew this before her demotion, because they quickly released a single by her, and wanted to test to see if there was damage. It was the third solo #1 hit by an AKB singer ever. That itself is a sign of talent. The first thing Im not sure,I remember seeing a program where the MC where "joking" with Sasshi about the whole scandal thing and they where saying things like "at the end of the day, it was your fault for dating that stupid guy!" and she was like "I know, I know". Also, the fact that she was demoted kind of proves it was somewhat true, I remember reading Yuki Kashiwagii having a similar "scandal" with a leaked picture of her and a guy, she wasn't demoted or anything cuz it turned out to be false. and the second part I know, but thats the point, people should focus on the talent of the girls rather thatn their "purity" and I can tell you Sasshi is not the only talented girl in AKB :/ |
| |
Feb 18, 2016 4:43 PM
#47
| I think it just means that the Japanese liked her for all of the wrong (sexist) reasons. |
| Be thankful for the wisdom granted to you. |
Feb 18, 2016 4:49 PM
#48
MortalMelancholy said: I think it just means that the Japanese liked her for all of the wrong (sexist) reasons. Not really.If you know nothing then don't talk. She is rather polar opposite of idols. Just CM companies are very sensitive about anything illegal,and contract itself includes correspondence to these illegal problems. |
umashikanekoFeb 18, 2016 4:54 PM
Feb 18, 2016 4:53 PM
#49
umashikaneko said: MortalMelancholy said: I think it just means that the Japanese liked her for all of the wrong (sexist) reasons. Not really.If you know nothing then don't talk. umashikaneko said: bullshit. beccky is all about likable clean character to general public and the man is only known for music talent and people either like music of the band or have no interest in them. If gender were opposite,result Would be opposite. Hmm? Becky's character, per se is assigning a gender role (and is thus sexist), which as you said is the reason people liked her. Way to be contradictory. Just because I don't agree with your opinions about it not being a gender role isn't a cause for insult. |
| Be thankful for the wisdom granted to you. |
Feb 18, 2016 5:00 PM
#50
badwolf45f said: Also, the fact that she was demoted kind of proves it was somewhat true The guy had proof that they were friends and that she said some risque things, but not proof that they were "friends with benefits". So that is why they could joke to her about "choosing her friends better". It was those things that got her demoted, though I think the demotion in her case it was more PR move than real punishment, because they released her single soon after that. badwolf45f said: people should focus on the talent of the girls rather thatn their "purity" and I can tell you Sasshi is not the only talented girl in AKB :/ However the whole point of groups like AKB48 or the former Menudo is to prevent any single person from becoming too talented or popular. That would threaten the group. Thus such people are "graduated". Which is another reason that when AKB punishes its members it shouldn't be viewed as "sexism". It is merely protecting the brand. Talent and scandals focus attention too much on a single person for the producer's taste. Oh, should say that the Japanese obsession with their stars is truly genderless. Kei Nishikori was once caught with a minor model, and his female fans went ballistic. One could say that this is the dark side of one of the best things about Japan: their 120% attitude towards everything. |
More topics from this board
Sticky: » The Current Events Board Will Be Closed on Friday JST ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Luna - Aug 2, 2021 |
271 |
by traed
»»
Aug 5, 2021 5:56 PM |
|
» Third shot of Sinovac COVID-19 vaccine offers big increase in antibody levels: study ( 1 2 )Desolated - Jul 30, 2021 |
50 |
by Desolated
»»
Aug 5, 2021 3:24 PM |
|
» Western vaccine producers engage in shameless profiteering while poorer countries are supplied mainly by China.Desolated - Aug 5, 2021 |
1 |
by Bourmegar
»»
Aug 5, 2021 3:23 PM |
|
» NLRB officer says Amazon violated US labor lawDesolated - Aug 3, 2021 |
17 |
by kitsune0
»»
Aug 5, 2021 1:41 PM |
|
» China Backs Cuba in Saying US Should Apply Sanctions To ItselfDesolated - Aug 5, 2021 |
10 |
by Desolated
»»
Aug 5, 2021 1:36 PM |