Manga 'Karakai Jouzu no Takagi-san' Ends 11-Year Serialization

Feels sad to say goodbye. Of course the spin-off is still there and on-going, but will miss these two. Although, with the movie it was highly likely manga would wrap up soon too.

Aug 17, 2023 10:39 PM by Sigmar-Unberogen

RobertBobert said:
It's really a sequel, but not a sequel, so you're wrong - you couldn't even more confirm that you're just arguing for the sake of arguing. Goodbye.

i mean, your whole argument is just screaming "you are wrong". how is that an argument? you didn't know Moto takagi didn't credit yamamoto shuichiro as writer. you didn't know moto takagi started as fanfic.

Aug 17, 2023 6:08 PM by Kuma

It's really a sequel, but not a sequel, so you're wrong - you couldn't even more confirm that you're just arguing for the sake of arguing. Goodbye.

Aug 17, 2023 1:33 PM by RobertBobert

RobertBobert said:

Kuma said:

i literally give you the context on HOW moto takagi serialization was not even yamamoto original idea and he didn't have much control over moto takagi and only credited as inspiration. it also again, not "literal" sequel in your average sense. please read again i edited my comment to give even more context.

you didn't clarify first argument, but made another one. both are inaccurate and didn't fit moto takagi background.

So, are you literally repeating the delusional dude above who claims that the manga isn't a sequel because it's written by a different author and since the author is different, the author of Takagi has no control over it? All dude, my patience just ran out. Now you are not only supporting a delusional argument for the sake of an argument, but also defending a deliberately delusional argument just to continue it. This is my last reply for you and I will finally add you to the ignore list to make sure I never have to have another delusional endless argument with you again.

again you just completely ignore HOW moto takagi serialization started even after i given you the context. moto takagi was started as fanfic that yamamoto approved, given official serialization, then only later incorporated into main series. the series timeline was indeed a sequel series, but the writing has more nuance. you accuse me being delusional, but you simply have no counter argument nor knowledge about series thus you accuse other being delusional. sound like you are persistent even when you didn't know anything.

Aug 17, 2023 1:20 PM by Kuma

Kuma said:

RobertBobert said:

This does not change the fact that he can and should control it, since this is literally a sequel to his most successful and popular work.

i literally give you the context on HOW moto takagi serialization was not even yamamoto original idea and he didn't have much control over moto takagi and only credited as inspiration. it also again, not "literal" sequel in your average sense. please read again i edited my comment to give even more context.

And I literally clarified what I meant after your very first answer, but you continued to ignore it, continuing to argue with a non-existent thesis. Now you're saying I never made it clear? Even though you made two posts trying to convince me that this was exactly what I had in mind? LOL.

you didn't clarify first argument, but made another one. both are inaccurate and didn't fit moto takagi background.

So, are you literally repeating the delusional dude above who claims that the manga isn't a sequel because it's written by a different author and since the author is different, the author of Takagi has no control over it? All dude, my patience just ran out. Now you are not only supporting a delusional argument for the sake of an argument, but also defending a deliberately delusional argument just to continue it. This is my last reply for you and I will finally add you to the ignore list to make sure I never have to have another delusional endless argument with you again.

Aug 17, 2023 1:01 PM by RobertBobert

RobertBobert said:

Kuma said:

you can clarify your argument if i missunderstood, but you never did.

because he did not have much control of it? moto takagi is not your average "literal" sequel. it started as yamamoto shuichiro made a single twitter illustration post of what if future nishikata family look like. then inaba made full fledged fanfic one shot manga based on twitter post which both went very popular and yamamoto give approval of inaba fanfic. editor who see this have idea "why not we publish this, this seems like easy money" and this idea was approved by both inaba and yamamoto.

This does not change the fact that he can and should control it, since this is literally a sequel to his most successful and popular work.

i literally give you the context on HOW moto takagi serialization was not even yamamoto original idea and he didn't have much control over moto takagi and only credited as inspiration. it also again, not "literal" sequel in your average sense. please read again i edited my comment to give even more context.

