New
Feb 6, 2020 4:56 AM
#401
FOR LORD NUXANOR LORD OF FLEXING, ALL HAIL LORD NUX SAMMA, LORD BRIGO, WE ARE THE FLEX LORDS |
Feb 6, 2020 4:57 AM
#402
azzuRe said: Ferien said: you know, maybe MAL should just cut this deep and remove this weak and useless scoring and ranking system in its entirety. Agree on removal of ranking system, but I would rather keep the scoring system. It is still useful when making anime recommendation to people to know what they enjoyed and what they avoid. I do not think you can not have a scoring system without having a ranking with it as well but people should indeed not focus on the ranking order when scoring cause that kinda would makes your score not your own anymore |
Feb 6, 2020 4:57 AM
#403
wow, geting so salty over this meme tells a lot about this comunity! |
Feb 6, 2020 4:59 AM
#404
HaXXspetten said: Nobody takes scores seriously anymore for quite a while, long before the recent troll incidents. And I wouldn't blame the bored teenager lemmings lynchmob of taking down what was not working anyway. There are several options:Mattinator95 said: More like fans of other series will start downvoting this in the same wayWho's ready for stains gate and FMB to get spammed even more to surpass this , .... This is why don't take scores seriously anymore . 1) Throw math at it basically what anidb.net does, which is to normalize ratings to fit the rater's own average (self-weighting), using temporary and permanent votes, having different categories of votes. Or what IMDB does, such as having more demographic groups and weight "good reviewers" higher but in an intransparent way. This is the hard way. 2) Let the children play I'm using my own system to find out a fair rating, and that is picking friends with high affinity only. I basically have a subset of 100 MAL users I trust, and of whom I know they use full range rating. I only care for that view, not for the official rating. MAL should offer more support for individualized views on the DB, one size fits all has failed, imho. You shouldn't need to abuse the friends function to get useable views. |
Feb 6, 2020 5:00 AM
#405
ibm3 said: Well unfortunately you're just as malicious in the eyes of the staffDHancock said: From the creators of "Let's make some bots to downgrade Chihayafuru 3 because it dared to face Vinland Saga" comes "Let's boost Ishuzoku Reviewers because Funimation dared to drop it". I think I'm getting used to create this kind of threads. I'll take the chance to ask @luna if there's any improvement or news about the supposed system to finish with fake accounts and mass rating trolling. I guess the issue is that we aren't bots but simply people who think this is fun ;) Making accounts for the sole purpose of upvoting or downvoting one or a few entries is against the terms of service regardless of whether the account happens to be created by hand or by a bot. Either way they have historically been deleted by the mods sooner or later. Now that's of course about to change but nevertheless in about two weeks time that kind of effort will be wasted anyway as any spam accounts will be discounted from the site's scoring formula henceforth |
Feb 6, 2020 5:00 AM
#406
They're not even being serious. Calm down. |
Feb 6, 2020 5:04 AM
#407
-GilgaSmash- said: jal90 said: Leulight said: jal90 said: Leulight said: cyruz said: Themousen said: Thanks to Nux, this anime will be legendary (well, it is already...) In a week, Ishuzoku Reviewers will take the #1 spot from FMAB, I'm sure of it I really hope everyone partaking in this will be successful enough to at some point be in a position where they have to waste their precious time dealing with something like this. To exist just to make the lives of other people more difficult is truly the pinnacle for some people in the anime community. Big thanks from the bottom of my heart. Maybe just do something about your flawed score system then. Maybe the next choice is completely removing the top anime and manga sections and we will all be laughing at how a bunch of self-righteous trolls fucked up another feature of this site. Seriously, if you are doing this shit at least don't make it sound like you are doing justice. Heh I am not a part of this 10 spamming movement, but would be really nice if the top sections are removed, the scoring system is flawed af. You can laugh all you want. If they don't do anything about the scoring system to make the scores ACTUALLY RELEVANT, this site can screw off for all I care. Yeah sure, and the solution is completely screwing them and rendering them unusable. They are creating a problem where there wasn't any. The scores are relevant, as long as they correspond to what people like and vote in consequence. It's bot spamming what is an issue here, not the tastes of the community. There was nothing to fix until a bunch of trolls felt they had to make a point and an even bigger bunch of trolls felt it was funny to fuck up things because Nux Taku ordered them so. So yeah, this will eventually be fixed and right now it's a dumb mass trolling. I hope we don't lose something in the process like we did with the review system. The scores are not relevant when they are community based Hope this helps It didn't help sorry. Hope there's more of an argument with that statement. |
