Attack on Titan
| def berserk, aot even if 139 didn't happen was not better than berserk also maybe u should not compare one is seinen and the other is shounen since in shounen characters tend to have very strong plot armor even in aot berserk can be compared more with claymore in terms of themes and slashing |
 |
Senyyy said: Berserk's Griff-ith said: berserk's story is very simpledef berserk, aot even if 139 didn't happen was not better than berserk also maybe u should not compare one is seinen and the other is shounen since in shounen characters tend to have very strong plot armor even in aot berserk can be compared more with claymore in terms of themes and slashing and aot’s after the last chap too my friend but no i’m not gonna engage to explain how berserk is much better and def less simple than aot |
|
| Def berserk even if aot wasn't ruined. |
 |
| AoT had a crazy anime adaption and I was constantly engaged pre Marley. So I will give it the point in hype and action. Even if the manga art wasn't impressive. But peak Berserk smokes AoT easily in terms of writing. It's admittedly long ago since I've read it, but from what I remember it felt far more grounded. The characters had more layers and the dialogue was rich. In AoT the plot and characters often felt contrived like they were merely fanservice. Especially when Eren became an uber edgelord. Painfully juvenille, not adequate for a series as bleak and ambitious as AoT. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
| Attack on titan Berserk is also amazing but nah, aot is more smart. both are legendary tho at this point. |
 |
| Berserk or My hero academia? What do ya'll think? Comparing seinen with shounen is too much of a reach. |
 Scordolo's Recent Reviews To your eternity Vanitas no Karte |
| Look mate, there are some things you just don't do in life. And one of those things is comparing anything to match Berserk. Look, I love Aot more than most, but there shouldn't even be a comparison though. |
     |
Scordolo said: Berserk or My hero academia? What do ya'll think? Comparing seinen with shounen is too much of a reach. Exactly, that's like comparing the bible to a children's book. |
|
| I Love Berserk. Though Aot is also pretty good, its a solid 6/10 |
 |
Griff-ith said: def berserk, aot even if 139 didn't happen was not better than berserk also maybe u should not compare one is seinen and the other is shounen since in shounen characters tend to have very strong plot armor even in aot berserk can be compared more with claymore in terms of themes and slashing Berserk isn't exactly great when it comes to not having plot armor though. It does a great job of killing of characters in the Golden Age arc. However post that major "good guy" characters never die even though there are shit ton of dangerous fight scenes in the story. |
 |
| I've never read Berserk so I can't say anything about it but AOT isn't really anything to write home about. It's easy to say that the last chapters ruined it but that's just not true, it was decent in the beginning with a somewhat original premise and serviceable characters but there were already noticeable cracks in the story going back as far as the inner government '""politics""" arc. It kinda redeemed itself with return to shiganshina but the basement reveal ruined what would have otherwise been a fairly compelling mystery, branching into the incredibly contrived world plot which showed that Isayama had no idea on how to write geopolitics, culminating in the retarded-ass paths and rushed garbage ending. So maybe Berserk? |
| If you will ask me what do I like more- Biryani or Pizza? I won't be able to answer it bc they are completely different food that tastes different and is cooked differently. So I can't say which one is better. That's the same case for AoT and Berserk. Both stories tackle multiple themes brilliantly. Both stories have brilliant Protagonists and Antagonists and both stories have their fair share of well-written side characters. It all comes down to preference. Tho I am quite surprised watching all this variety of answers. |
   |
| Berserk is far better than attack on titan. It provides justice to all it genres,all the characters are amazingly written and showcased,the story is better and more realistic. |
 |
engich said: Aot of course. Berserk is only carried by gore, rape and edgy stuff while the whole story and themes are average at best. Guts is a bland edgy mc, the politics and worldbuilding of berserk are terribly written. The only good thing in berserk is the art. Berserk is an extremely realistic story with real life elements,Aot is a great show indeed but it doesnt stand out that much to me,because of the weird ways they handle the "problems" in the show(Annie's crystallization, levi's fidget spinner mode etc.) And the story is too *DEEP* that in the 2nd and 3rd season most of the their was spent in foreshadowing amd explaining the big storyline,which is good now,that we already in 5 seasons but if u were to judge each season separately than it isnt THAT good. |
|
| one is plot driven and one is character driven, I personaly like SnK more but berserk is there too |
    |
| Both decline in quality after certain events, so in terms of absoluteness, both are lacking. But compared at their respective peaks, Berserk is far better. |
