| I just pull a number out my ass and see if it looks cool |
    |
| 1-5 = Characters are annoying as shit. 6-10 = Characters are enjoyable. 6 = I don't like the pacing of the story. And this ruins anything else that might have been good about it. 7 = I like the pacing of the story, but I want certain moments to last longer. 8 = I like it and I got a boner at least once for a satisfactory length of time. 9 = I like it and I got a boner almost every episode. 10 = Incredible and exactly what I had in mind nothing is missing. |
 |
| i start all rating at 10...minus 1 point for bad visuals...minus 1 point for bad VA...minus 1 point for bad audio/OST...minus 1 point for bad pacing/changing timeline of events(<---looking at you solo leveling)...minus 1 point for removing content...and then minus 1-4 points for overall lack of enjoyment. using this grading method i usually end with a rating of 6-8. 5 or below for me means that i REALLY hated that show and will definitely never watch it again in the future, or recommend it to anyone...unless that person wants to watch a dumpster fire. 6- is passable(mostly) <---guilty pleasure anime (it was terrible but i loved it for no reason lul) 7- is a pretty solid anime, might be willing to watch again at some point. 8- is a really good show, starting to recommend it to other people to watch. 9- this show was great, adaptation was great. just needs a touch up here or there and the show would be perfect. DEF gonna rewatch in the future... and 10...nothing needs to be said...it was fantastic. adaptation was faithful...visuals were great...audio was on point...VA's did a fantastic job...loved every minute of it. |
| Hmm, it's usually based on my enjoyment. 8-10/10 are the good ones. |
 |
| Instinct. I don't think too much about it. |
| For me it goes like this, now-a-days, 9 and 10 is any anime that can make me cry (joy or sadness). Since I don't have much emotional stimulation in real life and live action almost never does it for me, any show that can do that will be a 9 or 10. 10 is reserved for anime that are exceptionally special. In the past I used to give 9 and 10 to many shows, some I have kept because they are actually good (and nostalgia) and others I have downgraded. 8 is a show I really liked. Typically I finish it very quickly, watching multiple episodes at a time (as long as it isn't currently airing). It gets an 8 and not higher, since it didn't tug on me emotionally like the ones I give 9 or 10. 7 is a show I like. That's it. 6 is a show I didn't like too much but it wasn't all that bad. 5 and below are shows I typically don't like. I typically start at 2 for the worst shows and add a point based on some aspects of it that I feel are good. I will admit that sometimes I give good shows a score of 2 to 5 just because I don't like one aspect of it. 1 is a score I never give. Even before my current reason for avoiding score 1, I used to not give any anime a 1/10. Now my current reason? It's simple, the abuse of the 1/10 rating has left a bad taste in my mouth and I just avoid it. Also I do understand that animators (not the parent companies and management) have a passion for their work (even though they may not produce the best show out there). Because of this I also don't like giving 1/10. It feels like in shitting on their work (even if it wasn't to my liking). I'd give a 1/10 to many Hollywood movies/shows, because I don't care about that industry. |
| Once you've watched enough anime, it's just a matter of comparing what you're going to rate with what you're rated in the past (do I like this anime as much as the ones I rated 7, a bit more or a bit less?) 7-10) love 5-6) like 3-4) watchable 1-2) dislike |
 |
| Ratings are based on my enjoyment like 10- Favorites (nope not ranking masterpiece) 9- Very Good( this is my scores on Masterpiece) 8- Good( this is normal score) 7- Semi Good( this one is also good but lack on something) 6- Fine( this one is average.) Mostly I recommend are 10-8 based on my score although I more forgiven I just rated them based on my enjoyment, 10 this is really click me even is no masterpiece but I just really like it. |
 |
Reply to Catalano
I just pull a number out my ass and see if it looks cool
| I wanna do the same but I don't have the time to rate each anime I've seen one by one.. I haven't seen some of them for 20 long years.. So it's not happening. Catalano said: I just pull a number out my ass and see if it looks cool |
| In my case, it is simply based on my enjoyment of it :) |
| Enjoyment + how good I think the story was. That's pretty much it. |
 |
| Just how much I enjoyed it. My scores usually range from 6-10 cause anything I just didn't like watching is something I end up dropping and don't want on my list anyways. Unless it's a movie or something. 6- I didn't mind watching/completing this but it's definitely lacking in some way. Be it story, animation or something else. 7- It was nice, sorta your average watch. Nothing outstanding but nothing too detrimental either. 8- I Enjoyed it and looked forward to the next ep every time. 9- It was really good, but not good enough to be considered one of my faves 10- One of my faves for whatever reason Unless it's a really long anime, I also never rate anything unless I've finished it. Never quite got people scoring anime and writing reviews about a series when there's just one or two episodes out. |
| enjoyment, then quality, then creativity |
can't yuck my yum  |
| Vibes. I rate things based on vibes. "But what about the explanation in your profile?" I wrote that 5-ish years ago, it was me trying to "reverse engineer" some logic out of my choices, and I somehow succeeded. |
More topics from this board
» Do any misconceptions about anime and media particularly bother you? ( 1 2 3 )RobertBobert - Aug 17 |
136 |
by RobertBobert
»»
19 minutes ago |
|
» Anime Sucks NowDigimonSommelier - 3 hours ago |
32 |
by deg
»»
28 minutes ago |
|
» Is Clannad After Story the deepest romance anime?Krystopher - 10 hours ago |
12 |
by DigiCat
»»
29 minutes ago |
|
» what is the best one season anime you'd rec anyone ? (less than 30 eps)ame - 3 hours ago |
10 |
by no_comparisonBM
»»
30 minutes ago |
|
» Battle shounen being misunderstood on this website ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kenzolo-folk - Aug 12 |
310 |
by DigiCat
»»
1 hour ago |