Noein: Mou Hitori no Kimi e

During their last summer of elementary school, four friends decide to undertake a test of courage at their local graveyard. Before the test begins, Haruka Kaminogi makes a last effort to pull Yuu Gotou away from his controlling mother. While doing so, Haruka suddenly has a strange vision of blue snow followed by the appearance of an imposing silver-haired man. Later, a similar vision occurs at the graveyard to both Haruka and her friends before they try to escape what they assume are ghosts.

Unbeknownst to the children, the people who appeared before them are Dragon Soldiers: an elite military group from a dimension known as La'cryma. The soldiers have traveled to this dimension to secure the "Dragon Torque"—an entity they believe to be their last hope for survival. However, both the Dragon Soldiers and Haruka are shocked to learn that the Dragon Torque is Haruka herself. She attempts to escape from the Dragon Soldiers as she finds her own last ray of hope—the strange silver-haired man who claims to be another version of Yuu himself.

[Written by MAL Rewrite]

Karasu Main

Nakai, Kazuya Japanese

Kaminogi, Haruka Main

Kudou, Haruka Japanese

Gotou, Yuu Main

Takimoto, Fujiko Japanese

Noein Main

Nakai, Kazuya Japanese

Atori Supporting

Suzumura, Kenichi Japanese

Tobi Supporting

Shiraishi, Ryouko Japanese

Fujiwara, Isami Supporting

Miyata, Kouki Japanese

Fukurou Supporting

Kiyasu, Kouhei Japanese

Lily Supporting

Nazuka, Kaori Japanese

Hasebe, Ai Supporting

Chiba, Saeko Japanese

Kawamura, Hiroshi Producer

Kasai, Tsutomu Producer

Akane, Kazuki Director, Script, Storyboard, Creator

Aketagawa, Jin Sound Director

Reviews

Jun 27, 2008

Alexius

Recommended

After completing Noein, I was left with the sensation you rarely get after finishing a series or movie where you personally think almost every little thing was done just right. There's very little else to say to try and express my tremendous respect and appreciation for this series. I personally believe it was orchestrated magnificently and its message carried across powerfully.

Most of all, what I truly respected in this series was its character-driven action, as opposed to plot-driven action. The characters were so fleshed out and their relationships and backgrounds so completely delved into, I had grown to feel like they were real people I ... knew. This was further effective in the juxtaposition that was utilized between future and present selves of these characters (which I will refrain from spoiling further about). The development of relationships between and of the numerous characters in this series, Yuu most of all, was unimaginably compelling and convincing, giving the series an overall true feeling of completion and purpose.

Haruka, most of all, pulled me into the series more and more with the further displays of her distinctive features. Having the ferocity and absolute concern of Hermione from Harry Potter, and the curiosity and strength of Lyra of The Golden Compass, the pleasant down-to-earth character of Haruka was one that you would simply be honored to be friends with. Despite her rough upbringing, her inner strength and selflessness were clear and well-presented in a realistic manner. Yuu, too, was a realistic character suffering from a harsh upbringing and from the effects of strained familial relationships. The relationship found between Yuu and Haruka, and their development, is what I truly believe to be the defining point of this series.

The story, too, gives this series what I believe its distinctness and genius. Carrying across a story filled with Quantum Mechanics, and a great deal of everyday storytelling in a little town in this mix, I believe that the timespaces and parallel universes shown in this series to be an absolutely interesting and entertaining interpretation of Quantum Physics and many of its theories. The unique settings and conflicts only help to improve upon this story.

The only problem I had with the story was the sometimes slow pace of it in the middle of the series. Whereas a lot of information and details given were important, I believed that if I wasn't motivated enough to finish the series, I might have stopped just because of that slowness.

In terms of art and sound, I believe that Noein also delivers. The art was particularly special (even though there were some parts I believe the CGI to be sort of distracting) with its mix of CGI and line art, and the classical music used was clearly appropriate.