| "Life is too bitter, so coffee, at least should be sweet..." - Hikigaya Hachiman (Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatte Iru) |
| Berserk is the only and obvious answer here. |
| Berserk. Easily. Attack On Titan isn't anything special at this point. It was. But at this point no. I still like Attack On Titan mind you but it's not special like Berserk is. Plus lets not mention the overall MAL score compared to AOT. |
  Even If We Painstakingly Piece Together Something Lost, It Doesn't Mean Things Will Ever go Back To How They Were - Guts  |
GalacticSamurai said: BerriesSan said: yeah very smart like your drugs bruhh have you even read the beserk aotard?Attack on titan Berserk is also amazing but nah, aot is more smart. both are legendary tho at this point. No I never read beserk, all I read was berserk. I'm sorry. I still stand by my take. Aot is the smartest series out there. |
|
| not even a question berserk even pre 139 aot does nothing better than berserk even the beserk anime beats it when compared to berserk aot is literal garbage whoever says aot is better is not to be taken seriously |
engich said: you clearly are to simple minded to understand the story because what you are saying makes you look like a clown Aot of course. Berserk is only carried by gore, rape and edgy stuff while the whole story and themes are average at best. Guts is a bland edgy mc, the politics and worldbuilding of berserk are terribly written. The only good thing in berserk is the art. |
| I don't think the two should be compared, however, here's my take. AoT has some really smart writing, and I appreciate that. However, the climax fell flat and left a sour taste in my mouth, and the writing was nothing special after 123. Berserk, I'm still too early to judge it properly, however, the writing is phenomenal. AoT is smart, but Berserk is on another level. It's not as smart as AoT but the character development and plot progression is on inhuman levels. Kentaro really poured it all into the series. AoT relies more on shock factor. Berserk relies more on gradual progression. AoT relies a lot on foreshadowing whereas Berserk focuses on the build-up. Personally, I'd favor Berserk. Also the AoT fans who say AoT is better, you're entitled to your opinion, get rid of your bias and give Berserk a try. |
Yesterday, you were the defeated. What have you become today? |
engich said: Aot of course. Berserk is only carried by gore, rape and edgy stuff while the whole story and themes are average at best. Guts is a bland edgy mc, the politics and worldbuilding of berserk are terribly written. The only good thing in berserk is the art. It's your opinion so it's not wrong. However it's a terrible, garbage opinion. The themes and dialogue in Berserk are insanely good. AoT also has some good themes but it's dialogue is carried by occasional good quotes by some of the characters. Don't mind me, I love AoT, but Berserk beats it easy. |
Yesterday, you were the defeated. What have you become today? |
Chota_Itachi said: AOT , specially i liked the ending so 100% AOT , berserk is good but its story is not as complex as AOT Complexity does not automatically make a story good, it's execution is very very important. Look at Naruto, simple plot at first but grows more and more complex, however the execution just doesn't keep up. Also I don't know what kind of emotional capacity you have that you liked AoT's ending. I guess you're an EreMika shipper? The themes, art, dialogue, and characters carry Berserk. AoT is carried by the Colossal Titan suddenly appearing out of nowhere. Berserk's execution is what makes the story good even tho it's simple. AoT's writing, foreshadowing and Levi being a Beyblade make it good. |
Yesterday, you were the defeated. What have you become today? |
YeagerBonebone said: Griff-ith said: def berserk, aot even if 139 didn't happen was not better than berserk also maybe u should not compare one is seinen and the other is shounen since in shounen characters tend to have very strong plot armor even in aot berserk can be compared more with claymore in terms of themes and slashing Berserk isn't exactly great when it comes to not having plot armor though. It does a great job of killing of characters in the Golden Age arc. However post that major "good guy" characters never die even though there are shit ton of dangerous fight scenes in the story. Mostly because Guts is basically Doomslayer after the golden age. Too angry to die. |
Yesterday, you were the defeated. What have you become today? |
More topics from this board
» Most underrated AOT part/arc in your opinion?DarkFirefly72 - Oct 7 |
11 |
by Rexaly
»»
Oct 9, 11:00 PM |
|
» 'Even a Child Can Do It': Shonen Jump Editor Calls Out Attack on Titan as Just 'Making a Lot of Noise'deg - Jul 18 |
6 |
by therealnagora
»»
Sep 13, 10:00 AM |
|
» Worst death of the series?Dragevard - May 29, 2021 |
3 |
by Kawaii_Otaku04
»»
Aug 3, 8:38 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 19 Discussionricardocsc - Oct 2, 2012 |
17 |
by Jeffrey8172
»»
Jul 11, 7:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 130 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )keragamming - Jul 6, 2020 |
213 |
by Adam_________
»»
Jun 3, 1:39 PM |