Feb 6, 2020 5:10 AM
#408
-GilgaSmash- said: jal90 said: -GilgaSmash- said: jal90 said: Leulight said: jal90 said: Leulight said: cyruz said: Themousen said: Thanks to Nux, this anime will be legendary (well, it is already...) In a week, Ishuzoku Reviewers will take the #1 spot from FMAB, I'm sure of it I really hope everyone partaking in this will be successful enough to at some point be in a position where they have to waste their precious time dealing with something like this. To exist just to make the lives of other people more difficult is truly the pinnacle for some people in the anime community. Big thanks from the bottom of my heart. Maybe just do something about your flawed score system then. Maybe the next choice is completely removing the top anime and manga sections and we will all be laughing at how a bunch of self-righteous trolls fucked up another feature of this site. Seriously, if you are doing this shit at least don't make it sound like you are doing justice. Heh I am not a part of this 10 spamming movement, but would be really nice if the top sections are removed, the scoring system is flawed af. You can laugh all you want. If they don't do anything about the scoring system to make the scores ACTUALLY RELEVANT, this site can screw off for all I care. Yeah sure, and the solution is completely screwing them and rendering them unusable. They are creating a problem where there wasn't any. The scores are relevant, as long as they correspond to what people like and vote in consequence. It's bot spamming what is an issue here, not the tastes of the community. There was nothing to fix until a bunch of trolls felt they had to make a point and an even bigger bunch of trolls felt it was funny to fuck up things because Nux Taku ordered them so. So yeah, this will eventually be fixed and right now it's a dumb mass trolling. I hope we don't lose something in the process like we did with the review system. The scores are not relevant when they are community based Hope this helps It didn't help sorry. Hope there's more of an argument with that statement. You know when the vote has no critics is completely pointless Community based poles would get mediocre stuff like demon slayer as anime of the year even tho objectively speaking (ratings being meant to be objective atleast 50%) it's not even top 20 Being highly rated because the community likes it is a point, it indicates that the community likes it. Don't use "pointless" as a buzzword here when you are talking about your own personal issues. |
Feb 6, 2020 5:10 AM
#409
just wait till more people watch it then score will drop where it belongs |
Feb 6, 2020 5:12 AM
#410
cyruz said: Themousen said: Thanks to Nux, this anime will be legendary (well, it is already...) In a week, Ishuzoku Reviewers will take the #1 spot from FMAB, I'm sure of it I really hope everyone partaking in this will be successful enough to at some point be in a position where they have to waste their precious time dealing with something like this. To exist just to make the lives of other people more difficult is truly the pinnacle for some people in the anime community. Big thanks from the bottom of my heart. lol |
Feb 6, 2020 5:13 AM
#411
Touma_Mikoto said: azzuRe said: Ferien said: you know, maybe MAL should just cut this deep and remove this weak and useless scoring and ranking system in its entirety. Agree on removal of ranking system, but I would rather keep the scoring system. It is still useful when making anime recommendation to people to know what they enjoyed and what they avoid. I do not think you can not have a scoring system without having a ranking with it as well but people should indeed not focus on the ranking order when scoring cause that kinda would makes your score not your own anymore Not really, I always find ranking system in MAL to be ridiculous since anime is such a wide spectrum of topic and audience, some would have massive viewership and others would be limited to a certain niche, there are shows that people would avoid and would never watched and never score and there's shows that would attract some niche and getting good score even with low viewership. Putting a rankng system on these is oversimplifying the variety of genre and niche in anime medium. If there's a ranking to be put on scale it should be sales (like box-office), or simply amount of viewers that watched it, not the score that given by viewers. |
The most important things in life is the people that you care about |
Feb 6, 2020 5:13 AM
#412
Community based scores are more often than not popularity based instead of quality based (that does not mean they are useless but they are also a bit skewed cause of it) Which is probably why people are saying they are not relevant |