And I literally clarified what I meant after your very first answer, but you continued to ignore it, continuing to argue with a non-existent thesis. Now you're saying I never made it clear? Even though you made two posts trying to convince me that this was exactly what I had in mind? LOL.

you didn't clarify first argument, but made another one. both are inaccurate and didn't fit moto takagi background.

Aug 17, 2023 12:56 PM by Kuma

Kuma said:

RobertBobert said:

There is still nothing anywhere about the that I called him the author. You are once again grossly distorting my words to argue for the sake of argument.

you can clarify your argument if i missunderstood, but you never did.

Or will you literally deny that he controls the development of a literal sequel to his main work?

because he did not have much control of it? moto takagi is not your average "literal" sequel. it started as yamamoto shuichiro made a single twitter illustration post of what if future nishikata family look like. then inaba made full fledged fanfic one shot manga based on twitter post which both went very popular and yamamoto give approval of inaba fanfic. editor who see this have idea "why not we publish this, this seems like easy money" and this idea was approved by both inaba and yamamoto.

This does not change the fact that he can and should control it, since this is literally a sequel to his most successful and popular work. And I literally clarified what I meant after your very first answer, but you continued to ignore it, continuing to argue with a non-existent thesis. Now you're saying I never made it clear? Even though you made two posts trying to convince me that this was exactly what I had in mind? LOL.

Aug 17, 2023 12:45 PM by RobertBobert

RobertBobert said:

Kuma said:

you say moto takagi is his decision. it is not. you say it here
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2112094&msgid=69708753#msg69708753

you say he control the writing and development, he is not. yamamoto extend of influence in moto takagi is approval and advice. you say it here
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2112094&msgid=69708884#msg69708884

There is still nothing anywhere about the that I called him the author. You are once again grossly distorting my words to argue for the sake of argument.

you can clarify your argument if i missunderstood, but you never did.

Or will you literally deny that he controls the development of a literal sequel to his main work?

because he did not have much control of it? moto takagi is not your average "literal" sequel. it started when yamamoto shuichiro get a paid request to made illustration about what if future nishikata family look like, yamamoto then post it on twitter. inaba inspired by twitter post then made full fledged fanfic one shot manga which both went very popular. yamamoto give approval of inaba fanfic. editor who see this have idea "why not we publish this" and this idea was approved by both inaba and yamamoto. it's only later yamamoto incorporate moto takagi into main series even further ahead by making nishikata-chan series.

Aug 17, 2023 12:42 PM by Kuma

Kuma said:

RobertBobert said:
@Kuma AND? Where did I say that he writes the plot or is the direct author? You are now starting to reproach me for the takes that you put into my words yourself.

you say moto takagi is his decision. it is not. you say it here
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2112094&msgid=69708753#msg69708753

you say he control the writing and development, he is not. yamamoto extend of influence in moto takagi is approval and advice. you say it here
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2112094&msgid=69708884#msg69708884

There is still nothing anywhere about the that I called him the author. You are once again grossly distorting my words to argue for the sake of argument. Or will you literally deny that he controls the development of a literal sequel to his main work?

Aug 17, 2023 12:13 PM by RobertBobert

RobertBobert said:
@Kuma AND? Where did I say that he writes the plot or is the direct author? You are now starting to reproach me for the takes that you put into my words yourself.

you say moto takagi is his decision. it is not. you say it here
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2112094&msgid=69708753#msg69708753

you say he control the writing and development, he is not. yamamoto extend of influence in moto takagi is approval and advice. you say it here
https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2112094&msgid=69708884#msg69708884

Aug 17, 2023 12:05 PM by Kuma

@Kuma AND? Where did I say that he writes the plot or is the direct author? You are now starting to reproach me for the takes that you put into my words yourself.

Aug 17, 2023 6:14 AM by RobertBobert

I really enjoyed 340913

Aug 17, 2023 2:12 AM by ateks

RobertBobert said:

Kuma said:

he DID NOT controls moto takagi. he only credited as Inspiration. what he credited as author from takagi franchise is original takagi, ashita wa daiyobi, and nishikata-chan. he didn't credited as author in moto takagi and yukari-chan.