Overall, this was one of the most enjoyable, if not the most, anime series I've ever watched. If given the opportunity to watch this series, I suggest and strongly recommend to not let it pass.

Reviewer’s Rating: 10

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by Alexius (5)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Mar 28, 2013

mahoganycow

Mixed Feelings

I briefly considered starting this review by summarizing the show's plot, but it's my opinion that Noein should win an award for “hardest plot to summarize,” so at the risk of making an idiot of myself, I decided against it. I then considered describing the concept in popular science that is behind Noein's plot, but that's almost as complicated as the plot. I'll spare myself some embarrassment.

Noein definitely has a unique look to it, albeit one that's fraught with inconsistency. The character designs are far from typical, being thinner and slightly more realistically proportioned than the norm. Although it eventually becomes clear that action was ... not intended to be the core of the series, the animation does have some strong moments, and, particularly in the first half, there's no shortage of creative futuristic combat. It's also a CGI-heavy show, with the invading ships from Shangri-La as well as many of the backgrounds being the most noticeable examples. The CGI looks good in general, but there are some painful hiccups. In particular, the model for Haruka's house sticks out like a sore thumb. In fact, it's pretty clear that visual quality control is a big issue across the board for Noein—when everything's working and the show is at its best, it looks fantastic, but the art quality varies on an almost minute-to-minute basis, and at its worst, it looks absolutely dreadful. When I think of the show's lovely backgrounds and its unusual use of deep, electric reds and blues in its color palette, I want to sing its praises...but then I recall a couple of action sequences that are reduced to stuttering gray messes by lapses in art and animation, and a multitude of moments where the character designs fall noticeably in quality, and it makes me think twice.

The music is acceptable, though lacking finesse. Noein's plot is an amalgamation of everyday content (like going to school and messing around with friends) and epic sci-fi content (like preventing the universe from disappearing), and the soundtrack strains to accommodate both of these aspects. The former is usually accompanied by tracks in which a recorder is used as the lead instrument, providing a distinctly childish and carefree sound that works well in this context. The more serious content is normally paired with fast-paced orchestral songs and chanted vocals. Both sides of the soundtrack are guilty of going a little over the top at times, and none of the individual songs are particularly memorable, but within the show the score suffices to build the mood.

When it comes to audio track language, I'd choose whatever your preference is, as they're both more than passable. The English dub contains a nice array of veteran voice actors. Crispin Freeman in particular sounds right at home as the haunted Karasu, his voice carrying his trademark dark edge of emotion and power, but that's not to leave some others out—Richard Epcar lends a genuinely creepy touch to Noein's booming, disembodied voice, and Melissa Fahn plays Haruka with conviction. Some secondary characters are not handled quite as well, with some unnatural sounding line deliveries being present. The dub's script also inexplicably changes a supporting cast member's gender from male to female, though that's more of a head-scratcher than a genuine problem. Overall, it's a very serviceable dub. The Japanese audio doesn't have a single hiccup that I can note, and if forced to choose at gunpoint I'd probably say that it's the better track, but it's a close enough race that you should be fine whether you go with the sub or the dub.

Despite all of the elements of sci-fi and action, it's evident that character drama is a little closer to the heart of the series. The main cast consists of Haruka, Yuu, and Karasu (who is Yuu, fifteen years in the future). Haruka is the kind of protagonist that's easy to get behind—kind, level-headed, trustworthy and above all, balanced, not leaning towards any extreme. She's a pretty open book, not written with a whole lot of complexity, but she projects enough likeability and believability to scrape by with a pass from me. The same can't be said of the male lead, Yuu, who is neither complexly written nor likeable. He spends most of the series switching schizophrenically between impotently wallowing in self-pity, and courageously risking his life to try to protect Haruka, and his changes in mood aren't very tactful—you never really know if the Yuu onscreen is the brave, devoted Yuu or the woe-is-me Yuu. Even worse, we don't know anything about his motivation for going to such great lengths to protect Haruka. A few flashbacks show that the two were childhood friends, but it's not elaborated on to any significant degree; the show presents their history in the visual equivalent of about three sentences, which makes it tough to give them a lot of thought as a couple, much less the couple that is supposed to be the centerpiece of the show.