Feb 6, 2020 5:14 AM
#413
Feb 6, 2020 5:17 AM
#414
Touma_Mikoto said: Community based scores are more often than not popularity based instead of quality based (that does not mean they are useless but they are also a bit skewed cause of it) Which is probably why people are saying they are not relevant Of course. They are not single indicators of quality. They are aggregates and are useful as aggregates, that is, to show tendencies, popularity and what the MAL community likes or dislikes as a whole. Just because they are not relevant the way some people want them to be doesn't mean they aren't relevant. |
Feb 6, 2020 5:18 AM
#415
jal90 said: -GilgaSmash- said: jal90 said: Leulight said: jal90 said: Leulight said: cyruz said: Themousen said: Thanks to Nux, this anime will be legendary (well, it is already...) In a week, Ishuzoku Reviewers will take the #1 spot from FMAB, I'm sure of it I really hope everyone partaking in this will be successful enough to at some point be in a position where they have to waste their precious time dealing with something like this. To exist just to make the lives of other people more difficult is truly the pinnacle for some people in the anime community. Big thanks from the bottom of my heart. Maybe just do something about your flawed score system then. Maybe the next choice is completely removing the top anime and manga sections and we will all be laughing at how a bunch of self-righteous trolls fucked up another feature of this site. Seriously, if you are doing this shit at least don't make it sound like you are doing justice. Heh I am not a part of this 10 spamming movement, but would be really nice if the top sections are removed, the scoring system is flawed af. You can laugh all you want. If they don't do anything about the scoring system to make the scores ACTUALLY RELEVANT, this site can screw off for all I care. Yeah sure, and the solution is completely screwing them and rendering them unusable. They are creating a problem where there wasn't any. The scores are relevant, as long as they correspond to what people like and vote in consequence. It's bot spamming what is an issue here, not the tastes of the community. There was nothing to fix until a bunch of trolls felt they had to make a point and an even bigger bunch of trolls felt it was funny to fuck up things because Nux Taku ordered them so. So yeah, this will eventually be fixed and right now it's a dumb mass trolling. I hope we don't lose something in the process like we did with the review system. The scores are not relevant when they are community based Hope this helps It didn't help sorry. Hope there's more of an argument with that statement. Because the community can't score things objectively. You give your score base on your own personal taste as everybody else. And the highest scores will always go to the animals that reach a broather public, the ones with most media, see Kimetsu no Yaiba case, It's an ok anime but not enouth to be to 20 or best of the year... The high scores are only there due the media exposure... As I said in my other post, the users recommendation by similarity are more useful than the scores... just watch a few episodes and decide for yourself if is good or not... |
Feb 6, 2020 5:21 AM
#416
azzuRe said: Not really, I always find ranking system in MAL to be ridiculous since anime is such a wide spectrum of topic and audience, some would have massive viewership and others would be limited to a certain niche, there are shows that people would avoid and would never watched and never score and there's shows that would attract some niche and getting good score even with low viewership. Putting a rankng system on these is oversimplifying the variety of genre and niche in anime medium. If there's a ranking to be put on scale it should be sales (like box-office), or simply amount of viewers that watched it, not the score that given by viewers. but it is not like MAL only has 1 ranking order you also have Most Popular & Most Favorited and you kinda can make your own ranking order using "Anime Search" it is just that when one has ratings there will be a highest/lowest rated one as well hence the you can not have one without the other |
Feb 6, 2020 5:23 AM
#417
Tecnomage36 said: jal90 said: -GilgaSmash- said: jal90 said: Leulight said: jal90 said: Leulight said: cyruz said: Themousen said: Thanks to Nux, this anime will be legendary (well, it is already...) In a week, Ishuzoku Reviewers will take the #1 spot from FMAB, I'm sure of it I really hope everyone partaking in this will be successful enough to at some point be in a position where they have to waste their precious time dealing with something like this. To exist just to make the lives of other people more difficult is truly the pinnacle for some people in the anime community. Big thanks from the bottom of my heart. Maybe just do something about your flawed score system then. Maybe the next choice is completely removing the top anime and manga sections and we will all be laughing at how a bunch of self-righteous trolls fucked up another feature of this site. Seriously, if you are doing this shit at least don't make it sound like you are doing justice. Heh I am not a part of this 10 spamming movement, but would be really nice if the top sections are removed, the scoring system is flawed af. You can laugh all you want. If they don't do anything about the scoring system to make the scores ACTUALLY RELEVANT, this site can screw off for all I care. Yeah sure, and the solution is completely screwing them and rendering them unusable. They are creating a problem where there wasn't any. The scores are relevant, as long as they correspond to what people like and vote in consequence. It's bot spamming what is an issue here, not the tastes of the community. There was nothing to fix until a bunch of trolls felt they had to make a point and an even bigger bunch of trolls felt it was funny to fuck up things because Nux Taku ordered them so. So yeah, this will eventually be fixed and right now it's a dumb mass trolling. I hope we don't lose something in the process like we did with the review system. The scores are not relevant when they are community based Hope this helps It didn't help sorry. Hope there's more of an argument with that statement. Because the community can't score things objectively. You give your score base on your own personal taste as everybody else. And the highest scores will always go to the animals that reach a broather public, the ones with most media, see Kimetsu no Yaiba case, It's an ok anime but not enouth to be to 20 or best of the year... The high scores are only there due the media exposure... As I said in my other post, the users recommendation by similarity are more useful than the scores... just watch a few episodes and decide for yourself if is good or not... Uhm, then what I said in the post above applies as well. Also, what's the deal with Kimetsu no Yaiba? Do you think it's the first show to blow up in popularity? I don't even think the show is good enough for its rank on MAL, but people loved it well enough for it to be there. That's all that matters in an aggregate. |
Feb 6, 2020 5:33 AM
#418
Shymander said: If anything, this just goes to show how relevant MAL's score is -- you don't see Nux instructing followers to bot Kitsu. You can cheer for Nux or you complain about the issue, not both. Egging this on creates more back-breaking work for us to resolve it. I felt his work was just cringey before, but this is being an asshole, plain and simple. Wtf is Kitsu that looks like furry porn |
Feb 6, 2020 5:39 AM
#419
lol He has all his sheep voting it 10 but he didn't even do it himself.. |
MALoween 2022 Candies: Bonus : MALoween 2023 Candies: Bonus : |
Feb 6, 2020 5:40 AM
#420
jal90 said: Tecnomage36 said: jal90 said: -GilgaSmash- said: jal90 said: Leulight said: jal90 said: Leulight said: cyruz said: Themousen said: Thanks to Nux, this anime will be legendary (well, it is already...) In a week, Ishuzoku Reviewers will take the #1 spot from FMAB, I'm sure of it I really hope everyone partaking in this will be successful enough to at some point be in a position where they have to waste their precious time dealing with something like this. To exist just to make the lives of other people more difficult is truly the pinnacle for some people in the anime community. Big thanks from the bottom of my heart. Maybe just do something about your flawed score system then. Maybe the next choice is completely removing the top anime and manga sections and we will all be laughing at how a bunch of self-righteous trolls fucked up another feature of this site. Seriously, if you are doing this shit at least don't make it sound like you are doing justice. Heh I am not a part of this 10 spamming movement, but would be really nice if the top sections are removed, the scoring system is flawed af. You can laugh all you want. If they don't do anything about the scoring system to make the scores ACTUALLY RELEVANT, this site can screw off for all I care. Yeah sure, and the solution is completely screwing them and rendering them unusable. They are creating a problem where there wasn't any. The scores are relevant, as long as they correspond to what people like and vote in consequence. It's bot spamming what is an issue here, not the tastes of the community. There was nothing to fix until a bunch of trolls felt they had to make a point and an even bigger bunch of trolls felt it was funny to fuck up things because Nux Taku ordered them so. So yeah, this will eventually be fixed and right now it's a dumb mass trolling. I hope we don't lose something in the process like we did with the review system. The scores are not relevant when they are community based Hope this helps It didn't help sorry. Hope there's more of an argument with that statement. Because the community can't score things objectively. You give your score base on your own personal taste as