If you're going to send a friend request, attach a message or strike up a conversation first.
10: Either life-changing, profound, intimately poignant works of art, utterly unmatched in the medium (Eureka Seven, The Sky Crawlers, Texhnolyze), or complete, perfect, intellectually stimulating, flawless, immersive dramas, fashioned in the exact way I want an anime to be constructed (Stand Alone Complex, Seirei no Moribito). 9: Anything scored a 9 is, ostensibly, a perfect show, and in any other list, would score a 10. A 9 is held back from a perfect score simply by virtue of the few 10s on my list existing, and as such, the criteria for a 9 are exactly the same as a 10. A 9 must be complex, faultless, inspired and unique (Higashi no Eden, Real Drive, Psycho-Pass, Patlabor), or aesthetically and emotionally distinctive in a way that incites the impassioned, sentimental part of my heart I thought lost (Ponyo, K-On!, A Letter to Momo, Overman King Gainer, Golden Boy). Criteria are obviously interchangeable and often interact with one another (Kill la Kill, Innocence, Turn A Gundam, Jin-Roh, Evangelion). 8: As with most individual rating systems on MyAnimeList, an 8 is the lowest an anime can be scored to qualify as a favourite. An 8 still must have profound emotive qualities, but, for one reason or another, simply doesn't reach me the same way a 9 might. An 8 can be objectively flawed, but, whether it be nostalgia (Dragon Ball, The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, FLCL, Mushishi, Kiki's Delivery Service), or sheer, distinctive, one-of-a-kind, auteurist quality (G no Reconguista, Gosenzo-sama Banbanzai, Mobile Suit Victory Gundam, The Big O, Gasaraki), it must be capable of subverting its perceived flaw. 7: The criteria for a 7 is a bit more nuanced, and as such, is hard to define. A 7 is an anime I considered to be, "indicative," of the medium at large, and the best an anime can be without being considered a favourite. This may be because—while it could have an excellent script or jaw-dropping production—it's lacking in that profound, emotional quality I associate with an 8 (Nadesico, Escaflowne The Movie, Vampire Hunter D: Bloodlust, Zettai Shounen, Kizumonogatari, Die Neue These). Furthermore, a 7 can appeal to me on purely arbitrary measures of aesthetics, sentimentality, or nostalgic value, irrelevant of how they stack up against other 7s (Parasite Dolls, Spirit of Wonder, Muumindani no Suisei, Kaze no Tairiku, Unico). Regardless, a 7 will almost always bring something new to the table (Cross Ange, Ping Pong, Otaku no Video, Ergo Proxy, Panty & Stocking, Ghost in the Shell), and those that don't, have most likely mastered the tropes, motifs and ideas of the previous works they draw inspiration from, but with their own added twist (Mushoku Tensei, Bounen no Xam'd, Princess Tutu, War in the Pocket). 6: A 6, in my eyes, is a quintessential "good" anime. Yes, it has evident flaws, but it is still far above your average, run-of-the-mill, flavour-of-the-month bullshit. What separates a 6 from a 7 is that, while a 6 will typically go above and beyond the baseline level of entertainment (Tachiguishi Retsuden, Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, Valverave, Hi-Evolution 2, Babylon), often pushing its ideas, concepts and themes past the standard, with varying degrees of execution, it is simply lacking that personalised element I seek from media (Attack on Titan, Gantz:O, Mobile Suit Gundam Unicorn, Occult Academy, Trigun). Again, this doesn't make a 6 a "bad" anime; it's just not intimate. Those that possess, and sustain, that particular intimate quality (Ichigo Mashimaro, NieA Under 7, Malice@Doll, MiniPato) may just be lacking in technical proficiency, and vice-versa (Le Chevalier De'on, Orbital Children, Patlabor WXIII). 5: This is likely where my rating system differs from most. Where most people might define a 5 as average and middle-of-the-road, I define a 5 as above-average—a show with a lot of merit, intrigue and intent, usually held back by an incompetent script (Hi-Evolution 3, Mardock Scramble, Phantom, Geneshaft, Mobile Suit Gundam ZZ) or insufficient creative direction, whether that be due to lack of funding, passion, manpower, a decent source material, or what have you (Speed Grapher, Kodomo no Jikan, Utawarerumono, Juuni Kokuki, 009 Re:Cyborg). 4: If a 5 is above-average then, you guessed it, a 4 is average. A 4 isn't necessarily bad, nor is it necessarily good either (Kampfer, Mirai Nikki, Your Name, Hellsing Ultimate, Koukaku Kidoutai: Shin Movie). There are no outstanding elements to a 4, but in the odd chance there is something special about a 4, it's dragged down and hampered by pure, unfiltered mediocrity, in a way that legitimately annoys me (Soukyuu no Fafner, Heat Guy J, Fruits Basket, Eureka Seven AO, Devilman Crybaby, Escaflowne). 