Show me where I either indicated that he was credited as the author. Do you understand that controlling the development of a franchise based on your IP and being a direct author are two different things?

you say yamamoto control moto takagi, but the extend he has control over it's IP is saying yes or no and giving some suggestion (which inaba didn't have to follow). he didn't for example giving out a plot for moto takagi because otherwise, he will credited as writer.

Aug 17, 2023 12:49 AM by Kuma

Kuma said:

RobertBobert said:

Thanks, I'm aware. There is literally a whole thread dedicated to this. Obviously I meant that he controls the writing and development of the story.

he DID NOT controls moto takagi. he only credited as Inspiration. what he credited as author from takagi franchise is original takagi, ashita wa daiyobi, and nishikata-chan. he didn't credited as author in moto takagi and yukari-chan.

Show me where I either indicated that he was credited as the author. Do you understand that controlling the development of a franchise based on your IP and being a direct author are two different things?

Aug 16, 2023 10:46 PM by RobertBobert

Fell out of reading this a while ago but it still feels weird to see it actually go, i actually kept up with the sequel manga more so its pretty sad that it will probably end too.

Aug 16, 2023 6:03 PM by JizzyHitler

RobertBobert said:

Kuma said:

if you are talking about moto takagi, that's not written by original author. what yamamoto shuichiro actually write is romance story about their daughter instead
https://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?id=157789

Thanks, I'm aware. There is literally a whole thread dedicated to this. Obviously I meant that he controls the writing and development of the story.

he DID NOT controls moto takagi. he only credited as Inspiration. what he credited as author from takagi franchise is original takagi, ashita wa daiyobi, and nishikata-chan. he didn't credited as author in moto takagi and yukari-chan.

Aug 16, 2023 4:25 PM by Kuma

Kuma said:

RobertBobert said:

It's possible that open romance just wasn't in his plans and he decided to leave it open by simply making the original manga and story about their daughter a teasing romantic comedy.

if you are talking about moto takagi, that's not written by original author. what yamamoto shuichiro actually write is romance story about their daughter instead
https://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?id=157789

Thanks, I'm aware. There is literally a whole thread dedicated to this. Obviously I meant that he controls the writing and development of the story.

Aug 16, 2023 4:02 PM by RobertBobert

RobertBobert said:

Kuma said:

we don't know author intention, but just pointed out how weird it is to just end series like this after hinted that

It's possible that open romance just wasn't in his plans and he decided to leave it open by simply making the original manga and story about their daughter a teasing romantic comedy.

if you are talking about moto takagi, that's not written by original author. what yamamoto shuichiro actually write is romance story about their daughter instead
https://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?id=157789

Aug 16, 2023 3:49 PM by Kuma

Kuma said:

RobertBobert said:

Let's say? But what are the author's intentions about this? If he intended to show it without fail, then there is no problem.

we don't know author intention, but just pointed out how weird it is to just end series like this after hinted that

It's possible that open romance just wasn't in his plans and he decided to leave it open by simply making the original manga and story about their daughter a teasing romantic comedy.

madarchod said:
@RobertBobert Lol... By that logic boruto shouldn't be considered as a sequel to Naruto as it is not written by kishimoto
Ps, You can never win argument with a toxic yaoi fans. They will try to insert gay relationship to every anime especially the ones with huge male cast like almost all the sports animes.
Western world can't comprehend close friendship between two males as anything other than being gay

I just appreciate it when people talk directly about their emotions and experiences, and not try to disguise them as shit like "green apples are ugly, so you're wrong in loving green apples." I understand that, as I said above, direct expression of such experiences can be perceived as "asshole", but if your thoughts could potentially be perceived as such, then what can I say? It's just a bureaucracy of thoughts in my opinion.

Aug 16, 2023 3:30 PM by RobertBobert

RobertBobert said:

Kuma said:

but it was hinted that

Let's say? But what are the author's intentions about this? If he intended to show it without fail, then there is no problem.

we don't know author intention, but just pointed out how weird it is to just end series like this after hinted that

Aug 16, 2023 3:17 PM by Kuma

Manga 'Karakai Jouzu no Takagi-san' Ends 11-Year Serialization

20 of 44 Comments Recent Comments

Related Database Entries

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters