| Just wondering since I'm seeing people refer to her as a boy. Also isn't Kalluto a girl as well? |
tsudecimo said: I think she is a transgender, she is actually boy, but believes/wants to be a girl. That's why only Killua refers to her as ''she'', while those who don't care for Alluka's feelings refer to her as ''he''. Although it could be random and for nothing like Pitou, Kalluto, etc |
 |
| Killua refers to her as "she" and that's good enough for me. |
| "Yes, I have been deprived of emotion. But not completely. Whoever did it, botched the job." - Geralt of Rivia |
| Boy, believes himself to be a girl. Kalluto most likely dresses up like a girl because he's jealous of the relationship between Alluka and Killua. |
| Alluka is most likely transgender: biological male, psychological gender identity is female. copy and modified from the other thread: Basically it's stated clearly Zoldyck family has five Sons. In the official Data book: Alluka is describe as the 4th brother who has yet to appear. Kalluto is describe as "A boy (shounen) who wears Kimono" http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=1buhh&s=5 And in the last month JUMP's report on Election Arc anime, Alluka is described "The fourth son in the family". The word is 'male' (男), and when you combine with four it refers to (fourth son), Son. Male. there's no ambiguity whatsoever. http://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2014/06/18/latest-preview-of-next-hunter-x-hunter-anime-arc-designs Those who are shown calling Alluka male: 1) Illumi, who always refer Alluka as younger brother. 2) Milluki, who also introduce Alluka to a stranger as his younger brother (along with Kalluto, so he called both Alluka and Kalluto male). 3) Mom 4) The butlers called Alluka as Bo-chan "坊ちゃん" , which literally translated as "Young Master", and it's used specifically for male children. http://www.wordsense.eu/坊っちゃん/ Again there's no gender neutral nor ambiguity in this word, it's only used for male . Those who are shown calling Alluka female: Killua...that's it. He told Gotoh that Alluka is a 'girl" (with quotation mark) and Gotoh is shown sweating and looked troubled. So if you deduce from the fact that the official statement + Zoldyck family + Butlers called Alluka male, but only Killua called Alluka 'her", Alluka is most likely transgender (born male, psychological female), but since only Killua respects her feelings so only he use the female pronoun. |
| Togashi is such a weirdo, I'll just pretend they're both girls. If they're truly male then let them look like one. Togashi and his cross dressing homosexuality at its finest. All this does is confuses his fans. If there's a reason why he made them look female then I can understand but I don't see any reason to make them like that. |
keragamming said: Togashi is such a weirdo, I'll just pretend they're both girls. If they're truly male then let them look like one. Togashi and his cross dressing homosexuality at its finest. All this does is confuses his fans. If there's a reason why he made them look female then I can understand but I don't see any reason to make them like that. People have told you the probable reasons: the transgender device can show that only Killua truly cares about Alluka's feelings in the family (actually no one cares about Killua's feelings in this family anyway). As for Kalluto cross-dressing, as Watashii said, he did it out of jealousy (because later on there's a Zoldyck family relationship charts which shown Kalluto jealous of Alluka). So it's not just doing it for lol sake for no reason..it's part of character quirks and relationship, and really why not? Togashi has drawn transgender character before in his previous works (Level E), he's always into gender-bending. One of the works he planned that got rejected by JUMP was about a boy dressed up as a girl. |
| lol kera always with these threads. The phobia is real. |
| ^ yea. shameful how this anime board has such a good amount of them. |
| I don't have anything against homosexuals. It's just that these stuff confuses people. It's also annoying. In my book they're both females, fuck what Togashi says. |
| a transgirl |
 |
| They are all vampires I tell you. But in all seriousness, I bet the family hates the idea of a girl inheriting the family and forces the children to admit they are males. |
| Glad I found this thread. Now I know for sure. |
keragamming said: I don't have anything against homosexuals. It's just that these stuff confuses people. It's also annoying. In my book they're both females, fuck what Togashi says. Females with penises. :3 What kcaco said is true, though. It's a good device to show just how much Killua cares for Alluka. |