3: Just like how a 6 is a quintessential "good" anime, a 3 is a quintessential "bad" anime. These are shows that I think are legitimately not good, in any way. A 3 can have something genuine to say, but has most likely offended my sensibilities to such an extent, that it overrides my ability to appreciate its themes, ideas and concepts in earnest (Mobile Suit Gundam F91, Cat Soup, Welcome to the NHK, Gantz, Attack on Titan Season 3 Part 2, Kuzu no Honkai). A 3 can also gain its rating by means of sheer mediocrity, similar to a 4, just without any enjoyable elements to counteract its mundanity (Mobile Suit Gundam NT, Noragami, Kuroshitsuji, Uchuu Senkan Yamamoto Youko). 2: A 2 is interesting, because it is, more often than not, an intriguing, unique show in the grand scheme of the medium, with plenty of redeemable elements. However, because of certain unforgivable aspects that squander its potential, ruin the show, and elicit genuine emotions of frustration, anger, or disgust from me, I'm forced to give it a 2 instead of a 3 (Blue Gender, Sword Art Online, Genocyber, Evangelion 3.0, Deadman Wonderland, Another, FLCL Alternative). 1: Here it is, the worst of the worst. Anything scored a 1 is genuinely fucking awful, reprehensible, irredeemable garbage, which "usually embodies a larger issue I have with the medium as a whole." A 1 either legitimately offends me (Getsuyoubi no Tawawa, FLCL Progressive, Persona 3 the Movie 3: Falling Down, Eureka Seven: Pocket ga Niji de Ippai), or is simply the most worthless, bland, ugly thing you've ever seen (Highway Jenny, Tsui no Sora, Shin Megami Tensei: Tokyo Mokushiroku, Tokyo Ghoul √A, Dragon Ball: Episode of Bardock).
Brain Powerd is definitely on my radar, but I think when I pick back up watching through Tomino stuff, I'll probably round out the Gundam stuff with G Reco next. I know you're pretty big on those ones so I'll be sure to lyk when I get around to them. I actually have the show on bluray since a while, so I'll watch it that way first and check out the movies when I feel like revisiting.
That's a fair take on lotgh, I'll see about checking out DNT at some point since you peaked my interest for sure. Hoping it lives up to the hype whatever the case cause I'm in the mood for a hit when I get back to watching shows. My required dosage of Imaishi peak is doing the trick for now with PSG2 tho haha.
Been seeing your occasional Letterboxd reviews btw, I like them! That Fear Street one was funny lol
yeah, it seems mad fun to keep theorising. s1 is definitely great fun on its own but the s2 rewatch is so, so tempting for that reason alone. i've been meaning to watch Tutu as well. i've no idea it was similar; largely heard it was just 'different', so to speak. will definitely bump it up the evergrowing queue lmao.
seeing the Despera announcement made me super interested in rewatching his works again. i can't imagine when i'll rewatch Texh but Lain and Malice Dolls are works that so desperately need a rewatch.
hey, that's great man. i've been good. 2024 was uh, a bit of a mess but we got out the other end. starting to also lock-in to adult life. very nervous but hey, gotta keep moving forward!
oh hey. my top 10 on mal isn't really in the 'proper' order actually and i haven't actually seen the show in a few years now. that said, however, it's aged so well for me and of the surprisingly decent amount that i remember (and few convos i've had with some other friends), the kill-the-past-esque thematic core continues to resonate, not to mention the unexpected brainworms once i really begun to dig into its metanarrative structure and getting to 'connect' everything. additionally, roger's final lines in ep 26 continue to resonate so deeply, it made me do a complete 180 on my original take.
i also want to say, it's been ages. hope you've held up well man. :)
she did develop her character, but it's not like in the first season. The first season focused more on her past and how she became who she is. No, because there are still those "case of the week" episodes. The drama of the season shifts from the protagonist to other people.
Thanks for the guides! Will definitely be saving these, been kinda dreading working it out, so this awesome haha. I'm a release order kinda guy over chronology if there's a choice. Will lyk my thoughts once I play them, I'll be interested in hearing your thoughts on them too.
Kind of reminds me, as a side note, that I did get up to finishing Turn A back on my Gundam binge. Been a while now for any detailed thoughts off the top, but long story short, I really liked it! Definitely remembered having some gripes but it's a top contender for best Tomino work I've seen so far. Depending the day you ask me, I might still say I actually prefer Victory, but it's pretty much a toss up, each for their own reasons.