everybody else. And the highest scores will always go to the animals that reach a broather public, the ones with most media, see Kimetsu no Yaiba case, It's an ok anime but not enouth to be to 20 or best of the year... The high scores are only there due the media exposure... As I said in my other post, the users recommendation by similarity are more useful than the scores... just watch a few episodes and decide for yourself if is good or not... Uhm, then what I said in the post above applies as well. Also, what's the deal with Kimetsu no Yaiba? Do you think it's the first show to blow up in popularity? I don't even think the show is good enough for its rank on MAL, but people loved it well enough for it to be there. That's all that matters in an aggregate. Kimetsu no Yaiba is just the fresher example that came to my mind, I believe that someone famous talking about it on twitter made the show blow out of proportion... But anime that reach more people will always get a boost on this kind of aggregation site... |
Feb 6, 2020 5:41 AM
#421
Everyone votes out of their own "opinion" so i dont know what we can do if some users vote 1-3 or go for full 10 on a show that is considered average(7 tops) by most .. So i dont really have anything in mind as solution to what is happening ..if ppl want to have a show as 10 when is not their "true" 10.. they just suk |
Feb 6, 2020 5:41 AM
#422
Sweet jesus the amount of salt being thrown here is amazing, please keep going as we could enjoy the chaos for only much longer before the score goes down again, or till all the nux fan accounts are removed But until then, just don't take it seriously and enjoy the ride cause the last thing you should bitch about is witch piece of fiction is better Also gotta love how people are using this platform to call demon slayer overrated trash, really mature of you guys to bitch about it |
yotiFeb 6, 2020 5:45 AM
Feb 6, 2020 5:43 AM
#423
TheLimo said: Are these people aware that by doing this they're only fucking up some MAL staffer's day? Funimation doesn't give a shit about MAL scores so what exactly is the point of doing this? They are f*cking up their day by signing up to MAL and rating anime, basically using for what it was created? Yes, I'm sure of it. I know what you're trying to say, but all of these people are actually not doing anything wrong. They are simply using MAL the way it should be. Rating anime. |
Feb 6, 2020 5:54 AM
#424
I thought hentai shows weren't supposed on the top anime list? That is what needs to be fixed here, it has the incorrect age rating. |
Feb 6, 2020 6:01 AM
#425
Kineta said: I think Symphogear was also massively upvotyed out of nowhere sometimes ago, along with a couple of manga entries.Hi. Me again. I wanted to make a follow-up post here, in light of the current onslaught of Ishuzoku Reviewers—led by one individual who has seeming lost his marbles or let internet fame get to his head. Thanks to this individual's easily-influenced mob followers, Ishukozu Reviewer's score has been tampered with so badly, it makes the trolls who spammed Chihayafuru 3 look weak. I don't have words to express how such a display of thoughtlessness makes the staff feel, particularly Luna and I who were in a sheer panic when we first saw the flood of scores. Negativity aside, I managed to find two silver linings in this whole fiasco. Before all this happened, I received word that the development team may be done Phase 1 sooner than expected, and so we were trying to schedule an earlier release date (taking into consideration the weekend and national holidays in Japan). Silver-lining #1 is we shouldn't have to live with this long. Second, we were so focused on combating illegitimate scores given by duplicate account creation, we didn't consider illegitimate scores given by legitimate users due to vote brigading. Don't get me wrong, we want to tamper with MAL scores as little as possible. However, when an entry receives upwards of 15,000 "10" votes in less than 24 hours and those votes can be linked to one source, there is clearly a problem... So silver lining #2 is we will try to modify what we're releasing in Phase 1 to also deal with this (and Pingu in the City, too). Once the release date is finalized, I will make a site-wide announcement explaining as much as I can related to this issue, Chihayafuru 3, and the changes this will lead to in MAL's Top page. (As I've said before, up votes and down votes typically cancel each other out for highly-rated, highly-popular series, so don't expect massive changes in the Top 10.) Finally, I just want to say thanks to some of the rational-thinking users who posted in this reddit thread. I know it soothed the moderator team a little to see others recognize that this senseless action only harms volunteers and users unrelated to the company this individual claims to be protesting against. Thank you to everyone who spoke out (here or elsewhere) for your support. We will continue to try and make this situation right as speedily as possible. Anyway, I'm honestly shocked at how quickly this site-wide solution is coming, I thought it would be a similar case to the API, but thanks god, good job MAL team. |