Much to its detriment, Noein also has a colossal number of supporting characters. It has a habit of casting one of them into the spotlight for a portion of an episode, then discarding them and never mentioning them or the importance of their actions again. The show struggles to explain even the basic motivations of some of the characters—we never do learn what exactly drives antagonist Atori's deep hatred of Karasu, why the kids' elementary school teacher is cool with their dangerous encounters with futuristic beings, or the purpose of the awkwardly introduced love triangle between three members of the Dragon Cavalry. Most of these characters' pasts and personalities ultimately end up being explained away with a brief flashback detailing a traumatic moment in their lives, and there's simply no excuse for that. The cast could have been halved, and not only would the series not lose anything, it would probably be better off.

The story, while good on paper, ends up dragging on, and on, and on. I watched intently, but to be honest, that was completely unwarranted; I could probably have slept through a third of the series and still understood the overarching plot, which says a lot about the lack of stringency in the writing. Much as with the characters, the sheer number of subplots that have, at best, a tenuous connection to the story is rather staggering. The show is dangerously lacking in focus, and to quantify that statement a little, I'll point out that Noein contains no less than two doomsday plots and four love stories, which are all occurring simultaneously in three different dimensions. Sadly, all of those dimensions feel like empty stages rather than worlds worth caring about. In theory, it could be done, but it's a tall order that the writers here just couldn't fill, and Noein all but implodes under the workload. The story still has enough interesting content and continuity to be deemed acceptable, but the way that it's organized and presented is decidedly less than good. Perhaps the worst side effect of this is that some great ideas end up getting buried. I think that a character drama in which children encounter their future selves is a superb concept, but many of the cast's “future selves” end up being throwaways—one small aspect of a massive conglomeration of plots.

To give credit where it's due, I actually think that, taken as a whole, Noein is a little bit closer to succeeding than it is to completely failing, and given the amount of elements that it tries to patch together, that's a pretty big compliment. By all indications, Noein should be an utter disaster, but it isn't. It's just not everything that it could have been. In addition, the show feels genuine, and while that's a pretty vague thing to say, I have to imagine that it counts for something. Though it doesn't stand up very well to close inspection, Noein has real heart, a lot of outward likeability, and a lot of ambition. It might be a bit of a mess, but it's definitely not lacking in creativity or artistic vision, and it has at least a couple of powerful moments. So if any aspect of the show interests you, I'd give it the benefit of the doubt and try out a couple of episodes. If you end up disliking it, at least you'll have satisfied your curiosity, and there's always the chance you might get more out of it than I did.

Reviewer’s Rating: 6

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by mahoganycow (34)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Mar 5, 2019

RyanSpring

Not Recommended

My wife and I had been meaning to watch this for many months but for various reasons other anime just kept jumping in front of it. When we finally got around to it, both very interested in the premise and confident we'd like it, we were both highly underwhelmed and disappointed.

The art is super inconsistent. The show has flashes of beauty, but those moments are few and far between, and for every one truly beautiful moment there are a dozen ugly cringe-worthy ones. The way characters are animated is really inconsistent as well. Sometimes they'll be super tall and thin. Other times they're overweight and ... oddly shaped. The inconsistencies with the art are really noticeable and absolutely detract from the show. Often times the show looks older than it is, which is rarely a good thing.

The voice acting is below average. There are zero standout performances in a positive way, though the two best, keeping in mind that best merely means passable, in the dub belong to secondary characters Toby and Koriyama respectively. The voice of Atori is over the top and impossible to take remotely seriously and the voice of Uchida is absolutely terrible. The actress can't decide where her accent is from. Sometimes she's from the southern part of the USA and other times she's British even though her last name is very Japanese.

The character development is PUTRID. These are among the most shallow, undeveloped, one dimensional, cookie cutter characters you'll ever see. Basically every single character has one role or purpose in the bigger picture story and that is the long and short of who they are as a person. The anime also wastes entire episodes on characters that are completely unimportant to the story, such as Yuu's mother, which only exasperates the anime's clear pacing issues and multiple slow, dull stretches.

Karasu is repetitive and has a five line vocabulary. He's like one of those toy dolls with a string where you pull it and it says one of five possible lines. From him you get Protect Haruka, Save Haruka, Haruka is in danger, I love Haruka and Haruka. He's not the only one though- the writing as a whole is really basic and crappy. It could have been written by a middle school student. Cheesy, bare bones lines are everywhere in this anime.

The music during fight scenes was actually really epic and badass. It was too good for the rest of the show, honestly. I tip my cap to the composer and only wish their work had a better anime around it.

All things considered, while this wasn't the worst anime I've ever seen in my life, objectively this show is just bad. I'll not be watching it a second time any time remotely soon and I honestly cannot recommend you watch it at all. It's just not good enough in any way to be worthy of your time.

+Epic fight scene music
+Cool, original premise (completely wasted by horribly botched execution)
+Semi-realistic/believable scientific concepts

-Inconsistent art/animation
-Some of the most underdeveloped, shallow characters ever
-Terrible writing
-Below average voice acting
-Pacing issues/dull stretches

OBJECTIVE RATING- 4
PERSONAL ENJOYMENT RATING- 4

Reviewer’s Rating: 4

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by RyanSpring (180)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Chaotic Slice of Life

by Yuhami

45 Entries · 38 Restacks

Best world-building in anime

by Walter_White18

50 Entries · 191 Restacks

Hermetic Influence in Anime

by TibetanJazz666

43 Entries · 101 Restacks

North American Anime & Manga Releases for June

Here are the North American anime & manga releases for June Week 1: June 4 - 10 Anime Releases Black Lagoon (incl. The Second Barrage & Roberta's Blood ...read more

Jun 3, 2019 6:11 AM by Sakana-san | Discuss (6 comments)

North American Anime & Manga Releases for January

Here are the North American anime & manga releases for January Week 1: January 5 - 11 Anime Releases Dai-Shogun: Great Revolution Complete Collection DVD Dai-Sho...read more

Jan 5, 2016 2:51 PM by trebmeg | Discuss (22 comments)

	Poll: Noein - Mou Hitori no Kimi e Episode 4 Discussion zao - Jun 24, 2008	12 replies	by AshRayKay »» Oct 7, 9:16 PM
	Poll: Noein - Mou Hitori no Kimi e Episode 3 Discussion koyaanisquatsi - Nov 26, 2009	11 replies	by AshRayKay »» Oct 7, 8:45 PM
	Poll: Noein - Mou Hitori no Kimi e Episode 11 Discussion zao - Jun 24, 2008	12 replies	by SuperJohnDoe »» Feb 6, 1:23 PM
	Poll: Noein - Mou Hitori no Kimi e Episode 7 Discussion HaiAlwaysHungry - Mar 14, 2009	9 replies	by SuperJohnDoe »» Feb 5, 12:16 PM
	Poll: Noein - Mou Hitori no Kimi e Episode 12 Discussion Drkness19 - Apr 15, 2009	10 replies	by Archean-Return »» Dec 24, 2023 3:59 AM

The Different Models of Time Travel in Anime

Time travel is a ubiquitous topic in all kinds of storytelling and anime is not an exception. In this article, we take a look at the different ways that it is implemented and provide some particular examples in anime.

by MAL_Articles

60,060 views

Spoiler

10 Anime Like Steins;Gate: Recommendation Corner

There simply are no other anime like Steins;Gate. But we'll try. This list of 10 anime share a theme, tone, or character style with the beloved Steins;Gate series.

by Littoface

1,003,221 views

CollectionSci-fi