| It's just a thing Togashi likes to do. At least you'll expect it from now. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
| third thread about girl or boy lol i think fourth will come soon |
 |
| Silva told Killua that Alluka isn't a human. :0 |
 |
Satan-sama said: Silva told Killua that Alluka isn't a human. :0 You've got a point. I think he's a boy but it looks like he's nothing of that. Killua calls him "a girl" but I've heard Illumi and his parents calling Alluka "a boy". Well I don't care, we'll probably never be sure of his/her gender. |
 |
| Male. |
| Simply Togashi fucking up with your brains, again. |
| Proud founder of The Official Anti-Ging Freecss Fan Club Join now! Kellhus said: GuusWayne said: there is a limit to the suspension of disbelief And it's the fan that did it. Not the smoking porn reading rubik cube genius rape ape with a magic boat. |
| Yes. |
  |
| Woah, stop with the trans-misogyny and check your privilege you shitlord. |
 |
| Wooaaahh.. look what i found !! i thought, we finally get some kawaii female character.. i'm really happy when i watch new OP.. then i found this thread.. :(.. TOGASHII SENSEEIII..... WHYYYYY??? |
"Eye for an eye a tooth for a tooth and eternal sleep... for the Dead." Heike`Code;02` |
| Alluka is a girl. She just happens to have a penis. |
Racaholic said: Alluka is a girl. She just happens to have a penis. lol best description |
|
IchigoRadiance said: I don't think you were supposed to take that as a literal fact. I mean, every other character at least acknowledges that Alluka is a part of the Zoldyck family, Where would she come from, who are her parents then? And if she really wasn't a Zoldyck, then why would the butlers refer to her as young master? I think that much of her family is terrified of her powers, they see her as a monster. Of course, even if she wasn't a human, she may still have a sex, and even without a sex, she would still have a gender. She wants to be referred to as a girl, and Killua refers to her as a girl, and his little sister. So if she was nonhuman, she would be a female non-human, regardless of what she has or not between her legs. Actually, |
Vanser said: Woah, stop with the trans-misogyny and check your privilege you shitlord.  |
| You mean Kalluto? It's a boy probably |
Archadian said: No, OP meant Alluka.You mean Kalluto? It's a boy probably And Kalluto is a confirmed male. |
| Proud founder of The Official Anti-Ging Freecss Fan Club Join now! Kellhus said: GuusWayne said: there is a limit to the suspension of disbelief And it's the fan that did it. Not the smoking porn reading rubik cube genius rape ape with a magic boat. |
Sapewloth said: Archadian said: No, OP meant Alluka.You mean Kalluto? It's a boy probably And Kalluto is a confirmed male. Series has a thing for traps I see. Kurapika looks so manly in hindsight.... |
insan3Spectre said: Killua refers to her as "she" and that's good enough for me. I agree, I believe in Killua referring Alluka as a girl; even though Alluka being called as a boy is more numbered but I trust Killua's words because everyone else from Killua's family are all weirdos except for Killua ( he's the only one who's normal, LOL). :) |
sweetangie said: insan3Spectre said: Killua refers to her as "she" and that's good enough for me. I agree, I believe in Killua referring Alluka as a girl; even though Alluka being called as a boy is more numbered but I trust Killua's words because everyone else from Killua's family are all weirdos except for Killua ( he's the only one who's normal, LOL). :) I mean, don't get me wrong, I think she is biologically male. I'm just respecting Killua referring to her gender as female. |
| "Yes, I have been deprived of emotion. But not completely. Whoever did it, botched the job." - Geralt of Rivia |
| It's a trap. |
IchigoRadiance said: I think it's too early to say that he is right. It really isn't. You can't completely ignore these facts. |
| Alluka refers to herself as Killua's sister and Killua calls her his sister as well. Therefore her gender at least is female. As for her actual biological sex we mightnever know. So think of her as a girl. |
| Anime is pseudo-gender anyway. Just attach a penis to a cute girl and bam suddenly it's a trap and you're somehow gay. |
 |