ClickBaitBusterFeb 6, 2020 6:06 AM
Feb 6, 2020 6:05 AM
#426
lagoon22 said: I thought hentai shows weren't supposed on the top anime list? That is what needs to be fixed here, it has the incorrect age rating. the age rating is correct though it is R+ - Mild Nudity (I would agree it is not really Mild though :P) but it is not fully Nudity either and probably for other reasons besides that one it is not a Rx - Hentai |
Feb 6, 2020 6:07 AM
#427
ClickBaitBuster said: Anyway, I'm honestly shocked at how quickly this site-wide solution is coming, I thought it would be a similar case to the API, but thanks god, good job MAL team. I think they needed to work on it ASAP seeing as how easily things got out of control. |
Feb 6, 2020 6:11 AM
#428
I havnt used my MAL account in years. Coming back to give this a 10/10. This for you Nux. 🙂 |
Feb 6, 2020 6:12 AM
#429
Glordit said: Yeah, that's why I think using Chihayafufu's case to press MAL's owners to seek a permanent solution was better than a quick fix of the score like a lot of users were asking MAL mods to do.ClickBaitBuster said: Anyway, I'm honestly shocked at how quickly this site-wide solution is coming, I thought it would be a similar case to the API, but thanks god, good job MAL team. I think they needed to work on it ASAP seeing as how easily things got out of control. Edit:I just went to check what's this Nux guy is and holy mother of cringe, cancer right out of the thumbnails.. Fucking yikes.. |
ClickBaitBusterFeb 6, 2020 6:18 AM
Feb 6, 2020 6:21 AM
#430
Well, tbh this will push the mods to actually remove the troll ratings on the site. |
"Life is too bitter, so coffee, at least should be sweet..." - Hikigaya Hachiman (Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatte Iru) |
Feb 6, 2020 6:22 AM
#431
jal90 said: Leulight said: jal90 said: Leulight said: cyruz said: Themousen said: Thanks to Nux, this anime will be legendary (well, it is already...) In a week, Ishuzoku Reviewers will take the #1 spot from FMAB, I'm sure of it I really hope everyone partaking in this will be successful enough to at some point be in a position where they have to waste their precious time dealing with something like this. To exist just to make the lives of other people more difficult is truly the pinnacle for some people in the anime community. Big thanks from the bottom of my heart. Maybe just do something about your flawed score system then. Maybe the next choice is completely removing the top anime and manga sections and we will all be laughing at how a bunch of self-righteous trolls fucked up another feature of this site. Seriously, if you are doing this shit at least don't make it sound like you are doing justice. Heh I am not a part of this 10 spamming movement, but would be really nice if the top sections are removed, the scoring system is flawed af. You can laugh all you want. If they don't do anything about the scoring system to make the scores ACTUALLY RELEVANT, this site can screw off for all I care. Yeah sure, and the solution is completely screwing them and rendering them unusable. They are creating a problem where there wasn't any. The scores are relevant, as long as they correspond to what people like and vote in consequence. It's bot spamming what is an issue here, not the tastes of the community. There was nothing to fix until a bunch of trolls felt they had to make a point and an even bigger bunch of trolls felt it was funny to fuck up things because Nux Taku ordered them so. So yeah, this will eventually be fixed and right now it's a dumb mass trolling. I hope we don't lose something in the process like we did with the review system. There were issues, spams from HxH and FMAB fanboys, Score manipulation, Deleting actual good reviews instead of troll reviews for clout. No, this site is overflowing with issues. I am just hoping this Meme spam actually works as a wake up call. If not, I will just entertain myself as I also find this quite funny. |
Feb 6, 2020 6:25 AM
#432
before this got fixed,we should made this to the number 1 spot,we can do it boyz |
Feb 6, 2020 6:26 AM
#433
Feb 6, 2020 6:29 AM
#434
I think that only people with atleast 8+ years on MAL should be able to vote. |
Feb 6, 2020 6:40 AM
#435