Honestly not surprised to hear it for the Galactic Heroes OVAs but considering that episode count I wasn't expecting the visual fidelity to be anything consistent or impressive. Thankfully, I'm usually able to look past that in favor of strong writing and certainly tone. Novels would be a good option, but I'm just awful at consistently reading things that aren't full of pictures cause I'm a complete manchild lmao. In any case, don't think the DNT route is speaking to me.
Yes, thank you. The first three seasons are worth watching, but the fourth isn't so much because there are 6 episodes, but only 3 are random episodes that already aired in previous seasons.
Great pitch, I'm always tuned in for movies lol. I'll definitely check it out at some point. I'd like to play more video games in general, but I have a habit of just saying that so who knows lol. I do think I'll be checking out MG first between them, soon as I figure out which version of what game is what exactly haha.
I'll keep it in mind for Ai-Ren. I've been re-reading manga from my collection as of late so I figure I'll be in the mood for new stuff pretty soon. Same with shows, been craving a top shelf ptw soon, I'm thinking legend of the galactic heroes.
Ay the man's back! Glad to hear DS2 was a good time! I'm not familiar with the franchise yet or most Kojima titles, but it looks pretty fuckin insane. I'm looking forward to checking them out.
Digging the new favourites additions btw! Definitely makes me way more curious about Ai-Ren
Have you had a chance to watch G-Witch? There's something particular to the UC and the new series about to air that I was curious about your opinion on.
I also saw someone recommend IBO, the entire UC, and G-reco at once and go unchallenged. Truly a new (better) era of Gundam fans are being born.
Yeah, I can see where you're coming from with the Lupe scene. While I don't think it quite lands with me, it's definitely a characteristic unique to Tomino and I can respect that.
Victory's approach to the anti-war messaging is pretty layered and definitely demands some rewatching to pick through it all. I think I agree with some of your main ideas here though. Also, that's a fair point on the Katejina scene. The lady captain came across too convinced by Katejina's loose reasoning which struck me as odd, but I guess if she was trying to rationalize it as an order from a superior that she had no choice in anyways, it makes much more sense.
Anyways, I appreciate the interesting discussion. Hope your Christmas was also great and cheers to the new year :)
All Comments (324) Comments
That's a fair take on lotgh, I'll see about checking out DNT at some point since you peaked my interest for sure. Hoping it lives up to the hype whatever the case cause I'm in the mood for a hit when I get back to watching shows. My required dosage of Imaishi peak is doing the trick for now with PSG2 tho haha.
Been seeing your occasional Letterboxd reviews btw, I like them! That Fear Street one was funny lol
seeing the Despera announcement made me super interested in rewatching his works again. i can't imagine when i'll rewatch Texh but Lain and Malice Dolls are works that so desperately need a rewatch.
hey, that's great man. i've been good. 2024 was uh, a bit of a mess but we got out the other end. starting to also lock-in to adult life. very nervous but hey, gotta keep moving forward!
i also want to say, it's been ages. hope you've held up well man. :)
Kind of reminds me, as a side note, that I did get up to finishing Turn A back on my Gundam binge. Been a while now for any detailed thoughts off the top, but long story short, I really liked it! Definitely remembered having some gripes but it's a top contender for best Tomino work I've seen so far. Depending the day you ask me, I might still say I actually prefer Victory, but it's pretty much a toss up, each for their own reasons.
Honestly not surprised to hear it for the Galactic Heroes OVAs but considering that episode count I wasn't expecting the visual fidelity to be anything consistent or impressive. Thankfully, I'm usually able to look past that in favor of strong writing and certainly tone. Novels would be a good option, but I'm just awful at consistently reading things that aren't full of pictures cause I'm a complete manchild lmao. In any case, don't think the DNT route is speaking to me.
I'll keep it in mind for Ai-Ren. I've been re-reading manga from my collection as of late so I figure I'll be in the mood for new stuff pretty soon. Same with shows, been craving a top shelf ptw soon, I'm thinking legend of the galactic heroes.
Digging the new favourites additions btw! Definitely makes me way more curious about Ai-Ren
I also saw someone recommend IBO, the entire UC, and G-reco at once and go unchallenged. Truly a new (better) era of Gundam fans are being born.
Victory's approach to the anti-war messaging is pretty layered and definitely demands some rewatching to pick through it all. I think I agree with some of your main ideas here though. Also, that's a fair point on the Katejina scene. The lady captain came across too convinced by Katejina's loose reasoning which struck me as odd, but I guess if she was trying to rationalize it as an order from a superior that she had no choice in anyways, it makes much more sense.
Anyways, I appreciate the interesting discussion. Hope your Christmas was also great and cheers to the new year :)