keragamming said: Togashi and his cross dressing homosexuality at its finest. Lol really? What if someone's biologically a man, psychologically a woman, and is attracted to women? Would you consider that person... straight? The thing is, being transgender or transvestite does not mean that person is a homosexual. I personally know a person that's biologically male, dresses like a female, and is interested in females (as you can imagine, it's uh... quite tough for the poor guy to find someone to date, lol). Alluka is a little different then what you guys seem to be implying anyway. At this point, unless I'm missing something, there's nothing to indicate that Alluka is psychologically female. Does Alluka consider herself a boy that likes to dress like a girl, or does Alluka consider herself to actually be a girl? There's a big difference. There's also the fact that the entire family except for Killua seems to be calling Alluka a "thing", rather than a person. They might just be staying purposefully vague, and the male gender being a translation error (different languages have different levels of how to say things while remaining gender neutral, there's much more of that in Japanese than English). |
| This is like Pitou all over again xD |
 |
Fadeout4 said: keragamming said: Togashi and his cross dressing homosexuality at its finest. There's also the fact that the entire family except for Killua seems to be calling Alluka a "thing", rather than a person. They might just be staying purposefully vague, and the male gender being a translation error (different languages have different levels of how to say things while remaining gender neutral, there's much more of that in Japanese than English). No it's not a fact. only Silva called Alluka a 'thing'. Both Illumi and Milluki called Alluka "younger brother" and used pronoun "he" with no ambiguity and there is certainly no translation error. The butlers all refer Alluka as young master (Bo-chan), an term used specifically for male children and sons. All these male pronouns and male calling are all exactly how literal it is in Japanese and Togashi did it purposefully. And No Japanese doesn't have the he=it thing going on. The official character descriptions (databook and anime report on Jump) clearly describe Alluka as the fourth son (male/brother) in the family. |
| Alluka is a boy. |
   |
BregasSa said: Wooaaahh.. look what i found !! i thought, we finally get some kawaii female character.. i'm really happy when i watch new OP.. then i found this thread.. :(.. TOGASHII SENSEEIII..... WHYYYYY??? Why so disappointed? Did you fap to that toon by any chance? |
jonnyhan said: BregasSa said: Wooaaahh.. look what i found !! i thought, we finally get some kawaii female character.. i'm really happy when i watch new OP.. then i found this thread.. :(.. TOGASHII SENSEEIII..... WHYYYYY??? Why so disappointed? Did you fap to that toon by any chance? What is the problem? lol Figures :v |
 |
BregasSa said: Wooaaahh.. look what i found !! i thought, we finally get some kawaii female character.. i'm really happy when i watch new OP.. then i found this thread.. :(.. TOGASHII SENSEEIII..... WHYYYYY??? But she is a girl. She just happens to have a penis. And on a side note, it's okay to find a boy kawaii, too. You won't turn gay from it. I think. |
| Proud founder of The Official Anti-Ging Freecss Fan Club Join now! Kellhus said: GuusWayne said: there is a limit to the suspension of disbelief And it's the fan that did it. Not the smoking porn reading rubik cube genius rape ape with a magic boat. |
| Apparently a boy. In japanese translation when Killua talk to Gotoh, it written like "There is no way you can put up delicacy care for Alluka. Alluka is a [Girl] after all" or something like that. |
| Apparently even Killua even called Alluka a boy when he was speaking with Morel over the phone. You don't actually hear what he said, but it's pretty obvious given that this was Morel's immediate response to hearing what's going on http://i.imgur.com/0Iu2Ozj.png |
 |
gedata said: Apparently even Killua even called Alluka a boy when he was speaking with Morel over the phone. You don't actually hear what he said, but it's pretty obvious given that this was Morel's immediate response to hearing what's going on http://i.imgur.com/0Iu2Ozj.png Is that just a translation or the manga has the same? OT: meh, whatever. The normal Zolyck sons have "illu" in their names, the trangenders have "allu". Is there a japanese here who knows if these means anything? |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 135 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 24, 2014 |
918 |
by ChrisDC
»»
Today, 12:35 AM |
|
Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 131 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - May 27, 2014 |
1069 |
by ChrisDC
»»
Today, 12:26 AM |
|
Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 112 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jan 14, 2014 |
534 |
by ChrisDC
»»
Today, 12:19 AM |
|
» Second seasonItsukisayo - Aug 22 |
23 |
by SKILIFT26
»»
Yesterday, 8:01 PM |
|
Poll: » Hunter x Hunter (2011) Episode 26 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Avato-chan - Apr 7, 2012 |
112 |
by iumaaga
»»
Yesterday, 7:45 PM |