| Higurashi was enjoyable but everyone looks like a moe, it was kinda disturbing since you have Moe characters killing each other |
| ? |
| No! |
MyNameIsTaken said: Higurashi was enjoyable but everyone looks like a moe, it was kinda disturbing since you have Moe characters killing each other that's the point, though the show still looks like shit |
gedataMar 4, 2015 9:11 AM
 |
| No. As in any piece of fiction, the most important aspects of an anime are story and characters. The impact of any other aspect is minimal. I suppose next we'd say soundtrack, and then animation, with artwork at the end. Really, as long as the story and characters are great, then you've got a great show. However, it is possible to, for example, remove a point for bad animation/art, but that should not greatly impact the rest of the show. I hope this makes sense :) |
Bittenfeld said: To tell you my honest feelings, Admiral Müller, as the groom at a wedding ceremony, the Kaiser is simply just a handsome man, I'm afraid to say. But as the supreme fleet admiral who leads entire fleets, he's really a godly person. Don't you think so, too? Müller said: I think he's quite godly as a groom, too. |
| It depends. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
| yes,if that animu looks ugly i won't watch it aku no hana is a good example |
| Oh, how I wish "Shinsekai Yori" had a bigger budget. |
 |
| Ping Pong was good so no. |
 |
| If you don't watch an anime for it's artstyle you're shallow. yes, shallow and pedantic. |
| I'm fairly tolerant regarding art style, or at least try to be, but yes. Aku no Hana exists in both manga and anime...and the way they chose to handle the anime certainly ruined it for me. The manga, on the other hand, was enjoyable. |
animefan8800 said: I really liked the artwork, and I felt that the pacing was far superior in the anime. But to each his own, right? :)I'm fairly tolerant regarding art style, or at least try to be, but yes. Aku no Hana exists in both manga and anime...and the way they chose to handle the anime certainly ruined it for me. The manga, on the other hand, was enjoyable. I'm only four volumes into the manga, and I think that overall it'll be better than the anime, but the art has nothing to do with it for me. |
Bittenfeld said: To tell you my honest feelings, Admiral Müller, as the groom at a wedding ceremony, the Kaiser is simply just a handsome man, I'm afraid to say. But as the supreme fleet admiral who leads entire fleets, he's really a godly person. Don't you think so, too? Müller said: I think he's quite godly as a groom, too. |
| Not necessarily, I think, if the story is worth watching and interesting. Afterall, I'm watching cause of the plot and not to stare at the art. But first thing you will most likely notice is the art so if you find it disturbing there's a chance that you'll drop it. Then there are also anime which have good art but not so interesting plots. |
 |
NERigby96 said: animefan8800 said: I really liked the artwork, and I felt that the pacing was far superior in the anime. But to each his own, right? :)I'm fairly tolerant regarding art style, or at least try to be, but yes. Aku no Hana exists in both manga and anime...and the way they chose to handle the anime certainly ruined it for me. The manga, on the other hand, was enjoyable. I'm only four volumes into the manga, and I think that overall it'll be better than the anime, but the art has nothing to do with it for me. Exactly, beauty is in the eye of the beholder as the saying goes. If you found the art pleasing then more power to you. ;) |
DejWo said: StevenHu said: Oh, how I wish "Shinsekai Yori" had a bigger budget. That terrible episode 5... The animation in that episode wasn't bad. It was just that particular episode had a guest director who used a different art style. |
|
| No, the art is not a deciseve anime is good or not and certainly can't ruin a good anime. |
| Art isn't the most decisive factor when it comes to determining the overall enjoyment so I guess no. |
Kagami_Hiiragi said: Idc if you think its weird, I have a life and friends and an income of money. |
Lancehot said: I'd say yes but in terms of bad art meaning being of an inconsistent quality rather than simply being of an artstyle I or others don't like. Agreed. Inconsistency is what comes to my mind whenever the topic of bad or lazy art is brought up. Ping Pong's art wasn't bad; it was just different and, most of all, intentional. It was part of the show's charm. Regarding inconsistency, I think that Birdy the Mighty Decode 2's action scenes are a good example of where it can take away from the viewing experience. It's clear that the art quality was drastically toned down during these scenes, to the point where all the details from the characters were removed (resulting in only basic outlines) and debris/smoke from damaged buildings were merely shown as polygons. And then after the action, the art quality would return to normal like nothing happened. It was jarring for sure... but to be fair, it did serve to maintain the quality of the animation and arguably added to the grittiness of the action, but I digress. |
 |
| Yes, or at least for me. I want something that's nice to watch as well as being fun to watch. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
SubaTonic said: StevenHu said: Oh, how I wish "Shinsekai Yori" had a bigger budget. While this didn't hurt the show much at all for me, I'd have liked that..especially for the music. There are several great tunes, but a lot of that anime's soundtrack is very, very generic. At least it got the job done. Don't care. Dvorak's Symphony is worth it. |