Themousen said: Death_That_Kid said: Themousen said: Wow, now that's an impressive bot raid We're currently witnessing a reversed Chihayafuru 3 And honestly, this anime being boosted is hilarious and I don't mind it We must spread the Holy Word of Ishuzoku Reviewers I doubt it’s so much a bot raid as normal users. As soon as news of Funimation dropping the show made it’s way around the internet, people want to do everything they can to meme it. Never even heard of Interspecies Reviewers until yesterday, but my fellow anime connoisseurs have “watched” it and rated it 10s. All hail Lord Nux Yeah I just watched his video as well Ishuzoku Reviewers was already flexing on everyone, now it's gonna be even better cyruz said: Themousen said: Thanks to Nux, this anime will be legendary (well, it is already...) In a week, Ishuzoku Reviewers will take the #1 spot from FMAB, I'm sure of it I really hope everyone partaking in this will be successful enough to at some point be in a position where they have to waste their precious time dealing with something like this. To exist just to make the lives of other people more difficult is truly the pinnacle for some people in the anime community. Big thanks from the bottom of my heart. My message was mostly ironic, but yep good luck fixing that (even though, as someone stated, it's not a bot boosting case like Chihayafuru 3, so I don't see any rule transgression in Ishuzoku Reviewer's case) I wouldn't be so sure of that, out of the lastest 10 users to rate Ishuzoku Reviewers 5m ago, 4 were accounts created today/yesterday. Other 3 were clearly a second account. |
Feb 6, 2020 6:47 AM
#436
Here I am just sitting back with a bucket of popcorn watching this shit show unfold and find it absolutely hilarious. I myself love the show and also find Nux's videos pretty good. Also I probably wont be voting because well forums and reviews aren't much of my thing (Stares at the 400+ anime I have downloaded at watched but never put into MAL because of my lazy ass). So please give me more of this stuff to fill my popcorn bucket with. Plus I think that brigading/bot-reviewing isn't really that good of a thing overall (Though I do think that mass negative reviews have more of an effect then mass positive ones). Though inherently scoring systems in communities (Especially ones with smaller inside groups) can be a bit skewed because of the view points within those inside groups (A insider group pulling their influence into how good an anime should be precised would still technically counts messing with the scores. Even if it is only by a few points and not mass adding 1/10 or 10/10). Anyway... *Gets back to popcorn eating* |
Feb 6, 2020 6:50 AM
#437
AvihayAnimes said: Even better idea, only Kineta, Luna and the forum mods should be able to voteI think that only people with atleast 8+ years on MAL should be able to vote. |
Feb 6, 2020 6:54 AM
#438
The best anime to be ever created |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Feb 6, 2020 6:55 AM
#439
Kobayasan said: I understand this is sarcastic, yet major rating systems such as imdb.com's work like that. You collect criteria for what a "good reviewer" is like: membership duration, activity in forums, contributions such as reviews and recommendations, number of rated anime, distribution of scores and so on. Based on that, different weights are assigned. In a nutshell, the more work you put into MAL, the more your opinion counts. Sounds fair.AvihayAnimes said: Even better idea, only Kineta, Luna and the forum mods should be able to voteI think that only people with atleast 8+ years on MAL should be able to vote. |
Feb 6, 2020 7:01 AM
#442
Mal score has never been relevant |
Feb 6, 2020 7:02 AM
#443
All my support to the staff. It might be funny for the community of this "Nux" but definitely not for the ones trying to fix that. |
Feb 6, 2020 7:02 AM
#444
Imagine being triggered about some drawn characters KEK. Feminists and SJWs are so fucking retarded lmao |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Feb 6, 2020 7:04 AM
#445
Interested to see how mods are going to handle this. Even if they remove the ratings from new accounts that created in the past week or so, I believe the score is still going to be quite high. |
Feb 6, 2020 7:05 AM
#446
Kobayasan said: AvihayAnimes said: Even better idea, only Kineta, Luna and the forum mods should be able to voteI think that only people with atleast 8+ years on MAL should be able to vote. My suggestion is actually really good. |
Feb 6, 2020 7:06 AM
#447
Oh boy, the adaptation of PART 2 is amazing so far, can't wait for PART 5, that's easily my favourite in the manga. |
-Aincrad-Feb 6, 2020 7:10 AM
Feb 6, 2020 7:06 AM
#448
Jokah said: Good job in generalizing a whole community, sounds fair.This thread perfectly sums up what a bunch of losers anime fans are. God, you guys are pathetic. |
Feb 6, 2020 7:06 AM
#449
Just watch Nux Taku's latest video, and you'll understand. |
Feb 6, 2020 7:07 AM
#450
More topics from this board
Poll: » Ishuzoku Reviewers Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Ashhk - Mar 28, 2020 |
192 |
by Dudcav1400000000
»»
Oct 14, 10:02 AM |
|
Poll: » Ishuzoku Reviewers Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jan 4, 2020 |
281 |
by Artromex
»»
Aug 27, 6:18 PM |
|
Poll: » Ishuzoku Reviewers Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Feb 1, 2020 |
156 |
by Artromex
»»
Aug 26, 5:48 AM |
|
» Season 2?1WanteD1 - Sep 17, 2023 |
2 |
by Kaneki456
»»
Jul 24, 10:49 AM |
|
» Anime is underratedSasora - Jan 9, 2022 |
20 |
by Talamare
»»
Jun 21, 5:12 PM |