mayukachan said: SubaTonic said: While this didn't hurt the show much at all for me, I'd have liked that..especially for the music. There are several great tunes, but a lot of that anime's soundtrack is very, very generic. At least it got the job done. Don't care. Dvorak's Symphony is worth it. But not as worth it as the Dvorak keyboard layout. |
 |
amazingbrian said: I'm more annoyed by lazy animation than actual artstyle |
| Yeah just look at all that shitty pre 2012 stuff. Unwatchable art. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| it can make a bad show worse... a good show... never botherd me :p |
Higashi_no_Kaze said: And people have the gall to recommend anime from that era too, disgusting.Yeah just look at all that shitty pre 2012 stuff. Unwatchable art. |
| Art can only ruin hentai. |
animefan8800 said: I don't know if 'pleasing' is the right word :P NERigby96 said: I really liked the artwork, and I felt that the pacing was far superior in the anime. But to each his own, right? :) I'm only four volumes into the manga, and I think that overall it'll be better than the anime, but the art has nothing to do with it for me. Exactly, beauty is in the eye of the beholder as the saying goes. If you found the art pleasing then more power to you. ;) But I did feel that it represented the story a little better than the artwork in the manga. It was different and slightly strange, just like the story. The artwork in the manga is almost cute, and while I like it too - and I think that it adds a certain layer of unease, what with how young they are - I think the rotoscoping gave the anime an edge. However, I can definitely see why some people don't like it. |
Bittenfeld said: To tell you my honest feelings, Admiral Müller, as the groom at a wedding ceremony, the Kaiser is simply just a handsome man, I'm afraid to say. But as the supreme fleet admiral who leads entire fleets, he's really a godly person. Don't you think so, too? Müller said: I think he's quite godly as a groom, too. |
| For me, yes, it can. I can't force myself through an anime with an art style I find terrible or ugly to look at. |
PoeticJustice said: Art can only ruin hentai. QFT |
| For me it can, but many people are willing to tolerate it. |
| Ad Astra Per Aspera |
| CGI can ruin a lot of anime. So yes. |
| Depends on the person watching it lol. |
Minori Kushieda Forever <3 |
| Yes, and that's why I can hardly watch any post-2005 Anime, because the art is so ugly. |
|
| Not always but personally I'm very picky with the artwork in an anime... |
 :::|| ---A N I M E L I S T--- || ---M A N G A L I S T--- || ---S I G N A T U R E S--- || ---C A R D S--- ||:::  |
| I can handle moderately bad art, but there are some that can cause cancer. Check Aku no Hana. |
Sakuyae said: I've watched it, and my doctor says I'm fine XDI can handle moderately bad art, but there are some that can cause cancer. Check Aku no Hana. |
Bittenfeld said: To tell you my honest feelings, Admiral Müller, as the groom at a wedding ceremony, the Kaiser is simply just a handsome man, I'm afraid to say. But as the supreme fleet admiral who leads entire fleets, he's really a godly person. Don't you think so, too? Müller said: I think he's quite godly as a groom, too. |
Sakuyae said: I can handle moderately bad art, but there are some that can cause cancer. Check Aku no Hana. The art in "Aku no Hana" is perfect for the show, but the rotoscoping wasn't great at times. |
|
SubaTonic said: Huh...I actually thought A-1 did a great job with SSY, unlike the 519581051 other shows they're working on....StevenHu said: Oh, how I wish "Shinsekai Yori" had a bigger budget. While this didn't hurt the show much at all for me, I'd have liked that..especially for the music. There are several great tunes, but a lot of that anime's soundtrack is very, very generic. At least it got the job done. Working_Designs said: Yes, and that's why I can hardly watch any post-2005 Anime, because the art is so ugly. |
210125Mar 4, 2015 11:47 AM
 |
Magnolia said: SubaTonic said: Huh...I actually thought A-1 did a great job with SSY, unlike the 519581051 other shows they're working on....While this didn't hurt the show much at all for me, I'd have liked that..especially for the music. There are several great tunes, but a lot of that anime's soundtrack is very, very generic. At least it got the job done. Working_Designs said: Yes, and that's why I can hardly watch any post-2005 Anime, because the art is so ugly. Ugly? Lina Inverse is HOT. |
|
| For me yes.. but I think i still would complete it ( with eyes hurting :l ) |
| Yeah it totally can. Equally for both old and new. It's a visual medium so visuals are very important. I will punch someone in the face if they can call cowboy bebop, end of eva or GITS SAC ugly. |
 Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
black1blade said: Yeah it totally can. Equally for both old and new. It's a visual medium so visuals are very important. I will punch someone in the face if they can call cowboy bebop, end of eva or GITS SAC ugly. You don't care about people complaining about the quality of the first two movies, right? |
|
More topics from this board
» Best anime with a single titlem_alhafidz - 11 minutes ago |
2 |
by Nirinbo
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Does it make sense to split an OVA?Duado - Yesterday |
7 |
by Duado
»»
13 minutes ago |
|
» If your mean score is below 6 ... ( 1 2 )Dual_A - Yesterday |
65 |
by SgtBateMan
»»
15 minutes ago |
|
» Is anime full of exposition?thewiru - Oct 14 |
8 |
by Shinji-Spark
»»
23 minutes ago |
|
» Most loyal anime charactersm_alhafidz - Oct 4 |
16 |
by SoumyaUkil73
»»
32 minutes ago |